Jan Lievens, Christ and the Centurion revisited

Fig 1. Jan Lievens, Christ and the Centurion, with Julius Civilis, 1657. Canvas, 86 x 69 cm. Private collection (image courtesy of the Hoogsteder Museum Foundation, The Hague).

In 1992 a newly-discovered painting was presented in the exhibition Rembrandt’s Academy at Hoogsteder & Hoogsteder in The Hague. Werner Sumowski and Paul Huys Janssen wrote extensively in the accompanying exhibition catalogue about the new addition to Jan Lievens’s oeuvre: Christ and the Centurion, monogrammed and dated I.L. 1657 (fig. 1).1 The painting has remained in a private collection since then. After Rembrandt’s Academy it has been exhibited four times, and has been written about on various occasions.2 In the Spring of 2025 the painting was displayed in the Rembrandt House Museum. It was the second time that it could be seen in this museum. In contrast with the first time, in 2009, the painting was freed of retouchings and overpaintings. Without these accretions, it became evident that this painting was an oil sketch, as Lloyd DeWitt had already suggested in his dissertation of 2006.3 This gave occasion to study the place of this work in the oeuvre of Lievens, and to reexamine the interpretation of the theme. This paper presents the resulting new insights.

Unnoticed until 1991
The early provenance of Christ and the Centurion remains unknown. It could be one of those history paintings by Lievens that appear in various estate inventories and auction catalogue without mention of dimensions or further description.4 Around the middle of the nineteenth century it was acquired by Gaston Gaudinot, out of whose estate it was auctioned in 1869. This French docteur appears to have been the personal physician of the Duc d’Orleans.5 His paintings collection, which was known in French art circles by around 1840, consisted mainly of French, Dutch, Flemish and Spanish works, of which 125 were auctioned after his death.6 In the Rembrandt’s Academy catalogue it was already noted that the lots in this auction were published in Hippolyte Mireur’s Dictionaire des ventes d’art faites en France et à l’étranger, but that the Lievens painting was not named in it.7 For this reason it did not enter the art historical literature. Because this painting – according to verbal account – remained in family possession after the Gaudinot sale (or shortly thereafter), the work remained out of sight for art historians until an auction in 1991.8

Miraculous Healing
In the middle of the painting stand Christ and the Roman army commander, the centurion. On Christ’s left-hand side there is a figure who can easily be identified. It is the Apostle Matthew, recognizable from the book he carries. The depiction of the miraculous healing of the servant of the centurion in this painting follows his Gospel account (Matthew 8).9 The story takes place after the Sermon on the Mount, when Christ, followed by a crowd as seen in the painting, heads on to Capernaum. When he entered the town, a centurion approached him. The commander asked Jesus to heal his ailing servant. Christ replied that he would go with him in order to do this, whereupon the centurion protested that he was unworthy of a visit from him, “but just say the word, and my servant will be healed.” (Matt. 8:8) Jesus was astonished by such great faith, and replied: “‘Go! Let it be done just as you believed it would.’ And his servant was healed at that moment.” (Matthew 8:13).

Astonished Spectators
Besides the figures that can be identified from the Bible text, the painting shows two further groups. One stands in the background to the left. It consists of three white and one black man. They wear different dress than Christ and his followers and all four of them wear a turban. They are not literally mentioned in the Bible text, and cannot be straightforwardly related to other passages from the life of Christ.10 It is tempting to see them simply as staffage, filling out the scene. Between the men in turbans and the followers of Christ stands another group, centred around a mounted rider. He is the only figure in the painting to look straight out to the viewer. His baton indicates a position as a military commander, confirmed by the men behind him carrying partisans. Together with his soldiers, he rides into the main scene. The only ones who notice him are the men in turbans in the background to the left, and the dog in the middle ground.

The initial composition
Because the rider does not appear in the Bible text, he and his army could be seen as staffage. Technical research in the preparations for the exhibition of 1992 and the accompanying catalogue demonstrated however that Lievens fundamentally changed the composition of the scene, precisely in order to add this group of figures. In addition, visual analysis of the painting shows that Lievens moreover gave them a central place in the composition.

Fig 2. X-ray of: Jan Lievens, Christ and the Centurion, with Julius Civilis, 1657.

The impulse for the technical research at the time was the observation with the naked eye of pentimenti that indicate that the composition was radically changed. For this reason infrared reflectograms and x-ray images were made. The infrared images revealed that no underdrawing is present, meaning that Lievens went directly to work in oil paint.11 The x-ray photograph shows that the two central figures were initially considerably larger, establishing a pyramidal composition (fig. 2). The standing figure’s head reached to two-thirds of the height of the canvas, the kneeling man came to approximately the middle of the painting with the plume of his helmet. The scene was originally enclosed with two deciduous forests left and right. A lighter area in the foliage left, visible in the x-ray, suggests that there was diagonal opening – or a light beam – starting at the top left, accentuating the initial large figure in the middle.

Space for the rider
Presumably Lievens introduced the changes shortly after laying out the initial conception. Rough craquelure in certain spots in the painting indicate that underlying paint layers were not entirely dry when Lievens made his changes. He replaced the deciduous forest on the left with an evergreen one, thereby establishing a phytological contrast between the two sides of the composition. The forest on the right contains a striking pentimento: whereas the tree behind Christ originally rose to the upper edge of the painting, the artist ultimately chose to break it off, further accentuating the dichotomy: fractured, winding deciduous trees against rigid, upright coniferous trees.

But more prominently, Lievens changed the composition to a more horizontal arrangement by reducing the two principal figures, giving room to fill the background.12 Lievens used the space to add the mounted rider. Pentimenti around the horse’s head and the rider’s baton show Lievens searching for the optimal location for this figure. Lievens integrated the rider in the principal group of the composition by distributing colour and lines. The white colours of the centurion are echoed in the rider and his horse, the red colours in Christ’s cloak in the rider’s dress. Together these points form two diagonal lines: one from the centurion to the rider, the other from Christ to the rider. The resulting asymmetrical triangle is strengthened by parallel diagonals elsewhere in the compositions. Another prominent line in the composition is the zigzagging contours of the trees left and right, (probably again) making use of the foliage as a leading line. Via the rider, this is continued in the meandering path leading to the foreground.

Hidden in plain sight
These observations make clear that Lievens adjusted his painting in order to add the rider. He placed him at the convergence of the diagonals, and at the midpoint of the vertical axis. He also used colour to link him to the two main figures. In this way he made him part of the main compositional group. He is evidently not a secondary figure, but a principle figure. This raises the question of who the rider is and what inspired the artist to include him.

An important indication of the answer to this question surfaced with the removal of overpaint in 2013. It became evident that the pupil of the rider’s right eye was originally absent, and was painted in during a subsequent restoration.13 The man for whom Lievens created space in the main compositional group thus had one eye. In the context of a Roman military figure, this detail instantly evokes the identification of the figure as a character from the ancient history of the Netherlands, celebrated in Lievens’s time. This can only be Julius Civilis: the famous, one-eyed Batavian commander, who was in the seventeenth century known as Claudius Civilis.

Fig 3. Antonio Tempesta (after Otto van Veen), The Roman Soldiers Beg Civilis for Mercy, No. 19 in the series (…) De Batavische oft oude Hollandtsche oorloghe teghen de Romeynen (The Batavian or Old Dutch War against the Romans), 1612. Etching, 162 x 209 mm. Amsterdam, Rijksmuseum, inv. no. RP-P-OB-77.926.

The Inspiration for the Scene
In creating this painting Lievens undoubtedly looked at the main examples in previous art in which Jesus appears together with a Roman. On these he modelled the heavy cloaks and full beards of Jesus and his followers and the cuirass and the white-plumed helmet of the centurion.14 Lievens will also have consulted existing representations of Christ’s meeting with the centurion. He will not have had much other guidance, owing to the rarity of the theme.15

For the addition of the famous Batavian there is however a specific print series which could have inspired Lievens: the print series by Antonio Tempesta (1555-1630) of the Batavian Revolt after Otto van Veen (1556-1629), from 1612. That Lievens knew the print series, and that it inspired other artists occupied with the history of the Batavians, was demonstrated by Henri van de Waal and further addressed by Elmer Kolfin in his publication on the Amsterdam Town Hall.16 Print nineteen from the series shows how the leader of the exhausted Roman army begs Julius Civilis for their lives (fig. 3). The inscription explains that Civilis grants mercy to them, on condition that they swear allegiance to the (anachronistic) “Netherlands”. The Roman leader kneels before the mounted Civilis, who wears a cuirass and a short cloak, and a plumed hat, and is surrounded by his army carrying spears.

There is no direct correspondence between the print and Lievens’s oil sketch, but as occurs more often with Lievens, there are various elements of the print that are echoed in the painting. The kneeling man was adapted by Lievens with some adjustment to the pose. The same applies to Civilis on his horse with the spear-bearing soldiers behind him. The two centurions have a similarly solicitous role in both the print and the painting, only in the painting Lievens elevated Christ to principal figure and relegated Civilis more to the background. The baton that he holds in his hand in the painting is admittedly absent in this particular print, but can be found in print eight in the series.17

Lievens in Amsterdam Circles
Christ and the Centurion has since its rediscovery always been seen as intended for an architectural setting, due to the rounded upper corners. However, the painting could not be linked to any particular building. Now that it has been determined that the painting casts a reference to Julius Civilis, it appears worthwhile to make a new attempt.

Christ and the Centurion originates in the period in which Lievens lived in The Hague. He was involved in various commissions in the city and participated in the establishment of the painter’s association Confrerie Pictura in 1656.18 In the same period he also worked in Amsterdam. In 1656 Lievens painted Quintus Fabius Maximus Dismounts on Orders from his Son for the Small Burgomasters Chamber in the Amsterdam Town Hall (fig. 4). In the following year – the same year that he made Christ and the Centurion – Lievens drew the portrait of one of the burgomasters Andries de Graeff (fig. 5).19

Fig 4. Jan Lievens, Quintus Fabius Maximus Dismounts on Orders of his Son, 1656. Oil on canvas, 203 x 175 cm. Amsterdam, Royal Palace (photography: Tom Haartsen).
Fig 5. Jan Lievens, Portrait of Andries de Graeff, 1657. Black charcoal, 42.1 x 31.3 cm. Haarlem, Teylers Museum, inv. no. P. 006.

Van de Waal and Kolfin relate how this Andries and his brother Cornelis de Graeff played a decisive role in the commission for the decoration program in the new Town Hall. This included the eight large paintings with rounded upper corners in the grand gallery surrounding the Burgerzaal (Citizens’ Hall), the Batavian Series.20 Lievens’ drawn De Graeff portrait proves that he had attracted the interest of one of these prominent figures, in the period in which their ideas for the decoration program came into fruition. In this context, now that Civilis evidently plays a role in this painting with rounded upper corners, it is tempting to study this work in connection with the Amsterdam Town Hall.

The New Testament Linked to Dutch National History
Lievens added Civilis to a Biblical scene, and combined a story from the New Testament with one from the ancient history of the Netherlands. In doing so he linked the theme of steadfastness in faith (Christ and the Centurion) with that of loyalty towards the Dutch nation (Julius Civilis and the Centurion), the core of contemporary songs (like the Wilhelmus), texts and other cultural expressions.  In this manner Lievens imbued divine legitimacy to Dutch national history. In painting, such a direct combination of a Batavian scene with one from the New Testament is a rarity, perhaps even unique. It does however fit well in the broader history of seventeenth-century culture, as Van de Waal wrote: “This divine link [between the Old and New Testament] could if desired also be drawn between other periods than that of the Old and New Testament; it became one of the ways, in which one sought to reconcile the culture of classical antiquity with the Christian faith.”21

Fig 6. Rembrandt, The Conspiracy of Claudius Civilis, c. 1661. Pen in brown, brown wash, corrections in white, 19.6 x 18.0 cm. Munich, Staatliche Graphische Sammlung München, inv. no. 1451.

Perhaps Jan Lievens submitted this complex painting as a proposal to the De Graeff brothers, in an effort to secure the commission for the Batavian Series in the grand gallery of the Amsterdam Town Hall, even before it went to Govert Flinck in 1659. Be that as it may, he did not receive the assignment for the whole series. After Flinck’s death in 1660 though, Lievens completed one of the lunettes in his stead: Brinio Raised on the Shield (fig. 4), depicting the Batavian victory over the Romans led by the chieftain today referred to as Brinno. Since Lievens was contracted for one of these gallery paintings, it is also possible that Lievens used the painting in its current, reworked form years later as presentation piece for a one of the lunettes in the gallery that had not been filled (and still aren’t) for which the themes are not known.22 It is noteworthy that Lievens’ Christ and the Centurion even roughly matches the original aspect ratio of Rembrandt’s sketch for The Conspiracy of Claudius Civilis (c. 1661–1662) (fig. 6), and Jurgen Ovens’s of Claudius Civilis leaving the Women and Children to fight at Xanten (1662), both for the Batavian Series.23

“Civilis inde ovalen opde Galderije”
The Amsterdam accounts clerk noted on 13 January 1661: “The officials of accounts announced to me, that the esteemed burgomasters have agreed with Jan Lievens and Jacques Jordaens that they each will make a piece with Claudius Civilis in the ovals in the gallery, for the sum of twelve hundred guilders each, without seeking any increase or honorarium or any other premise they may come up with.” 24 The payment to Lievens subsequently took place on 23 March, only two months and one week after the note about the commission “for the piece of Brinio in the oval [the lunette] in the gallery”.25 As explanation for the short period between the two archival documents De Waal suggested that the clerk’s note in January was only made when the payment to Lievens was approaching, while the decision had already been made earlier, in order to avoid criticism of the public expenditure.26

Notably, the first source refers to “Claudius Civilis”, while Lievens was paid for “Brinio”. However tempting it is to see a connection between the words of the accounts clerk and the currently proposed Civilis in Christ and the Centurion, the explanation offered by Van de Waal is sufficiently plausible to relate the decision of the treasurers to link the payment to Brinio Raised on the Shield. Moreover, Jordaens did deliver a scene with Civilis. Perhaps the clerk used “Claudius Civilis” as a general reference to a Batavian scene, much like later descriptions also confuse names.

For Brinio Raised on the Shield there are two known oil sketches that have been preserved (figs. 7 and 8). The version in the Amsterdam Museum, painted on paper, is generally seen as the presentation piece. Gregor Weber argues that the other piece, on canvas, served this function.27 Similarities in paint handling, colour, and buildup, with Quintus Fabius Maximus, Christ and the Centurion, and Brinio Raised on the Shield, were already described in Rembrandt’s Academy and De Witt’s dissertation.28 Kolfin also addresses the correspondences in motifs with the Quintus Fabius Maximus and Brinio paintings.29 These are partially applicable also to Christ and the Centurion, which falls between them in terms of date. The paint handling in the various oil sketches is similar, although the somewhat larger Christ and the Centurion does show greater detail.

Fig 7. Jan Lievens, Brinio Raised on the Shield, 1661. Oil on canvas, 546 x 538 cm. Amsterdam, Royal Palace Amsterdam (photography: E&P Hesmerg).
Fig 8. Jan Lievens, Brinio Raised on the Shield, c. 1660. Oil on paper, 60.5 x 59 cm. Amsterdam, Amsterdam Museum, inv. no. SA 790. 

The Stadholders of Orange as Batavians
An interesting question is whether the references to the stadholders of the House of Orange, as Kolfin points out in the Brinio, can also be observed in Christ and the Centurion.30 As Van de Waal explains, the Dutch were freed from the Spanish yoke by the State army under the supreme command of the stadholder, just as their ancestors were freed from the Romans by the Batavian army under the leadership of Julius Civilis and Brinno.31 In addition to this, the  Batavian chiefs were elected leaders of the army, just like the stadholders.32 For this reason the most important commission from the Oranges in the same period, the decorations of the Oranjezaal, is bursting with references to the Batavians.33 Lievens, who also painted for this commission, was of course familiar with these. On the relationship between the stadholders and the decoration of the new Amsterdam Town Hall Kolfin states: “[…] that the stadholders were in fact servants of the States General and the appointed supreme commanders of the duration of the conflict. It appears that this was precisely the message of the Batavian Series.” 34

Faith in Christ and Loyalty to Nation
In Jan Lievens’s Christ and the Centurion from 1657, the central rider mounted on the horse was added at a later stage to the scene by the artist. For this, the painting had to undergo a substantial change. The relevance of the rider in the painting was additionally emphasized by the artist through its composition integration and colour referencing. Moreover, the rider addresses the viewer with his gaze, underscoring his primary role. A recent restoration made clear that the figure initially only had one eye, leading to the identification of him as the Batavian chieftain Julius (or Claudius) Civilis, one of the “Dutch” protagonists in the Batavian Revolt against the Romans.35

It can be concluded that Lievens here shows how he arrived at an intriguing iconography through a masterful composition. In it he combined the symbolism of the Biblical story with the symbolism of the story from the Dutch national history of Julius Civilis sparing the lives of the Romans, on condition that they pledge allegiance to the Netherlands. The painting can now be titled Christ and the Centurion, with Julius Civilis, a combination of loyalty to the Christian faith and loyalty to the Netherlands, a familiar trope in Dutch seventeenth century culture.

In 1657, a painting with such a subject would not have been out of place in the newly completed Amsterdam Town Hall. The decorative program in the grand gallery enclosing the Citizens’ Hall eventually would depict scenes from the Batavian Revolt. Lievens’s work appears to be an oil sketch from the period when he was working for the Town Hall and for Andries de Graeff, a burgomaster who presided over the decoration program. The fact that the decision regarding which painter would receive the commission for the Batavian Series had not yet been made evokes the idea that Lievens’s painting has a place in the early genesis of this famous decorative program.

  1. Werner Sumowski, Paul Huys Janssen, The Hoogsteder Exhibition of Rembrandt’s Academy, exh. cat. The Hague: Hoogsteder & Hoogsteder, 1992, cat. no. 28.
  2. Exhibition catalogues: Albert Blanckert, Jezus in de Gouden Eeuw, exh. cat. Rotterdam: Kunsthal, 2000–2001; Akira Kofuku, Rembrandt and the Rembrandt School. The Bible, mythology and ancient history, exh. cat. Tokyo: Museum of Western Art, 2003; Arthur K. Wheelock et al., Jan Lievens. A Dutch Master Rediscovered, exh. cat. Washington: National Gallery of Art; Milwaukee: Milwaukee Art Museum; Amsterdam: Rembrandt House Museum, 2008-2009, cat.no. 52; Louis van Tilborgh, Constantijn Huygens. Kunstkenner en verzamelaar, exh. cat. The Hague: Museum Bredius, 2013, cat. no. 14. Other literature: Werner Sumowski, Gemälde der Rembrandtschüler, vol. 4, Landau, 1983, p. 3726, no. 2356, fig. 3964; Helga Gutbrod, Lievens und Rembrandt : Studien zum Verhältnis ihrer Kunst, Frankfurt am Main, 1996, p. 299; Edwin Buijssen (ed.), Haagse schilders in de Gouden Eeuw, Het Hoogsteder lexicon van alle schilders werkzaam in Den Haag 1600-1700, The Hague, 1998, p. 191; Lloyd DeWitt, Evolution and Ambition in the career of Jan Lievens, 1607-1674, Phd. Diss. University of Maryland, College Park, 2006, p. 228.
  3. DeWitt, Evolution (see note 2), p. 228.
  4. For example those mentioned in the Montias Database of 17th Century Dutch Art Inventories and the Getty Provenance Research Index.
  5. Sumowski, Huys Janssen, Academy (see note 1), p. 220.
  6. Dr Gaston Gaudinot sale, Paris (Drouot), 13-14 February 1869.
  7. Sumowski, Huys Janssen, Academy (see note 1), p. 220.
  8. Ibid.
  9. Sumowski, Huys Janssen, Academy (see note 1), p. 226. Huys Janssen explains that the miracle as described in Luke and John differs from the version told by Matthew.
  10. After listening to the centurion, and before addressing him directly, Jesus speaks to his followers: “I tell you, many will come from east and west and sit at table with Abraham, Isaac, and Jacob in the kingdom of heaven.” (Matthew 8:11) Perhaps Lievens incorporated this part of the text and explicitly included people coming from the east (from the standpoint of his Dutch audience). A second possibility is that they are Pharisees. This group plays the role elsewhere in Matthew of disbelieving critics, and here they may serve to accentuate the belief of the centurion in the Christian faith. In early prints (Sebald Beham, Israhel van Meckenem, Hans Schaüfelein and Cornelis Massijs) and several Italian prints from Lievens’s time (seventeenth century prints after Paolo Veronese), Pharisees wear such headdresses. A parallel between blacks and overseas regions, such as in Lievens’s Brinio, is convincingly outlined by Elmer Kolfin (in: Elmer Kolfin, De kunst van de macht, Jordaens, Lievens en Rembrandt in het Paleis op de Dam, Zwolle, 2023, p. 67), does not seem to apply here.
  11. Sumowski, Huys Janssen, Academy (see note 1), p. 223.
  12. Sumowski, Huys Janssen, Academy (see note 1), pp. 223, 226.
  13. The right eye from the perspective of the viewer. There, a pupil was painted in, in a later restoration. Because of the sketchy manner it is difficult to ascertain whether or not both eyes are present, but in the left the lower eyelid is visible, while it is undefined in the right eye.
  14. For example: Jacobus Neeffs (after Jacob Jordaens), Judgement of Christ, etching, c. 1630-1645; Marinus van der Goes (after Jacques Jordaens), Judgement of Christ, engraving, c. 1614-1639; Willem Panneels (after Peter Paul Rubens), Adoration of the kings, etching, 1630; Nicolaes Lauwers (after Peter Paul Rubens), Ecce Homo, engraving, c. 1619-1652; and many more. Generally, for examples of inspiration drawn from prints by Lievens, see De
    Witt, Evolution (see note 2).
  15. Sumowski, Huys Janssen, Academy (see note 1), p. 226. Huys Janssen refers to examples by Nicolaes Moeyaert (Herentals, St. Waltrudis church) and Adam Camerarius (Amsterdam, Rijksmuseum, inv. no. SK-A-733). DeWitt refers to a painting by Bartholomeus Breenbergh (Karlsruhe, Staatliche Kunsthalle Karlsruhe, inv. no. 228) and the Moeyaert in Herentals (DeWitt, Evolution (see note 2), p. 227). But also see a woodcut with this subject by Cornelis van Sichem II in Der zielen lusthof (1629). Also of interest: Claes Moeyeart, Christ and the Centurion, 1632 (Minneapolis, Minneapolis Institute of Art, inv. no. 2012.84.5). Although the painting is known under this subject, it may in fact depict Cornelius kneeling before Peter, since more than one figure is shown kneeling and the composition closely resembles prints of this subject.
  16. Henri van de Waal, “’s Lands oudste verleden in de voorstelling van Vondel en zijn tijdgenooten”, Elsevier’s Maandschrift 47 (1937); Henri van de Waal, “Tempesta en de historieschilderingen op het Amsterdamse stadhuis”, Oud Holland 56 (1939); Henri van de Waal, Drie eeuwen vaderlandsche geschied-uitbeelding 1500-1800, een iconologische studie, The Hague, 1952; Kolfin, Kunst (see note 10).
  17. Antonio Tempesta (after Otto van Veen), Print 8 in (…)De Batavische oft oude Hollandtsche oorloghe teghen de Romeynen, 1612. Etching, 167 x 210 mm. Rijksmuseum, Amsterdam, inv. no. RP-P-OB-37.614. Jürgen Ovens based his drawing for the Batavian Series depicting Claudius Civilis leaving the Women and Children to fight at Xanten (Hamburg, Hamburger Kunsthalle, inv. no. 22342) on this print.
  18. On the period in The Hague: Buijssen Haagse (see note 2), pp.191-193.
  19. Haarlem, Teylers Museum, inv. no. P 006. For the identification and context, see: Gregor Weber, “Dus leeft de dappre Graaf: Zu einem Bildnis Andries de Graeffs von Jan Lievens (1607-1674)”, Oud Holland 99 (1985), pp. 44-56.
  20. Van de Waal, Eeuwen (see note 16), p. 230; Kolfin, De kunst van de macht (see note 10), pp. 19-20.
  21. Van de Waal, “’s Lands” (see note 16), p. 301-302.
  22.  Kolfin, Kunst (see note 10), p. 41. Four Batavian scenes were never completed. For two the themes are known, for the other two are not known.
  23. Munich, Staatliche Graphische Sammlung München, inv. no. 1451; Hamburg, Hamburger Kunsthalle, Kupferstichkabinett, inv. no. 22342. A lesser-known drawing of Rembrandt’s Conspiracy of Claudius Civilis (Edinburgh, National Galleries of Scotland, inv. no. D 23862) shows – when compared to the drawing in Munich – that the lower section of the painting is covered by a frieze and that portions of the left and right sides are obscured. This may indicate that an alternative conception of the framing of the lunettes was considered before the one ultimately implemented. It is possible that this earlier framing was already envisioned when Lievens produced his oil sketch Christ and the Centurion.
  24. Van de Waal, Eeuwen (see note 16), p. 225, referring to SAA, 5039, 2 resolutieboek, f. 66r.
  25. Ibid., referring to SAA, 5039, 153 rapiamus 1661, f.195v.
  26. Van de Waal, Eeuwen (see note 16), p. 225.
  27. Gregor Weber, “Jan Lievens’s ‘The Shield-raising of Brinio’ a Second Oil Sketch”, Hoogsteder-Naumann Mercury 12/13 (1992), nt. 8.
  28. Dewitt, Evolution (see note 2), p. 221.
  29. Kolfin, Kunst (see note 10), p.67.
  30. Kolfin, Kunst (see note 10), p. 44.
  31. For, among other things, contemporary poetry in which Civilis and others are compared to the members of the House of Orange: Van de Waal, Eeuwen (see note 16), pp. 220-221, 223.
  32. Kolfin, Kunst (see note 10), p. 47.
  33. Margriet van Eikema Hommes, Elmer Kolfin, De Oranjezaal in Huis ten Bosch, Een zaal uit loutere liefde, Zwolle, 2013, p. 77.
  34. Kolfin, Kunst (see note 10), pp. 41-47, 77.
  35. One may ask, in light of points discussed in this article, whether the “Christ” figure in the first version was in fact Christ at all. If so, the oil sketch would initially have represented solely a Christian scene without any reference to the Batavian Revolt, thereby less relatable to the (eventual) decoration program of the Town Hall’s gallery. Given that in the initial design the groups left and right with Biblical and/or eastern figures do not seem to have been included (aside from a bearded man on the right, judging from the x-ray), the large central figure may originally have been Julius Civilis. In compositional terms, this would align the painting more closely with the print by Tempesta after Van Veen. The apparent similarity in hairstyle between the final Christ figure and the initial figure, together with the possible initial presence of a (holy) beam of light directed toward the figure, may argue against this hypothesis; nevertheless, Brinno in Lievens’s Brinio Raised on the Shield likewise features long hair and even incorporates a diagonal compositional line through the clouds, comparable to the line through the foliage in the initial version of the present subject. The later insertion of Christ could then be understood as a deliberate twist, imparting a more prominent Christian meaning to the historical scene. These suggestions and observations were kindly shared by Jochem van Eijsden.

In memoriam Sébastien Abraham Corneille Dudok van Heel (1938—2025)

With the passing of Sébastien Abraham Corneille Dudok van Heel on 20 January 2025 at the age of 86, we have lost a distinguished archivist, historian and art historian, and a distinct voice and colourful character within the field of Rembrandt studies. Bas, as he was known to his family, friends and colleagues, was a free and independent spirit, sharp-minded and outspoken, with an infectious sense of humour. His home was always open to family and friends as well as to colleagues from around the world; he was an exceptionally generous host.

When it came to scholarship, Bas was uncompromising, some might even say stubborn. Facts to him were essential for any kind of research, and disregard for them was unacceptable. Bas presented his views with great conviction and could be impatient and unforgiving in academic discourse. At the same time, sitting in the corner of his sofa by the window overlooking the Prinsengracht, and in his last home the Reguliersgracht, Bas was generous with his time and loved to share his own findings, his phenomenal knowledge, and his opinions. Many will fondly remember his unique way of talking about Amsterdamers of past centuries as if they were neighbours. Bas connected easily with younger generations, despite never having operated a computer or a smart phone. His writings revolved around sixteenth- and seventeenth-century Amsterdam, its art and people and their place in history and society, long before ‘contextualising’ became a buzzword.

Born in Bergen-op-Zoom and raised in Amersfoort, Bas moved to Amsterdam after a brief stint as an assistant teacher; the city remained his home for the rest of his life. From 1969, he was employed by the City Archives Amsterdam (then called Gemeentearchief). Bas soon passed the oral exam required to read history at the University of Amsterdam (as he did not have the relevant secondary school qualifications); he graduated in 1979. Aged 63, he took early retirement from the Archives. Bas was proud that he overcame subsequent challenges and obtained his PhD in art history at Radboud University in Nijmegen in 2006.

Bas’s interest in Rembrandt developed at the Archives under the tutelage of the eminent scholar of Amsterdam, Isabella H. van Eeghen (1913-1996). It is probably fair to say that Bas initially took inspiration more from documents relating to Rembrandt than the artist’s works. His visit to the paintings section of the vast exhibition at the Rijksmuseum in 1956, celebrating the 350th anniversary of Rembrandt’s birth left him far from impressed. The 18-year-old was deeply disappointed by what he recalled decades later vividly as the “poepkleuren” (poo colours) of most paintings on display. The 300th anniversary of Rembrandt’s death in 1969 provided him with a first occasion to publish, unleashing a steady stream of articles and essays, many devoted to the artist’s life and work, over the following 50 years.

With his groundbreaking Rembrandt biography for the catalogue of the memorable exhibition in Berlin, Amsterdam and London (1991-1992), Bas reshaped the understanding of the artist. A thorough analysis of the Rembrandt documents (to the publication of which, in 1979, he had contributed significantly) placed the artist firmly in his artistic and social environment. He included pioneering maps of Amsterdam, pinpointing the homes of the artist, colleagues, patrons and collectors, visualising his essential social networks. He also threw more light on Rembrandt’s often questionable behaviour towards contemporaries, including his partner Geertje Dircx. Bas elaborated on the latter aspect in the biography for the exhibition catalogue Rembrandt’s Women (Edinburgh and London 2001), an essay that was also published separately by the Rembrandt House Museum.

His PhD thesis, De jonge Rembrandt onder tijdgenoten (The Young Rembrandt among Contemporaries, 2006), based on seminal, revised and enlarged articles, contains a wealth of information, including on artists such as Pieter Lastman and his circle. It places Rembrandt and his art in the context of the religious confrontations of the 1620s and 1630s. Bas continued to elaborate upon themes of this book, for example on Hendrick Uylenburgh’s workshop and its significance for portraiture in Amsterdam, exploring Rembrandt’s role, and suggesting an intriguing cameo appearance of Frans Hals, in 1633. He summarised the fruits of this research in his last publication on Rembrandt, for the exhibition catalogue Rembrandt and Amsterdam Portraiture 1590-1670 (Madrid 2020).

While this latter essay is available in English, most of Bas’s articles appeared in Dutch, in periodicals such as Maandblad and Jaarboek van het Genootschap Amstelodamum, Kroniek van het Rembrandthuis, Jaarboek van het Centraal Bureau voor Genealogie and De Nederlandsche Leeuw. It is to be hoped that his PhD thesis and a selection of his ground-breaking articles will be made accessible in English in the future, to benefit international Rembrandt research.

Many will remember Bas as an outstanding Rembrandt scholar, but he was a prolific author on a wide range of subjects and artists, from Jacob Cornelisz to Frans Hals and Jacob de Wit, and from the history of collecting to that of the full-length portrait in Amsterdam, among others.

However, his magnum opus is Van Amsterdamse burgers tot Europese aristocraten (From Amsterdam Burghers to European Aristocrats), a multi-volume monument to his decades-long research in the archives. It explores an early 15th-century Amsterdam couple and the three branches of their family. Their patrician descendants for centuries dominated the economy, politics and culture, at first in Amsterdam, subsequently expanding across the Dutch Republic, its colonies, and beyond. The books contain a staggering wealth of information and will remain immensely useful to historians, genealogists, heraldists, and social as well as art historians. The first two volumes were published in 2008, followed by volumes IV to VI in 2024, together covering two of the three branches of the family. Volume III, containing the essays accompanying the latter volumes, was finished shortly before Bas died and a group of dedicated friends and colleagues is working towards its publication in the near future.

Suffering from poor eyesight since childhood, Bas never rode a bicycle – highly unusual in the Netherlands – but walked whenever possible. Building on this fitness, he took to bodybuilding in his early eighties. And, as was characteristic of him, he did so systematically and with enormous discipline, and thus also with the desired, visible results – of which he was very proud. It was this extraordinary strength of mind and body that allowed him to complete his magnum opus during the final two years of his life, even while suffering from terminal cancer.

Bas Dudok van Heel will live on through his profound scholarship, and in our memories. Many of us have not only lost a special colleague but also a dear friend.

Christian Tico Seifert
Senior Curator (Northern European Art), National Galleries of Scotland, Edinburgh

  1. Werner Sumowski, Paul Huys Janssen, The Hoogsteder Exhibition of Rembrandt’s Academy, exh. cat. The Hague: Hoogsteder & Hoogsteder, 1992, cat. no. 28.
  2. Exhibition catalogues: Albert Blanckert, Jezus in de Gouden Eeuw, exh. cat. Rotterdam: Kunsthal, 2000–2001; Akira Kofuku, Rembrandt and the Rembrandt School. The Bible, mythology and ancient history, exh. cat. Tokyo: Museum of Western Art, 2003; Arthur K. Wheelock et al., Jan Lievens. A Dutch Master Rediscovered, exh. cat. Washington: National Gallery of Art; Milwaukee: Milwaukee Art Museum; Amsterdam: Rembrandt House Museum, 2008-2009, cat.no. 52; Louis van Tilborgh, Constantijn Huygens. Kunstkenner en verzamelaar, exh. cat. The Hague: Museum Bredius, 2013, cat. no. 14. Other literature: Werner Sumowski, Gemälde der Rembrandtschüler, vol. 4, Landau, 1983, p. 3726, no. 2356, fig. 3964; Helga Gutbrod, Lievens und Rembrandt : Studien zum Verhältnis ihrer Kunst, Frankfurt am Main, 1996, p. 299; Edwin Buijssen (ed.), Haagse schilders in de Gouden Eeuw, Het Hoogsteder lexicon van alle schilders werkzaam in Den Haag 1600-1700, The Hague, 1998, p. 191; Lloyd DeWitt, Evolution and Ambition in the career of Jan Lievens, 1607-1674, Phd. Diss. University of Maryland, College Park, 2006, p. 228.
  3. DeWitt, Evolution (see note 2), p. 228.
  4. For example those mentioned in the Montias Database of 17th Century Dutch Art Inventories and the Getty Provenance Research Index.
  5. Sumowski, Huys Janssen, Academy (see note 1), p. 220.
  6. Dr Gaston Gaudinot sale, Paris (Drouot), 13-14 February 1869.
  7. Sumowski, Huys Janssen, Academy (see note 1), p. 220.
  8. Ibid.
  9. Sumowski, Huys Janssen, Academy (see note 1), p. 226. Huys Janssen explains that the miracle as described in Luke and John differs from the version told by Matthew.
  10. After listening to the centurion, and before addressing him directly, Jesus speaks to his followers: “I tell you, many will come from east and west and sit at table with Abraham, Isaac, and Jacob in the kingdom of heaven.” (Matthew 8:11) Perhaps Lievens incorporated this part of the text and explicitly included people coming from the east (from the standpoint of his Dutch audience). A second possibility is that they are Pharisees. This group plays the role elsewhere in Matthew of disbelieving critics, and here they may serve to accentuate the belief of the centurion in the Christian faith. In early prints (Sebald Beham, Israhel van Meckenem, Hans Schaüfelein and Cornelis Massijs) and several Italian prints from Lievens’s time (seventeenth century prints after Paolo Veronese), Pharisees wear such headdresses. A parallel between blacks and overseas regions, such as in Lievens’s Brinio, is convincingly outlined by Elmer Kolfin (in: Elmer Kolfin, De kunst van de macht, Jordaens, Lievens en Rembrandt in het Paleis op de Dam, Zwolle, 2023, p. 67), does not seem to apply here.
  11. Sumowski, Huys Janssen, Academy (see note 1), p. 223.
  12. Sumowski, Huys Janssen, Academy (see note 1), pp. 223, 226.
  13. The right eye from the perspective of the viewer. There, a pupil was painted in, in a later restoration. Because of the sketchy manner it is difficult to ascertain whether or not both eyes are present, but in the left the lower eyelid is visible, while it is undefined in the right eye.
  14. For example: Jacobus Neeffs (after Jacob Jordaens), Judgement of Christ, etching, c. 1630-1645; Marinus van der Goes (after Jacques Jordaens), Judgement of Christ, engraving, c. 1614-1639; Willem Panneels (after Peter Paul Rubens), Adoration of the kings, etching, 1630; Nicolaes Lauwers (after Peter Paul Rubens), Ecce Homo, engraving, c. 1619-1652; and many more. Generally, for examples of inspiration drawn from prints by Lievens, see De
    Witt, Evolution (see note 2).
  15. Sumowski, Huys Janssen, Academy (see note 1), p. 226. Huys Janssen refers to examples by Nicolaes Moeyaert (Herentals, St. Waltrudis church) and Adam Camerarius (Amsterdam, Rijksmuseum, inv. no. SK-A-733). DeWitt refers to a painting by Bartholomeus Breenbergh (Karlsruhe, Staatliche Kunsthalle Karlsruhe, inv. no. 228) and the Moeyaert in Herentals (DeWitt, Evolution (see note 2), p. 227). But also see a woodcut with this subject by Cornelis van Sichem II in Der zielen lusthof (1629). Also of interest: Claes Moeyeart, Christ and the Centurion, 1632 (Minneapolis, Minneapolis Institute of Art, inv. no. 2012.84.5). Although the painting is known under this subject, it may in fact depict Cornelius kneeling before Peter, since more than one figure is shown kneeling and the composition closely resembles prints of this subject.
  16. Henri van de Waal, “’s Lands oudste verleden in de voorstelling van Vondel en zijn tijdgenooten”, Elsevier’s Maandschrift 47 (1937); Henri van de Waal, “Tempesta en de historieschilderingen op het Amsterdamse stadhuis”, Oud Holland 56 (1939); Henri van de Waal, Drie eeuwen vaderlandsche geschied-uitbeelding 1500-1800, een iconologische studie, The Hague, 1952; Kolfin, Kunst (see note 10).
  17. Antonio Tempesta (after Otto van Veen), Print 8 in (…)De Batavische oft oude Hollandtsche oorloghe teghen de Romeynen, 1612. Etching, 167 x 210 mm. Rijksmuseum, Amsterdam, inv. no. RP-P-OB-37.614. Jürgen Ovens based his drawing for the Batavian Series depicting Claudius Civilis leaving the Women and Children to fight at Xanten (Hamburg, Hamburger Kunsthalle, inv. no. 22342) on this print.
  18. On the period in The Hague: Buijssen Haagse (see note 2), pp.191-193.
  19. Haarlem, Teylers Museum, inv. no. P 006. For the identification and context, see: Gregor Weber, “Dus leeft de dappre Graaf: Zu einem Bildnis Andries de Graeffs von Jan Lievens (1607-1674)”, Oud Holland 99 (1985), pp. 44-56.
  20. Van de Waal, Eeuwen (see note 16), p. 230; Kolfin, De kunst van de macht (see note 10), pp. 19-20.
  21. Van de Waal, “’s Lands” (see note 16), p. 301-302.
  22.  Kolfin, Kunst (see note 10), p. 41. Four Batavian scenes were never completed. For two the themes are known, for the other two are not known.
  23. Munich, Staatliche Graphische Sammlung München, inv. no. 1451; Hamburg, Hamburger Kunsthalle, Kupferstichkabinett, inv. no. 22342. A lesser-known drawing of Rembrandt’s Conspiracy of Claudius Civilis (Edinburgh, National Galleries of Scotland, inv. no. D 23862) shows – when compared to the drawing in Munich – that the lower section of the painting is covered by a frieze and that portions of the left and right sides are obscured. This may indicate that an alternative conception of the framing of the lunettes was considered before the one ultimately implemented. It is possible that this earlier framing was already envisioned when Lievens produced his oil sketch Christ and the Centurion.
  24. Van de Waal, Eeuwen (see note 16), p. 225, referring to SAA, 5039, 2 resolutieboek, f. 66r.
  25. Ibid., referring to SAA, 5039, 153 rapiamus 1661, f.195v.
  26. Van de Waal, Eeuwen (see note 16), p. 225.
  27. Gregor Weber, “Jan Lievens’s ‘The Shield-raising of Brinio’ a Second Oil Sketch”, Hoogsteder-Naumann Mercury 12/13 (1992), nt. 8.
  28. Dewitt, Evolution (see note 2), p. 221.
  29. Kolfin, Kunst (see note 10), p.67.
  30. Kolfin, Kunst (see note 10), p. 44.
  31. For, among other things, contemporary poetry in which Civilis and others are compared to the members of the House of Orange: Van de Waal, Eeuwen (see note 16), pp. 220-221, 223.
  32. Kolfin, Kunst (see note 10), p. 47.
  33. Margriet van Eikema Hommes, Elmer Kolfin, De Oranjezaal in Huis ten Bosch, Een zaal uit loutere liefde, Zwolle, 2013, p. 77.
  34. Kolfin, Kunst (see note 10), pp. 41-47, 77.
  35. One may ask, in light of points discussed in this article, whether the “Christ” figure in the first version was in fact Christ at all. If so, the oil sketch would initially have represented solely a Christian scene without any reference to the Batavian Revolt, thereby less relatable to the (eventual) decoration program of the Town Hall’s gallery. Given that in the initial design the groups left and right with Biblical and/or eastern figures do not seem to have been included (aside from a bearded man on the right, judging from the x-ray), the large central figure may originally have been Julius Civilis. In compositional terms, this would align the painting more closely with the print by Tempesta after Van Veen. The apparent similarity in hairstyle between the final Christ figure and the initial figure, together with the possible initial presence of a (holy) beam of light directed toward the figure, may argue against this hypothesis; nevertheless, Brinno in Lievens’s Brinio Raised on the Shield likewise features long hair and even incorporates a diagonal compositional line through the clouds, comparable to the line through the foliage in the initial version of the present subject. The later insertion of Christ could then be understood as a deliberate twist, imparting a more prominent Christian meaning to the historical scene. These suggestions and observations were kindly shared by Jochem van Eijsden.

Samuel van Hoogstraten as Rembrandt’s teaching assistant

Introduction: “When I was still a disciple” 
In his Inleyding tot de hooge schoole der schilderkonst (1678), Samuel van Hoogstraten calls himself a ‘’discipel’’ (pupil), when referring to his time with Rembrandt,36 between circa 1642 and 1647. For a long time, this was seen as the sole extent of his role during this period. Later art historians (Werner Sumowski, Jonathan Bikker and David de Witt) opted for another dimension: that of Rembrandt’s teaching assistant, during the last four years of his stay.37 In the context of the recent exhibition and research project on Van Hoogstraten (Kunsthistorisches Museum Vienna, Rembrandt House Museum, and RKD),38 the notion of an assistantship following his pupilship has become commonplace.39 However, there are no documented assistenten (assistants) in painters workshops in seventeenth-century Holland.40 Leerlingen (pupils) and gezellen (journeymen) though, are well attested. All three roles imply a subordinate position,41 and an assistant role could still be assumed by Van Hoogstraten in his capacity as a pupil, but the idea of an assistant may equally connote remuneration and professional skill. This suggests that he may have served as a journeyman, a capacity not yet considered. This article examines how Van Hoogstraten’s possible role, articulated in the literature as a “teaching assistant”, in Rembrandt’s workshop should be understood, based on guild regulations, dictionary entries, archival documents, and artworks.

1.1 The rules
In order to clarify Van Hoogstraten’s proposed assistant role, it is helpful to examine the implications of the use of the term “assistant” for his probable de jure role (pupil or journeyman) in the context of a seventeenth-century Amsterdam painter’s workshop. The most formal reference point for understanding Van Hoogstraten’s position with Rembrandt is the ordinances of the Amsterdam Guild of Saint Luke.42 An eighteenth-century ordinance book states that Amsterdam-based pupils (called “leerjongens”) had to be registered with the guild and serve a pupilship for the minimum of two years.43 Journeymen (called “(werk)gesellen” and “knechts” – servants or hands),44 are described simply as working: no minimum term or registration requirement is mentioned.45 Both pupils and journeymen had to appear with a master at the guild office upon arrival in the city and pay a fee of ten stivers.46 Journeymen who failed to find employment received reimbursement for travel and lodging expenses.47 This was effectively a refund of the ten stivers.

The guild ordinances, however, do not further define the terms pupils and journeyman. The Dutch-Latin dictionary Etymologicum Teutonicae Linguae (1599), offers some clarification through contemporary synonyms. The term  “leerlinck” is translated as “discipulus”, which is also the Latin translation given for “leerkind”, “leer-ionghe”, “leerknecht”, and “discipel”.48 The phrase “gheselle van een ampt” (journeyman in a trade) is translated in Latin as “collega” (colleague),49 while “knecht” – synonym for “dienaer” (servant) – is translated as “servus”, “famulus”, “minister”, and “puer”.50 In correspondence with the regulations in the guild ordinances, a journeyman painter was a trained practitioner working in someone else’s employ. This fits with the profile of a documented example: Louis du Prêt. In 1624, at around the age of thirty-five, this painter was described as a “knecht” of portraitist Cornelis van der Voort. 51 Among his colleagues however, Du Prêt was an esteemed connoisseur of Italian painting.52

1.2 The practice 
Moreover, the guild ordinances do not clearly specify the distinct roles or tasks of pupils and journeymen. As Ronald de Jager (1990) has shown, surviving contracts between master painters and young aspiring ones also rarely distinguish between these functions.53 Broadly speaking, all young men in a master painter’s studio were expected to be diligent and obedient, to paint, to prepare materials, and to act only with permission.54 While a distinction between pupil and journeyman evidently existed, the official period of pupilship appears to have been prolonged in seventeenth-century Amsterdam, as we will see. De Jager already notes that artistic training was generally lengthy and often consisted of an initial phase of about four years, followed by a second, concluding phase of approximately two.55 Despite the diversity of contracts, a rough trajectory from novice pupil to experienced journeyman in Amsterdam can be discerned, comparable to a line emerging from a scatter plot. This will help to estimate Van Hoogstraten’s formal role in Rembrandt’s workshop.

The starting point is the 1626 agreement in which fourteen-year-old Gerrit Willemsz Horst began a six-year pupilship with Anthony Lust.56 In the contract, the term “dienaer” is consistently crossed out and replaced by “leerknecht”.57 Horst’s age, title and (remarkably long) contract mark him as a typical novice. A next step in pupilship is found in the 1635 contract of Adriaen Carman, who at seventeen became Isaac Isaacsz’ “leerknecht” for two years. Though also described as a “dienaer”, Carman was taught painting and related skills, prepared canvases, and ground pigments.58 No tuition or wage was paid; instead, Carman’s father annually gifted Isaacsz a small barrel of herring or stockfish, worth about twelve guilders,59 modest compared to common fees.60 He thus appears to have occupied a position virtually between pupil and journeyman. Notably, Carman was permitted to create his own work: one painting per year on a daelder (Dutch silver thaler) size canvas or panel (c. 123 × 92 cm).61

1.3 Learning on the job
A typical journeyman was Markus Waltusz. Although this twenty-one-year-old entered into service with Bartholomeus van der Helst as a “discipel” in 1652, he did so for a daily wage of ten and a half stivers. His duties included painting, keeping shop, and following orders. Van der Helst was to instruct him.62 While not explicitly referred to as a journeyman, Waltusz effectively functioned as one: he got paid,63 was hired for only a year (shorter than permitted for pupils), and had already been described as a painter six months earlier at the time of his marriage.64 A final example, at the endpoint of the progression from pupil to journeyman, is the 1649 contract between Gerardus van Berleborch and Lambertus Jansz de Hue,65 both referred to as “schilder” (painter). Van Berleborch entered De Hue’s service for one year at fifteen stivers per day, with restrictions on painting for himself or others except on Sundays and during the time of one free month.66

The case of Waltusz (and to some extent Carman) illustrates that in Amsterdam, one could functionally be a journeyman while remaining contractually a pupil. Masters and guilds appear to have prolonged pupil status as much as possible. This seems to reflect a broader development from the late sixteenth to the early eighteenth century. 67 A 1766 publication compiling all known Amsterdam guild regulations shows that in 1553, masters were limited to two pupils,68 and by 1579, journeymen were required to pay a weekly fee of one half or one stiver, depending on their wages.69 Such distinctions between pupils and journeymen are absent in the abovementioned ordinance book.70 This practice of gradually blurring the boundaries between pupils and journeyman, and extending the pupilship period, makes it convincing that Van Hoogstraten formally remained a pupil throughout his time with Rembrandt, even if he may already have taken on responsibilities more typical of a journeyman, or even a master.

1.4 Early signs
The fact that Carman, as a pupil, and Van Berleborch, as a journeyman, were allowed to produce independent work invites addressing a complicating aspect of Van Hoogstraten’s time in Rembrandt’s workshop: between 1644 and 1647, Van Hoogstraten made and signed paintings, one or two works per year.71 It has previously been argued that only master painters were entitled to sign their work, as a mark of completed training.72 This view is primarily based on guild regulations from The Hague and Utrecht dating to the 1650s,73 the only known ordinances of their kind. No such rule appears to have existed in Amsterdam. There, both pupils and journeymen (with their master’s consent) could produce independent work. Moreover, some Amsterdam contracts specify who owned the work produced by pupils,74 suggesting such arrangements were negotiable. Clearly, attitudes in Amsterdam differed from those in The Hague and Utrecht.

Although Carman’s is the only known pupil with such an production arrangement, among the scarce surviving pupil-master contracts from Amsterdam, it is possible that Van Hoogstraten – who as a pupil produced around two small-format paintings per year (ranging from 54 × 45 cm to 74 × 48 cm, grote stooter (groat) to tien stuiver (ten stivers) size),75 but roughly adding up to a daelder size – had had a similar opportunity as Carman. De Witt and Leonore van Sloten have already noted that Van Hoogstraten’s early works display a distinctly personal character,76 suggesting they may not have been intended for open-market sale, or made on commission. So even if Amsterdam guild practice held that only masters sell signed work, such production might have gone unnoticed by the guild. In any case, Van Hoogstraten’s early signed and dated paintings offer little indication that he was a master; he probably created them while still a pupil.

2.1 A teaching pupil
In the literature, the idea of Van Hoogstraten as Rembrandt’s teaching assistant has largely relied on the suggestion that he gave painting instructions to Drost while still working in Rembrandt’s studio. Although this notion is convincing of itself – based on the proposed stylistic similarities between the two artists’ works – it remains just one example.77 However, recent research by the author into the life and work of Barent Fabritius now provides further support for the notion of Van Hoogstraten as a teaching pupil within Rembrandt’s workshop, this time in the domain of drawing. Fabritius is likely to have spent some years of his training in Rembrandt’s studio, approximately between 1645 and 1647, just as his elder brother Carel a few years before. This is primarily based on the evidence of Barent Fabritius’s early drawings, which also reveal a striking affinity with works by Van Hoogstraten from the latter half of the 1640s.78

Although Barent Fabritius is generally not considered a pupil of Rembrandt in the most recent literature on him,79 several of his early drawings do suggest his presence in Rembrandt’s workshop. The most important of these is a copy after Rembrandt’s painting Susanna and the Elders. Fabritius reproduced the painting faithfully (figs. 1 and 2). There are some differences between the copy and the original, and technical examination of the painting indicates that the drawing must have been made after an intermediate stage in the painting’s creation, in 1646 or 1647.80 At that moment it was a direct copy. In fact, it was so precise, it shows that Rembrandt was still at work on the painting: he was in the process of correcting the position of Susanna’s left foot.81 The painting must therefore have been present in the studio at the time the drawing was made – when Van Hoogstraten was also active there.

Fig 1. Rembrandt, Susanna and the Elders, 1647. Oil on panel, 76.6 × 92.8 cm. Berlin, Staatlichen Museen zu Berlin, Gemäldegalerie, inv. no. 828D.
Fig 2. Attributed to Barent Fabritius, Susanna and the Elders, c. 1646-1647. Pen and brown ink, washed with red and grey, on paper, 178 × 238 mm. Budapest, Szépművészeti Múzeum, inv. no. 1737.

2.2 Drawing inspiration
The Suzanna drawing thus originated in Rembrandt’s studio, yet notably, Fabritius did not adopt Rembrandt’s drawing style. The drawings currently attributed to Rembrandt from the second half of the 1650’s are characterized by a more sketchily approach, in solely black ink and chalk.82 Fabritius appears to have been inspired instead by Van Hoogstraten. Several of Fabritius’s drawings were at one point even attributed to him.83 Shared characteristics include doll-like figures, a pictorial rendering in a full tonal range, and use of varied materials (fig. 3 and fig 4).

Fig 3. Attributed to Barent Fabritius, The Departure of the Prodigal Son, c. 1650. Chalk, red chalk, pen in black ink, brush in black and red, 198 × 320 mm. Städel Museum, Frankfurt am Main, inv. no. 817 Z. 
Fig 4. Samuel van Hoogstraten, Balaam blesses the Israelites, c. 1646. Pen in grey, brush in grey, red chalk, grey wash, heightened with white, 174 x 309 mm. London, The British Museum, inv. no. 1895,0915.1175.

In the early part of the second half of the 1640s, both artists employed multiple media, especially red chalk. Van Hoogstraten though used it more prominently, primarily in the initial layout and contours of the figures. Barent applied it more sparingly, mainly for accentuation and detailing. There are also differences in how each artist created houding in their drawings.84 Fabritius typically developed the background in chalk, leaving it more indistinct in order to achieve a convincing atmospheric perspective.85 Van Hoogstraten tended to work more sketchily with a fine pen in the backgrounds, while rendering the foreground with greater precision.

Fig 5. (Here) attributed to Barent Fabritius and Samuel van Hoogstraten, The Rest on the Flight into Egypt, c. 1646-1647. Black chalk, pen in brown and grey ink, grey wash, red chalk, and white heightening, 195 × 223 mm. Dresden, Staatliche Kunstsammlungen, Kupferstich-Kabinett, inv. no. c 1443r.

Van Hoogstraten’s role as his drawing instructor becomes apparent in Fabritius’s Rest on the Flight into Egypt (fig. 5).86 The drawing’s chaotic character stems from the variety of materials, linework, and especially the coexistence of different drawing styles. It appears to have been corrected – there are even two Josephs – confirmed by handwritten suggestions on the verso, strikingly rare among Rembrandt and his pupils.87 In the corrections, the angular black pen lines in Joseph’s face are particularly telling, echoing Van Hoogstraten’s figural stylizations, such as the sharp nasal bridge and long, slightly arched eyebrows seen in his drawings from around 1647 (Table 1).88 The “second”, more sketch-like Joseph is faint, but resembles Van Hoogstraten’s looser sketched works of the period: the lobed coiffure and broken, scratchy contour of the left shoulder recall those of Joseph in his Adoration of the Shepherds (c. 1647), while the facial features echo the peering Zechariah in Van Hoogstraten’s Visitation (1646/1648). That the drawing at the basis of the Dresden sheet is in fact by Fabritius, is evident from, among other things, the dark grey washes and broad zigzag hatching in the shadow areas.89 These features closely resemble those found in Barent’s Susanna and the Elders. In addition, the restrained use of red chalk – in the Dresden drawing for instance applied on the donkey, is comparable in its seemingly arbitrary application for emphasis and detail in the two drawings. The text on the back is possible too by Barent’s hand.90

 

Table 1.
u.l.: detail from fig 5. 
u.ctr.: detail from fig 4.
l.l.: detail from fig 5. 
l.ctr.: Samuel van Hoogstraten, The Adoration of the Shepherds, c. 1646-1647. Black chalk, pen in brown, red chalk, brown wash, brush in brown, heightened with white, 153 × 204 mm. Hamburg, Hamburger Kunsthalle, inv. no. 22050.
l.r.: Samuel van Hoogstraten, The Visitation, c. 1646-1648. Pen in brown, red chalk, brown wash, brush in brown, 72 × 88 mm. Amsterdam, Amsterdam Museum, inv. no. TA 10153. 

2.3 Dual master

Fig 6. Attributed to Rembrandt, The Rest on the Flight into Egypt, c. 1647. Pen and brown ink on paper, 126 × 203 mm. Berlin, Staatlichen Museen zu Berlin, Kupferstichkabinett, inv. no. KdZ 5262.

Taking a step back, it is striking that three key elements in the two drawings by Fabritius discussed here are echoed in Van Hoogstraten’s discussion of drawing in his Inleyding: the value of copying paintings as a means of sharpening perception and understanding composition;91 the didactic function of corrections in the drawing itself;92 and the painterly quality of red chalk drawing.93 Combined with stylistic affinities and the presence of corrections by Van Hoogstraten in one of Fabritius’s sheets, this suggests a pedagogical relationship between them, likely dating to 1645-1647. Additionally, these principles appear to have been situated within the context of Rembrandt’s workshop. Fabritius’s Dresden drawing is closely related to an undated sketch by Rembrandt in Berlin with the same subject, and the annotations on Fabritius’s sheet are in turn visualized by Rembrandt himself (fig. 6).94 While Van Hoogstraten’s role in Fabritius’s training seems more direct, Rembrandt, too, appears to have contributed to his artistic development.

The three-way artistic relationship between Fabritius, Rembrandt and Van Hoogstraten is likewise revealed in Fabritius’s drawing of The Adoration of the Shepherds in Leiden (fig. 7) The drawing closely relates to Van Hoogstraten’s painting of the same subject from 1647, almost certainly created in Amsterdam (fig. 8).95

Fig 7. Attributed to Barent Fabritius, The Adoration of the Shepherds, c. 1647. Black and red chalk, pen in brown, brown wash heightened with white, 193 × 248 mm. Leiden, Leiden University, inv. no. PK-T-AW-274.
Fig 8. Samuel van Hoogstraten, The Adoration of the Shepherds, 1647. Oil on panel, 58.2 × 70.8 cm. Dordrechts Museum, Dordrecht, inv. no. DM/980/567.

 

Striking similarities include a figure lifting the cloth in the manger like a crumpled rag, the half-height wooden partition on the right, and the wide-brimmed hat. The shepherd seen from the back is derived from the figure of Saint John the Evangelist in Van Hoogstraten’s drawing The Crucifixion (fig. 9).96 At the same time, Fabritius seems to have drawn inspiration from Rembrandt’s Tobit and Anna with the Kid from 1645–46 (fig. 10), echoing the lighting from the left, the slanted shanty roof in the upper right, and the seated figure right of center. Thematically and compositionally, the drawing also resonates with Rembrandt’s The Dream of Joseph in the Stable (fig. 11).

Fig 9. Attributed to Samuel van Hoogstraten, The Crucifixion, c. 1649, Pen in brown, brown wash, brush in brown, heightened with white, 155 × 150 mm. Bremen, Kunsthalle Bremen, 1951/385.
Fig 10. Rembrandt, The Wife of Tobias with the Goat, 1645. Oil on panel, 21.5 × 16.5 cm. Staatlichen Museen zu Berlin, Gemäldegalerie, inv. no. 828F.

 

Fig 11. Rembrandt, The Dream of Joseph, 1645. Oil on panel, 52 × 41 cm. Staatlichen Museen zu Berlin, Gemäldegalerie, inv. no. 828E.

 

2.4 Primus inter pares
In the context of the idea that Van Hoogstraten remained a pupil throughout his time with Rembrandt, it is worth pointing to evidence that he was still in training between 1644 and 1647. In 1646, he made a drawing of The Adoration of the Shepherds, after a painting Rembrandt made for the Passion series, commissioned by Stadtholder Frederik Hendrik.97 Several comparable drawings by other Rembrandt pupils from around 1646 survive.98 Fabritius’s Susanna and the Elders is not unique in this regard. During this same period, figure drawing from nude models also took place in Rembrandt’s workshop. Three such drawings by pupils and an etching by the master himself, The Walking Trainer (B 194), attest to this practice.99 One of the pupil drawings has long been attributed to Van Hoogstraten (fig. 12); another, long unattributed (fig. 13),100 appears to be by Barent Fabritius.101 Around 1646, Van Hoogstraten thus participated in group training exercises alongside Fabritius – at a similar level, even while giving him drawing instruction.

Fig 12. Attributed to Samuel van Hoogstraten, Standing Nude Man, c. 1646. Pen in brown, brown wash, white gouache, 247 × 155 mm. Paris, Musée du Louvre, inv. no. RF 4713 recto.
Fig 13. (Here) attributed to Barent Fabritius, Standing Nude Man, c. 1646. Pen in brown, brown wash, white gouache, 252 × 193 mm. London, The British Museum, inv. no. Oo,9.94.

 

There is no evidence that around 1645 other Rembrandt pupils were correcting each other’s work. It is therefore justified to assume that peer correction was not standard practice in the studio, and that Van Hoogstraten acted as primus inter pares – a pupil with teaching responsibilities. This raises the question whether his role was unique in the history of Rembrandt’s studio, or if there were predecessors or successors. A possible predecessor may have been Van Hoogstraten’s fellow Dordrecht native Ferdinand Bol.102 Although Bol already referred to himself as a painter in Dordrecht as early as 1635, he worked in Rembrandt’s studio in the late 1630s, which is usually considered a pupilship.103 Only from 1642 onward does he seem to produce works typical of a master painter.104 Moreover, Bol appears to have influenced later Rembrandt pupils, such as Carel Fabritius.105 So, while no direct evidence has been found, Bol may have served as a functional forerunner to Van Hoogstraten.106 At a later stage in his career, Van Hoogstraten appears to have implemented a similar system in his own studio. Arnold Houbraken was, according to himself, the eldest pupil among Van Hoogstraten’s disciples and had a room of his own.107

Conclusion: Once a disciple, always a disciple
Recent scholarship has argued that Samuel van Hoogstraten, after starting a pupilship with Rembrandt in 1642, became an “assistant” in the studio from 1644, until 1647, entrusted with teaching pupils and producing his own work. While this may imply the status of a journeyman, it is unlikely that Van Hoogstraten attained that position. In the course of the seventeenth century, extended pupilship (with some privileges) appeared to be favored over journeymanship in Amsterdam. Van Hoogstraten thus likely remained, in formal terms, a pupil under Rembrandt. The idea of Van Hoogstraten being a teaching assistant instructing his peers, as a primus inter pares, is further substantiated by evidence that he provided drawing instruction to Barent Fabritius. His early drawn works reveal corrections by Van Hoogstraten, but also stylistic affinities with him, and pedagogical principles later articulated by him in his Inleyding. The close parallels between Fabritius’s drawings and Rembrandt’s works further underscore that this happened under the supervision of Rembrandt. Van Hoogstraten thus emerges as a key figure mediating Rembrandt’s pedagogy within the workshop, in the capacity of a pupil. Whether other pupils before or after him adopted comparable roles remains an open question, meriting further research.

 

 

 

  1. Werner Sumowski, Paul Huys Janssen, The Hoogsteder Exhibition of Rembrandt’s Academy, exh. cat. The Hague: Hoogsteder & Hoogsteder, 1992, cat. no. 28.
  2. Exhibition catalogues: Albert Blanckert, Jezus in de Gouden Eeuw, exh. cat. Rotterdam: Kunsthal, 2000–2001; Akira Kofuku, Rembrandt and the Rembrandt School. The Bible, mythology and ancient history, exh. cat. Tokyo: Museum of Western Art, 2003; Arthur K. Wheelock et al., Jan Lievens. A Dutch Master Rediscovered, exh. cat. Washington: National Gallery of Art; Milwaukee: Milwaukee Art Museum; Amsterdam: Rembrandt House Museum, 2008-2009, cat.no. 52; Louis van Tilborgh, Constantijn Huygens. Kunstkenner en verzamelaar, exh. cat. The Hague: Museum Bredius, 2013, cat. no. 14. Other literature: Werner Sumowski, Gemälde der Rembrandtschüler, vol. 4, Landau, 1983, p. 3726, no. 2356, fig. 3964; Helga Gutbrod, Lievens und Rembrandt : Studien zum Verhältnis ihrer Kunst, Frankfurt am Main, 1996, p. 299; Edwin Buijssen (ed.), Haagse schilders in de Gouden Eeuw, Het Hoogsteder lexicon van alle schilders werkzaam in Den Haag 1600-1700, The Hague, 1998, p. 191; Lloyd DeWitt, Evolution and Ambition in the career of Jan Lievens, 1607-1674, Phd. Diss. University of Maryland, College Park, 2006, p. 228.
  3. DeWitt, Evolution (see note 2), p. 228.
  4. For example those mentioned in the Montias Database of 17th Century Dutch Art Inventories and the Getty Provenance Research Index.
  5. Sumowski, Huys Janssen, Academy (see note 1), p. 220.
  6. Dr Gaston Gaudinot sale, Paris (Drouot), 13-14 February 1869.
  7. Sumowski, Huys Janssen, Academy (see note 1), p. 220.
  8. Ibid.
  9. Sumowski, Huys Janssen, Academy (see note 1), p. 226. Huys Janssen explains that the miracle as described in Luke and John differs from the version told by Matthew.
  10. After listening to the centurion, and before addressing him directly, Jesus speaks to his followers: “I tell you, many will come from east and west and sit at table with Abraham, Isaac, and Jacob in the kingdom of heaven.” (Matthew 8:11) Perhaps Lievens incorporated this part of the text and explicitly included people coming from the east (from the standpoint of his Dutch audience). A second possibility is that they are Pharisees. This group plays the role elsewhere in Matthew of disbelieving critics, and here they may serve to accentuate the belief of the centurion in the Christian faith. In early prints (Sebald Beham, Israhel van Meckenem, Hans Schaüfelein and Cornelis Massijs) and several Italian prints from Lievens’s time (seventeenth century prints after Paolo Veronese), Pharisees wear such headdresses. A parallel between blacks and overseas regions, such as in Lievens’s Brinio, is convincingly outlined by Elmer Kolfin (in: Elmer Kolfin, De kunst van de macht, Jordaens, Lievens en Rembrandt in het Paleis op de Dam, Zwolle, 2023, p. 67), does not seem to apply here.
  11. Sumowski, Huys Janssen, Academy (see note 1), p. 223.
  12. Sumowski, Huys Janssen, Academy (see note 1), pp. 223, 226.
  13. The right eye from the perspective of the viewer. There, a pupil was painted in, in a later restoration. Because of the sketchy manner it is difficult to ascertain whether or not both eyes are present, but in the left the lower eyelid is visible, while it is undefined in the right eye.
  14. For example: Jacobus Neeffs (after Jacob Jordaens), Judgement of Christ, etching, c. 1630-1645; Marinus van der Goes (after Jacques Jordaens), Judgement of Christ, engraving, c. 1614-1639; Willem Panneels (after Peter Paul Rubens), Adoration of the kings, etching, 1630; Nicolaes Lauwers (after Peter Paul Rubens), Ecce Homo, engraving, c. 1619-1652; and many more. Generally, for examples of inspiration drawn from prints by Lievens, see De
    Witt, Evolution (see note 2).
  15. Sumowski, Huys Janssen, Academy (see note 1), p. 226. Huys Janssen refers to examples by Nicolaes Moeyaert (Herentals, St. Waltrudis church) and Adam Camerarius (Amsterdam, Rijksmuseum, inv. no. SK-A-733). DeWitt refers to a painting by Bartholomeus Breenbergh (Karlsruhe, Staatliche Kunsthalle Karlsruhe, inv. no. 228) and the Moeyaert in Herentals (DeWitt, Evolution (see note 2), p. 227). But also see a woodcut with this subject by Cornelis van Sichem II in Der zielen lusthof (1629). Also of interest: Claes Moeyeart, Christ and the Centurion, 1632 (Minneapolis, Minneapolis Institute of Art, inv. no. 2012.84.5). Although the painting is known under this subject, it may in fact depict Cornelius kneeling before Peter, since more than one figure is shown kneeling and the composition closely resembles prints of this subject.
  16. Henri van de Waal, “’s Lands oudste verleden in de voorstelling van Vondel en zijn tijdgenooten”, Elsevier’s Maandschrift 47 (1937); Henri van de Waal, “Tempesta en de historieschilderingen op het Amsterdamse stadhuis”, Oud Holland 56 (1939); Henri van de Waal, Drie eeuwen vaderlandsche geschied-uitbeelding 1500-1800, een iconologische studie, The Hague, 1952; Kolfin, Kunst (see note 10).
  17. Antonio Tempesta (after Otto van Veen), Print 8 in (…)De Batavische oft oude Hollandtsche oorloghe teghen de Romeynen, 1612. Etching, 167 x 210 mm. Rijksmuseum, Amsterdam, inv. no. RP-P-OB-37.614. Jürgen Ovens based his drawing for the Batavian Series depicting Claudius Civilis leaving the Women and Children to fight at Xanten (Hamburg, Hamburger Kunsthalle, inv. no. 22342) on this print.
  18. On the period in The Hague: Buijssen Haagse (see note 2), pp.191-193.
  19. Haarlem, Teylers Museum, inv. no. P 006. For the identification and context, see: Gregor Weber, “Dus leeft de dappre Graaf: Zu einem Bildnis Andries de Graeffs von Jan Lievens (1607-1674)”, Oud Holland 99 (1985), pp. 44-56.
  20. Van de Waal, Eeuwen (see note 16), p. 230; Kolfin, De kunst van de macht (see note 10), pp. 19-20.
  21. Van de Waal, “’s Lands” (see note 16), p. 301-302.
  22.  Kolfin, Kunst (see note 10), p. 41. Four Batavian scenes were never completed. For two the themes are known, for the other two are not known.
  23. Munich, Staatliche Graphische Sammlung München, inv. no. 1451; Hamburg, Hamburger Kunsthalle, Kupferstichkabinett, inv. no. 22342. A lesser-known drawing of Rembrandt’s Conspiracy of Claudius Civilis (Edinburgh, National Galleries of Scotland, inv. no. D 23862) shows – when compared to the drawing in Munich – that the lower section of the painting is covered by a frieze and that portions of the left and right sides are obscured. This may indicate that an alternative conception of the framing of the lunettes was considered before the one ultimately implemented. It is possible that this earlier framing was already envisioned when Lievens produced his oil sketch Christ and the Centurion.
  24. Van de Waal, Eeuwen (see note 16), p. 225, referring to SAA, 5039, 2 resolutieboek, f. 66r.
  25. Ibid., referring to SAA, 5039, 153 rapiamus 1661, f.195v.
  26. Van de Waal, Eeuwen (see note 16), p. 225.
  27. Gregor Weber, “Jan Lievens’s ‘The Shield-raising of Brinio’ a Second Oil Sketch”, Hoogsteder-Naumann Mercury 12/13 (1992), nt. 8.
  28. Dewitt, Evolution (see note 2), p. 221.
  29. Kolfin, Kunst (see note 10), p.67.
  30. Kolfin, Kunst (see note 10), p. 44.
  31. For, among other things, contemporary poetry in which Civilis and others are compared to the members of the House of Orange: Van de Waal, Eeuwen (see note 16), pp. 220-221, 223.
  32. Kolfin, Kunst (see note 10), p. 47.
  33. Margriet van Eikema Hommes, Elmer Kolfin, De Oranjezaal in Huis ten Bosch, Een zaal uit loutere liefde, Zwolle, 2013, p. 77.
  34. Kolfin, Kunst (see note 10), pp. 41-47, 77.
  35. One may ask, in light of points discussed in this article, whether the “Christ” figure in the first version was in fact Christ at all. If so, the oil sketch would initially have represented solely a Christian scene without any reference to the Batavian Revolt, thereby less relatable to the (eventual) decoration program of the Town Hall’s gallery. Given that in the initial design the groups left and right with Biblical and/or eastern figures do not seem to have been included (aside from a bearded man on the right, judging from the x-ray), the large central figure may originally have been Julius Civilis. In compositional terms, this would align the painting more closely with the print by Tempesta after Van Veen. The apparent similarity in hairstyle between the final Christ figure and the initial figure, together with the possible initial presence of a (holy) beam of light directed toward the figure, may argue against this hypothesis; nevertheless, Brinno in Lievens’s Brinio Raised on the Shield likewise features long hair and even incorporates a diagonal compositional line through the clouds, comparable to the line through the foliage in the initial version of the present subject. The later insertion of Christ could then be understood as a deliberate twist, imparting a more prominent Christian meaning to the historical scene. These suggestions and observations were kindly shared by Jochem van Eijsden.
  36. Samuel van Hoogstraten, Inleyding tot de hooge schoole der schilderkonst: anders de zichtbaere werelt, Rotterdam 1678, p. 18. Van Hoogstraten here refers to the period when he was “still a disciple”, during which, as part of a “we”, he and others discussed a particular question, to which a certain “Fabritius” responded with an answer. It is generally assumed that this refers to Carel Fabritius, who is assumed to have studied with Rembrandt between approximately 1641 and 1643.
  37. Werner Sumowski described Van Hoogstraten as “pädagogisch begabt, Assistent Rembrandts gewesen” (Werner Sumowski, Gemälde der Rembrandt-Schüler II, Landau/Pfalz 1984, p. 1286). As supporting evidence, Sumowski argued that Van Hoogstraten corrected drawings by Constantijn Daniël van Renesse (; p. 1290, nt. 2). When discussing one of these drawings (Moses and Reuel’s Daughters at the Well, Amsterdam, Rijksmuseum, inv. no. RP-T-1893-A-2782) Sumowski suggested the possibility that “Samuel van Hoogstraten acted as assistant to the master on occasional trips even at a later date”. (Werner Sumowski, Drawings of the Rembrandt School IX, New York 1985, no. 2159x). Building on this, Jonathan Bikker suggested in his monograph on Willem Drost that Van Hoogstraten “might have supervised Drost during his early days in Rembrandt’s studio” (Jonathan Bikker, Willem Drost, A Rembrandt Pupil in Amsterdam and Venice, New Haven/London 2005, p. 11). David de Witt later observed, in his Abraham van Dijck monograph, concerning Van Hoogstraten: “by 1646 his training would have been complete, but he appears to have stayed on as a tutor or head pupil for several years” (David De Witt, Life and Work of Late Rembrandt Pupil Abraham van Dijck, c. 1635-1680, Amsterdam 2020, p. 11).
  38. Sabine Pénot, Rembrandt – Hoogstraten. Colour and Illusion, exh. cat. Vienna: Kunsthistorisches Museum Wien, 2024; Nathalie Maciesza, Epco Runia, Samuel van Hoogstraten. De Illusionist, exh. cat. Amsterdam: Rembrandt House Museum, 2025; Sabine van Beek, Leonore van Sloten, David de Witt et al., Samuel van Hoogstraten: Catalogue Raisonné, The Hague 2025.
  39. The catalogue of the Vienna exhibition assumes a position for Van Hoogstraten as an assistant for approximately three to four years (Angelina Illes, in: exh. cat. Vienna 2024 (see note 3), p. 29; Jonathan Bikker, in: exh. cat. Vienna 2024 (see note 3), p. 93), though it makes no mention of any teaching responsibilities. These are, however, included in the publication accompanying the exhibition at the Rembrandt House Museum (Michiel Roscam Abbing, in: exh. cat. Amsterdam 2025 (see note 3), p. 19; David De Witt, in: exh. cat. Amsterdam 2025 (see note 3), p. 131), and in the online Van Hoogstraten catalogue raisonné by the RKD (Michiel Roscam Abbing, in: The Hague 2025 (see note 3), “With Rembrandt in Amsterdam”. https://vanhoogstraten.rkdstudies.nl/samuel-van-hoogstraten-the-ingenious-and-poetic-painter/with-rembrandt-inamsterdam/, 26 May 2025).
  40. The term “assistent” was used in Holland in the 17th century, albeit in other contexts, see: Woordenboek Nederlandse taal, s.v. assistent, https://gtb.ivdnt.org/iWDB/search?actie=article&wdb=WNT&id=M004535&lemma=assistent&domein=0&conc=true, 11
    July 2025.
  41. “Een min of meer ondergeschikte helper”, a more or less subordinate helper (see note 5); “A person who helps or supports somebody, usually in their job”: Oxford English Dictionary, s.v. assistant, https://www.oed.com/view/Entry/12041, 11 July 2025.
  42. The guild archive has been lost. For a comprehensive account of the Amsterdam Guild of Saint Luke and its ordinances, see: Isabella H. van Eeghen, “Schilders of Sint Lucasgilde”, in: Isabella H. van Eeghen (ed.), Inventarissen der archieven van de gilden en van het brouwerscollege, Amsterdam 1951, passim.; Isabella H. van Eeghen (Jasper Hillegers, translator), “The Amsterdam Guild of Saint Luke in the 17th Century”, Journal of Historians for Netherlandish Art 4.2 (2012), passim., DOI:10.5092/jhna.2012.4.2.4, 11 July 2025. The current article relies exclusively on the guild regulations of the Amsterdam De Kroniek 2024/25 – Museum Rembrandthuis 10 painters’ guild. It is often assumed that the regulations of painters’ guilds in different Dutch towns did not differ substantially in content. On that assumption, gaps in the regulations of one town might be filled by those of another. However, the discussion later in this article regarding whether apprentices were permitted to produce their own work shows that crucial differences did in fact exist. For that reason, guild regulations from other cities are not used here to fill the gaps in the surviving Amsterdam regulations.
  43. Extract van de willekeuren en ordonnantien den gilde van St. Lucas verleent, Amsterdam 1720, p. 11.
  44. Extract (see note 8), p. 11; This is also the case in the chapter title and margin of the 1766 publication of all known guild charters: Ordonnantien en willekeuren van het Lucas-gilde binnen Amsterdam, Amsterdam 1766, p. 64, 68. It is noteworthy that the dean and headmen of the guild employed a gilde kneght (Extract (see note 8), pp. 26-27. This was not a pupilship, and the tasks meet the definition of an assistant in the Oxford English Dictionary and the Woordenboek Nederlandse Taal (see note 6)
  45. Extract (see note 8), pp. 12-13
  46. Extract (see note 8), pp. 11-12.
  47. Extract (see note 8), p. 12.
  48. Cornelis Kiliaen (ed. Frans Claes), Etymologicum teutonicae linguae, Antwerp 1599 (The Hague 1972), p. 278, s.v. leerionghe; leer-kind; leer-knecht; leerlinck; p. 703, s.v. discipel. In the regulations of the Haarlem Guild of St. Luke from 1634 (NHA, 1105, Ambachtsgilden te Haarlem (Gilden Haarlem), no. 219), the terms “leerling”, “leerjongen”, and “discipel” are
    used. This might suggest that a distinction existed between them, but they are actually used interchangeably. The same applies to the terms “(werk)gezel”, “knecht”, and – a new term – “gast”. The latter is synonymous with journeyman or servant: “Knecht van een ambachtsman of fabrikant; gezel, werkknecht”, servant of a tradesman or manufacturer; journeyman, workshop hand: Woordenboek Nederlandse taal, s.v. gast, https://gtb.ivdnt.org/iWDB/searchactie=article&wdb=WNT&id=M017355.re.35&lemma=werkgast&domein=0&conc=true,
    16 oktober 2025.
  49. Kiliaen, Etymologicum (see note 13), p. 139, s.v. ghe-selle van een ampt. The Latin word “collega” is likewise a translation for “ambtgenoot”, “maet”, and “vennoot” (Kiliaen, Etymologicum (see note 13), p. 18, s.v. ampt-ghenoot; p. 302, s.v. maet, med-maet, maetken; p. 579, s.v. veyn-out, veyn-noot, ven-noot, vennoot, veyn-gnoot).
  50. Kiliaen, Etymologicum (see note 13), p. 244, s.v. knecht, dienaer.
  51. Nicolaas de Roever, “Drie Amsterdamsche Schilders (Pieter Isaaksz, Abraham Vinck, Cornelis van der Voort)”, Oud Holland 3 (1885), p. 198.
  52. In 1619, he was asked together with several artists who had traveled to Italy, including Pieter Lastman, Adriaen van Nieulandt, and Barent van Someren, to assess the authenticity of a Caravaggio painting from the collection of the late Louis Finson. Abraham Bredius, Nicolaas de Roever, “Pieter Lastman en François Venant”, Oud Holland 4 (1886), pp. 7-8.
  53. Ronald de Jager “Meester, leerjongen, leertijd. Een analyse van Zeventiende-eeuwse Noord-Nederlandse leerlingcontracten van kunstschilders, goud- en zilversmeden”, Oud Holland 104 (1990), p. 96, nt. 107. The title of “gezel” is, in fact, never mentioned in the known Amsterdam contracts.
  54. De Jager, “Meester” (see note 18), pp. 73-75.
  55. De Jager, “Meester” (see note 18), p. 71.
  56. Stadsarchief Amsterdam (hereafter SAA), 5075, 393A, nots. Jacob Jacobs and Nicolaes Jacobs, ff. 59r-59v, 20-07-1626; Abraham Bredius, “Gerrit Willemsz. Horst”, Oud Holland 50 (1933), pp. 5-6; De Jager, “Meester” (see note 18), p. 98, no. 7.
  57. This underscores a clear distinction: as was also evidenced by the entries in Kiliaen, Etymologicum (see note 13), dienaer was a synonym for knecht, not for leerknecht (see note 15).
  58. Abraham Bredius, Künstlerinventare. Urkunden zur Geschichte der holländischen Kunst des XVIten, XVIIten und XVIIIten Jahrhunderts V, The Hague 191, pp. 1482-1483; De Jager, “Meester” (see note 18), p. 98, no. 10.
  59. The value of a barrel of herring in Amsterdam in 1635 was approximately 120 grams of silver (Bo Poulsen, Dutch Herring. An Environmental History, c. 1600–1860, Amsterdam 2008, p. 93, table 6.9); in the seventeenth century, ten grams of silver corresponded to the value of roughly one guilder.
  60. The tuition fees in Holland for a two-year contract averaged 61.5 guilders per year (De Jager, “Meester” (see note 18), p. 75).
  61. Josua Bruyn, “Een onderzoek naar 17de -eeuwse schilderijformaten, voornamelijk in Noord-Nederland”, Oud Holland 93 (1979), p. 113.
  62. Abraham Bredius, Künstlerinventare. Urkunden zur Geschichte der holländischen Kunst des XVIten, XVIIten und XVIIIten Jahrhunderts II, The Hague 1916, pp. 400-401; De Jager, “Meester” (see note 18), p. 98
  63. As a journeyman painter Waltusz earned less than half the daily wage of peers in other trades. In 1652, journeymen carpenters and bricklayers in Amsterdam earned approximately 26 to 27 stivers per summer day (although there are no exact figures for 1651, data is available for 1633, 27 and 25 stivers respectively, and for 1667, 28 and 27 stivers respectively).
    This disparity between painter’s journeymen and their peers in other trades mirrors the situation in 1579. The guild
    regulations (gildebrief) of the St. Luke’s Guild from that year mention journeymen earning 4 stivers and others earning 10
    stivers per day (Ordonnantien (see note 9), p. 17, art. 11). Taking the average of 7 stivers, these were notably low wages –
    practically half – when compared to the 14 and 12 stivers earned by carpenters and bricklayers, respectively, in that same
    year. For the wages of the workers mentioned here, see: Hubert Nutseling, Welvaart en werkgelegenheid in Amsterdam
    1540–1860, Amsterdam/Dieren 1985, p. 252, appendix 5.1, table A.
  64. SAA, DTB 5001, 469, p. 241, 30-09-1651; Judith van Gent, Bartholomeus van der Helst (circa 1613-1670): een studie naar zijn leven en zijn werk, Utrecht (Utrecht University), p. 41.
  65. Virtually nothing is known about Gerardus van Berleborch (Bernard Renckens, “G. van Berkborch”, Oud Holland 84 (1967), no. 4, passim). He or his father was likely from the region around Bad Berleburg in Germany. He appears to have been present in Leiden in 1665, when he is recorded as a witness (“Gerrit van Berleberg”) at the baptism of a child of the painter Jacobus Geutkien (Erfgoed Leiden en Omstreken (hereafter ELO), DTB 1004, 237, fol. 236v, 3-12-1665).
  66. SAA, 5075, 875, not. Jacob van Zwieten, pp. 638-640, 16-10-1649; Johannes G. van Dillen, Bronnen tot de geschiedenis van het bedrijfsleven en het gildewezen van Amsterdam 1510-1672 III, p. 540, no. 1057.
  67. A possible reason for this may be that young painters attained the status of master more quickly. This benefited the guild financially, as it earned income only from masters and pupils, not from journeymen.
  68. Ordonnantien (see note 9), p. 10, art. 3.
  69. Ordonnantien (see note 9), p. 17, art. 11.
  70. Joachim von Sandrart’s famous anecdote about Rembrandt’s studio being filled with “countless elite children”, pupils who each paid an annual tuition fee of 100 guilders suggests that the legal limit on the number of pupils was, in practice, a dead letter (Joachim von Sandrardt, Teutsche Academie, Nuremberg 1675, p. 326; Van Eeghen, “Guild” (see note 7), p. 6).
  71. Young Man Reading with a Vanitas Still Life, 1644, oil on panel, 58 x 74 cm, Rotterdam, Museum Boijmans Van Beuningen, inv. no. 1386; Self-portrait, 1644, oil on panel, 63 x 48 cm, The Hague, Museum Bredius, inv. no. 056-1946; Self-portrait, 1645, oil on panel, 54.1 x 44.8 cm, Liechtenstein, The Princely Collections, Vaduz-Vienna, inv. no. GE 107; Portrait of a Child, 1645, oil on panel, 68.6 x 57.8 cm, private collection; The Adoration of the Shepherds, 1647, oil on canvas, 58.2 x 70.8 cm, Dordrecht, Dordrechts Museum, inv. no. DM/980/567.
  72. Godefridus J. Hoogewerff, De geschiedenis van de St. Lucasgilden in Nederland, Amsterdam 1947, p. 24; Ernst van de Wetering “Problems of Pupilship and Studio Practice” in: Josua Bruyn et al., A Corpus of Rembrandt Paintings II: 1631-1634, Amsterdam 1986, p. 57; Bikker, Drost (see note 2), p. 11; Angelina Illes, in: exh. cat. Vienna 2024 (see note 3), p. 29.
  73. Samuel Muller Fz., Schilders-vereenigingen te Utrecht. Bescheiden uit het Gemeentearchief, Utrecht 1880, p. 76; Frederik D.O. Obreen, Archief voor Nederlandsche Kunstgeschiedenis IV, Rotterdam 1881/1882, p. 51. The very fact that such a regulation had to be instituted in these cities already indicates that works were being signed by non-masters.
  74. De Jager, “Meester” (see note 18), pp. 77-79.
  75. Bruyn, “Onderzoek”, (see note 26), p. 113.
  76. David de Witt, Leonore van Sloten, in: The Hague 2025 (see note 3), “Rembrandt’s Impact”, https://vanhoogstraten.rkdstudies.nl/catalogus-schilderijen/rembrandts-impact/, 3 June 2025.
  77. Almost exclusively, reference is made to Bikker, Drost (see note 2), p. 11. Also in the exhibition catalogue of the Van Hoogstraten exhibition in Amsterdam, Drost is cited as an example of an early student of Van Hoogstraten (David de Witt, in: exh. cat. Amsterdam 2025 (see note 3), p. 131.
  78. Since Daniël Pont’s monograph on Barent Fabritius, (Daniël Pont, Barent Fabritius 1624–1673, The Hague, 1958) and Sumowski’s Drawings of the Rembrandt School (see note 2), no subsequent scholarly efforts have systematically De Kroniek 2024/25 – Museum Rembrandthuis 12 reconstructed his drawn oeuvre or analyzed the development of his distinctive style. The author’s forthcoming dissertation addresses this lacuna, and catalogues drawings by Barent Fabritius.
  79. Pont was among the first to suggest he may not have been a direct pupil of Rembrandt, but instead only came into contact with Rembrandt’s work indirectly, through his brother Carel (Pont, Barent (see note 43), p. 96). In the literature, uncertainty on this matter appears to have become the norm, with scholars consistently noting – or implicitly dealing with – the lack of evidence for a formal pupilship with Rembrandt (see: Paul Huys Jansen, Werner Sumowski, The Hoogsteder Exhibition of Rembrandt’s Academy, exh. cat. The Hague: Hoogsteder & Hoogsteder, 1992, p. 139; Walter A. Liedkte in: Hubert von Sonneburg, Rembrandt/Not Rembrandt in the Metropolitan Museum of Art I, exh. cat. New York City: The Metropolitan Museum of Art, 1995, cat. 48, pp. 145-146; Peter C. Sutton in: Albert Blankert, Rembrandt. A Genius and his impact, exh. cat. Melbourne: National Gallery of Victoria; Canberra: National Gallery of Australia, 1997, p. 283; Jan Blanc, Dans l’atelier de Rembrandt. Le maître et ses élèves, Paris 2006, p. 140.
  80. Holm Bevers, “Das Susanna-Thema im Werkstattzusammenhang: Zeichnungen”, in: Holm Bevers, Katja Kleinert, Claudia Laurenze-Landsberg, Rembrandts Berliner Susanna und die beiden Alten. Die Schaffung eins meisterwerks, exh. cat. Berlin: Staatliche Museen zu Berlin, Kupferstichkabinett; Gemäldegalerie, 2015, pp. 49-50.
  81. Katja Kleinert, Claudia Laurenze-Landsberg, “Wandlungen eines Gemäldes. Rembrandts Berliner Susanna und die beiden Alten”, in: exh. cat. Berlin 2015 (see note 45), p. 19, 32.
  82. See for instance Rembrandt’s Holy Family in the Carpenter’s workshop or his Star of the Kings (London, The British Museum, inv. nos. 1900,0824.144, 1910,0212.189).
  83. The drawing of a male model (here attributed to Barent Fabritius) has been described as stylistically very close to Van Hoogstraten (Martin Royalton-Kisch in: Catalogue of Drawings by Rembrandt and his School, London: The British Museum, 2010, cat. 71). The Departure of the Prodigal Son, a drawing already earlier attributed to Fabritius, is still considered a work by Van Hoogstraten (Frankfurt am Main, Städel Museum, inv. no. 817).
  84. A convincing spatial representation of the scene, achieved through a successful use of proportion, perspective, light, and color. For a elaboration on this definition, including references, see: Leonore van Sloten, “Regels voor de kunst”, in: David de Witt, Leonore van Sloten, Jaap van der Veen, Rembrandts late leerlingen. In de leer bij een genie, exh. cat. Amsterdam: Rembrandt House Museum, 2015, p. 73, note 31.
  85. In drawings by Barent Fabritius from the second half of the 1640s, his preparatory chalk underdrawing is generally careful and precise but not detailed, with clear, exact contours rendered in continuous, rounded lines. The somewhat squat figures possess a doll-like, slightly caricatural character. When using pen to trace or fill in the figures, particularly those in the foreground, the style becomes sketchier and more angular. Fabritius’s hatching lines become more carefully placed as they  grow finer, laid loosely side by side with only occasional thin-pen scratching, while thicker lines, including contours, are rendered in a zigzag, looser manner, often applied to foreground elements such as a repoussoir. Groups of hatching in shadowed, complex motifs (e.g., figures or foreground foliage) are neither intertwined nor uniformly oriented, and though the balance of light and shadow varies between drawings, it remains consistent within each composition; early mastery is evident in his wash applications, where loosely brushed transitions in shadows lend a painterly quality, enhancing figural plasticity and atmospheric depth, as seen in drawings with dramatic chiaroscuro effects.
  86. Although it has been argued by Holm Bevers that this drawing is by Constantijn Daniël van Renesse and dates from between 1650 and 1652 (Holm Bevers, “Ausstellungen zu Rembrandt in Rückblick”, Kunstchronik, 58 (2005), p. 480; Holm Bevers, in: Rembrandt. Die Zeichnungen im Berliner Kupferstichkabinett, exh. cat. Berlin: Staatliche Museen zu Berlin, Kupferstichkabinett, 2006, cat. no. 45, p. 158, nt. 12; Holm Bevers in: Holm Bevers et al., Drawings by Rembrandt and his Pupils. Telling the Difference, exh. cat. Los Angeles: The J. Paul Getty Museum, 2009, cat. no. 31.2, pp. 190-191), a number of features are so uncharacteristic of Van Renesse that the attribution cannot be sustained. This applies in particular to elements such as the heavy, coarse scratches in the shadow areas and the sketch-like rendering of the faces of Joseph and Mary. Van Renesse typically keeps shadow areas and light transitions in brush clear and even. Also characteristic is his meticulous penwork, marked by fine, short strokes in the contours and hatching lines (see for instance: The Judgment of Salomon, New York City (The Metropolitan Museum of Art, Robert Lehman Collection, inv. no. 1975.1.806; Daniel in the Lion’s Den, Rotterdam, Museum Boijmans Van Beuningen, inv. no. MB 200). Generally, it shows the boldness of Barent much more than the careful restraint of Renesse
  87. “Beeter waer ‚t dat [om de veranderin[g]] een eesel van achteren was, dan dat al de hoofden iuist wt het stuck sien. Dat oock omtrent de boom wat meerder groente was. | 1 losep heft af te swaer en te onbesuist | 2 Maria most het kindeken wat meerder vieren, want een teeder kint magh sulck duwen niet ver[dragen]. | losep al te kort en dick, sijn hooft wast hem wt de [borst?]. Sijn hebben alle beide al te groote koppen”. Transcript from: Leonore van Sloten, in: exh. cat. Amsterdam 2015 (see note 49), p. 73, nt. 27. “It would be better that [for the alteration] there were a donkey from the back, than that all the heads are looking straight out of the work. That there were also somewhat more greenery around the tree. | 1 Joseph lifts too heavily and too inconsiderately. | 2 Mary ought to ease the little child somewhat more, for a tender infant cannot [endure] such pushing. | Joseph is all too short and stout, his head grows out of the [chest?]. They both have all too large heads”. These instructions are also partly articulated within the drawing itself. Joseph is indeed shown tugging firmly at Mary’s arm, whereas in the more sketch-like version, he supports her more gently at the back. The small patch of greenery in the lower corner may also be a later addition, in correspondence with the suggestion.
  88. The face does not appear to be a correction in the technical sense, but rather an example of a foreshortened face viewed from below – a challenging principle of perspective.
  89. An attribution proposed Christian Dittrich (Christian Dittrich in: Christian Dittrich, Thomas Ketelsen, Rembrandt. Die Dresdener Zeichnungen 2004, exh. cat. Dresden: Staatliche Kunstsammlungen Dresden, Kupferstich-Kabinett, 2004, cat. no.14, pp. 80-81).
  90. Brusati implied the possibility that the text was written partly by Rembrandt and partly by Van Hoogstraten (Celeste Brusati, Artifice & Illusion. The Art and Writing of Samuel van Hoogstraten, Chicago/London 1995, pp. 31, 275, note 40). Rembrandt was excluded as the author of the instructions by Bevers, while Van Hoogstraten as author remained an option. Van Renesse was likewise ruled out by Bevers, based on a comparison with the handwriting on his Daniel in the Lions’ Den drawing and The Judgment of Solomon drawing (see note 51); Holm Bevers, in: exh. cat. Los Angeles 2009 (see note 51), cat. 31.1–31.2, p. 190; 191, note 3). To this may be added that the handwriting also closely resembles that of Barent Fabritius. Although little comparative material survives, the compact, small script of Fabritius’s name beneath the death inventory of his sister-in-law Aeltje, dated 24 April 1643 (SAA, 5075, 1628a, not. David de l’Hommel, p. 399), shows a strong resemblance to the instructions on the Dresden sheet.
  91. “Once you have mastered your handling and your eye is somewhat clarified, it will no longer trouble you to translate many naturalistic paintings into a naturalistic drawing”. “Wanneer gy uwe handeling nu machtich zijt, en uw oog wat verklaert is, zoo zal ‚t u ook niet verscheelen veel verwige Schilderyen in een verwige teykeningen na te klaren” (Van Hoogstraten, Inleyding (see note 1), p. 27)
  92. “I advise masters, when they review the drawings of their pupils, to improve them by making sketches of the same subject themselves. This is an excellent exercise and has greatly assisted many in the art of composition”. “De meesters raed ik, als ze de Teykeningen haerer discipelen overzien, datze de zelve, met schetssen op ‚t zelve voorwerp te maeken, verbeeteren. Dit oeffent ongemeen, en heeft veelen geweldich in de schikkunst geholpen” (Van Hoogstraten, Inleyding (see note 1), p. 192).
  93. “And certainly, this manner of drawing with pen and brush is likewise the most suitable for completing a masterly work in its full force. For one can also, whenever it proves convenient, work into it with red chalk and crayons, as though one were almost painting with colours”. “En zeker deeze wijze van met pen en pinseel te teykenen, is ook allerbequaemst om een meesterlijk werk in zijn volle kracht te voleinden. Dewijl men’er ook, als’t pas geeft, met rood krijt en kryons in kan speelen, als of men byna met verwen schilderde” (Van Hoogstraten, Inleyding (see note 1), p. 31.
  94. On stylistic grounds, this Rembrandt drawing has been placed among a group of history drawings dating to around 1650 (Otto Benesch, The Drawings of Rembrandt V, New York 1957, no. 902). Among other arguments, this dating led Bevers to attribute the Dresden drawing to Constantijn van Renesse, rather than Barent Fabritius (Holm Bevers, in: exh. cat. Berlin 2006 (see note 51), cat. no. 45, p. 157, 158, nt. 12) However, it remains questionable whether the Rembrandt drawing in Berlin should be understood within that context. Unlike the other history drawings, this work is not an autonomous composition but rather a sketched response to the Dresden sheet. It is plausible that the sketch was already made around 1647. In terms of linework, it is not far removed from the portrait sketch of Jan Six, dating from in or before 1647 (Amsterdam, Six Collection).
    It is drawn in a similarly free style, applied in a sketch, comparable to other drawings from the second half of the 1640’s (see
    note 47). Rembrandt’s Berlin drawing could thus have been made quite soon after Fabritius’s corrected drawing
  95. Josua Bruyn, “Gemälde der Rembrandt-Schüler II by Werner Sumowski Review”, Oud Holland 101 (1987) no. 3, p. 229.
  96. https://rkd.nl/images/313061, 17 July 2025. In terms of drawing style, this work is not far removed from Van Hoogstraten’s drawing The Sacrifice of Manoah of 1649 (Braunschweig, Herzog Anton Ulrich Museum, inv. no. Z 335; https://rkd.nl/images/71286, 17 July 2025). We may even assume that The Crucifixion predates it; the departing angel in the  Braunschweig drawing – also seen from the back – appears to be a more developed and refined treatment of the motif of a figure seen from behind.
  97. Samuel van Hoogstraten, The Adoration of the Shepherds. London, The British Museum, inv. no. 1895,0915.1203; https://rkd.nl/images/313552, 17 July 2025. A drawing of The Circumcision, likewise painted as a part of the Passion series in 1646, has been attributed to Gerbrand van den Eeckhout (Brussels, Koninklijke Musea voor Schone Kunsten België, inv. no. 4060/1212). There are also two copies after Rembrandt’s Holy Family with a Curtain from 1646 (London, The British Museum, inv. no. 1895,0915.1200; Oxford, Ashmolean Museum, inv. no. WA1986.56).
  98. Josua Bruyn in: Josua Bruyn et al., A Corpus of Rembrandt Paintings III: 1635-1642, Amsterdam 1989 pp. 13-16.
  99. Martin Royalton-Kisch, Drawings by Rembrandt and his Circle in the British Museum, London: The British Museum, 1992, cat. no. 87, pp. 180-182; Holm Bevers, “Drawings in Rembrandt’s Workshop”, in: exh. cat. Los Angeles 2009 (see note 51), pp. 13-17; David de Witt, “Leren van het leven: tekeningen van Rembrandts leerlingen” in: Judith Noorman, David de Witt, Rembrandts Naakte Waarheid. Tekenen naar naaktmodellen in de Gouden Eeuw, exh. cat. Amsterdam: Rembrandt House Museum, 2015, pp. 117-120.
  100. Initially, this drawing was attributed to Rembrandt, but as early as 1908, this attribution was already being questioned (Martin Conway, “Some Rembrandt Drawings”, Burlington Magazine 14 (1908/1909), p.37).
  101. This sheet has previously been judged the weakest of the three (David de Witt, in: exh. cat. Amsterdam 2015 (see note 64), p. 118), and it has even been suggested that Rembrandt may have corrected it. (Martin Royalton-Kisch, in: col. cat. London 2010 (see note 48), cat. 71). The fine parallel pen strokes in the boy’s torso are comparable to those in the body of Susanna in the Budapest drawing. The somewhat arbitrary use of red chalk (in the model’s right armpit area, on the reverse side of the cushion, and in the upper left corner) also stands out in both sheets. The type of loose, heavy pen lines used for the cushion corresponds to those found in the cloak of the old man in the Susanna drawing.
  102. For a first suggestion of Bol being the assistant of Rembrandt, see: Albert Blanckert, Ferdinand Bol (1616-1680). Rembrandt’s Pupil, Doornspijk 1982, pp. 17-18.
  103. Blanckert, Bol (see note 67), pp. 17-18; David de Witt, “Ferdinand Bol, discipel van Rembrandt”, in: Norbert Middelkoop, Ferdinand Bol en Govert Flinck. Rembrandts meesterleerlingen, Amsterdam (Rembrandt House Museum/Amsterdam Museum) 2017, pp. 44-45
  104. Portrait of a Lady, 1642. Berlin, Staatliche Museen zu Berlin, Gemäldegalerie, inv. no. 809. However, there are paintings by Bol, or attributed to him, of an earlier date or dating. The Liberation of St Peter (private collection), dated around 1636, may be, given its strong connection to the work of Benjamin Cuyp (David de Witt, in: exh. cat. Amsterdam 2017 (see note 68), pp. 42-43), made before Bol’s departure to Amsterdam. Gideon’s Sacrifice of 1640, signed by Bol (Utrecht, Museum Catharijneconvent, inv. no. RMCC s24), is typical in subject matter and composition of his later work from the 1640s, and may
    be made under conditions comparable to those proposed in this article for the paintings by Van Hoogstraten, dating from
    between 1644 and 1647. Other works attributed to Bol prior to 1642 are often copies or adaptations of compositions by
    Rembrandt.
  105. Christopher Brown, Carel Fabritius, Oxford 1981, p. 47; Gero Seelig in: Frederik J. Duparc, Carel Fabritius 1622-1654, exh. cat. The Hague: Mauritshuis; Schwerin: Staatliches Museum, 2004-2005, cat. no. 4, p. 97.
  106. Erna Kok erroneously states that Bol is mentioned as Rembrandt’s “werckgesel” in a document of 30 August 1640 (Erna Kok, “Govert Flinck en Ferdinand Bol en hun netwerken van opdrachtgevers,” in: exh. cat. Amsterdam 2017 (see note 68), p. 71, p. 244, n. 37). Bol’s exact role during his time in Rembrandt’s workshop is never documented. It is striking that the drawn copies after three of Rembrandt’s paintings from around 1636 are attributed to Ferdinand Bol (Peter Schatborn, “Tekeningen van Govert Flinck en Ferdinand Bol”, in: exh. cat. Amsterdam 2017 (see note 68), p.185). Apart from these sheets and those datable around 1646 by later pupils, there are few, if any, known drawings by Rembrandt’s pupils that are direct copies after his history or figure paintings. It is possible that Bol played an important role in introducing this method into the studio, and that it was later adopted by Van Hoogstraten. Van Hoogstraten is likely to have been in contact with Bol while in Amsterdam. After Bol established himself as an independent master, around 1642, he too began to draw in red chalk. He did so, however, almost exclusively in preparatory studies for (mainly) paintings – see, for instance, Joseph brings his Father before Pharaoh (Dresden, Gemäldegalerie, inv. no. 1605), and its preliminary drawing (Amsterdam, Rijksmuseum, inv. no. RP-T-1883-A-276). Van Hoogstraten may well have adopted this practice from him. This suggests that, even as an official pupil of Rembrandt, Van Hoogstraten felt the freedom to look to the work of other contemporaries as well. Van Sloten has argued that Bol continued to visit Rembrandt during the first half of the 1640s (Leonore van Sloten, “Ferdinand Bol, de etser”, in: exh. cat. Amsterdam 2017 (see note 68), pp. 218–221). Bol’s use of red chalk for preparatory studies may therefore have been the source of Van Hoogstraten’s conception that the use of red chalk contributes to the painterly quality of a drawing.
  107. Arnold Houbraken, De groote schouburgh der Nederlantsche konstschilders en schilderessen, Amsterdam, 1976, p. 165.

In memoriam Ger Luijten (1956-2022)

On Monday, 19 December 2022, at the age of 66, drs. Ger Luijten, art historian and director of the Fondation Custodia in Paris, very suddenly passed away. With his death, the art historical world has lost not only a particularly amicable person, but also an important connoisseur and champion. The Rembrandt House collaborated with Ger and his team in Paris on various projects; driven by a mutual love of works on paper, old as well as new. But also in his earlier role as Head of the Print Collection at the Rijksmuseum, the Rembrandt House could always count on Ger’s enthusiastic and generous collaboration, arising from a powerful drive to share art with others.

After completing his studies in Art History at Utrecht University, Ger embarked on his museum career in 1987 at Museum Boijmans Van Beuningen, where he served until 1990 as research assistant for the Rotterdam collection of prints and drawings. He left for the Rijksmuseum in Amsterdam to become Chief Curator of prints of the Rijksprentenkabinet, where in 2001 he was appointed Head of the Print Collection. Exhibitions he produced during this period on drawings and prints of the 16th and 17th centuries yielded important catalogues such as Dawn of the Golden Age. Northern Netherlandish Art, 1580-1620 and Mirror of Everyday Life: Genre Prints in the Netherlands, 1550-1700. As part of his work in explaining and sharing the art of printmaking, Ger also played an important role as editor of catalogues of oeuvres of Dutch and Flemish printmakers who appeared in the Hollstein series. He served on the editorial boards of scholarly periodicals, including Simiolus. And he was closely involved, as board member, in activities and developments at the RKD and the Vereniging Rembrandt.

Collaboration between Ger and the Rembrandt House mostly took place during his early years as director of the Fondation Custodia. In 2010 Ger succeeded the retired Mària van Berge-Gerbaud as director, and for the twelve ensuing years Ger devoted himself with heart and soul to the foundation that administers the legacy of Frits Lugt, and to the staff that cares every day for this important Dutch collection in Paris. The collection of the Fondation is linked to that of the Rembrandt House Museum thanks to the presence of work by Rembrandt. Besides works by many other artists, Frits Lugt acquired a considerable number of prints by Rembrandt, of extraordinary quality. And at the same time also a large group of drawings, plus no less than two handwritten letters by the master. In 2010/11 the Rembrandt House Museum and Fondation Custodia dedicated an exhibition to Frits Lugt and his collection, entitled Kabinet van een kenner (Un cabinet particulier / A connoisseur’s cabinet). And in 2012 the Fondation and the Rembrandt House were two of the three venues to present selections of drawings from the collection of the Hamburger Kunsthalle, on the occasion of the completion of a comprehensive collection catalogue of this German collection of Netherlandish works on paper.  

Besides a fascination for Rembrandt, our institutions also share a love of contemporary graphic art. Both the Rembrandt House and Fondation own a substantial collection of work by contemporary graphic artists – more specifically etchers, whose work is indebted to Rembrandt. In collaboration with the Hercules Segers Foundation and on the initiative of former Rembrandt House director Ed de Heer many exhibitions of these graphic artists were presented. Under Mària van Berge-Gerbaud the Fondation had already joined this initiative. Upon his appointment Ger continued with it and in 2013 the two museums organized the exhibition Peter Vos. Metamorfosen. When new leadership of the Rembrandt House decided in 2017 to take leave of these monographic exhibitions, Ger continued with renewed passion. In recent years he opened the Paris venue for graphic artists Anna Metz and Siemen Dijkstra, among others.

Ger’s love of the arts, and in particular for art that is refined and poetic, found expression not only in important exhibitions and publications but also in personal contact with others. Enthusiastic, and drawing on vast knowledge, Ger always knew how to clarify what art has to say. The gift of conveying knowledge and passion made him a great teacher of young art historians and everyone who worked with him. The memories of Ger’s inspiring personality, but also of visits to the Fondation, where Ger toured us through the museum and his new collection of “sublime” oil sketches, will always remain with us.

Leonore van Sloten, Senior Curator, Rembrandt House Museum

Ger in passionate conversation in the galleries of the Fondation Custodia. Photo: Fondation Custoria.
Ger in passionate conversation in the galleries of the Fondation Custodia. Photo: Fondation Custoria.

 

  1. Werner Sumowski, Paul Huys Janssen, The Hoogsteder Exhibition of Rembrandt’s Academy, exh. cat. The Hague: Hoogsteder & Hoogsteder, 1992, cat. no. 28.
  2. Exhibition catalogues: Albert Blanckert, Jezus in de Gouden Eeuw, exh. cat. Rotterdam: Kunsthal, 2000–2001; Akira Kofuku, Rembrandt and the Rembrandt School. The Bible, mythology and ancient history, exh. cat. Tokyo: Museum of Western Art, 2003; Arthur K. Wheelock et al., Jan Lievens. A Dutch Master Rediscovered, exh. cat. Washington: National Gallery of Art; Milwaukee: Milwaukee Art Museum; Amsterdam: Rembrandt House Museum, 2008-2009, cat.no. 52; Louis van Tilborgh, Constantijn Huygens. Kunstkenner en verzamelaar, exh. cat. The Hague: Museum Bredius, 2013, cat. no. 14. Other literature: Werner Sumowski, Gemälde der Rembrandtschüler, vol. 4, Landau, 1983, p. 3726, no. 2356, fig. 3964; Helga Gutbrod, Lievens und Rembrandt : Studien zum Verhältnis ihrer Kunst, Frankfurt am Main, 1996, p. 299; Edwin Buijssen (ed.), Haagse schilders in de Gouden Eeuw, Het Hoogsteder lexicon van alle schilders werkzaam in Den Haag 1600-1700, The Hague, 1998, p. 191; Lloyd DeWitt, Evolution and Ambition in the career of Jan Lievens, 1607-1674, Phd. Diss. University of Maryland, College Park, 2006, p. 228.
  3. DeWitt, Evolution (see note 2), p. 228.
  4. For example those mentioned in the Montias Database of 17th Century Dutch Art Inventories and the Getty Provenance Research Index.
  5. Sumowski, Huys Janssen, Academy (see note 1), p. 220.
  6. Dr Gaston Gaudinot sale, Paris (Drouot), 13-14 February 1869.
  7. Sumowski, Huys Janssen, Academy (see note 1), p. 220.
  8. Ibid.
  9. Sumowski, Huys Janssen, Academy (see note 1), p. 226. Huys Janssen explains that the miracle as described in Luke and John differs from the version told by Matthew.
  10. After listening to the centurion, and before addressing him directly, Jesus speaks to his followers: “I tell you, many will come from east and west and sit at table with Abraham, Isaac, and Jacob in the kingdom of heaven.” (Matthew 8:11) Perhaps Lievens incorporated this part of the text and explicitly included people coming from the east (from the standpoint of his Dutch audience). A second possibility is that they are Pharisees. This group plays the role elsewhere in Matthew of disbelieving critics, and here they may serve to accentuate the belief of the centurion in the Christian faith. In early prints (Sebald Beham, Israhel van Meckenem, Hans Schaüfelein and Cornelis Massijs) and several Italian prints from Lievens’s time (seventeenth century prints after Paolo Veronese), Pharisees wear such headdresses. A parallel between blacks and overseas regions, such as in Lievens’s Brinio, is convincingly outlined by Elmer Kolfin (in: Elmer Kolfin, De kunst van de macht, Jordaens, Lievens en Rembrandt in het Paleis op de Dam, Zwolle, 2023, p. 67), does not seem to apply here.
  11. Sumowski, Huys Janssen, Academy (see note 1), p. 223.
  12. Sumowski, Huys Janssen, Academy (see note 1), pp. 223, 226.
  13. The right eye from the perspective of the viewer. There, a pupil was painted in, in a later restoration. Because of the sketchy manner it is difficult to ascertain whether or not both eyes are present, but in the left the lower eyelid is visible, while it is undefined in the right eye.
  14. For example: Jacobus Neeffs (after Jacob Jordaens), Judgement of Christ, etching, c. 1630-1645; Marinus van der Goes (after Jacques Jordaens), Judgement of Christ, engraving, c. 1614-1639; Willem Panneels (after Peter Paul Rubens), Adoration of the kings, etching, 1630; Nicolaes Lauwers (after Peter Paul Rubens), Ecce Homo, engraving, c. 1619-1652; and many more. Generally, for examples of inspiration drawn from prints by Lievens, see De
    Witt, Evolution (see note 2).
  15. Sumowski, Huys Janssen, Academy (see note 1), p. 226. Huys Janssen refers to examples by Nicolaes Moeyaert (Herentals, St. Waltrudis church) and Adam Camerarius (Amsterdam, Rijksmuseum, inv. no. SK-A-733). DeWitt refers to a painting by Bartholomeus Breenbergh (Karlsruhe, Staatliche Kunsthalle Karlsruhe, inv. no. 228) and the Moeyaert in Herentals (DeWitt, Evolution (see note 2), p. 227). But also see a woodcut with this subject by Cornelis van Sichem II in Der zielen lusthof (1629). Also of interest: Claes Moeyeart, Christ and the Centurion, 1632 (Minneapolis, Minneapolis Institute of Art, inv. no. 2012.84.5). Although the painting is known under this subject, it may in fact depict Cornelius kneeling before Peter, since more than one figure is shown kneeling and the composition closely resembles prints of this subject.
  16. Henri van de Waal, “’s Lands oudste verleden in de voorstelling van Vondel en zijn tijdgenooten”, Elsevier’s Maandschrift 47 (1937); Henri van de Waal, “Tempesta en de historieschilderingen op het Amsterdamse stadhuis”, Oud Holland 56 (1939); Henri van de Waal, Drie eeuwen vaderlandsche geschied-uitbeelding 1500-1800, een iconologische studie, The Hague, 1952; Kolfin, Kunst (see note 10).
  17. Antonio Tempesta (after Otto van Veen), Print 8 in (…)De Batavische oft oude Hollandtsche oorloghe teghen de Romeynen, 1612. Etching, 167 x 210 mm. Rijksmuseum, Amsterdam, inv. no. RP-P-OB-37.614. Jürgen Ovens based his drawing for the Batavian Series depicting Claudius Civilis leaving the Women and Children to fight at Xanten (Hamburg, Hamburger Kunsthalle, inv. no. 22342) on this print.
  18. On the period in The Hague: Buijssen Haagse (see note 2), pp.191-193.
  19. Haarlem, Teylers Museum, inv. no. P 006. For the identification and context, see: Gregor Weber, “Dus leeft de dappre Graaf: Zu einem Bildnis Andries de Graeffs von Jan Lievens (1607-1674)”, Oud Holland 99 (1985), pp. 44-56.
  20. Van de Waal, Eeuwen (see note 16), p. 230; Kolfin, De kunst van de macht (see note 10), pp. 19-20.
  21. Van de Waal, “’s Lands” (see note 16), p. 301-302.
  22.  Kolfin, Kunst (see note 10), p. 41. Four Batavian scenes were never completed. For two the themes are known, for the other two are not known.
  23. Munich, Staatliche Graphische Sammlung München, inv. no. 1451; Hamburg, Hamburger Kunsthalle, Kupferstichkabinett, inv. no. 22342. A lesser-known drawing of Rembrandt’s Conspiracy of Claudius Civilis (Edinburgh, National Galleries of Scotland, inv. no. D 23862) shows – when compared to the drawing in Munich – that the lower section of the painting is covered by a frieze and that portions of the left and right sides are obscured. This may indicate that an alternative conception of the framing of the lunettes was considered before the one ultimately implemented. It is possible that this earlier framing was already envisioned when Lievens produced his oil sketch Christ and the Centurion.
  24. Van de Waal, Eeuwen (see note 16), p. 225, referring to SAA, 5039, 2 resolutieboek, f. 66r.
  25. Ibid., referring to SAA, 5039, 153 rapiamus 1661, f.195v.
  26. Van de Waal, Eeuwen (see note 16), p. 225.
  27. Gregor Weber, “Jan Lievens’s ‘The Shield-raising of Brinio’ a Second Oil Sketch”, Hoogsteder-Naumann Mercury 12/13 (1992), nt. 8.
  28. Dewitt, Evolution (see note 2), p. 221.
  29. Kolfin, Kunst (see note 10), p.67.
  30. Kolfin, Kunst (see note 10), p. 44.
  31. For, among other things, contemporary poetry in which Civilis and others are compared to the members of the House of Orange: Van de Waal, Eeuwen (see note 16), pp. 220-221, 223.
  32. Kolfin, Kunst (see note 10), p. 47.
  33. Margriet van Eikema Hommes, Elmer Kolfin, De Oranjezaal in Huis ten Bosch, Een zaal uit loutere liefde, Zwolle, 2013, p. 77.
  34. Kolfin, Kunst (see note 10), pp. 41-47, 77.
  35. One may ask, in light of points discussed in this article, whether the “Christ” figure in the first version was in fact Christ at all. If so, the oil sketch would initially have represented solely a Christian scene without any reference to the Batavian Revolt, thereby less relatable to the (eventual) decoration program of the Town Hall’s gallery. Given that in the initial design the groups left and right with Biblical and/or eastern figures do not seem to have been included (aside from a bearded man on the right, judging from the x-ray), the large central figure may originally have been Julius Civilis. In compositional terms, this would align the painting more closely with the print by Tempesta after Van Veen. The apparent similarity in hairstyle between the final Christ figure and the initial figure, together with the possible initial presence of a (holy) beam of light directed toward the figure, may argue against this hypothesis; nevertheless, Brinno in Lievens’s Brinio Raised on the Shield likewise features long hair and even incorporates a diagonal compositional line through the clouds, comparable to the line through the foliage in the initial version of the present subject. The later insertion of Christ could then be understood as a deliberate twist, imparting a more prominent Christian meaning to the historical scene. These suggestions and observations were kindly shared by Jochem van Eijsden.
  36. Samuel van Hoogstraten, Inleyding tot de hooge schoole der schilderkonst: anders de zichtbaere werelt, Rotterdam 1678, p. 18. Van Hoogstraten here refers to the period when he was “still a disciple”, during which, as part of a “we”, he and others discussed a particular question, to which a certain “Fabritius” responded with an answer. It is generally assumed that this refers to Carel Fabritius, who is assumed to have studied with Rembrandt between approximately 1641 and 1643.
  37. Werner Sumowski described Van Hoogstraten as “pädagogisch begabt, Assistent Rembrandts gewesen” (Werner Sumowski, Gemälde der Rembrandt-Schüler II, Landau/Pfalz 1984, p. 1286). As supporting evidence, Sumowski argued that Van Hoogstraten corrected drawings by Constantijn Daniël van Renesse (; p. 1290, nt. 2). When discussing one of these drawings (Moses and Reuel’s Daughters at the Well, Amsterdam, Rijksmuseum, inv. no. RP-T-1893-A-2782) Sumowski suggested the possibility that “Samuel van Hoogstraten acted as assistant to the master on occasional trips even at a later date”. (Werner Sumowski, Drawings of the Rembrandt School IX, New York 1985, no. 2159x). Building on this, Jonathan Bikker suggested in his monograph on Willem Drost that Van Hoogstraten “might have supervised Drost during his early days in Rembrandt’s studio” (Jonathan Bikker, Willem Drost, A Rembrandt Pupil in Amsterdam and Venice, New Haven/London 2005, p. 11). David de Witt later observed, in his Abraham van Dijck monograph, concerning Van Hoogstraten: “by 1646 his training would have been complete, but he appears to have stayed on as a tutor or head pupil for several years” (David De Witt, Life and Work of Late Rembrandt Pupil Abraham van Dijck, c. 1635-1680, Amsterdam 2020, p. 11).
  38. Sabine Pénot, Rembrandt – Hoogstraten. Colour and Illusion, exh. cat. Vienna: Kunsthistorisches Museum Wien, 2024; Nathalie Maciesza, Epco Runia, Samuel van Hoogstraten. De Illusionist, exh. cat. Amsterdam: Rembrandt House Museum, 2025; Sabine van Beek, Leonore van Sloten, David de Witt et al., Samuel van Hoogstraten: Catalogue Raisonné, The Hague 2025.
  39. The catalogue of the Vienna exhibition assumes a position for Van Hoogstraten as an assistant for approximately three to four years (Angelina Illes, in: exh. cat. Vienna 2024 (see note 3), p. 29; Jonathan Bikker, in: exh. cat. Vienna 2024 (see note 3), p. 93), though it makes no mention of any teaching responsibilities. These are, however, included in the publication accompanying the exhibition at the Rembrandt House Museum (Michiel Roscam Abbing, in: exh. cat. Amsterdam 2025 (see note 3), p. 19; David De Witt, in: exh. cat. Amsterdam 2025 (see note 3), p. 131), and in the online Van Hoogstraten catalogue raisonné by the RKD (Michiel Roscam Abbing, in: The Hague 2025 (see note 3), “With Rembrandt in Amsterdam”. https://vanhoogstraten.rkdstudies.nl/samuel-van-hoogstraten-the-ingenious-and-poetic-painter/with-rembrandt-inamsterdam/, 26 May 2025).
  40. The term “assistent” was used in Holland in the 17th century, albeit in other contexts, see: Woordenboek Nederlandse taal, s.v. assistent, https://gtb.ivdnt.org/iWDB/search?actie=article&wdb=WNT&id=M004535&lemma=assistent&domein=0&conc=true, 11
    July 2025.
  41. “Een min of meer ondergeschikte helper”, a more or less subordinate helper (see note 5); “A person who helps or supports somebody, usually in their job”: Oxford English Dictionary, s.v. assistant, https://www.oed.com/view/Entry/12041, 11 July 2025.
  42. The guild archive has been lost. For a comprehensive account of the Amsterdam Guild of Saint Luke and its ordinances, see: Isabella H. van Eeghen, “Schilders of Sint Lucasgilde”, in: Isabella H. van Eeghen (ed.), Inventarissen der archieven van de gilden en van het brouwerscollege, Amsterdam 1951, passim.; Isabella H. van Eeghen (Jasper Hillegers, translator), “The Amsterdam Guild of Saint Luke in the 17th Century”, Journal of Historians for Netherlandish Art 4.2 (2012), passim., DOI:10.5092/jhna.2012.4.2.4, 11 July 2025. The current article relies exclusively on the guild regulations of the Amsterdam De Kroniek 2024/25 – Museum Rembrandthuis 10 painters’ guild. It is often assumed that the regulations of painters’ guilds in different Dutch towns did not differ substantially in content. On that assumption, gaps in the regulations of one town might be filled by those of another. However, the discussion later in this article regarding whether apprentices were permitted to produce their own work shows that crucial differences did in fact exist. For that reason, guild regulations from other cities are not used here to fill the gaps in the surviving Amsterdam regulations.
  43. Extract van de willekeuren en ordonnantien den gilde van St. Lucas verleent, Amsterdam 1720, p. 11.
  44. Extract (see note 8), p. 11; This is also the case in the chapter title and margin of the 1766 publication of all known guild charters: Ordonnantien en willekeuren van het Lucas-gilde binnen Amsterdam, Amsterdam 1766, p. 64, 68. It is noteworthy that the dean and headmen of the guild employed a gilde kneght (Extract (see note 8), pp. 26-27. This was not a pupilship, and the tasks meet the definition of an assistant in the Oxford English Dictionary and the Woordenboek Nederlandse Taal (see note 6)
  45. Extract (see note 8), pp. 12-13
  46. Extract (see note 8), pp. 11-12.
  47. Extract (see note 8), p. 12.
  48. Cornelis Kiliaen (ed. Frans Claes), Etymologicum teutonicae linguae, Antwerp 1599 (The Hague 1972), p. 278, s.v. leerionghe; leer-kind; leer-knecht; leerlinck; p. 703, s.v. discipel. In the regulations of the Haarlem Guild of St. Luke from 1634 (NHA, 1105, Ambachtsgilden te Haarlem (Gilden Haarlem), no. 219), the terms “leerling”, “leerjongen”, and “discipel” are
    used. This might suggest that a distinction existed between them, but they are actually used interchangeably. The same applies to the terms “(werk)gezel”, “knecht”, and – a new term – “gast”. The latter is synonymous with journeyman or servant: “Knecht van een ambachtsman of fabrikant; gezel, werkknecht”, servant of a tradesman or manufacturer; journeyman, workshop hand: Woordenboek Nederlandse taal, s.v. gast, https://gtb.ivdnt.org/iWDB/searchactie=article&wdb=WNT&id=M017355.re.35&lemma=werkgast&domein=0&conc=true,
    16 oktober 2025.
  49. Kiliaen, Etymologicum (see note 13), p. 139, s.v. ghe-selle van een ampt. The Latin word “collega” is likewise a translation for “ambtgenoot”, “maet”, and “vennoot” (Kiliaen, Etymologicum (see note 13), p. 18, s.v. ampt-ghenoot; p. 302, s.v. maet, med-maet, maetken; p. 579, s.v. veyn-out, veyn-noot, ven-noot, vennoot, veyn-gnoot).
  50. Kiliaen, Etymologicum (see note 13), p. 244, s.v. knecht, dienaer.
  51. Nicolaas de Roever, “Drie Amsterdamsche Schilders (Pieter Isaaksz, Abraham Vinck, Cornelis van der Voort)”, Oud Holland 3 (1885), p. 198.
  52. In 1619, he was asked together with several artists who had traveled to Italy, including Pieter Lastman, Adriaen van Nieulandt, and Barent van Someren, to assess the authenticity of a Caravaggio painting from the collection of the late Louis Finson. Abraham Bredius, Nicolaas de Roever, “Pieter Lastman en François Venant”, Oud Holland 4 (1886), pp. 7-8.
  53. Ronald de Jager “Meester, leerjongen, leertijd. Een analyse van Zeventiende-eeuwse Noord-Nederlandse leerlingcontracten van kunstschilders, goud- en zilversmeden”, Oud Holland 104 (1990), p. 96, nt. 107. The title of “gezel” is, in fact, never mentioned in the known Amsterdam contracts.
  54. De Jager, “Meester” (see note 18), pp. 73-75.
  55. De Jager, “Meester” (see note 18), p. 71.
  56. Stadsarchief Amsterdam (hereafter SAA), 5075, 393A, nots. Jacob Jacobs and Nicolaes Jacobs, ff. 59r-59v, 20-07-1626; Abraham Bredius, “Gerrit Willemsz. Horst”, Oud Holland 50 (1933), pp. 5-6; De Jager, “Meester” (see note 18), p. 98, no. 7.
  57. This underscores a clear distinction: as was also evidenced by the entries in Kiliaen, Etymologicum (see note 13), dienaer was a synonym for knecht, not for leerknecht (see note 15).
  58. Abraham Bredius, Künstlerinventare. Urkunden zur Geschichte der holländischen Kunst des XVIten, XVIIten und XVIIIten Jahrhunderts V, The Hague 191, pp. 1482-1483; De Jager, “Meester” (see note 18), p. 98, no. 10.
  59. The value of a barrel of herring in Amsterdam in 1635 was approximately 120 grams of silver (Bo Poulsen, Dutch Herring. An Environmental History, c. 1600–1860, Amsterdam 2008, p. 93, table 6.9); in the seventeenth century, ten grams of silver corresponded to the value of roughly one guilder.
  60. The tuition fees in Holland for a two-year contract averaged 61.5 guilders per year (De Jager, “Meester” (see note 18), p. 75).
  61. Josua Bruyn, “Een onderzoek naar 17de -eeuwse schilderijformaten, voornamelijk in Noord-Nederland”, Oud Holland 93 (1979), p. 113.
  62. Abraham Bredius, Künstlerinventare. Urkunden zur Geschichte der holländischen Kunst des XVIten, XVIIten und XVIIIten Jahrhunderts II, The Hague 1916, pp. 400-401; De Jager, “Meester” (see note 18), p. 98
  63. As a journeyman painter Waltusz earned less than half the daily wage of peers in other trades. In 1652, journeymen carpenters and bricklayers in Amsterdam earned approximately 26 to 27 stivers per summer day (although there are no exact figures for 1651, data is available for 1633, 27 and 25 stivers respectively, and for 1667, 28 and 27 stivers respectively).
    This disparity between painter’s journeymen and their peers in other trades mirrors the situation in 1579. The guild
    regulations (gildebrief) of the St. Luke’s Guild from that year mention journeymen earning 4 stivers and others earning 10
    stivers per day (Ordonnantien (see note 9), p. 17, art. 11). Taking the average of 7 stivers, these were notably low wages –
    practically half – when compared to the 14 and 12 stivers earned by carpenters and bricklayers, respectively, in that same
    year. For the wages of the workers mentioned here, see: Hubert Nutseling, Welvaart en werkgelegenheid in Amsterdam
    1540–1860, Amsterdam/Dieren 1985, p. 252, appendix 5.1, table A.
  64. SAA, DTB 5001, 469, p. 241, 30-09-1651; Judith van Gent, Bartholomeus van der Helst (circa 1613-1670): een studie naar zijn leven en zijn werk, Utrecht (Utrecht University), p. 41.
  65. Virtually nothing is known about Gerardus van Berleborch (Bernard Renckens, “G. van Berkborch”, Oud Holland 84 (1967), no. 4, passim). He or his father was likely from the region around Bad Berleburg in Germany. He appears to have been present in Leiden in 1665, when he is recorded as a witness (“Gerrit van Berleberg”) at the baptism of a child of the painter Jacobus Geutkien (Erfgoed Leiden en Omstreken (hereafter ELO), DTB 1004, 237, fol. 236v, 3-12-1665).
  66. SAA, 5075, 875, not. Jacob van Zwieten, pp. 638-640, 16-10-1649; Johannes G. van Dillen, Bronnen tot de geschiedenis van het bedrijfsleven en het gildewezen van Amsterdam 1510-1672 III, p. 540, no. 1057.
  67. A possible reason for this may be that young painters attained the status of master more quickly. This benefited the guild financially, as it earned income only from masters and pupils, not from journeymen.
  68. Ordonnantien (see note 9), p. 10, art. 3.
  69. Ordonnantien (see note 9), p. 17, art. 11.
  70. Joachim von Sandrart’s famous anecdote about Rembrandt’s studio being filled with “countless elite children”, pupils who each paid an annual tuition fee of 100 guilders suggests that the legal limit on the number of pupils was, in practice, a dead letter (Joachim von Sandrardt, Teutsche Academie, Nuremberg 1675, p. 326; Van Eeghen, “Guild” (see note 7), p. 6).
  71. Young Man Reading with a Vanitas Still Life, 1644, oil on panel, 58 x 74 cm, Rotterdam, Museum Boijmans Van Beuningen, inv. no. 1386; Self-portrait, 1644, oil on panel, 63 x 48 cm, The Hague, Museum Bredius, inv. no. 056-1946; Self-portrait, 1645, oil on panel, 54.1 x 44.8 cm, Liechtenstein, The Princely Collections, Vaduz-Vienna, inv. no. GE 107; Portrait of a Child, 1645, oil on panel, 68.6 x 57.8 cm, private collection; The Adoration of the Shepherds, 1647, oil on canvas, 58.2 x 70.8 cm, Dordrecht, Dordrechts Museum, inv. no. DM/980/567.
  72. Godefridus J. Hoogewerff, De geschiedenis van de St. Lucasgilden in Nederland, Amsterdam 1947, p. 24; Ernst van de Wetering “Problems of Pupilship and Studio Practice” in: Josua Bruyn et al., A Corpus of Rembrandt Paintings II: 1631-1634, Amsterdam 1986, p. 57; Bikker, Drost (see note 2), p. 11; Angelina Illes, in: exh. cat. Vienna 2024 (see note 3), p. 29.
  73. Samuel Muller Fz., Schilders-vereenigingen te Utrecht. Bescheiden uit het Gemeentearchief, Utrecht 1880, p. 76; Frederik D.O. Obreen, Archief voor Nederlandsche Kunstgeschiedenis IV, Rotterdam 1881/1882, p. 51. The very fact that such a regulation had to be instituted in these cities already indicates that works were being signed by non-masters.
  74. De Jager, “Meester” (see note 18), pp. 77-79.
  75. Bruyn, “Onderzoek”, (see note 26), p. 113.
  76. David de Witt, Leonore van Sloten, in: The Hague 2025 (see note 3), “Rembrandt’s Impact”, https://vanhoogstraten.rkdstudies.nl/catalogus-schilderijen/rembrandts-impact/, 3 June 2025.
  77. Almost exclusively, reference is made to Bikker, Drost (see note 2), p. 11. Also in the exhibition catalogue of the Van Hoogstraten exhibition in Amsterdam, Drost is cited as an example of an early student of Van Hoogstraten (David de Witt, in: exh. cat. Amsterdam 2025 (see note 3), p. 131.
  78. Since Daniël Pont’s monograph on Barent Fabritius, (Daniël Pont, Barent Fabritius 1624–1673, The Hague, 1958) and Sumowski’s Drawings of the Rembrandt School (see note 2), no subsequent scholarly efforts have systematically De Kroniek 2024/25 – Museum Rembrandthuis 12 reconstructed his drawn oeuvre or analyzed the development of his distinctive style. The author’s forthcoming dissertation addresses this lacuna, and catalogues drawings by Barent Fabritius.
  79. Pont was among the first to suggest he may not have been a direct pupil of Rembrandt, but instead only came into contact with Rembrandt’s work indirectly, through his brother Carel (Pont, Barent (see note 43), p. 96). In the literature, uncertainty on this matter appears to have become the norm, with scholars consistently noting – or implicitly dealing with – the lack of evidence for a formal pupilship with Rembrandt (see: Paul Huys Jansen, Werner Sumowski, The Hoogsteder Exhibition of Rembrandt’s Academy, exh. cat. The Hague: Hoogsteder & Hoogsteder, 1992, p. 139; Walter A. Liedkte in: Hubert von Sonneburg, Rembrandt/Not Rembrandt in the Metropolitan Museum of Art I, exh. cat. New York City: The Metropolitan Museum of Art, 1995, cat. 48, pp. 145-146; Peter C. Sutton in: Albert Blankert, Rembrandt. A Genius and his impact, exh. cat. Melbourne: National Gallery of Victoria; Canberra: National Gallery of Australia, 1997, p. 283; Jan Blanc, Dans l’atelier de Rembrandt. Le maître et ses élèves, Paris 2006, p. 140.
  80. Holm Bevers, “Das Susanna-Thema im Werkstattzusammenhang: Zeichnungen”, in: Holm Bevers, Katja Kleinert, Claudia Laurenze-Landsberg, Rembrandts Berliner Susanna und die beiden Alten. Die Schaffung eins meisterwerks, exh. cat. Berlin: Staatliche Museen zu Berlin, Kupferstichkabinett; Gemäldegalerie, 2015, pp. 49-50.
  81. Katja Kleinert, Claudia Laurenze-Landsberg, “Wandlungen eines Gemäldes. Rembrandts Berliner Susanna und die beiden Alten”, in: exh. cat. Berlin 2015 (see note 45), p. 19, 32.
  82. See for instance Rembrandt’s Holy Family in the Carpenter’s workshop or his Star of the Kings (London, The British Museum, inv. nos. 1900,0824.144, 1910,0212.189).
  83. The drawing of a male model (here attributed to Barent Fabritius) has been described as stylistically very close to Van Hoogstraten (Martin Royalton-Kisch in: Catalogue of Drawings by Rembrandt and his School, London: The British Museum, 2010, cat. 71). The Departure of the Prodigal Son, a drawing already earlier attributed to Fabritius, is still considered a work by Van Hoogstraten (Frankfurt am Main, Städel Museum, inv. no. 817).
  84. A convincing spatial representation of the scene, achieved through a successful use of proportion, perspective, light, and color. For a elaboration on this definition, including references, see: Leonore van Sloten, “Regels voor de kunst”, in: David de Witt, Leonore van Sloten, Jaap van der Veen, Rembrandts late leerlingen. In de leer bij een genie, exh. cat. Amsterdam: Rembrandt House Museum, 2015, p. 73, note 31.
  85. In drawings by Barent Fabritius from the second half of the 1640s, his preparatory chalk underdrawing is generally careful and precise but not detailed, with clear, exact contours rendered in continuous, rounded lines. The somewhat squat figures possess a doll-like, slightly caricatural character. When using pen to trace or fill in the figures, particularly those in the foreground, the style becomes sketchier and more angular. Fabritius’s hatching lines become more carefully placed as they  grow finer, laid loosely side by side with only occasional thin-pen scratching, while thicker lines, including contours, are rendered in a zigzag, looser manner, often applied to foreground elements such as a repoussoir. Groups of hatching in shadowed, complex motifs (e.g., figures or foreground foliage) are neither intertwined nor uniformly oriented, and though the balance of light and shadow varies between drawings, it remains consistent within each composition; early mastery is evident in his wash applications, where loosely brushed transitions in shadows lend a painterly quality, enhancing figural plasticity and atmospheric depth, as seen in drawings with dramatic chiaroscuro effects.
  86. Although it has been argued by Holm Bevers that this drawing is by Constantijn Daniël van Renesse and dates from between 1650 and 1652 (Holm Bevers, “Ausstellungen zu Rembrandt in Rückblick”, Kunstchronik, 58 (2005), p. 480; Holm Bevers, in: Rembrandt. Die Zeichnungen im Berliner Kupferstichkabinett, exh. cat. Berlin: Staatliche Museen zu Berlin, Kupferstichkabinett, 2006, cat. no. 45, p. 158, nt. 12; Holm Bevers in: Holm Bevers et al., Drawings by Rembrandt and his Pupils. Telling the Difference, exh. cat. Los Angeles: The J. Paul Getty Museum, 2009, cat. no. 31.2, pp. 190-191), a number of features are so uncharacteristic of Van Renesse that the attribution cannot be sustained. This applies in particular to elements such as the heavy, coarse scratches in the shadow areas and the sketch-like rendering of the faces of Joseph and Mary. Van Renesse typically keeps shadow areas and light transitions in brush clear and even. Also characteristic is his meticulous penwork, marked by fine, short strokes in the contours and hatching lines (see for instance: The Judgment of Salomon, New York City (The Metropolitan Museum of Art, Robert Lehman Collection, inv. no. 1975.1.806; Daniel in the Lion’s Den, Rotterdam, Museum Boijmans Van Beuningen, inv. no. MB 200). Generally, it shows the boldness of Barent much more than the careful restraint of Renesse
  87. “Beeter waer ‚t dat [om de veranderin[g]] een eesel van achteren was, dan dat al de hoofden iuist wt het stuck sien. Dat oock omtrent de boom wat meerder groente was. | 1 losep heft af te swaer en te onbesuist | 2 Maria most het kindeken wat meerder vieren, want een teeder kint magh sulck duwen niet ver[dragen]. | losep al te kort en dick, sijn hooft wast hem wt de [borst?]. Sijn hebben alle beide al te groote koppen”. Transcript from: Leonore van Sloten, in: exh. cat. Amsterdam 2015 (see note 49), p. 73, nt. 27. “It would be better that [for the alteration] there were a donkey from the back, than that all the heads are looking straight out of the work. That there were also somewhat more greenery around the tree. | 1 Joseph lifts too heavily and too inconsiderately. | 2 Mary ought to ease the little child somewhat more, for a tender infant cannot [endure] such pushing. | Joseph is all too short and stout, his head grows out of the [chest?]. They both have all too large heads”. These instructions are also partly articulated within the drawing itself. Joseph is indeed shown tugging firmly at Mary’s arm, whereas in the more sketch-like version, he supports her more gently at the back. The small patch of greenery in the lower corner may also be a later addition, in correspondence with the suggestion.
  88. The face does not appear to be a correction in the technical sense, but rather an example of a foreshortened face viewed from below – a challenging principle of perspective.
  89. An attribution proposed Christian Dittrich (Christian Dittrich in: Christian Dittrich, Thomas Ketelsen, Rembrandt. Die Dresdener Zeichnungen 2004, exh. cat. Dresden: Staatliche Kunstsammlungen Dresden, Kupferstich-Kabinett, 2004, cat. no.14, pp. 80-81).
  90. Brusati implied the possibility that the text was written partly by Rembrandt and partly by Van Hoogstraten (Celeste Brusati, Artifice & Illusion. The Art and Writing of Samuel van Hoogstraten, Chicago/London 1995, pp. 31, 275, note 40). Rembrandt was excluded as the author of the instructions by Bevers, while Van Hoogstraten as author remained an option. Van Renesse was likewise ruled out by Bevers, based on a comparison with the handwriting on his Daniel in the Lions’ Den drawing and The Judgment of Solomon drawing (see note 51); Holm Bevers, in: exh. cat. Los Angeles 2009 (see note 51), cat. 31.1–31.2, p. 190; 191, note 3). To this may be added that the handwriting also closely resembles that of Barent Fabritius. Although little comparative material survives, the compact, small script of Fabritius’s name beneath the death inventory of his sister-in-law Aeltje, dated 24 April 1643 (SAA, 5075, 1628a, not. David de l’Hommel, p. 399), shows a strong resemblance to the instructions on the Dresden sheet.
  91. “Once you have mastered your handling and your eye is somewhat clarified, it will no longer trouble you to translate many naturalistic paintings into a naturalistic drawing”. “Wanneer gy uwe handeling nu machtich zijt, en uw oog wat verklaert is, zoo zal ‚t u ook niet verscheelen veel verwige Schilderyen in een verwige teykeningen na te klaren” (Van Hoogstraten, Inleyding (see note 1), p. 27)
  92. “I advise masters, when they review the drawings of their pupils, to improve them by making sketches of the same subject themselves. This is an excellent exercise and has greatly assisted many in the art of composition”. “De meesters raed ik, als ze de Teykeningen haerer discipelen overzien, datze de zelve, met schetssen op ‚t zelve voorwerp te maeken, verbeeteren. Dit oeffent ongemeen, en heeft veelen geweldich in de schikkunst geholpen” (Van Hoogstraten, Inleyding (see note 1), p. 192).
  93. “And certainly, this manner of drawing with pen and brush is likewise the most suitable for completing a masterly work in its full force. For one can also, whenever it proves convenient, work into it with red chalk and crayons, as though one were almost painting with colours”. “En zeker deeze wijze van met pen en pinseel te teykenen, is ook allerbequaemst om een meesterlijk werk in zijn volle kracht te voleinden. Dewijl men’er ook, als’t pas geeft, met rood krijt en kryons in kan speelen, als of men byna met verwen schilderde” (Van Hoogstraten, Inleyding (see note 1), p. 31.
  94. On stylistic grounds, this Rembrandt drawing has been placed among a group of history drawings dating to around 1650 (Otto Benesch, The Drawings of Rembrandt V, New York 1957, no. 902). Among other arguments, this dating led Bevers to attribute the Dresden drawing to Constantijn van Renesse, rather than Barent Fabritius (Holm Bevers, in: exh. cat. Berlin 2006 (see note 51), cat. no. 45, p. 157, 158, nt. 12) However, it remains questionable whether the Rembrandt drawing in Berlin should be understood within that context. Unlike the other history drawings, this work is not an autonomous composition but rather a sketched response to the Dresden sheet. It is plausible that the sketch was already made around 1647. In terms of linework, it is not far removed from the portrait sketch of Jan Six, dating from in or before 1647 (Amsterdam, Six Collection).
    It is drawn in a similarly free style, applied in a sketch, comparable to other drawings from the second half of the 1640’s (see
    note 47). Rembrandt’s Berlin drawing could thus have been made quite soon after Fabritius’s corrected drawing
  95. Josua Bruyn, “Gemälde der Rembrandt-Schüler II by Werner Sumowski Review”, Oud Holland 101 (1987) no. 3, p. 229.
  96. https://rkd.nl/images/313061, 17 July 2025. In terms of drawing style, this work is not far removed from Van Hoogstraten’s drawing The Sacrifice of Manoah of 1649 (Braunschweig, Herzog Anton Ulrich Museum, inv. no. Z 335; https://rkd.nl/images/71286, 17 July 2025). We may even assume that The Crucifixion predates it; the departing angel in the  Braunschweig drawing – also seen from the back – appears to be a more developed and refined treatment of the motif of a figure seen from behind.
  97. Samuel van Hoogstraten, The Adoration of the Shepherds. London, The British Museum, inv. no. 1895,0915.1203; https://rkd.nl/images/313552, 17 July 2025. A drawing of The Circumcision, likewise painted as a part of the Passion series in 1646, has been attributed to Gerbrand van den Eeckhout (Brussels, Koninklijke Musea voor Schone Kunsten België, inv. no. 4060/1212). There are also two copies after Rembrandt’s Holy Family with a Curtain from 1646 (London, The British Museum, inv. no. 1895,0915.1200; Oxford, Ashmolean Museum, inv. no. WA1986.56).
  98. Josua Bruyn in: Josua Bruyn et al., A Corpus of Rembrandt Paintings III: 1635-1642, Amsterdam 1989 pp. 13-16.
  99. Martin Royalton-Kisch, Drawings by Rembrandt and his Circle in the British Museum, London: The British Museum, 1992, cat. no. 87, pp. 180-182; Holm Bevers, “Drawings in Rembrandt’s Workshop”, in: exh. cat. Los Angeles 2009 (see note 51), pp. 13-17; David de Witt, “Leren van het leven: tekeningen van Rembrandts leerlingen” in: Judith Noorman, David de Witt, Rembrandts Naakte Waarheid. Tekenen naar naaktmodellen in de Gouden Eeuw, exh. cat. Amsterdam: Rembrandt House Museum, 2015, pp. 117-120.
  100. Initially, this drawing was attributed to Rembrandt, but as early as 1908, this attribution was already being questioned (Martin Conway, “Some Rembrandt Drawings”, Burlington Magazine 14 (1908/1909), p.37).
  101. This sheet has previously been judged the weakest of the three (David de Witt, in: exh. cat. Amsterdam 2015 (see note 64), p. 118), and it has even been suggested that Rembrandt may have corrected it. (Martin Royalton-Kisch, in: col. cat. London 2010 (see note 48), cat. 71). The fine parallel pen strokes in the boy’s torso are comparable to those in the body of Susanna in the Budapest drawing. The somewhat arbitrary use of red chalk (in the model’s right armpit area, on the reverse side of the cushion, and in the upper left corner) also stands out in both sheets. The type of loose, heavy pen lines used for the cushion corresponds to those found in the cloak of the old man in the Susanna drawing.
  102. For a first suggestion of Bol being the assistant of Rembrandt, see: Albert Blanckert, Ferdinand Bol (1616-1680). Rembrandt’s Pupil, Doornspijk 1982, pp. 17-18.
  103. Blanckert, Bol (see note 67), pp. 17-18; David de Witt, “Ferdinand Bol, discipel van Rembrandt”, in: Norbert Middelkoop, Ferdinand Bol en Govert Flinck. Rembrandts meesterleerlingen, Amsterdam (Rembrandt House Museum/Amsterdam Museum) 2017, pp. 44-45
  104. Portrait of a Lady, 1642. Berlin, Staatliche Museen zu Berlin, Gemäldegalerie, inv. no. 809. However, there are paintings by Bol, or attributed to him, of an earlier date or dating. The Liberation of St Peter (private collection), dated around 1636, may be, given its strong connection to the work of Benjamin Cuyp (David de Witt, in: exh. cat. Amsterdam 2017 (see note 68), pp. 42-43), made before Bol’s departure to Amsterdam. Gideon’s Sacrifice of 1640, signed by Bol (Utrecht, Museum Catharijneconvent, inv. no. RMCC s24), is typical in subject matter and composition of his later work from the 1640s, and may
    be made under conditions comparable to those proposed in this article for the paintings by Van Hoogstraten, dating from
    between 1644 and 1647. Other works attributed to Bol prior to 1642 are often copies or adaptations of compositions by
    Rembrandt.
  105. Christopher Brown, Carel Fabritius, Oxford 1981, p. 47; Gero Seelig in: Frederik J. Duparc, Carel Fabritius 1622-1654, exh. cat. The Hague: Mauritshuis; Schwerin: Staatliches Museum, 2004-2005, cat. no. 4, p. 97.
  106. Erna Kok erroneously states that Bol is mentioned as Rembrandt’s “werckgesel” in a document of 30 August 1640 (Erna Kok, “Govert Flinck en Ferdinand Bol en hun netwerken van opdrachtgevers,” in: exh. cat. Amsterdam 2017 (see note 68), p. 71, p. 244, n. 37). Bol’s exact role during his time in Rembrandt’s workshop is never documented. It is striking that the drawn copies after three of Rembrandt’s paintings from around 1636 are attributed to Ferdinand Bol (Peter Schatborn, “Tekeningen van Govert Flinck en Ferdinand Bol”, in: exh. cat. Amsterdam 2017 (see note 68), p.185). Apart from these sheets and those datable around 1646 by later pupils, there are few, if any, known drawings by Rembrandt’s pupils that are direct copies after his history or figure paintings. It is possible that Bol played an important role in introducing this method into the studio, and that it was later adopted by Van Hoogstraten. Van Hoogstraten is likely to have been in contact with Bol while in Amsterdam. After Bol established himself as an independent master, around 1642, he too began to draw in red chalk. He did so, however, almost exclusively in preparatory studies for (mainly) paintings – see, for instance, Joseph brings his Father before Pharaoh (Dresden, Gemäldegalerie, inv. no. 1605), and its preliminary drawing (Amsterdam, Rijksmuseum, inv. no. RP-T-1883-A-276). Van Hoogstraten may well have adopted this practice from him. This suggests that, even as an official pupil of Rembrandt, Van Hoogstraten felt the freedom to look to the work of other contemporaries as well. Van Sloten has argued that Bol continued to visit Rembrandt during the first half of the 1640s (Leonore van Sloten, “Ferdinand Bol, de etser”, in: exh. cat. Amsterdam 2017 (see note 68), pp. 218–221). Bol’s use of red chalk for preparatory studies may therefore have been the source of Van Hoogstraten’s conception that the use of red chalk contributes to the painterly quality of a drawing.
  107. Arnold Houbraken, De groote schouburgh der Nederlantsche konstschilders en schilderessen, Amsterdam, 1976, p. 165.

Lievens in Antwerp: a New Portrait Discovery

Jan Lievens, Portrait of a Man with a Gold Chain, c. 1638.
1. Jan Lievens, Portrait of a Man with a Gold Chain, c. 1638. Canvas, 59 x 46 cm. Amsterdam, The Rembrandt House Museum, on loan from David and Michelle Berrong-Bader.

 

Jan Lievens, Portrait of Constantijn Huygens, 1629.
2. Jan Lievens, Portrait of Constantijn Huygens, 1629. Panel, 99 x 84 cm. Rijksmuseum, Amsterdam (SK-C-1467), on loan from the Musée de la Chartreuse, Douai, since 1962.

Detail (stripped state): possible remnants of a signature, middle right.
3. Detail (stripped state): possible remnants of a signature, middle right.

Portraiture evidently suited Jan Lievens (1607-1674) well. His earliest independent work, according to Jan Jacobsz Orlers (1570-1646), was a likeness of his mother that earned him immediate local fame.108 Later, Constantijn Huygens (1596-1687) encouraged the young Lievens in the same direction. Despite his initial misgivings, Lievens produced a striking and memorable likeness of the Stadholder’s secretary, even evoking his preoccupied state of mind (fig. 2).109 It was certainly the right specialty for his subsequent move to London (1632), where Anthony van Dyck (1599-1641) was kept busy with portrait commissions. Lievens did not break through the market there, however, and proceeded to Antwerp (1634). He evidently sought courtly patronage, such as he later achieved with commissions in The Hague and Berlin110. Recently, a portrait has resurfaced that strongly suggests that he did achieve at least one high-level commission for a portrait painting during his nine years in the city on the Scheldt.

 

A Rediscovered Portrait

In November 2020, a bust-length portrait of a mature man in near profile appeared in a mixed sale in Vienna, as from the “Circle of Bartholomeus van der Helst” (fig. 1).111 This was not an overestimation, as the high quality of the work was evident, but it was nonetheless inaccurate. The handling displays none of the smooth and broad application typical of Van der Helst, nor his typical dynamism of sweeping lines. Closer inspection reveals a remarkable, even dazzling range of textural effects, especially in the frizzy hair but also in the skin, beard stubble, and fabric. These are choregraphed to enhance the sitter’s presence, in a grand presentation closely aligned with the work of a different Dutch artist, namely Jan Lievens, and more specifically that of his Antwerp period, from 1634 to 1644. It was purchased at the sale by David and Michelle Berrong-Bader and was cleaned by Michel van de Laar, revealing minor losses, and the possible remnants of a monogram (fig. 3). This striking painting is currently on loan to the Rembrandt House Museum.

It is perhaps not very surprising that this work went largely unrecognized at the sale, as there are no directly comparable painted portraits by Lievens from the same period. Instead the most relevant paintings are found among Lievens’s tronies from the period, most significantly the Old Man in Schwerin (fig. 4), with its striking rendering of a full beard in layers of fine strokes in opaque paint, some of it dragged112 This striking technique employs physical texture, known as kenlijkheid,113. to catch the eye and draws these lines forward, conjuring an open, nest-like structure for the beard. It provides a direct parallel to the handing of the hair at the side of the head in the Bader-Berrong painting (figs. 5, 6). The effect is enhanced by the use of black, grey, white and ochre for the various layers of depth. We already see a leadup in the colour play of cool greys and ochres in Lievens’s signal and final masterpiece in Leiden, the Job on the Dungheap of 1631, now in Ottawa,

Jan Lievens, A Bearded Old Man with Folded Hands, c. 1637.
4. Jan Lievens, A Bearded Old Man with Folded Hands, c. 1637. Panel, 61.5 x 51 cm. Schwering, Staatliches Museum Schwerin (G 327)

detail of fig. 1: hair.
5. detail of fig. 1: hair.

detail of fig. 4: hair.
6. detail of fig. 4: hair.

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

114 and the closely related Penitent Magdalene in the Bader Collection at Queen’s University in Kingston.115 These brilliant technical experiments carried out in friendly competition with Rembrandt in Leiden, until 1631, still echo around six years later in the newly resurfaced portrait.

Jan Lievens, Head of a Bearded Old Man, monogrammed and dated 1640, lower right.
8. Jan Lievens, Head of a Bearded Old Man, monogrammed and dated 1640, lower right. Canvas, 76.2 x 62.5 cm. New Orleans, New Orleans Museum of Art, gift of Mr. and Mrs. Henry H. Weldon (81.294).

At the same time, the impact of Anthony van Dyck’s portraiture studied in London and Antwerp also reveals itself. The gently undulating surface and fluid, sweeping contours of the collar and edges of folds of the jerkin depart from the stiff solidity of the Leiden years, witnessed in the Huygens portrait. We see this development already in Lievens’s drawn portrait of his friend and fellow artist in Antwerp, the still life specialist Jan Davidsz. de Heem (1606-1684: fig. 7).116 In his Head of an Old Man in New Orleans, which bears a monogram and date of 1640, Lievens appears to have gone even further in adopting Van Dyck’s manner (fig. 8).117 He has moved further away from the flamboyant textural effects of his Leiden years, and towards a smoother idealization of the figure. Even accounting for possible wear, the beard and hair no longer show the prickly, toothy effect of the webs of thin opaque dragged strokes in the Schwerin and Bader-Berrong paintings; these can therefore be placed earlier. The soft and atmospheric handling approximates another male tronie, in the Bader Collection in Kingston, which must also date around 1640.118

 

Jan Lievens, Portrait of Jan Davidsz. de Heem, c. 1636. Black chalk with grey-brown body colour. London, British Museum
7. Jan Lievens, Portrait of Jan Davidsz. de Heem, c. 1636. Black chalk with grey-brown body colour. London, British Museum (1895,0915.1199).

The date and place of a portrait often find reflection in the fashion represented. The most prominent element in the Bader-Berrong portrait is the broad, flat collar. It is largely the same as worn in several portraits drawn by Lievens in Antwerp around 1636/37, including that of Jan Davidsz. de Heem (fig. 7), and of Adriaen Brouwer (1603-1638). 119 It is quite different from the lace collars that dominate elite male portraiture in Amsterdam and London in the second half of the 1630s. When Lievens portrayed Constantijn Huygens in a drawing on a visit to Leiden in 1639, it was, by contrast, in a lace collar.120 Yet it appears to have been a general preference for portrait representations in each location, and that behind the scenes, in real life, lace and flat collars were both worn in both locations. Marieke de Winkel speculates that the preference for flat collars in Antwerp portraits may even have been dictated by painters who saw the surface of the flat collar as better suited to the fluid lines and undulating surfaces characterizing local painting fashion in general and who may have been disinclined to labour over the details of lace.121

det. of fig. 1: brocade textile of the jerkin.
9. det. of fig. 1: brocade textile of the jerkin.

detail of: Jan Lievens, Portrait of Adriaen Trip, 1644, private collection.
10. detail of: Jan Lievens, Portrait of Adriaen Trip, 1644, private collection.

Lievens was himself otherwise not shy when it came to description of detail. He devoted special attention to the man’s striking jerkin peering out from under the collar. Liquid strokes of thin black and ochre paint describe a stiff textile with a reflective surface pattern, likely brocade. 122  The artist occasionally employed such strokes as part of his demonstrative mastery of brush and paint, as he did in the metallic trim on the front of the doublet of the young merchant Adriaen Trip, painted soon after Lievens moved to Amsterdam in 1644 (figs. 9 and 10).

The kind of imposing presentation in the Bader-Berrong painting was favoured by Lievens, as already observed by Huygens soon after he encountered the artist in a visit to Leiden in 1628.123 Wearing the shoes of the liefhebber, or art lover, the secretary to the stadholder was exercising powers of observation and analysis in the well-known passage of his autobiography contrasting Lievens’s inclinations with Rembrandt’s talent for conjuring grand emotions even in small figures. His characterization of Lievens was later echoed in the inscription on the print after Anthony van Dyck’s portrait of the artist: “Pictor Humanarvm Figvrarem Maiorvm”(Painter of Grand Human Figures).124

Already his earliest known paintings fill the frame with the subject. This can also be said of his first known formal portrait, depicting Huygens himself (fig. 2).125  He forms a stable and imposing pyramidal shape in the picture plane, with his rich black cloak billowing out to the right and left. The overall focus falls on the sharply defined eyes, with their fixed gaze to the right, emphasized by tonal contrast of iris against the whites of the eyes, and shadows cast by the light from the side.

 

Despite Huygens’s high praise, Lievens did not right away attract substantial commissions for painted portraits. An intriguing pen portrait of King Charles I may represent a fleeting high point of his stay in London, although Orlers claims he also painted a portrait of the British royal family.126

Jan Lievens, Portrait of Petrus Egidius de Morrion, 1637
11. Jan Lievens, Portrait of Petrus Egidius de Morrion, 1637. Panel, 83.5 x 59 cm. Budapest, Museum of Fine Arts (4311).

 

Jan Lievens, Portrait of Hieronymus de Bran, c. 1635-1643. Black chalk, 144 x 134 mm (octagonal). San Francisco, Fine Arts Museums of San Francisco, Achenbach Foundation (1986.2.40).
12. Jan Lievens, Portrait of Hieronymus de Bran, c. 1635-1643. Black chalk, 144 x 134 mm (octagonal). San Francisco, Fine Arts Museums of San Francisco, Achenbach Foundation (1986.2.40).

Commissions for painted portraits appear to have represented a threshold Lievens found difficult to cross in his first ventures outside the United Provinces. Only one example from the Antwerp period (1634-1644) was previously known, and it is notable for its eccentricity (fig. 11). Egidius Petrus de Morrion is shown peering through an illusionistic carved frame, bearing an illusionistic piece of paper identifying the sitter and claiming an astonishing age of 112 years. The cartouche is completed with the artist’s signature and a date of 1637. Strangely, we know nothing else about De Morrion. The Latinized first and second names (for Gillis and Pieter or Peter) strongly suggest a scholarly profile, and the man’s sharp gaze and smile evoke intellect and wit. It could be that he was portrayed for reasons other than his extreme age. But the portrait does not project high social or political status, and thus falls short of the court patronage ambitions that drew Lievens to London and Antwerp.

 

From the 1630s we mainly have drawn portraits, mostly of fellow artists. In Antwerp, he drew striking portraits of painters Adriaen Brouwer and Jan Davidsz. De Heem, who, judging by the inclusion of all three in Brouwer’s famous Smokers in New York, were his friends.127 His portrait prints of these and other acquaintances, including flower painter Daniel Seghers, were inspired by Van Dyck’s series of famous men and women, the Iconography, and likely intended to form part of a similar series.128

 

Curiously, Lievens did manage to secure high level patronage for drawn portraits. In terms of characterization of the sitter, the work from these years most closely related to the Bader-Barrong portrait is a drawing of the military captain Hieronymus de Bran (in a lace collar, exceptionally: fig. 12).129 It appears to have been intended for inclusion in the Iconography.130 The context must have been similar for both: a portrait of a man in a high political or military position, as their formal poses exude fortitude. The gold chain both men wear speaks of a gift of favour from a King or Emperor, usually awarded for service, often political or military but sometimes also literary or artistic. We do not see a medallion identifying the ruler. We also do not have any other attributes or clear connections leading to a specific identity for the handsome sitter here. It is tempting to look to Lievens’s most prominent commissions for history paintings in these years, but these were for the Jesuits, and were obtained through his father-in-law, a prominent Antwerp sculptor already working on the same projects.131 An impressive drawn portrait of a man has been identified as Thomas Howard, Earl of Arundel (1585-1646), the noble collector who fled to Antwerp in the wake of the demise of Charles I.132 The expressive head betrays a downcast sentiment, in line with his distressed situation in exile, in Antwerp, around 1643. By this time, Lievens was probably already looking to move on in search of patronage.

A comparably high social status is represented in the portrait now on loan to the Rembrandt House Museum. The sitter gazes slightly upwards, and seems to sets his sights on higher aspirations, probably more worldly than spiritual, as Lievens did. A similar, slightly elevated gaze occurs in Lievens‘ portrait of Huygens (fig. 2) and subsequently in several tronies, in which the artist also experimented with a grand effect.133 It reflected his image of himself as well. His confident attitude rubbed several people the wrong way, first of all Huygens himself, but also the Earl of Ancram (c. 1579-1655), who wrote with clear irritation at Lievens’s claim to be the best painter in all of Northern Europe.134 Status mattered to Lievens, in ways it did not to his friend Rembrandt, who turned out one bourgeois portrait after another after arriving in Amsterdam. Around 1637, in Antwerp, Lievens evidently found his moment, and later in the Northern Netherlands he would indeed attract commissions, also for portraits, at the highest levels.

 

David de Witt is Senior Curator at The Rembrandt House Museum

 

My thanks to Stephanie Dickey for her careful reading of this article, and for her valuable insights and suggestions.

 

  1. Werner Sumowski, Paul Huys Janssen, The Hoogsteder Exhibition of Rembrandt’s Academy, exh. cat. The Hague: Hoogsteder & Hoogsteder, 1992, cat. no. 28.
  2. Exhibition catalogues: Albert Blanckert, Jezus in de Gouden Eeuw, exh. cat. Rotterdam: Kunsthal, 2000–2001; Akira Kofuku, Rembrandt and the Rembrandt School. The Bible, mythology and ancient history, exh. cat. Tokyo: Museum of Western Art, 2003; Arthur K. Wheelock et al., Jan Lievens. A Dutch Master Rediscovered, exh. cat. Washington: National Gallery of Art; Milwaukee: Milwaukee Art Museum; Amsterdam: Rembrandt House Museum, 2008-2009, cat.no. 52; Louis van Tilborgh, Constantijn Huygens. Kunstkenner en verzamelaar, exh. cat. The Hague: Museum Bredius, 2013, cat. no. 14. Other literature: Werner Sumowski, Gemälde der Rembrandtschüler, vol. 4, Landau, 1983, p. 3726, no. 2356, fig. 3964; Helga Gutbrod, Lievens und Rembrandt : Studien zum Verhältnis ihrer Kunst, Frankfurt am Main, 1996, p. 299; Edwin Buijssen (ed.), Haagse schilders in de Gouden Eeuw, Het Hoogsteder lexicon van alle schilders werkzaam in Den Haag 1600-1700, The Hague, 1998, p. 191; Lloyd DeWitt, Evolution and Ambition in the career of Jan Lievens, 1607-1674, Phd. Diss. University of Maryland, College Park, 2006, p. 228.
  3. DeWitt, Evolution (see note 2), p. 228.
  4. For example those mentioned in the Montias Database of 17th Century Dutch Art Inventories and the Getty Provenance Research Index.
  5. Sumowski, Huys Janssen, Academy (see note 1), p. 220.
  6. Dr Gaston Gaudinot sale, Paris (Drouot), 13-14 February 1869.
  7. Sumowski, Huys Janssen, Academy (see note 1), p. 220.
  8. Ibid.
  9. Sumowski, Huys Janssen, Academy (see note 1), p. 226. Huys Janssen explains that the miracle as described in Luke and John differs from the version told by Matthew.
  10. After listening to the centurion, and before addressing him directly, Jesus speaks to his followers: “I tell you, many will come from east and west and sit at table with Abraham, Isaac, and Jacob in the kingdom of heaven.” (Matthew 8:11) Perhaps Lievens incorporated this part of the text and explicitly included people coming from the east (from the standpoint of his Dutch audience). A second possibility is that they are Pharisees. This group plays the role elsewhere in Matthew of disbelieving critics, and here they may serve to accentuate the belief of the centurion in the Christian faith. In early prints (Sebald Beham, Israhel van Meckenem, Hans Schaüfelein and Cornelis Massijs) and several Italian prints from Lievens’s time (seventeenth century prints after Paolo Veronese), Pharisees wear such headdresses. A parallel between blacks and overseas regions, such as in Lievens’s Brinio, is convincingly outlined by Elmer Kolfin (in: Elmer Kolfin, De kunst van de macht, Jordaens, Lievens en Rembrandt in het Paleis op de Dam, Zwolle, 2023, p. 67), does not seem to apply here.
  11. Sumowski, Huys Janssen, Academy (see note 1), p. 223.
  12. Sumowski, Huys Janssen, Academy (see note 1), pp. 223, 226.
  13. The right eye from the perspective of the viewer. There, a pupil was painted in, in a later restoration. Because of the sketchy manner it is difficult to ascertain whether or not both eyes are present, but in the left the lower eyelid is visible, while it is undefined in the right eye.
  14. For example: Jacobus Neeffs (after Jacob Jordaens), Judgement of Christ, etching, c. 1630-1645; Marinus van der Goes (after Jacques Jordaens), Judgement of Christ, engraving, c. 1614-1639; Willem Panneels (after Peter Paul Rubens), Adoration of the kings, etching, 1630; Nicolaes Lauwers (after Peter Paul Rubens), Ecce Homo, engraving, c. 1619-1652; and many more. Generally, for examples of inspiration drawn from prints by Lievens, see De
    Witt, Evolution (see note 2).
  15. Sumowski, Huys Janssen, Academy (see note 1), p. 226. Huys Janssen refers to examples by Nicolaes Moeyaert (Herentals, St. Waltrudis church) and Adam Camerarius (Amsterdam, Rijksmuseum, inv. no. SK-A-733). DeWitt refers to a painting by Bartholomeus Breenbergh (Karlsruhe, Staatliche Kunsthalle Karlsruhe, inv. no. 228) and the Moeyaert in Herentals (DeWitt, Evolution (see note 2), p. 227). But also see a woodcut with this subject by Cornelis van Sichem II in Der zielen lusthof (1629). Also of interest: Claes Moeyeart, Christ and the Centurion, 1632 (Minneapolis, Minneapolis Institute of Art, inv. no. 2012.84.5). Although the painting is known under this subject, it may in fact depict Cornelius kneeling before Peter, since more than one figure is shown kneeling and the composition closely resembles prints of this subject.
  16. Henri van de Waal, “’s Lands oudste verleden in de voorstelling van Vondel en zijn tijdgenooten”, Elsevier’s Maandschrift 47 (1937); Henri van de Waal, “Tempesta en de historieschilderingen op het Amsterdamse stadhuis”, Oud Holland 56 (1939); Henri van de Waal, Drie eeuwen vaderlandsche geschied-uitbeelding 1500-1800, een iconologische studie, The Hague, 1952; Kolfin, Kunst (see note 10).
  17. Antonio Tempesta (after Otto van Veen), Print 8 in (…)De Batavische oft oude Hollandtsche oorloghe teghen de Romeynen, 1612. Etching, 167 x 210 mm. Rijksmuseum, Amsterdam, inv. no. RP-P-OB-37.614. Jürgen Ovens based his drawing for the Batavian Series depicting Claudius Civilis leaving the Women and Children to fight at Xanten (Hamburg, Hamburger Kunsthalle, inv. no. 22342) on this print.
  18. On the period in The Hague: Buijssen Haagse (see note 2), pp.191-193.
  19. Haarlem, Teylers Museum, inv. no. P 006. For the identification and context, see: Gregor Weber, “Dus leeft de dappre Graaf: Zu einem Bildnis Andries de Graeffs von Jan Lievens (1607-1674)”, Oud Holland 99 (1985), pp. 44-56.
  20. Van de Waal, Eeuwen (see note 16), p. 230; Kolfin, De kunst van de macht (see note 10), pp. 19-20.
  21. Van de Waal, “’s Lands” (see note 16), p. 301-302.
  22.  Kolfin, Kunst (see note 10), p. 41. Four Batavian scenes were never completed. For two the themes are known, for the other two are not known.
  23. Munich, Staatliche Graphische Sammlung München, inv. no. 1451; Hamburg, Hamburger Kunsthalle, Kupferstichkabinett, inv. no. 22342. A lesser-known drawing of Rembrandt’s Conspiracy of Claudius Civilis (Edinburgh, National Galleries of Scotland, inv. no. D 23862) shows – when compared to the drawing in Munich – that the lower section of the painting is covered by a frieze and that portions of the left and right sides are obscured. This may indicate that an alternative conception of the framing of the lunettes was considered before the one ultimately implemented. It is possible that this earlier framing was already envisioned when Lievens produced his oil sketch Christ and the Centurion.
  24. Van de Waal, Eeuwen (see note 16), p. 225, referring to SAA, 5039, 2 resolutieboek, f. 66r.
  25. Ibid., referring to SAA, 5039, 153 rapiamus 1661, f.195v.
  26. Van de Waal, Eeuwen (see note 16), p. 225.
  27. Gregor Weber, “Jan Lievens’s ‘The Shield-raising of Brinio’ a Second Oil Sketch”, Hoogsteder-Naumann Mercury 12/13 (1992), nt. 8.
  28. Dewitt, Evolution (see note 2), p. 221.
  29. Kolfin, Kunst (see note 10), p.67.
  30. Kolfin, Kunst (see note 10), p. 44.
  31. For, among other things, contemporary poetry in which Civilis and others are compared to the members of the House of Orange: Van de Waal, Eeuwen (see note 16), pp. 220-221, 223.
  32. Kolfin, Kunst (see note 10), p. 47.
  33. Margriet van Eikema Hommes, Elmer Kolfin, De Oranjezaal in Huis ten Bosch, Een zaal uit loutere liefde, Zwolle, 2013, p. 77.
  34. Kolfin, Kunst (see note 10), pp. 41-47, 77.
  35. One may ask, in light of points discussed in this article, whether the “Christ” figure in the first version was in fact Christ at all. If so, the oil sketch would initially have represented solely a Christian scene without any reference to the Batavian Revolt, thereby less relatable to the (eventual) decoration program of the Town Hall’s gallery. Given that in the initial design the groups left and right with Biblical and/or eastern figures do not seem to have been included (aside from a bearded man on the right, judging from the x-ray), the large central figure may originally have been Julius Civilis. In compositional terms, this would align the painting more closely with the print by Tempesta after Van Veen. The apparent similarity in hairstyle between the final Christ figure and the initial figure, together with the possible initial presence of a (holy) beam of light directed toward the figure, may argue against this hypothesis; nevertheless, Brinno in Lievens’s Brinio Raised on the Shield likewise features long hair and even incorporates a diagonal compositional line through the clouds, comparable to the line through the foliage in the initial version of the present subject. The later insertion of Christ could then be understood as a deliberate twist, imparting a more prominent Christian meaning to the historical scene. These suggestions and observations were kindly shared by Jochem van Eijsden.
  36. Samuel van Hoogstraten, Inleyding tot de hooge schoole der schilderkonst: anders de zichtbaere werelt, Rotterdam 1678, p. 18. Van Hoogstraten here refers to the period when he was “still a disciple”, during which, as part of a “we”, he and others discussed a particular question, to which a certain “Fabritius” responded with an answer. It is generally assumed that this refers to Carel Fabritius, who is assumed to have studied with Rembrandt between approximately 1641 and 1643.
  37. Werner Sumowski described Van Hoogstraten as “pädagogisch begabt, Assistent Rembrandts gewesen” (Werner Sumowski, Gemälde der Rembrandt-Schüler II, Landau/Pfalz 1984, p. 1286). As supporting evidence, Sumowski argued that Van Hoogstraten corrected drawings by Constantijn Daniël van Renesse (; p. 1290, nt. 2). When discussing one of these drawings (Moses and Reuel’s Daughters at the Well, Amsterdam, Rijksmuseum, inv. no. RP-T-1893-A-2782) Sumowski suggested the possibility that “Samuel van Hoogstraten acted as assistant to the master on occasional trips even at a later date”. (Werner Sumowski, Drawings of the Rembrandt School IX, New York 1985, no. 2159x). Building on this, Jonathan Bikker suggested in his monograph on Willem Drost that Van Hoogstraten “might have supervised Drost during his early days in Rembrandt’s studio” (Jonathan Bikker, Willem Drost, A Rembrandt Pupil in Amsterdam and Venice, New Haven/London 2005, p. 11). David de Witt later observed, in his Abraham van Dijck monograph, concerning Van Hoogstraten: “by 1646 his training would have been complete, but he appears to have stayed on as a tutor or head pupil for several years” (David De Witt, Life and Work of Late Rembrandt Pupil Abraham van Dijck, c. 1635-1680, Amsterdam 2020, p. 11).
  38. Sabine Pénot, Rembrandt – Hoogstraten. Colour and Illusion, exh. cat. Vienna: Kunsthistorisches Museum Wien, 2024; Nathalie Maciesza, Epco Runia, Samuel van Hoogstraten. De Illusionist, exh. cat. Amsterdam: Rembrandt House Museum, 2025; Sabine van Beek, Leonore van Sloten, David de Witt et al., Samuel van Hoogstraten: Catalogue Raisonné, The Hague 2025.
  39. The catalogue of the Vienna exhibition assumes a position for Van Hoogstraten as an assistant for approximately three to four years (Angelina Illes, in: exh. cat. Vienna 2024 (see note 3), p. 29; Jonathan Bikker, in: exh. cat. Vienna 2024 (see note 3), p. 93), though it makes no mention of any teaching responsibilities. These are, however, included in the publication accompanying the exhibition at the Rembrandt House Museum (Michiel Roscam Abbing, in: exh. cat. Amsterdam 2025 (see note 3), p. 19; David De Witt, in: exh. cat. Amsterdam 2025 (see note 3), p. 131), and in the online Van Hoogstraten catalogue raisonné by the RKD (Michiel Roscam Abbing, in: The Hague 2025 (see note 3), “With Rembrandt in Amsterdam”. https://vanhoogstraten.rkdstudies.nl/samuel-van-hoogstraten-the-ingenious-and-poetic-painter/with-rembrandt-inamsterdam/, 26 May 2025).
  40. The term “assistent” was used in Holland in the 17th century, albeit in other contexts, see: Woordenboek Nederlandse taal, s.v. assistent, https://gtb.ivdnt.org/iWDB/search?actie=article&wdb=WNT&id=M004535&lemma=assistent&domein=0&conc=true, 11
    July 2025.
  41. “Een min of meer ondergeschikte helper”, a more or less subordinate helper (see note 5); “A person who helps or supports somebody, usually in their job”: Oxford English Dictionary, s.v. assistant, https://www.oed.com/view/Entry/12041, 11 July 2025.
  42. The guild archive has been lost. For a comprehensive account of the Amsterdam Guild of Saint Luke and its ordinances, see: Isabella H. van Eeghen, “Schilders of Sint Lucasgilde”, in: Isabella H. van Eeghen (ed.), Inventarissen der archieven van de gilden en van het brouwerscollege, Amsterdam 1951, passim.; Isabella H. van Eeghen (Jasper Hillegers, translator), “The Amsterdam Guild of Saint Luke in the 17th Century”, Journal of Historians for Netherlandish Art 4.2 (2012), passim., DOI:10.5092/jhna.2012.4.2.4, 11 July 2025. The current article relies exclusively on the guild regulations of the Amsterdam De Kroniek 2024/25 – Museum Rembrandthuis 10 painters’ guild. It is often assumed that the regulations of painters’ guilds in different Dutch towns did not differ substantially in content. On that assumption, gaps in the regulations of one town might be filled by those of another. However, the discussion later in this article regarding whether apprentices were permitted to produce their own work shows that crucial differences did in fact exist. For that reason, guild regulations from other cities are not used here to fill the gaps in the surviving Amsterdam regulations.
  43. Extract van de willekeuren en ordonnantien den gilde van St. Lucas verleent, Amsterdam 1720, p. 11.
  44. Extract (see note 8), p. 11; This is also the case in the chapter title and margin of the 1766 publication of all known guild charters: Ordonnantien en willekeuren van het Lucas-gilde binnen Amsterdam, Amsterdam 1766, p. 64, 68. It is noteworthy that the dean and headmen of the guild employed a gilde kneght (Extract (see note 8), pp. 26-27. This was not a pupilship, and the tasks meet the definition of an assistant in the Oxford English Dictionary and the Woordenboek Nederlandse Taal (see note 6)
  45. Extract (see note 8), pp. 12-13
  46. Extract (see note 8), pp. 11-12.
  47. Extract (see note 8), p. 12.
  48. Cornelis Kiliaen (ed. Frans Claes), Etymologicum teutonicae linguae, Antwerp 1599 (The Hague 1972), p. 278, s.v. leerionghe; leer-kind; leer-knecht; leerlinck; p. 703, s.v. discipel. In the regulations of the Haarlem Guild of St. Luke from 1634 (NHA, 1105, Ambachtsgilden te Haarlem (Gilden Haarlem), no. 219), the terms “leerling”, “leerjongen”, and “discipel” are
    used. This might suggest that a distinction existed between them, but they are actually used interchangeably. The same applies to the terms “(werk)gezel”, “knecht”, and – a new term – “gast”. The latter is synonymous with journeyman or servant: “Knecht van een ambachtsman of fabrikant; gezel, werkknecht”, servant of a tradesman or manufacturer; journeyman, workshop hand: Woordenboek Nederlandse taal, s.v. gast, https://gtb.ivdnt.org/iWDB/searchactie=article&wdb=WNT&id=M017355.re.35&lemma=werkgast&domein=0&conc=true,
    16 oktober 2025.
  49. Kiliaen, Etymologicum (see note 13), p. 139, s.v. ghe-selle van een ampt. The Latin word “collega” is likewise a translation for “ambtgenoot”, “maet”, and “vennoot” (Kiliaen, Etymologicum (see note 13), p. 18, s.v. ampt-ghenoot; p. 302, s.v. maet, med-maet, maetken; p. 579, s.v. veyn-out, veyn-noot, ven-noot, vennoot, veyn-gnoot).
  50. Kiliaen, Etymologicum (see note 13), p. 244, s.v. knecht, dienaer.
  51. Nicolaas de Roever, “Drie Amsterdamsche Schilders (Pieter Isaaksz, Abraham Vinck, Cornelis van der Voort)”, Oud Holland 3 (1885), p. 198.
  52. In 1619, he was asked together with several artists who had traveled to Italy, including Pieter Lastman, Adriaen van Nieulandt, and Barent van Someren, to assess the authenticity of a Caravaggio painting from the collection of the late Louis Finson. Abraham Bredius, Nicolaas de Roever, “Pieter Lastman en François Venant”, Oud Holland 4 (1886), pp. 7-8.
  53. Ronald de Jager “Meester, leerjongen, leertijd. Een analyse van Zeventiende-eeuwse Noord-Nederlandse leerlingcontracten van kunstschilders, goud- en zilversmeden”, Oud Holland 104 (1990), p. 96, nt. 107. The title of “gezel” is, in fact, never mentioned in the known Amsterdam contracts.
  54. De Jager, “Meester” (see note 18), pp. 73-75.
  55. De Jager, “Meester” (see note 18), p. 71.
  56. Stadsarchief Amsterdam (hereafter SAA), 5075, 393A, nots. Jacob Jacobs and Nicolaes Jacobs, ff. 59r-59v, 20-07-1626; Abraham Bredius, “Gerrit Willemsz. Horst”, Oud Holland 50 (1933), pp. 5-6; De Jager, “Meester” (see note 18), p. 98, no. 7.
  57. This underscores a clear distinction: as was also evidenced by the entries in Kiliaen, Etymologicum (see note 13), dienaer was a synonym for knecht, not for leerknecht (see note 15).
  58. Abraham Bredius, Künstlerinventare. Urkunden zur Geschichte der holländischen Kunst des XVIten, XVIIten und XVIIIten Jahrhunderts V, The Hague 191, pp. 1482-1483; De Jager, “Meester” (see note 18), p. 98, no. 10.
  59. The value of a barrel of herring in Amsterdam in 1635 was approximately 120 grams of silver (Bo Poulsen, Dutch Herring. An Environmental History, c. 1600–1860, Amsterdam 2008, p. 93, table 6.9); in the seventeenth century, ten grams of silver corresponded to the value of roughly one guilder.
  60. The tuition fees in Holland for a two-year contract averaged 61.5 guilders per year (De Jager, “Meester” (see note 18), p. 75).
  61. Josua Bruyn, “Een onderzoek naar 17de -eeuwse schilderijformaten, voornamelijk in Noord-Nederland”, Oud Holland 93 (1979), p. 113.
  62. Abraham Bredius, Künstlerinventare. Urkunden zur Geschichte der holländischen Kunst des XVIten, XVIIten und XVIIIten Jahrhunderts II, The Hague 1916, pp. 400-401; De Jager, “Meester” (see note 18), p. 98
  63. As a journeyman painter Waltusz earned less than half the daily wage of peers in other trades. In 1652, journeymen carpenters and bricklayers in Amsterdam earned approximately 26 to 27 stivers per summer day (although there are no exact figures for 1651, data is available for 1633, 27 and 25 stivers respectively, and for 1667, 28 and 27 stivers respectively).
    This disparity between painter’s journeymen and their peers in other trades mirrors the situation in 1579. The guild
    regulations (gildebrief) of the St. Luke’s Guild from that year mention journeymen earning 4 stivers and others earning 10
    stivers per day (Ordonnantien (see note 9), p. 17, art. 11). Taking the average of 7 stivers, these were notably low wages –
    practically half – when compared to the 14 and 12 stivers earned by carpenters and bricklayers, respectively, in that same
    year. For the wages of the workers mentioned here, see: Hubert Nutseling, Welvaart en werkgelegenheid in Amsterdam
    1540–1860, Amsterdam/Dieren 1985, p. 252, appendix 5.1, table A.
  64. SAA, DTB 5001, 469, p. 241, 30-09-1651; Judith van Gent, Bartholomeus van der Helst (circa 1613-1670): een studie naar zijn leven en zijn werk, Utrecht (Utrecht University), p. 41.
  65. Virtually nothing is known about Gerardus van Berleborch (Bernard Renckens, “G. van Berkborch”, Oud Holland 84 (1967), no. 4, passim). He or his father was likely from the region around Bad Berleburg in Germany. He appears to have been present in Leiden in 1665, when he is recorded as a witness (“Gerrit van Berleberg”) at the baptism of a child of the painter Jacobus Geutkien (Erfgoed Leiden en Omstreken (hereafter ELO), DTB 1004, 237, fol. 236v, 3-12-1665).
  66. SAA, 5075, 875, not. Jacob van Zwieten, pp. 638-640, 16-10-1649; Johannes G. van Dillen, Bronnen tot de geschiedenis van het bedrijfsleven en het gildewezen van Amsterdam 1510-1672 III, p. 540, no. 1057.
  67. A possible reason for this may be that young painters attained the status of master more quickly. This benefited the guild financially, as it earned income only from masters and pupils, not from journeymen.
  68. Ordonnantien (see note 9), p. 10, art. 3.
  69. Ordonnantien (see note 9), p. 17, art. 11.
  70. Joachim von Sandrart’s famous anecdote about Rembrandt’s studio being filled with “countless elite children”, pupils who each paid an annual tuition fee of 100 guilders suggests that the legal limit on the number of pupils was, in practice, a dead letter (Joachim von Sandrardt, Teutsche Academie, Nuremberg 1675, p. 326; Van Eeghen, “Guild” (see note 7), p. 6).
  71. Young Man Reading with a Vanitas Still Life, 1644, oil on panel, 58 x 74 cm, Rotterdam, Museum Boijmans Van Beuningen, inv. no. 1386; Self-portrait, 1644, oil on panel, 63 x 48 cm, The Hague, Museum Bredius, inv. no. 056-1946; Self-portrait, 1645, oil on panel, 54.1 x 44.8 cm, Liechtenstein, The Princely Collections, Vaduz-Vienna, inv. no. GE 107; Portrait of a Child, 1645, oil on panel, 68.6 x 57.8 cm, private collection; The Adoration of the Shepherds, 1647, oil on canvas, 58.2 x 70.8 cm, Dordrecht, Dordrechts Museum, inv. no. DM/980/567.
  72. Godefridus J. Hoogewerff, De geschiedenis van de St. Lucasgilden in Nederland, Amsterdam 1947, p. 24; Ernst van de Wetering “Problems of Pupilship and Studio Practice” in: Josua Bruyn et al., A Corpus of Rembrandt Paintings II: 1631-1634, Amsterdam 1986, p. 57; Bikker, Drost (see note 2), p. 11; Angelina Illes, in: exh. cat. Vienna 2024 (see note 3), p. 29.
  73. Samuel Muller Fz., Schilders-vereenigingen te Utrecht. Bescheiden uit het Gemeentearchief, Utrecht 1880, p. 76; Frederik D.O. Obreen, Archief voor Nederlandsche Kunstgeschiedenis IV, Rotterdam 1881/1882, p. 51. The very fact that such a regulation had to be instituted in these cities already indicates that works were being signed by non-masters.
  74. De Jager, “Meester” (see note 18), pp. 77-79.
  75. Bruyn, “Onderzoek”, (see note 26), p. 113.
  76. David de Witt, Leonore van Sloten, in: The Hague 2025 (see note 3), “Rembrandt’s Impact”, https://vanhoogstraten.rkdstudies.nl/catalogus-schilderijen/rembrandts-impact/, 3 June 2025.
  77. Almost exclusively, reference is made to Bikker, Drost (see note 2), p. 11. Also in the exhibition catalogue of the Van Hoogstraten exhibition in Amsterdam, Drost is cited as an example of an early student of Van Hoogstraten (David de Witt, in: exh. cat. Amsterdam 2025 (see note 3), p. 131.
  78. Since Daniël Pont’s monograph on Barent Fabritius, (Daniël Pont, Barent Fabritius 1624–1673, The Hague, 1958) and Sumowski’s Drawings of the Rembrandt School (see note 2), no subsequent scholarly efforts have systematically De Kroniek 2024/25 – Museum Rembrandthuis 12 reconstructed his drawn oeuvre or analyzed the development of his distinctive style. The author’s forthcoming dissertation addresses this lacuna, and catalogues drawings by Barent Fabritius.
  79. Pont was among the first to suggest he may not have been a direct pupil of Rembrandt, but instead only came into contact with Rembrandt’s work indirectly, through his brother Carel (Pont, Barent (see note 43), p. 96). In the literature, uncertainty on this matter appears to have become the norm, with scholars consistently noting – or implicitly dealing with – the lack of evidence for a formal pupilship with Rembrandt (see: Paul Huys Jansen, Werner Sumowski, The Hoogsteder Exhibition of Rembrandt’s Academy, exh. cat. The Hague: Hoogsteder & Hoogsteder, 1992, p. 139; Walter A. Liedkte in: Hubert von Sonneburg, Rembrandt/Not Rembrandt in the Metropolitan Museum of Art I, exh. cat. New York City: The Metropolitan Museum of Art, 1995, cat. 48, pp. 145-146; Peter C. Sutton in: Albert Blankert, Rembrandt. A Genius and his impact, exh. cat. Melbourne: National Gallery of Victoria; Canberra: National Gallery of Australia, 1997, p. 283; Jan Blanc, Dans l’atelier de Rembrandt. Le maître et ses élèves, Paris 2006, p. 140.
  80. Holm Bevers, “Das Susanna-Thema im Werkstattzusammenhang: Zeichnungen”, in: Holm Bevers, Katja Kleinert, Claudia Laurenze-Landsberg, Rembrandts Berliner Susanna und die beiden Alten. Die Schaffung eins meisterwerks, exh. cat. Berlin: Staatliche Museen zu Berlin, Kupferstichkabinett; Gemäldegalerie, 2015, pp. 49-50.
  81. Katja Kleinert, Claudia Laurenze-Landsberg, “Wandlungen eines Gemäldes. Rembrandts Berliner Susanna und die beiden Alten”, in: exh. cat. Berlin 2015 (see note 45), p. 19, 32.
  82. See for instance Rembrandt’s Holy Family in the Carpenter’s workshop or his Star of the Kings (London, The British Museum, inv. nos. 1900,0824.144, 1910,0212.189).
  83. The drawing of a male model (here attributed to Barent Fabritius) has been described as stylistically very close to Van Hoogstraten (Martin Royalton-Kisch in: Catalogue of Drawings by Rembrandt and his School, London: The British Museum, 2010, cat. 71). The Departure of the Prodigal Son, a drawing already earlier attributed to Fabritius, is still considered a work by Van Hoogstraten (Frankfurt am Main, Städel Museum, inv. no. 817).
  84. A convincing spatial representation of the scene, achieved through a successful use of proportion, perspective, light, and color. For a elaboration on this definition, including references, see: Leonore van Sloten, “Regels voor de kunst”, in: David de Witt, Leonore van Sloten, Jaap van der Veen, Rembrandts late leerlingen. In de leer bij een genie, exh. cat. Amsterdam: Rembrandt House Museum, 2015, p. 73, note 31.
  85. In drawings by Barent Fabritius from the second half of the 1640s, his preparatory chalk underdrawing is generally careful and precise but not detailed, with clear, exact contours rendered in continuous, rounded lines. The somewhat squat figures possess a doll-like, slightly caricatural character. When using pen to trace or fill in the figures, particularly those in the foreground, the style becomes sketchier and more angular. Fabritius’s hatching lines become more carefully placed as they  grow finer, laid loosely side by side with only occasional thin-pen scratching, while thicker lines, including contours, are rendered in a zigzag, looser manner, often applied to foreground elements such as a repoussoir. Groups of hatching in shadowed, complex motifs (e.g., figures or foreground foliage) are neither intertwined nor uniformly oriented, and though the balance of light and shadow varies between drawings, it remains consistent within each composition; early mastery is evident in his wash applications, where loosely brushed transitions in shadows lend a painterly quality, enhancing figural plasticity and atmospheric depth, as seen in drawings with dramatic chiaroscuro effects.
  86. Although it has been argued by Holm Bevers that this drawing is by Constantijn Daniël van Renesse and dates from between 1650 and 1652 (Holm Bevers, “Ausstellungen zu Rembrandt in Rückblick”, Kunstchronik, 58 (2005), p. 480; Holm Bevers, in: Rembrandt. Die Zeichnungen im Berliner Kupferstichkabinett, exh. cat. Berlin: Staatliche Museen zu Berlin, Kupferstichkabinett, 2006, cat. no. 45, p. 158, nt. 12; Holm Bevers in: Holm Bevers et al., Drawings by Rembrandt and his Pupils. Telling the Difference, exh. cat. Los Angeles: The J. Paul Getty Museum, 2009, cat. no. 31.2, pp. 190-191), a number of features are so uncharacteristic of Van Renesse that the attribution cannot be sustained. This applies in particular to elements such as the heavy, coarse scratches in the shadow areas and the sketch-like rendering of the faces of Joseph and Mary. Van Renesse typically keeps shadow areas and light transitions in brush clear and even. Also characteristic is his meticulous penwork, marked by fine, short strokes in the contours and hatching lines (see for instance: The Judgment of Salomon, New York City (The Metropolitan Museum of Art, Robert Lehman Collection, inv. no. 1975.1.806; Daniel in the Lion’s Den, Rotterdam, Museum Boijmans Van Beuningen, inv. no. MB 200). Generally, it shows the boldness of Barent much more than the careful restraint of Renesse
  87. “Beeter waer ‚t dat [om de veranderin[g]] een eesel van achteren was, dan dat al de hoofden iuist wt het stuck sien. Dat oock omtrent de boom wat meerder groente was. | 1 losep heft af te swaer en te onbesuist | 2 Maria most het kindeken wat meerder vieren, want een teeder kint magh sulck duwen niet ver[dragen]. | losep al te kort en dick, sijn hooft wast hem wt de [borst?]. Sijn hebben alle beide al te groote koppen”. Transcript from: Leonore van Sloten, in: exh. cat. Amsterdam 2015 (see note 49), p. 73, nt. 27. “It would be better that [for the alteration] there were a donkey from the back, than that all the heads are looking straight out of the work. That there were also somewhat more greenery around the tree. | 1 Joseph lifts too heavily and too inconsiderately. | 2 Mary ought to ease the little child somewhat more, for a tender infant cannot [endure] such pushing. | Joseph is all too short and stout, his head grows out of the [chest?]. They both have all too large heads”. These instructions are also partly articulated within the drawing itself. Joseph is indeed shown tugging firmly at Mary’s arm, whereas in the more sketch-like version, he supports her more gently at the back. The small patch of greenery in the lower corner may also be a later addition, in correspondence with the suggestion.
  88. The face does not appear to be a correction in the technical sense, but rather an example of a foreshortened face viewed from below – a challenging principle of perspective.
  89. An attribution proposed Christian Dittrich (Christian Dittrich in: Christian Dittrich, Thomas Ketelsen, Rembrandt. Die Dresdener Zeichnungen 2004, exh. cat. Dresden: Staatliche Kunstsammlungen Dresden, Kupferstich-Kabinett, 2004, cat. no.14, pp. 80-81).
  90. Brusati implied the possibility that the text was written partly by Rembrandt and partly by Van Hoogstraten (Celeste Brusati, Artifice & Illusion. The Art and Writing of Samuel van Hoogstraten, Chicago/London 1995, pp. 31, 275, note 40). Rembrandt was excluded as the author of the instructions by Bevers, while Van Hoogstraten as author remained an option. Van Renesse was likewise ruled out by Bevers, based on a comparison with the handwriting on his Daniel in the Lions’ Den drawing and The Judgment of Solomon drawing (see note 51); Holm Bevers, in: exh. cat. Los Angeles 2009 (see note 51), cat. 31.1–31.2, p. 190; 191, note 3). To this may be added that the handwriting also closely resembles that of Barent Fabritius. Although little comparative material survives, the compact, small script of Fabritius’s name beneath the death inventory of his sister-in-law Aeltje, dated 24 April 1643 (SAA, 5075, 1628a, not. David de l’Hommel, p. 399), shows a strong resemblance to the instructions on the Dresden sheet.
  91. “Once you have mastered your handling and your eye is somewhat clarified, it will no longer trouble you to translate many naturalistic paintings into a naturalistic drawing”. “Wanneer gy uwe handeling nu machtich zijt, en uw oog wat verklaert is, zoo zal ‚t u ook niet verscheelen veel verwige Schilderyen in een verwige teykeningen na te klaren” (Van Hoogstraten, Inleyding (see note 1), p. 27)
  92. “I advise masters, when they review the drawings of their pupils, to improve them by making sketches of the same subject themselves. This is an excellent exercise and has greatly assisted many in the art of composition”. “De meesters raed ik, als ze de Teykeningen haerer discipelen overzien, datze de zelve, met schetssen op ‚t zelve voorwerp te maeken, verbeeteren. Dit oeffent ongemeen, en heeft veelen geweldich in de schikkunst geholpen” (Van Hoogstraten, Inleyding (see note 1), p. 192).
  93. “And certainly, this manner of drawing with pen and brush is likewise the most suitable for completing a masterly work in its full force. For one can also, whenever it proves convenient, work into it with red chalk and crayons, as though one were almost painting with colours”. “En zeker deeze wijze van met pen en pinseel te teykenen, is ook allerbequaemst om een meesterlijk werk in zijn volle kracht te voleinden. Dewijl men’er ook, als’t pas geeft, met rood krijt en kryons in kan speelen, als of men byna met verwen schilderde” (Van Hoogstraten, Inleyding (see note 1), p. 31.
  94. On stylistic grounds, this Rembrandt drawing has been placed among a group of history drawings dating to around 1650 (Otto Benesch, The Drawings of Rembrandt V, New York 1957, no. 902). Among other arguments, this dating led Bevers to attribute the Dresden drawing to Constantijn van Renesse, rather than Barent Fabritius (Holm Bevers, in: exh. cat. Berlin 2006 (see note 51), cat. no. 45, p. 157, 158, nt. 12) However, it remains questionable whether the Rembrandt drawing in Berlin should be understood within that context. Unlike the other history drawings, this work is not an autonomous composition but rather a sketched response to the Dresden sheet. It is plausible that the sketch was already made around 1647. In terms of linework, it is not far removed from the portrait sketch of Jan Six, dating from in or before 1647 (Amsterdam, Six Collection).
    It is drawn in a similarly free style, applied in a sketch, comparable to other drawings from the second half of the 1640’s (see
    note 47). Rembrandt’s Berlin drawing could thus have been made quite soon after Fabritius’s corrected drawing
  95. Josua Bruyn, “Gemälde der Rembrandt-Schüler II by Werner Sumowski Review”, Oud Holland 101 (1987) no. 3, p. 229.
  96. https://rkd.nl/images/313061, 17 July 2025. In terms of drawing style, this work is not far removed from Van Hoogstraten’s drawing The Sacrifice of Manoah of 1649 (Braunschweig, Herzog Anton Ulrich Museum, inv. no. Z 335; https://rkd.nl/images/71286, 17 July 2025). We may even assume that The Crucifixion predates it; the departing angel in the  Braunschweig drawing – also seen from the back – appears to be a more developed and refined treatment of the motif of a figure seen from behind.
  97. Samuel van Hoogstraten, The Adoration of the Shepherds. London, The British Museum, inv. no. 1895,0915.1203; https://rkd.nl/images/313552, 17 July 2025. A drawing of The Circumcision, likewise painted as a part of the Passion series in 1646, has been attributed to Gerbrand van den Eeckhout (Brussels, Koninklijke Musea voor Schone Kunsten België, inv. no. 4060/1212). There are also two copies after Rembrandt’s Holy Family with a Curtain from 1646 (London, The British Museum, inv. no. 1895,0915.1200; Oxford, Ashmolean Museum, inv. no. WA1986.56).
  98. Josua Bruyn in: Josua Bruyn et al., A Corpus of Rembrandt Paintings III: 1635-1642, Amsterdam 1989 pp. 13-16.
  99. Martin Royalton-Kisch, Drawings by Rembrandt and his Circle in the British Museum, London: The British Museum, 1992, cat. no. 87, pp. 180-182; Holm Bevers, “Drawings in Rembrandt’s Workshop”, in: exh. cat. Los Angeles 2009 (see note 51), pp. 13-17; David de Witt, “Leren van het leven: tekeningen van Rembrandts leerlingen” in: Judith Noorman, David de Witt, Rembrandts Naakte Waarheid. Tekenen naar naaktmodellen in de Gouden Eeuw, exh. cat. Amsterdam: Rembrandt House Museum, 2015, pp. 117-120.
  100. Initially, this drawing was attributed to Rembrandt, but as early as 1908, this attribution was already being questioned (Martin Conway, “Some Rembrandt Drawings”, Burlington Magazine 14 (1908/1909), p.37).
  101. This sheet has previously been judged the weakest of the three (David de Witt, in: exh. cat. Amsterdam 2015 (see note 64), p. 118), and it has even been suggested that Rembrandt may have corrected it. (Martin Royalton-Kisch, in: col. cat. London 2010 (see note 48), cat. 71). The fine parallel pen strokes in the boy’s torso are comparable to those in the body of Susanna in the Budapest drawing. The somewhat arbitrary use of red chalk (in the model’s right armpit area, on the reverse side of the cushion, and in the upper left corner) also stands out in both sheets. The type of loose, heavy pen lines used for the cushion corresponds to those found in the cloak of the old man in the Susanna drawing.
  102. For a first suggestion of Bol being the assistant of Rembrandt, see: Albert Blanckert, Ferdinand Bol (1616-1680). Rembrandt’s Pupil, Doornspijk 1982, pp. 17-18.
  103. Blanckert, Bol (see note 67), pp. 17-18; David de Witt, “Ferdinand Bol, discipel van Rembrandt”, in: Norbert Middelkoop, Ferdinand Bol en Govert Flinck. Rembrandts meesterleerlingen, Amsterdam (Rembrandt House Museum/Amsterdam Museum) 2017, pp. 44-45
  104. Portrait of a Lady, 1642. Berlin, Staatliche Museen zu Berlin, Gemäldegalerie, inv. no. 809. However, there are paintings by Bol, or attributed to him, of an earlier date or dating. The Liberation of St Peter (private collection), dated around 1636, may be, given its strong connection to the work of Benjamin Cuyp (David de Witt, in: exh. cat. Amsterdam 2017 (see note 68), pp. 42-43), made before Bol’s departure to Amsterdam. Gideon’s Sacrifice of 1640, signed by Bol (Utrecht, Museum Catharijneconvent, inv. no. RMCC s24), is typical in subject matter and composition of his later work from the 1640s, and may
    be made under conditions comparable to those proposed in this article for the paintings by Van Hoogstraten, dating from
    between 1644 and 1647. Other works attributed to Bol prior to 1642 are often copies or adaptations of compositions by
    Rembrandt.
  105. Christopher Brown, Carel Fabritius, Oxford 1981, p. 47; Gero Seelig in: Frederik J. Duparc, Carel Fabritius 1622-1654, exh. cat. The Hague: Mauritshuis; Schwerin: Staatliches Museum, 2004-2005, cat. no. 4, p. 97.
  106. Erna Kok erroneously states that Bol is mentioned as Rembrandt’s “werckgesel” in a document of 30 August 1640 (Erna Kok, “Govert Flinck en Ferdinand Bol en hun netwerken van opdrachtgevers,” in: exh. cat. Amsterdam 2017 (see note 68), p. 71, p. 244, n. 37). Bol’s exact role during his time in Rembrandt’s workshop is never documented. It is striking that the drawn copies after three of Rembrandt’s paintings from around 1636 are attributed to Ferdinand Bol (Peter Schatborn, “Tekeningen van Govert Flinck en Ferdinand Bol”, in: exh. cat. Amsterdam 2017 (see note 68), p.185). Apart from these sheets and those datable around 1646 by later pupils, there are few, if any, known drawings by Rembrandt’s pupils that are direct copies after his history or figure paintings. It is possible that Bol played an important role in introducing this method into the studio, and that it was later adopted by Van Hoogstraten. Van Hoogstraten is likely to have been in contact with Bol while in Amsterdam. After Bol established himself as an independent master, around 1642, he too began to draw in red chalk. He did so, however, almost exclusively in preparatory studies for (mainly) paintings – see, for instance, Joseph brings his Father before Pharaoh (Dresden, Gemäldegalerie, inv. no. 1605), and its preliminary drawing (Amsterdam, Rijksmuseum, inv. no. RP-T-1883-A-276). Van Hoogstraten may well have adopted this practice from him. This suggests that, even as an official pupil of Rembrandt, Van Hoogstraten felt the freedom to look to the work of other contemporaries as well. Van Sloten has argued that Bol continued to visit Rembrandt during the first half of the 1640s (Leonore van Sloten, “Ferdinand Bol, de etser”, in: exh. cat. Amsterdam 2017 (see note 68), pp. 218–221). Bol’s use of red chalk for preparatory studies may therefore have been the source of Van Hoogstraten’s conception that the use of red chalk contributes to the painterly quality of a drawing.
  107. Arnold Houbraken, De groote schouburgh der Nederlantsche konstschilders en schilderessen, Amsterdam, 1976, p. 165.
  108. Jan Jacobsz. Orlers, Beschrijvinge der Stadt Leyden, 2nd ed., Leiden, 1641, p. 376.
  109. See the translation from the original Latin: “Constantijn Huygens on Lievens and Rembrandt,” in: Arthur K. Wheelock et al., Jan Lievens. A Dutch Master Rediscovered, exh. cat. Washington: National Gallery of Art; Milwaukee: Milwaukee Art Museum; Amsterdam: Museum Het Rembrandthuis, 2008-2009, p. 287.
  110. See: Arthur K. Wheelock, “Jan Lievens: Bringing New Light to an Old Master,” in: Wheelock, Lievens (see note 2), pp. 13-23; and: Lloyd DeWitt, Evolution and Ambition in the Career of Jan Lievens (1607-1674), Ph.D. dissertation, University of Maryland, 2006: https://www.researchgate.net/publication/277127128_Evolution_and_Ambition_in_the_Career_of_Jan_Lievens_1607-1674
  111. Property from Aristocratic Estates and Important Provenance, Vienna (Dorotheum), 8 September 2020, lot 59 (as Circle of Bartholomeus van der Helst).
  112. Werner Sumowski, Gemälde der Rembrandt-Schüler, Landau, vol. 5, 1990, p. 3109, no. 2127, ill. p. 3279
  113. Ernst van de Wetering, Rembrandt: the Painter at Work, Amsterdam, 1997, pp. 182-185.
  114. Jan Lievens, Job in his Misery, monogrammed and dated 1631, canvas, 171.5 x 148.6 cm, Ottawa, National Gallery of Canada (4093). See Lloyd DeWitt in Wheelock, Lievens (see note 2), pp. 130-131, no. 25 (colour illus.).
  115. Jan Lievens, The Penitent Magdalene, c. 1631. Canvas, 63.5 x 49.5 cm. Kingston, Agnes Etherington Art Centre, gift of Dr. and Mrs. Alfred Bader, 1975 (18.126). See David de Witt in Wheelock, Lievens, pp. 128-129, no. 24 (colour illus.).
  116. Portrait of Jan Davidsz. de Heem, c. 1635/37, black chalk with some white body colour, 265 x 201 mm, London, British Museum (1895,0915.1199); Werner Sumowski, Drawings of the Rembrandt School, New York, vol. 7 (1983), pp. 3682-3683, no. 1652x (illus.).
  117. See entry by Lloyd DeWitt in: Wheelock, Lievens (see note 2), pp. 154-155, no. 38 (colour illus.).
  118. Jan Lievens, Head of a Bearded Old Man, c. 1640. Panel, 55 x 43 cm (oval), Kingston, Agnes Etherington Art Centre, gift of Alfred and Isabel Bader. See: David de Witt, The Bader Collection: Dutch and Flemish Paintings. Kingston, 2008, p. 198, no. 117 (colour illus.).
  119. Jan Lievens, Portrait of Adriaen Brouwer, c. 1635/37, black chalk with touches of pen in black, 221 x 185 mm, Paris, Fondation Custodia, Collection Frits Lugt (1203); Sumowski, Drawings (see note 9), pp. 3356-3357, no. 1594 (illus.).
  120. Jan Lievens, Portrait of Constantijn Huygens, 1639, black chalk with touches of pen in brown, 238 x 174 mm, London, British Museum (1836.8.11.342); see Wheelock, Lievens (see note 2), p. 242-243, no. 103 (colour illus.).
  121. Email correspondence with the author, 9 September 2020.
  122. My thanks to Stephanie Dickey for this information (email, 31 October 2022), confirmed by Marieke de Winkel.
  123. See Wheelock, Lievens (see note 2), p. 286.
  124. Lucas Vorsterman, after Anthony van Dyck, Portrait of Jan Lievens, c. 1630-1645, engraving, 241 x 158 mm, in 6 states, for the series: Icones Principorum Vivorum Doctorum Pictorum…; see: Marie Mauquoy-Hendrickx, L’Iconographie d’Antoine van Dyck, 2nd ed., Brussels, 1991, vol. 1, p. 155, no. 85; vol. 2, pl. 54 (illus.).
  125. Wheelock, Lievens (see note 2), pp. 112-113, no. 112 (colour illus.).
  126. Jan Lievens, Portrait of Charles I, pen in brown, 183 x 140 mm, Turin, Biblioteca Reale (D. C. 16365); Sumowski, Drawings (see note 9), pp. 3898-3899, no. 1754xx, (illus.); Orlers, Beschrijvinge (see note 1), pp. 375-377.
  127. Karolien de Klippel, “Adriaen Brouwer, Portrait Painter: New Identifications and an Iconographic Novelty,” Simiolus 30 (2003), pp. 196-216.
  128. Stephanie Dickey, “Jan Lievens and Printmaking,” in Wheelock, Lievens (see note 2), pp. 60-62. On the Iconography, see Mauquoy-Hendrickx, Iconographie (see note 7).
  129. DeWitt, Evolution (see note 3), p. 192, illus. fig. 144 (Lievens c. 1635/43, H. de Bran); attribution by Werner Sumowski: written correspondence with the museum of 28 July 1986; and: Drawings of the Rembrandt School, vol. 12 (Addenda), Leiden (forthcoming), no. 3104x.
  130. See Mauquoy-Hendrick, Iconography (see note 17), vol. 1, p. 214, no. 190; vol. 2, pl. 119.
  131. See DeWitt, Evolution (see note 3), pp. 160-164.
  132. Jan Lievens, Portrait of Thomas Howard, Earl of Arundel, black and red chalk, 180 x 140 mm, Staatliche Museen zu Berlin, Kupferstichkabinett (KdZ 5869); Wheelock, Lievens (see note 2), p. 249, no. 109 (colour illus.).
  133. Jan Lievens, Profile Head of an Old Woman in Oriental Dress, c. 1630, panel, 43.2 x 33.7 cm, Kingston, Agnes Etherington Art Centre, gift of Alfred and Isabel Bader, 2005 (48-002). See entry by David de Witt in Wheelock, Lievens (see note 2), pp. 122-123, no. 21 (colour illus.).
  134. Letter to his son the Earl of Lothian, May 1654: Correspondence of Sir Robert Kerr, First Earl of Ancram, and His Son William, Third Earl of Lothian, vol. 2, London, 1875, p. 383; C. Hofstede de Groot, “Hollandsche Kunst in Schotland,” Oud Holland 11 (1893), p. 214.

Unravelling A Myth: Tulp’s Chimpanzee and Rembrandt

A book by the prominent 17th-century Dutch physician and acquaintance of Rembrandt, Nicolaes Tulp, contains a print of an anthropoid ape. The University of British Columbia (UBC) Library owns a copy of the book in which an original red chalk drawing occupies the place of the engraving. Hugh Sinclair, its last private owner, believed it was the preparatory drawing for the print, and that it was drawn by Rembrandt. In this article we will examine the evidence and unravel a Rembrandt myth, which to this date has remained under the radar of Rembrandt specialists.

 

The drawing in: N. Tulp, Observationum Medicarum, p. 275, copy of Hugh Sinclair. Vancouver, UBC Library.
1. The drawing in: N. Tulp, Observationum Medicarum, p. 275, copy of Hugh Sinclair. Vancouver, UBC Library.

A drawing attributed to Rembrandt

In 1965, the University of British Columbia (UBC) Library acquired the collection of historical medical books from the medical researcher Hugh Macdonald Sinclair (1910-1990).135 The purchase of this collection forms a significant portion of the Gibson Collection of Medicine and Science. An inventory, listing the contents of the 65 tea chests containing approximately 7000 books, accompanied the purchase.136

While most of the items in the list are brief records with some minor annotations prepared by the collector, Hugh Sinclair, there is one full page detailing his copy of the Observationum Medicarum of 1641, written by the Amsterdam physician and surgeon Nicolaes Tulp (1593-1674). In UBC’s copy of the first edition, there is an original red chalk drawing representing a seated ‘Orang-outang’ (Fig. 1) whereas in other copies of this edition, one finds a print of the same composition, in mirror image (Fig. 2).137 In his description, Sinclair presumes this drawing to be the original from which the engraving for the plate was made and argues that it was drawn by Rembrandt. However, the drawing, which is neither dated nor signed, has never been discussed in the literature on Rembrandt. Its existence has also never been signalled in the literature on the discovery of anthropoid apes, for which orangutan was a generic term until the end of the eighteenth century.

 

Unknown artist, Portrait of a chimpanzee. Engraving, in: N. Tulp, Observationum Medicarum, Amsterdam 1641, p. 275. Leiden, Leiden University Libraries
2. Unknown artist, Portrait of a chimpanzee. Engraving, in: N. Tulp, Observationum Medicarum, Amsterdam 1641, p. 275. Leiden, Leiden University Libraries, 615F2.

The birth of a Rembrandt myth

A review of the Library’s acquisition files revealed that there was a great deal of press coverage concerning the acquisition and the Rembrandt claim. For example, UBC Reports, a newsletter of the university, made a big splash of the acquisition:

A rare 1641 edition of a medical text by Nicholaas Tulp, physician to Rembrandt, which has been bound into it a red chalk drawing of a chimpanzee, allegedly by the great Dutch painter. The chalk drawing is the original used to make a copper engraving which is used to illustrate other copies of the Tulp book also in the collection.138

Other newspaper clippings and correspondence in the acquisition files pick up the claim. The Oxford Times (February 25, 1966) quotes Dr. Sinclair about the sale “… including a copy of Tulp’s Observations worth 3,000 pounds and containing a drawing attributed to Rembrandt”. An article in the Vancouver Sun (March 24, 1966) entitled, UBC has puzzle painting, reflects caution when quoting Dr. William Gibson (Professor and Head of the History of Medicine and Science Department): “We’re not making it a cause celebre” and explaining that the university had no plans to get experts to verify or disprove whether the drawing was an original Rembrandt.

 

Motivation to investigate further

In 2017, while researching the Gibson Collection, Charlotte Beck, a librarian at UBC re-discovered Sinclair’s inventory of the collection he sold to UBC in 1965 and the note in the original catalogue record for Tulp’s Observationum Medicarum, “attributed by some to be by Rembrandt,” caught her attention. With Katherine Kalsbeek, Head of Rare Books and Special Collections, she began to investigate the basis for this attribution. Recently a new impulse arose at the UBC to investigate this matter further.

At the Rembrandt House Museum in the summer of 2021 another copy of the 1641 edition of the Observationum Medicarum appeared in the exhibition Hansken. Rembrandt’s Elephant. Rembrandt was fascinated by unfamiliar animals from distant regions and his drawings of the elephant Hansken bear witness to this.139 A similar interest surfaces in Tulp’s book. Never before had such a human-like animal reached the European continent alive. The book was exhibited opened to the page with the engraving (Fig. 2). Next to it was a seventeenth-century map of Guinea in Africa, on which the same animal (actually a chimpanzee), appears in the same seated position.

Nina Siegal reviewed the exhibition for The New York Times.140 Her piece caught the attention of Katherine Kalsbeek in Vancouver. She contacted Michiel Roscam Abbing, guest curator of the exhibition. The present article is the result of the collaborative research that followed.

Hugh Sinclair’s description of the book and the drawing. Hugh Sinclair’s typescript inventory, Vancouver, UBC Library.
3. Hugh Sinclair’s description of the book and the drawing. Hugh Sinclair’s typescript inventory, Vancouver, UBC Library.


Claims made by Sinclair

In the last line of his description, Sinclair recalls a visit to his library by the “late Professor William Jackson of Harvard”. Jackson, at the time an internationally renowned bibliographer and a librarian at the Houghton Library, part of Harvard College Library, died in Boston on October 4, 1964, which implies that Sinclair wrote the inventory in connection to the sale. Sinclair begins his entry with a brief description of both editions of Tulp’s book in his possession, from 1641 and 1739 respectively.141 This is followed by an elaboration of the drawing in the earliest edition. Sinclair argues that the drawing should be attributed to Rembrandt. He had discussed this with scholars, including Professor Jackson. The entry is published here for the first time (Fig. 3): 

Tulp, Nicolaas (1593-1674). Observationum medicarum libri tres. Amstelredami, 1641. Bount in contemporary vellum with on title-page: “Simon Mollerius Chirurgus jure me possidet 1641 die 18 Nov.”

Also another edition: Observationes medicae. Edition sexta. LB, 1739. Bound in contemporary calf, gilt, with the plate of the “orang-outang” on p. 271.

The first of these is the rare first edition of 1641, which was the first book to contain a plate of a man-like ape, called by Tulp for the first time “orang-outang” (in fact, a chimpanzee). (The true orang was first described in 1658; the gorilla was not even discovered until 1847). But in this copy of the first edition, the plate which should be at p. 275 is replaced by an original red chalk drawing, mirror image of the actual plate. The drawing bound into the book is obviously the original from which the copper engraving for the plate was made, and there are the following strong reasons for believing it was drawn by Rembrandt.

Tulp was the first to describe the vasa lactea and the ileocaecal valve. Apart from being the outstanding general practitioner of his time in Amsterdam, he also was an important figure in the civic affairs of the town (four times Burgomaster; eight times City Treasurer; City Councillor from 1629-53; etc.). Rembrandt (1606-1669) was his close friend, and the famous “Anatomy Lesson” of 1632 shows Tulp as the central figure carrying out the dissection. Tulp in the above book refers to a patient of his who is certainly Rembrandt (chap. XVIII, pp. 37-9): “Insignis Pictor … in arte sua abunde sagax, et vix ulli secundus”: the painter was so pleased of his cure by Tulp that he could not adequately praise his healer. So these friends were presumably in close contact in Amsterdam around 1641 (the year Rembrandt painted Anna Wijmer whose son Jan married Tulp’s daughter Margaretha).

At this time Prince Frederik Hendrik of Nassau was sent an alive “orang-outang” from the Dutch East Indies. It was a centre of attraction in Amsterdam, and was carefully described by Tulp who also pictured it in his book. The excitement caused by the arrival of the ape in Amsterdam is further shown by a second representation, made for William Grotius (brother of the celebrated Hugo) which he sent to friends in Paris; this led to the French philosopher and naturalist Claude Peiresc placing the animal between monkey and man (E.T. Hamy: Documents inédits sur l’Homo Sylvestris rapporté d’Angola en 1630. Bull. Mus. Hist. Nat., Paris, 1897, 5, 277-282).

Who more likely for Tulp to ask to draw this interesting ape than his friend and patient Rembrandt who was so indebted to him? Further, Rembrandt himself kept a pet monkey which he still included in his large family portrait after its lamented death. He drew dead birds, “The slaughtered ox” three times, elephants and lions. In this early period he used red and black chalk on various occasions, although his later drawings are almost exclusively in pen and wash. The red chalk drawing in this book is supremely well done, and the cross-hatching in particular is exactly similar to that in red chalk drawings preserved in the Rembrandt House in Amsterdam.

Dr. Heckscher, in his great study Rembrandt’s Anatomy of Dr. Nicolaas Tulp (1958) states (p. 152): “Menno Hertzberger, Amsterdam, offered and sold recently a copy of the Observationes in which the place of the plate is taken by an excellent drawing that might conceivably be the original design”. This is the book referred to. Soon after I obtained it, the Dutch Government tried to stop export. Professor Horst Gerson, Director of the Netherlands Institute of Art History, later informed Dr. Heckscher that he believed the drawing preceded the print; and Dr. Menno Hertzberger, when he recently visited my library, told me it had been attributed to Rembrandt. The late Professor William Jackson of Harvard came to see the book and told me he was quite certain the drawing bound in was the original for the published copper engraving.

 

Ownership inscription by Simon Mollerius, 1641.
4. Ownership inscription by Simon Mollerius, 1641.

Claims made by others

Sinclair does not say when he bought the book, but he does say from whom. The Amsterdam antiquarian Menno Hertzberger (1897-1982) specialized in historical medical publications. In his sales catalogue from 1954, the book is offered under lot 442 and the drawing is shown on page 71.142 In the catalogue Hertzberger gives the following detailed description:

This engraving, representing an “orang outang” or chimpanzee, is replaced by a sketch in red chalk of the same subject in inversed sense. We have found no mention of any other copy having this feature. The drawing appears to be by a contemporary hand and, as such, might be the earliest in existence showing this animal and might have served for the engraving. Possibly it was made by the Surgeon Simon Mollerius, the first owner of the copy, whose autograph, dated 1641, is found on title together with two later ownership’s entries.

As the catalogue entry notes, the book was bought in 1641 by Simon Mollerius, according to the ownership inscription dated November 28, 1641 (Fig. 4). Mollerius married IJtje Gerrits on 1 January 1633 in Amsterdam. He was 25 years old and came from Emden in Germany. In February 1642 Mollerius sold a house in the Oude Looiersstraat. On October 10, 1649 he was buried in the Westerkerk as „master Simon Mollerius“ and living on the Prinsengracht. Surgeons took care of the sick and were allowed to perform simple medical treatments. They were trained by the Surgeons Guild. Mollerius undoubtedly attended Tulp’s lessons and he would have benefitted from the medical chapters in the book.

Rembrandt, The Anatomy Lesson of Dr. Nicolaes Tulp, 1632. Oil on canvas, 169.5 x 216.5 cm. The Hague, Mauritshuis.
5. Rembrandt, The Anatomy Lesson of Dr. Nicolaes Tulp, 1632. Oil on canvas, 169.5 x 216.5 cm. The Hague, Mauritshuis.

In 1958, art historian William S. Heckscher (1904-1999) published a monographic study on Rembrandt’s Anatomy Lesson of Dr. Nicolaes Tulp, now in the Mauritshuis (Fig. 5). In this study, Heckscher refers to the chimpanzee that Tulp describes, as well as the copy of the book sold by Hertzberger, and its drawing. Hertzberger’s own copy of the sales catalogue records six handwritten names in the margin of lot 442, five of which precede with a cross (Fig. 6).143 No doubt he sent a copy to these six, one of them “Heckscher”, assuming they might be interested in purchasing the book. The only name without a cross is the buyer, “Dr. Sinclair”. Heckscher received the sales catalogue and noted its assertion that the drawing might be the original after which the engraving was made.144 Hertzberger suggests that the drawing might have been made by the book’s first owner, the surgeon Mollerius. But here he contradicts himself: how could a drawing have been made by the first owner of the book if that same drawing served as an example of the engraving that should have been included in that book? Heckscher does not follow this suggestion and neither of them mention Rembrandt.

Handwritten notes by Menno Hertzberger in his sales catalogue Medicine Hippocrates-Claude Bernard (1954). Amsterdam, Allard Pierson, University of Amsterdam, Archives of Menno Hertzberger
6. Handwritten notes by Menno Hertzberger in his sales catalogue Medicine Hippocrates-Claude Bernard (1954). Amsterdam, Allard Pierson, University of Amsterdam, Archives of Menno Hertzberger, UBA235.

The assumption that the drawing was the model for the engraving was understandable though, because the drawing seems to be a mirror image of the engraving. According to Sinclair, the art historians he consulted were of that opinion. Horst Gerson (1907-1978), the then director of the Netherlands Institute for Art Historical Documentation, later informed Heckscher that he (also) believed that the drawing preceded the print. Professor William Jackson was likewise convinced that the drawing was the original from which the copper engraving was made. Sinclair does not mention that he was also in direct contact with Heckscher.145

 

A later owner of the copy had the drawing made

Analysis of the binding of the book provides new insight into the genesis of the drawing. It is not pasted or bound as a separate sheet, but made on the sheet of paper on which the engraving should have been printed. This is easy to explain. Two print runs were required in 1641. In the first, the inscription and page number were printed in the lead type („Medicarum Lib. III.    275“) and the space below was left blank for the second printing run. The second printing was necessary to print the image of the copper plate. In this specific case, only the first print run took place, and the copy was sold without the engraving of the described chimpanzee. A printer’s error. This means that the drawing could never have been made before 1641 and could never have been the original to which the engraving was made.

Anonymus, Portrait of a chimpanzee. Engraving, in: De drie Boecken der Medicijnsche Aenmerkingen, after Tulp 1641. Allard Pierson, University of Amsterdam
7. Anonymus, Portrait of a chimpanzee. Engraving, in: De drie Boecken der Medicijnsche Aenmerkingen, after Tulp 1641. Allard Pierson, University of Amsterdam, OK 62-1902, p. 275.

In the year after Mollerius‘ death, in 1650, a Dutch translation of Tulp’s book entitled De drie boecken der medicijnsche aenmerkingen, was published. This was an unauthorized translation. Tulp had nothing to do with it, but was naturally vexed, and toward the end of his life produced his own translation from the Latin. It did not go to press, however, most likely because of Tulp’s death in 1674.146 Unsurprisingly, the Amsterdam bookseller who published the unauthorized translation, Jacob Benjamyn (c. 1624-1673), did not have at his disposal the copper plates that were used in 1641. These remained in Tulp’s possession and would be used for two subsequent Latin editions, in 1652 and in 1672, still during Tulp’s lifetime. They were also intended to be used to illustrate Tulp’s own, never-published translation.147 Benjamyn had very good copies made, which have never been used for any other edition. The engraving of the great ape is a mirror image of the engraving from 1641 (Fig. 7).

The unknown draftsman of the chimpanzee in the copy that Sinclair bought from Hertzberger followed the engraving of the translated edition of 1650 to fill in the blank page with the missing image. We can be sure as he also took over the engraved text on both sides of the head, “Tab. XIIII” and “Homo sylvestris. Orang-outang,” exactly after the example he had before him (Fig. 8).

So what can be concluded is that, after Mollerius’ death in 1649, in or after 1650, a later owner commissioned the illustration in red chalk. A second entry, dated October 18, 1682, shows that the book was then owned by Dethard Meppen (1656-1702), a lawyer who obtained his doctorate in Jena in 1677.148 It is unknown who owned the book between 1649 and 1682.

 

Unknown artist, Portrait of a chimpanzee, 1650 or later. Red chalk, in: N. Tulp, Observationum Medicarum, p. 275, copy of Hugh Sinclair. Vancouver, UBC Library
8. Unknown artist, Portrait of a chimpanzee, 1650 or later. Red chalk, in: N. Tulp, Observationum Medicarum, p. 275, copy of Hugh Sinclair. Vancouver, UBC Library

Sinclair’s hypotheses

In theory the draftsman could still have been Rembrandt, since he died in 1669. Sinclair argued that Rembrandt was responsible for the drawing. He relates that Hertzberger had visited his library and assured him that the drawing was attributed to Rembrandt.149 However there is no evidence of any other scholar’s support of this view. Tulp’s description of one of his patients, an unnamed painter cured by him, leads Sinclair to unreservedly assume that that unnamed patient must be Rembrandt: „Who more likely for Tulp to ask and draw this interesting ape than his friend and patient Rembrandt who was so indebted to him?”

Sinclair further states that shortly after purchasing the book, the Dutch government tried to stop its export. If there really was an attempt to ban export, it must have had to do with the attribution to Rembrandt. However, during our research in the National Archives in The Hague we were unable to confirm this event.150 Nor has any correspondence about this case with Sinclair been found in Menno Herzberger’s personal archive.151 In the Netherlands, the Cultural Heritage Preservation Act (Wet tot Behoud van Cultuurbezit) today the Heritage Act (Erfgoedwet) only came into effect in 1985. In the 1950s there was not even any legal basis to ban the export of such an item.152

The book collector achieves some traction when he points to drawings by Rembrandt in red chalk with a similar hatching. Sinclair states that drawings with cross-hatching that is ‘exactly similar’ are kept in the Rembrandt House Museum. However, there was and is not a single red chalk drawing by Rembrandt in the Museum’s collection. In 2021 Sinclair’s attribution was confidently rejected on stylistic grounds by Peter Schatborn, former head of the Rijksmuseum’s Print Room, one of world’s leading Rembrandt experts, and compiler of the most recent catalogue of Rembrandt’s drawings.153

 

Willem Blaeu, Map of Guinea (dedicated to Nicolaes Tulp), 1634. Engraving and water colour. University of Amsterdam
9. Willem Blaeu, Map of Guinea (dedicated to Nicolaes Tulp), 1634. Engraving and water colour, 38.5 x 52.5 cm. Allard Pierson, University of Amsterdam, HB-KZL 33.20.62.

The arrival of the anthropoid ape in Europe

Tulp wrote in his report that the ‘Orang-outang’ was a gift to Stadholder Frederik Hendrik and, in his memory, came from Angola. He does not record the year he saw the animal. But Sinclair had found a publication stating that the ape arrived in Holland in 1630.154 He does not elaborate on this information however, and does not mention that Rembrandt was still living in Leiden at that time, and would only meet Tulp and paint the Anatomy Lesson in Amsterdam two years later.

Ernst Brinck (1582-1649), the regent from Harderwijk who made notes about the elephant Hansken, also confirms 1630 as the year of the chimpanzee’s arrival. His notes specify that the ape arrived in Amsterdam and was brought by ships of the West India Company.155 It is unknown how long the animal lived.

It is plausible that a portrait was made of the chimpanzee on its arrival in Amsterdam. In 1641 that portrait was available to Tulp who had an engraving made after it. No longer extant, this original had already been in the hands of the Amsterdam mapmaker Willem Jansz Blaeu (1571-1638). Blaeu’s map of Guinea from 1634, dedicated to Nicolaes Tulp, shows the sitting ape (Fig. 9).156 Sinclair was evidently unaware that the original portrait was known and published some seven years before publication of Tulp’s book.

 

Conclusion

The long-standing myth that Rembrandt was the creator of this drawing seems to have originated with Hugh Sinclair himself. We can now conclude that the drawing in Sinclair’s book is a later version, made in or after 1650, after a copy of a copy of the original portrait of the chimpanzee that must have been made shortly after the animal’s arrival in Amsterdam in 1630. Based on our research, it is evident that the drawing in Sinclair’s book was commissioned by a later owner of the book and done by an unknown artist.

Katherine Kalsbeek (BA, MLIS) has worked with UBC Library since 2004 and is currently the Head, Rare Books & Special Collections (RBSC).

Michiel Roscam Abbing (1958) was awarded his doctorate at Amsterdam University with a thesis on Rembrandt documents, Rembrant toont syn konst (1999). He compiled a list of New Rembrandt documents (2006) and was guest-curator of the exhibition Hansken, Rembrandt’s elephant (2021) in the Rembrandt House Museum. 

Charlotte Beck, a reference librarian at Woodward Library, UBC, is the liaison for the rehabilitation sciences and as the history of science and medicine librarian has oversight for the Gibson collection.

 

  1. Werner Sumowski, Paul Huys Janssen, The Hoogsteder Exhibition of Rembrandt’s Academy, exh. cat. The Hague: Hoogsteder & Hoogsteder, 1992, cat. no. 28.
  2. Exhibition catalogues: Albert Blanckert, Jezus in de Gouden Eeuw, exh. cat. Rotterdam: Kunsthal, 2000–2001; Akira Kofuku, Rembrandt and the Rembrandt School. The Bible, mythology and ancient history, exh. cat. Tokyo: Museum of Western Art, 2003; Arthur K. Wheelock et al., Jan Lievens. A Dutch Master Rediscovered, exh. cat. Washington: National Gallery of Art; Milwaukee: Milwaukee Art Museum; Amsterdam: Rembrandt House Museum, 2008-2009, cat.no. 52; Louis van Tilborgh, Constantijn Huygens. Kunstkenner en verzamelaar, exh. cat. The Hague: Museum Bredius, 2013, cat. no. 14. Other literature: Werner Sumowski, Gemälde der Rembrandtschüler, vol. 4, Landau, 1983, p. 3726, no. 2356, fig. 3964; Helga Gutbrod, Lievens und Rembrandt : Studien zum Verhältnis ihrer Kunst, Frankfurt am Main, 1996, p. 299; Edwin Buijssen (ed.), Haagse schilders in de Gouden Eeuw, Het Hoogsteder lexicon van alle schilders werkzaam in Den Haag 1600-1700, The Hague, 1998, p. 191; Lloyd DeWitt, Evolution and Ambition in the career of Jan Lievens, 1607-1674, Phd. Diss. University of Maryland, College Park, 2006, p. 228.
  3. DeWitt, Evolution (see note 2), p. 228.
  4. For example those mentioned in the Montias Database of 17th Century Dutch Art Inventories and the Getty Provenance Research Index.
  5. Sumowski, Huys Janssen, Academy (see note 1), p. 220.
  6. Dr Gaston Gaudinot sale, Paris (Drouot), 13-14 February 1869.
  7. Sumowski, Huys Janssen, Academy (see note 1), p. 220.
  8. Ibid.
  9. Sumowski, Huys Janssen, Academy (see note 1), p. 226. Huys Janssen explains that the miracle as described in Luke and John differs from the version told by Matthew.
  10. After listening to the centurion, and before addressing him directly, Jesus speaks to his followers: “I tell you, many will come from east and west and sit at table with Abraham, Isaac, and Jacob in the kingdom of heaven.” (Matthew 8:11) Perhaps Lievens incorporated this part of the text and explicitly included people coming from the east (from the standpoint of his Dutch audience). A second possibility is that they are Pharisees. This group plays the role elsewhere in Matthew of disbelieving critics, and here they may serve to accentuate the belief of the centurion in the Christian faith. In early prints (Sebald Beham, Israhel van Meckenem, Hans Schaüfelein and Cornelis Massijs) and several Italian prints from Lievens’s time (seventeenth century prints after Paolo Veronese), Pharisees wear such headdresses. A parallel between blacks and overseas regions, such as in Lievens’s Brinio, is convincingly outlined by Elmer Kolfin (in: Elmer Kolfin, De kunst van de macht, Jordaens, Lievens en Rembrandt in het Paleis op de Dam, Zwolle, 2023, p. 67), does not seem to apply here.
  11. Sumowski, Huys Janssen, Academy (see note 1), p. 223.
  12. Sumowski, Huys Janssen, Academy (see note 1), pp. 223, 226.
  13. The right eye from the perspective of the viewer. There, a pupil was painted in, in a later restoration. Because of the sketchy manner it is difficult to ascertain whether or not both eyes are present, but in the left the lower eyelid is visible, while it is undefined in the right eye.
  14. For example: Jacobus Neeffs (after Jacob Jordaens), Judgement of Christ, etching, c. 1630-1645; Marinus van der Goes (after Jacques Jordaens), Judgement of Christ, engraving, c. 1614-1639; Willem Panneels (after Peter Paul Rubens), Adoration of the kings, etching, 1630; Nicolaes Lauwers (after Peter Paul Rubens), Ecce Homo, engraving, c. 1619-1652; and many more. Generally, for examples of inspiration drawn from prints by Lievens, see De
    Witt, Evolution (see note 2).
  15. Sumowski, Huys Janssen, Academy (see note 1), p. 226. Huys Janssen refers to examples by Nicolaes Moeyaert (Herentals, St. Waltrudis church) and Adam Camerarius (Amsterdam, Rijksmuseum, inv. no. SK-A-733). DeWitt refers to a painting by Bartholomeus Breenbergh (Karlsruhe, Staatliche Kunsthalle Karlsruhe, inv. no. 228) and the Moeyaert in Herentals (DeWitt, Evolution (see note 2), p. 227). But also see a woodcut with this subject by Cornelis van Sichem II in Der zielen lusthof (1629). Also of interest: Claes Moeyeart, Christ and the Centurion, 1632 (Minneapolis, Minneapolis Institute of Art, inv. no. 2012.84.5). Although the painting is known under this subject, it may in fact depict Cornelius kneeling before Peter, since more than one figure is shown kneeling and the composition closely resembles prints of this subject.
  16. Henri van de Waal, “’s Lands oudste verleden in de voorstelling van Vondel en zijn tijdgenooten”, Elsevier’s Maandschrift 47 (1937); Henri van de Waal, “Tempesta en de historieschilderingen op het Amsterdamse stadhuis”, Oud Holland 56 (1939); Henri van de Waal, Drie eeuwen vaderlandsche geschied-uitbeelding 1500-1800, een iconologische studie, The Hague, 1952; Kolfin, Kunst (see note 10).
  17. Antonio Tempesta (after Otto van Veen), Print 8 in (…)De Batavische oft oude Hollandtsche oorloghe teghen de Romeynen, 1612. Etching, 167 x 210 mm. Rijksmuseum, Amsterdam, inv. no. RP-P-OB-37.614. Jürgen Ovens based his drawing for the Batavian Series depicting Claudius Civilis leaving the Women and Children to fight at Xanten (Hamburg, Hamburger Kunsthalle, inv. no. 22342) on this print.
  18. On the period in The Hague: Buijssen Haagse (see note 2), pp.191-193.
  19. Haarlem, Teylers Museum, inv. no. P 006. For the identification and context, see: Gregor Weber, “Dus leeft de dappre Graaf: Zu einem Bildnis Andries de Graeffs von Jan Lievens (1607-1674)”, Oud Holland 99 (1985), pp. 44-56.
  20. Van de Waal, Eeuwen (see note 16), p. 230; Kolfin, De kunst van de macht (see note 10), pp. 19-20.
  21. Van de Waal, “’s Lands” (see note 16), p. 301-302.
  22.  Kolfin, Kunst (see note 10), p. 41. Four Batavian scenes were never completed. For two the themes are known, for the other two are not known.
  23. Munich, Staatliche Graphische Sammlung München, inv. no. 1451; Hamburg, Hamburger Kunsthalle, Kupferstichkabinett, inv. no. 22342. A lesser-known drawing of Rembrandt’s Conspiracy of Claudius Civilis (Edinburgh, National Galleries of Scotland, inv. no. D 23862) shows – when compared to the drawing in Munich – that the lower section of the painting is covered by a frieze and that portions of the left and right sides are obscured. This may indicate that an alternative conception of the framing of the lunettes was considered before the one ultimately implemented. It is possible that this earlier framing was already envisioned when Lievens produced his oil sketch Christ and the Centurion.
  24. Van de Waal, Eeuwen (see note 16), p. 225, referring to SAA, 5039, 2 resolutieboek, f. 66r.
  25. Ibid., referring to SAA, 5039, 153 rapiamus 1661, f.195v.
  26. Van de Waal, Eeuwen (see note 16), p. 225.
  27. Gregor Weber, “Jan Lievens’s ‘The Shield-raising of Brinio’ a Second Oil Sketch”, Hoogsteder-Naumann Mercury 12/13 (1992), nt. 8.
  28. Dewitt, Evolution (see note 2), p. 221.
  29. Kolfin, Kunst (see note 10), p.67.
  30. Kolfin, Kunst (see note 10), p. 44.
  31. For, among other things, contemporary poetry in which Civilis and others are compared to the members of the House of Orange: Van de Waal, Eeuwen (see note 16), pp. 220-221, 223.
  32. Kolfin, Kunst (see note 10), p. 47.
  33. Margriet van Eikema Hommes, Elmer Kolfin, De Oranjezaal in Huis ten Bosch, Een zaal uit loutere liefde, Zwolle, 2013, p. 77.
  34. Kolfin, Kunst (see note 10), pp. 41-47, 77.
  35. One may ask, in light of points discussed in this article, whether the “Christ” figure in the first version was in fact Christ at all. If so, the oil sketch would initially have represented solely a Christian scene without any reference to the Batavian Revolt, thereby less relatable to the (eventual) decoration program of the Town Hall’s gallery. Given that in the initial design the groups left and right with Biblical and/or eastern figures do not seem to have been included (aside from a bearded man on the right, judging from the x-ray), the large central figure may originally have been Julius Civilis. In compositional terms, this would align the painting more closely with the print by Tempesta after Van Veen. The apparent similarity in hairstyle between the final Christ figure and the initial figure, together with the possible initial presence of a (holy) beam of light directed toward the figure, may argue against this hypothesis; nevertheless, Brinno in Lievens’s Brinio Raised on the Shield likewise features long hair and even incorporates a diagonal compositional line through the clouds, comparable to the line through the foliage in the initial version of the present subject. The later insertion of Christ could then be understood as a deliberate twist, imparting a more prominent Christian meaning to the historical scene. These suggestions and observations were kindly shared by Jochem van Eijsden.
  36. Samuel van Hoogstraten, Inleyding tot de hooge schoole der schilderkonst: anders de zichtbaere werelt, Rotterdam 1678, p. 18. Van Hoogstraten here refers to the period when he was “still a disciple”, during which, as part of a “we”, he and others discussed a particular question, to which a certain “Fabritius” responded with an answer. It is generally assumed that this refers to Carel Fabritius, who is assumed to have studied with Rembrandt between approximately 1641 and 1643.
  37. Werner Sumowski described Van Hoogstraten as “pädagogisch begabt, Assistent Rembrandts gewesen” (Werner Sumowski, Gemälde der Rembrandt-Schüler II, Landau/Pfalz 1984, p. 1286). As supporting evidence, Sumowski argued that Van Hoogstraten corrected drawings by Constantijn Daniël van Renesse (; p. 1290, nt. 2). When discussing one of these drawings (Moses and Reuel’s Daughters at the Well, Amsterdam, Rijksmuseum, inv. no. RP-T-1893-A-2782) Sumowski suggested the possibility that “Samuel van Hoogstraten acted as assistant to the master on occasional trips even at a later date”. (Werner Sumowski, Drawings of the Rembrandt School IX, New York 1985, no. 2159x). Building on this, Jonathan Bikker suggested in his monograph on Willem Drost that Van Hoogstraten “might have supervised Drost during his early days in Rembrandt’s studio” (Jonathan Bikker, Willem Drost, A Rembrandt Pupil in Amsterdam and Venice, New Haven/London 2005, p. 11). David de Witt later observed, in his Abraham van Dijck monograph, concerning Van Hoogstraten: “by 1646 his training would have been complete, but he appears to have stayed on as a tutor or head pupil for several years” (David De Witt, Life and Work of Late Rembrandt Pupil Abraham van Dijck, c. 1635-1680, Amsterdam 2020, p. 11).
  38. Sabine Pénot, Rembrandt – Hoogstraten. Colour and Illusion, exh. cat. Vienna: Kunsthistorisches Museum Wien, 2024; Nathalie Maciesza, Epco Runia, Samuel van Hoogstraten. De Illusionist, exh. cat. Amsterdam: Rembrandt House Museum, 2025; Sabine van Beek, Leonore van Sloten, David de Witt et al., Samuel van Hoogstraten: Catalogue Raisonné, The Hague 2025.
  39. The catalogue of the Vienna exhibition assumes a position for Van Hoogstraten as an assistant for approximately three to four years (Angelina Illes, in: exh. cat. Vienna 2024 (see note 3), p. 29; Jonathan Bikker, in: exh. cat. Vienna 2024 (see note 3), p. 93), though it makes no mention of any teaching responsibilities. These are, however, included in the publication accompanying the exhibition at the Rembrandt House Museum (Michiel Roscam Abbing, in: exh. cat. Amsterdam 2025 (see note 3), p. 19; David De Witt, in: exh. cat. Amsterdam 2025 (see note 3), p. 131), and in the online Van Hoogstraten catalogue raisonné by the RKD (Michiel Roscam Abbing, in: The Hague 2025 (see note 3), “With Rembrandt in Amsterdam”. https://vanhoogstraten.rkdstudies.nl/samuel-van-hoogstraten-the-ingenious-and-poetic-painter/with-rembrandt-inamsterdam/, 26 May 2025).
  40. The term “assistent” was used in Holland in the 17th century, albeit in other contexts, see: Woordenboek Nederlandse taal, s.v. assistent, https://gtb.ivdnt.org/iWDB/search?actie=article&wdb=WNT&id=M004535&lemma=assistent&domein=0&conc=true, 11
    July 2025.
  41. “Een min of meer ondergeschikte helper”, a more or less subordinate helper (see note 5); “A person who helps or supports somebody, usually in their job”: Oxford English Dictionary, s.v. assistant, https://www.oed.com/view/Entry/12041, 11 July 2025.
  42. The guild archive has been lost. For a comprehensive account of the Amsterdam Guild of Saint Luke and its ordinances, see: Isabella H. van Eeghen, “Schilders of Sint Lucasgilde”, in: Isabella H. van Eeghen (ed.), Inventarissen der archieven van de gilden en van het brouwerscollege, Amsterdam 1951, passim.; Isabella H. van Eeghen (Jasper Hillegers, translator), “The Amsterdam Guild of Saint Luke in the 17th Century”, Journal of Historians for Netherlandish Art 4.2 (2012), passim., DOI:10.5092/jhna.2012.4.2.4, 11 July 2025. The current article relies exclusively on the guild regulations of the Amsterdam De Kroniek 2024/25 – Museum Rembrandthuis 10 painters’ guild. It is often assumed that the regulations of painters’ guilds in different Dutch towns did not differ substantially in content. On that assumption, gaps in the regulations of one town might be filled by those of another. However, the discussion later in this article regarding whether apprentices were permitted to produce their own work shows that crucial differences did in fact exist. For that reason, guild regulations from other cities are not used here to fill the gaps in the surviving Amsterdam regulations.
  43. Extract van de willekeuren en ordonnantien den gilde van St. Lucas verleent, Amsterdam 1720, p. 11.
  44. Extract (see note 8), p. 11; This is also the case in the chapter title and margin of the 1766 publication of all known guild charters: Ordonnantien en willekeuren van het Lucas-gilde binnen Amsterdam, Amsterdam 1766, p. 64, 68. It is noteworthy that the dean and headmen of the guild employed a gilde kneght (Extract (see note 8), pp. 26-27. This was not a pupilship, and the tasks meet the definition of an assistant in the Oxford English Dictionary and the Woordenboek Nederlandse Taal (see note 6)
  45. Extract (see note 8), pp. 12-13
  46. Extract (see note 8), pp. 11-12.
  47. Extract (see note 8), p. 12.
  48. Cornelis Kiliaen (ed. Frans Claes), Etymologicum teutonicae linguae, Antwerp 1599 (The Hague 1972), p. 278, s.v. leerionghe; leer-kind; leer-knecht; leerlinck; p. 703, s.v. discipel. In the regulations of the Haarlem Guild of St. Luke from 1634 (NHA, 1105, Ambachtsgilden te Haarlem (Gilden Haarlem), no. 219), the terms “leerling”, “leerjongen”, and “discipel” are
    used. This might suggest that a distinction existed between them, but they are actually used interchangeably. The same applies to the terms “(werk)gezel”, “knecht”, and – a new term – “gast”. The latter is synonymous with journeyman or servant: “Knecht van een ambachtsman of fabrikant; gezel, werkknecht”, servant of a tradesman or manufacturer; journeyman, workshop hand: Woordenboek Nederlandse taal, s.v. gast, https://gtb.ivdnt.org/iWDB/searchactie=article&wdb=WNT&id=M017355.re.35&lemma=werkgast&domein=0&conc=true,
    16 oktober 2025.
  49. Kiliaen, Etymologicum (see note 13), p. 139, s.v. ghe-selle van een ampt. The Latin word “collega” is likewise a translation for “ambtgenoot”, “maet”, and “vennoot” (Kiliaen, Etymologicum (see note 13), p. 18, s.v. ampt-ghenoot; p. 302, s.v. maet, med-maet, maetken; p. 579, s.v. veyn-out, veyn-noot, ven-noot, vennoot, veyn-gnoot).
  50. Kiliaen, Etymologicum (see note 13), p. 244, s.v. knecht, dienaer.
  51. Nicolaas de Roever, “Drie Amsterdamsche Schilders (Pieter Isaaksz, Abraham Vinck, Cornelis van der Voort)”, Oud Holland 3 (1885), p. 198.
  52. In 1619, he was asked together with several artists who had traveled to Italy, including Pieter Lastman, Adriaen van Nieulandt, and Barent van Someren, to assess the authenticity of a Caravaggio painting from the collection of the late Louis Finson. Abraham Bredius, Nicolaas de Roever, “Pieter Lastman en François Venant”, Oud Holland 4 (1886), pp. 7-8.
  53. Ronald de Jager “Meester, leerjongen, leertijd. Een analyse van Zeventiende-eeuwse Noord-Nederlandse leerlingcontracten van kunstschilders, goud- en zilversmeden”, Oud Holland 104 (1990), p. 96, nt. 107. The title of “gezel” is, in fact, never mentioned in the known Amsterdam contracts.
  54. De Jager, “Meester” (see note 18), pp. 73-75.
  55. De Jager, “Meester” (see note 18), p. 71.
  56. Stadsarchief Amsterdam (hereafter SAA), 5075, 393A, nots. Jacob Jacobs and Nicolaes Jacobs, ff. 59r-59v, 20-07-1626; Abraham Bredius, “Gerrit Willemsz. Horst”, Oud Holland 50 (1933), pp. 5-6; De Jager, “Meester” (see note 18), p. 98, no. 7.
  57. This underscores a clear distinction: as was also evidenced by the entries in Kiliaen, Etymologicum (see note 13), dienaer was a synonym for knecht, not for leerknecht (see note 15).
  58. Abraham Bredius, Künstlerinventare. Urkunden zur Geschichte der holländischen Kunst des XVIten, XVIIten und XVIIIten Jahrhunderts V, The Hague 191, pp. 1482-1483; De Jager, “Meester” (see note 18), p. 98, no. 10.
  59. The value of a barrel of herring in Amsterdam in 1635 was approximately 120 grams of silver (Bo Poulsen, Dutch Herring. An Environmental History, c. 1600–1860, Amsterdam 2008, p. 93, table 6.9); in the seventeenth century, ten grams of silver corresponded to the value of roughly one guilder.
  60. The tuition fees in Holland for a two-year contract averaged 61.5 guilders per year (De Jager, “Meester” (see note 18), p. 75).
  61. Josua Bruyn, “Een onderzoek naar 17de -eeuwse schilderijformaten, voornamelijk in Noord-Nederland”, Oud Holland 93 (1979), p. 113.
  62. Abraham Bredius, Künstlerinventare. Urkunden zur Geschichte der holländischen Kunst des XVIten, XVIIten und XVIIIten Jahrhunderts II, The Hague 1916, pp. 400-401; De Jager, “Meester” (see note 18), p. 98
  63. As a journeyman painter Waltusz earned less than half the daily wage of peers in other trades. In 1652, journeymen carpenters and bricklayers in Amsterdam earned approximately 26 to 27 stivers per summer day (although there are no exact figures for 1651, data is available for 1633, 27 and 25 stivers respectively, and for 1667, 28 and 27 stivers respectively).
    This disparity between painter’s journeymen and their peers in other trades mirrors the situation in 1579. The guild
    regulations (gildebrief) of the St. Luke’s Guild from that year mention journeymen earning 4 stivers and others earning 10
    stivers per day (Ordonnantien (see note 9), p. 17, art. 11). Taking the average of 7 stivers, these were notably low wages –
    practically half – when compared to the 14 and 12 stivers earned by carpenters and bricklayers, respectively, in that same
    year. For the wages of the workers mentioned here, see: Hubert Nutseling, Welvaart en werkgelegenheid in Amsterdam
    1540–1860, Amsterdam/Dieren 1985, p. 252, appendix 5.1, table A.
  64. SAA, DTB 5001, 469, p. 241, 30-09-1651; Judith van Gent, Bartholomeus van der Helst (circa 1613-1670): een studie naar zijn leven en zijn werk, Utrecht (Utrecht University), p. 41.
  65. Virtually nothing is known about Gerardus van Berleborch (Bernard Renckens, “G. van Berkborch”, Oud Holland 84 (1967), no. 4, passim). He or his father was likely from the region around Bad Berleburg in Germany. He appears to have been present in Leiden in 1665, when he is recorded as a witness (“Gerrit van Berleberg”) at the baptism of a child of the painter Jacobus Geutkien (Erfgoed Leiden en Omstreken (hereafter ELO), DTB 1004, 237, fol. 236v, 3-12-1665).
  66. SAA, 5075, 875, not. Jacob van Zwieten, pp. 638-640, 16-10-1649; Johannes G. van Dillen, Bronnen tot de geschiedenis van het bedrijfsleven en het gildewezen van Amsterdam 1510-1672 III, p. 540, no. 1057.
  67. A possible reason for this may be that young painters attained the status of master more quickly. This benefited the guild financially, as it earned income only from masters and pupils, not from journeymen.
  68. Ordonnantien (see note 9), p. 10, art. 3.
  69. Ordonnantien (see note 9), p. 17, art. 11.
  70. Joachim von Sandrart’s famous anecdote about Rembrandt’s studio being filled with “countless elite children”, pupils who each paid an annual tuition fee of 100 guilders suggests that the legal limit on the number of pupils was, in practice, a dead letter (Joachim von Sandrardt, Teutsche Academie, Nuremberg 1675, p. 326; Van Eeghen, “Guild” (see note 7), p. 6).
  71. Young Man Reading with a Vanitas Still Life, 1644, oil on panel, 58 x 74 cm, Rotterdam, Museum Boijmans Van Beuningen, inv. no. 1386; Self-portrait, 1644, oil on panel, 63 x 48 cm, The Hague, Museum Bredius, inv. no. 056-1946; Self-portrait, 1645, oil on panel, 54.1 x 44.8 cm, Liechtenstein, The Princely Collections, Vaduz-Vienna, inv. no. GE 107; Portrait of a Child, 1645, oil on panel, 68.6 x 57.8 cm, private collection; The Adoration of the Shepherds, 1647, oil on canvas, 58.2 x 70.8 cm, Dordrecht, Dordrechts Museum, inv. no. DM/980/567.
  72. Godefridus J. Hoogewerff, De geschiedenis van de St. Lucasgilden in Nederland, Amsterdam 1947, p. 24; Ernst van de Wetering “Problems of Pupilship and Studio Practice” in: Josua Bruyn et al., A Corpus of Rembrandt Paintings II: 1631-1634, Amsterdam 1986, p. 57; Bikker, Drost (see note 2), p. 11; Angelina Illes, in: exh. cat. Vienna 2024 (see note 3), p. 29.
  73. Samuel Muller Fz., Schilders-vereenigingen te Utrecht. Bescheiden uit het Gemeentearchief, Utrecht 1880, p. 76; Frederik D.O. Obreen, Archief voor Nederlandsche Kunstgeschiedenis IV, Rotterdam 1881/1882, p. 51. The very fact that such a regulation had to be instituted in these cities already indicates that works were being signed by non-masters.
  74. De Jager, “Meester” (see note 18), pp. 77-79.
  75. Bruyn, “Onderzoek”, (see note 26), p. 113.
  76. David de Witt, Leonore van Sloten, in: The Hague 2025 (see note 3), “Rembrandt’s Impact”, https://vanhoogstraten.rkdstudies.nl/catalogus-schilderijen/rembrandts-impact/, 3 June 2025.
  77. Almost exclusively, reference is made to Bikker, Drost (see note 2), p. 11. Also in the exhibition catalogue of the Van Hoogstraten exhibition in Amsterdam, Drost is cited as an example of an early student of Van Hoogstraten (David de Witt, in: exh. cat. Amsterdam 2025 (see note 3), p. 131.
  78. Since Daniël Pont’s monograph on Barent Fabritius, (Daniël Pont, Barent Fabritius 1624–1673, The Hague, 1958) and Sumowski’s Drawings of the Rembrandt School (see note 2), no subsequent scholarly efforts have systematically De Kroniek 2024/25 – Museum Rembrandthuis 12 reconstructed his drawn oeuvre or analyzed the development of his distinctive style. The author’s forthcoming dissertation addresses this lacuna, and catalogues drawings by Barent Fabritius.
  79. Pont was among the first to suggest he may not have been a direct pupil of Rembrandt, but instead only came into contact with Rembrandt’s work indirectly, through his brother Carel (Pont, Barent (see note 43), p. 96). In the literature, uncertainty on this matter appears to have become the norm, with scholars consistently noting – or implicitly dealing with – the lack of evidence for a formal pupilship with Rembrandt (see: Paul Huys Jansen, Werner Sumowski, The Hoogsteder Exhibition of Rembrandt’s Academy, exh. cat. The Hague: Hoogsteder & Hoogsteder, 1992, p. 139; Walter A. Liedkte in: Hubert von Sonneburg, Rembrandt/Not Rembrandt in the Metropolitan Museum of Art I, exh. cat. New York City: The Metropolitan Museum of Art, 1995, cat. 48, pp. 145-146; Peter C. Sutton in: Albert Blankert, Rembrandt. A Genius and his impact, exh. cat. Melbourne: National Gallery of Victoria; Canberra: National Gallery of Australia, 1997, p. 283; Jan Blanc, Dans l’atelier de Rembrandt. Le maître et ses élèves, Paris 2006, p. 140.
  80. Holm Bevers, “Das Susanna-Thema im Werkstattzusammenhang: Zeichnungen”, in: Holm Bevers, Katja Kleinert, Claudia Laurenze-Landsberg, Rembrandts Berliner Susanna und die beiden Alten. Die Schaffung eins meisterwerks, exh. cat. Berlin: Staatliche Museen zu Berlin, Kupferstichkabinett; Gemäldegalerie, 2015, pp. 49-50.
  81. Katja Kleinert, Claudia Laurenze-Landsberg, “Wandlungen eines Gemäldes. Rembrandts Berliner Susanna und die beiden Alten”, in: exh. cat. Berlin 2015 (see note 45), p. 19, 32.
  82. See for instance Rembrandt’s Holy Family in the Carpenter’s workshop or his Star of the Kings (London, The British Museum, inv. nos. 1900,0824.144, 1910,0212.189).
  83. The drawing of a male model (here attributed to Barent Fabritius) has been described as stylistically very close to Van Hoogstraten (Martin Royalton-Kisch in: Catalogue of Drawings by Rembrandt and his School, London: The British Museum, 2010, cat. 71). The Departure of the Prodigal Son, a drawing already earlier attributed to Fabritius, is still considered a work by Van Hoogstraten (Frankfurt am Main, Städel Museum, inv. no. 817).
  84. A convincing spatial representation of the scene, achieved through a successful use of proportion, perspective, light, and color. For a elaboration on this definition, including references, see: Leonore van Sloten, “Regels voor de kunst”, in: David de Witt, Leonore van Sloten, Jaap van der Veen, Rembrandts late leerlingen. In de leer bij een genie, exh. cat. Amsterdam: Rembrandt House Museum, 2015, p. 73, note 31.
  85. In drawings by Barent Fabritius from the second half of the 1640s, his preparatory chalk underdrawing is generally careful and precise but not detailed, with clear, exact contours rendered in continuous, rounded lines. The somewhat squat figures possess a doll-like, slightly caricatural character. When using pen to trace or fill in the figures, particularly those in the foreground, the style becomes sketchier and more angular. Fabritius’s hatching lines become more carefully placed as they  grow finer, laid loosely side by side with only occasional thin-pen scratching, while thicker lines, including contours, are rendered in a zigzag, looser manner, often applied to foreground elements such as a repoussoir. Groups of hatching in shadowed, complex motifs (e.g., figures or foreground foliage) are neither intertwined nor uniformly oriented, and though the balance of light and shadow varies between drawings, it remains consistent within each composition; early mastery is evident in his wash applications, where loosely brushed transitions in shadows lend a painterly quality, enhancing figural plasticity and atmospheric depth, as seen in drawings with dramatic chiaroscuro effects.
  86. Although it has been argued by Holm Bevers that this drawing is by Constantijn Daniël van Renesse and dates from between 1650 and 1652 (Holm Bevers, “Ausstellungen zu Rembrandt in Rückblick”, Kunstchronik, 58 (2005), p. 480; Holm Bevers, in: Rembrandt. Die Zeichnungen im Berliner Kupferstichkabinett, exh. cat. Berlin: Staatliche Museen zu Berlin, Kupferstichkabinett, 2006, cat. no. 45, p. 158, nt. 12; Holm Bevers in: Holm Bevers et al., Drawings by Rembrandt and his Pupils. Telling the Difference, exh. cat. Los Angeles: The J. Paul Getty Museum, 2009, cat. no. 31.2, pp. 190-191), a number of features are so uncharacteristic of Van Renesse that the attribution cannot be sustained. This applies in particular to elements such as the heavy, coarse scratches in the shadow areas and the sketch-like rendering of the faces of Joseph and Mary. Van Renesse typically keeps shadow areas and light transitions in brush clear and even. Also characteristic is his meticulous penwork, marked by fine, short strokes in the contours and hatching lines (see for instance: The Judgment of Salomon, New York City (The Metropolitan Museum of Art, Robert Lehman Collection, inv. no. 1975.1.806; Daniel in the Lion’s Den, Rotterdam, Museum Boijmans Van Beuningen, inv. no. MB 200). Generally, it shows the boldness of Barent much more than the careful restraint of Renesse
  87. “Beeter waer ‚t dat [om de veranderin[g]] een eesel van achteren was, dan dat al de hoofden iuist wt het stuck sien. Dat oock omtrent de boom wat meerder groente was. | 1 losep heft af te swaer en te onbesuist | 2 Maria most het kindeken wat meerder vieren, want een teeder kint magh sulck duwen niet ver[dragen]. | losep al te kort en dick, sijn hooft wast hem wt de [borst?]. Sijn hebben alle beide al te groote koppen”. Transcript from: Leonore van Sloten, in: exh. cat. Amsterdam 2015 (see note 49), p. 73, nt. 27. “It would be better that [for the alteration] there were a donkey from the back, than that all the heads are looking straight out of the work. That there were also somewhat more greenery around the tree. | 1 Joseph lifts too heavily and too inconsiderately. | 2 Mary ought to ease the little child somewhat more, for a tender infant cannot [endure] such pushing. | Joseph is all too short and stout, his head grows out of the [chest?]. They both have all too large heads”. These instructions are also partly articulated within the drawing itself. Joseph is indeed shown tugging firmly at Mary’s arm, whereas in the more sketch-like version, he supports her more gently at the back. The small patch of greenery in the lower corner may also be a later addition, in correspondence with the suggestion.
  88. The face does not appear to be a correction in the technical sense, but rather an example of a foreshortened face viewed from below – a challenging principle of perspective.
  89. An attribution proposed Christian Dittrich (Christian Dittrich in: Christian Dittrich, Thomas Ketelsen, Rembrandt. Die Dresdener Zeichnungen 2004, exh. cat. Dresden: Staatliche Kunstsammlungen Dresden, Kupferstich-Kabinett, 2004, cat. no.14, pp. 80-81).
  90. Brusati implied the possibility that the text was written partly by Rembrandt and partly by Van Hoogstraten (Celeste Brusati, Artifice & Illusion. The Art and Writing of Samuel van Hoogstraten, Chicago/London 1995, pp. 31, 275, note 40). Rembrandt was excluded as the author of the instructions by Bevers, while Van Hoogstraten as author remained an option. Van Renesse was likewise ruled out by Bevers, based on a comparison with the handwriting on his Daniel in the Lions’ Den drawing and The Judgment of Solomon drawing (see note 51); Holm Bevers, in: exh. cat. Los Angeles 2009 (see note 51), cat. 31.1–31.2, p. 190; 191, note 3). To this may be added that the handwriting also closely resembles that of Barent Fabritius. Although little comparative material survives, the compact, small script of Fabritius’s name beneath the death inventory of his sister-in-law Aeltje, dated 24 April 1643 (SAA, 5075, 1628a, not. David de l’Hommel, p. 399), shows a strong resemblance to the instructions on the Dresden sheet.
  91. “Once you have mastered your handling and your eye is somewhat clarified, it will no longer trouble you to translate many naturalistic paintings into a naturalistic drawing”. “Wanneer gy uwe handeling nu machtich zijt, en uw oog wat verklaert is, zoo zal ‚t u ook niet verscheelen veel verwige Schilderyen in een verwige teykeningen na te klaren” (Van Hoogstraten, Inleyding (see note 1), p. 27)
  92. “I advise masters, when they review the drawings of their pupils, to improve them by making sketches of the same subject themselves. This is an excellent exercise and has greatly assisted many in the art of composition”. “De meesters raed ik, als ze de Teykeningen haerer discipelen overzien, datze de zelve, met schetssen op ‚t zelve voorwerp te maeken, verbeeteren. Dit oeffent ongemeen, en heeft veelen geweldich in de schikkunst geholpen” (Van Hoogstraten, Inleyding (see note 1), p. 192).
  93. “And certainly, this manner of drawing with pen and brush is likewise the most suitable for completing a masterly work in its full force. For one can also, whenever it proves convenient, work into it with red chalk and crayons, as though one were almost painting with colours”. “En zeker deeze wijze van met pen en pinseel te teykenen, is ook allerbequaemst om een meesterlijk werk in zijn volle kracht te voleinden. Dewijl men’er ook, als’t pas geeft, met rood krijt en kryons in kan speelen, als of men byna met verwen schilderde” (Van Hoogstraten, Inleyding (see note 1), p. 31.
  94. On stylistic grounds, this Rembrandt drawing has been placed among a group of history drawings dating to around 1650 (Otto Benesch, The Drawings of Rembrandt V, New York 1957, no. 902). Among other arguments, this dating led Bevers to attribute the Dresden drawing to Constantijn van Renesse, rather than Barent Fabritius (Holm Bevers, in: exh. cat. Berlin 2006 (see note 51), cat. no. 45, p. 157, 158, nt. 12) However, it remains questionable whether the Rembrandt drawing in Berlin should be understood within that context. Unlike the other history drawings, this work is not an autonomous composition but rather a sketched response to the Dresden sheet. It is plausible that the sketch was already made around 1647. In terms of linework, it is not far removed from the portrait sketch of Jan Six, dating from in or before 1647 (Amsterdam, Six Collection).
    It is drawn in a similarly free style, applied in a sketch, comparable to other drawings from the second half of the 1640’s (see
    note 47). Rembrandt’s Berlin drawing could thus have been made quite soon after Fabritius’s corrected drawing
  95. Josua Bruyn, “Gemälde der Rembrandt-Schüler II by Werner Sumowski Review”, Oud Holland 101 (1987) no. 3, p. 229.
  96. https://rkd.nl/images/313061, 17 July 2025. In terms of drawing style, this work is not far removed from Van Hoogstraten’s drawing The Sacrifice of Manoah of 1649 (Braunschweig, Herzog Anton Ulrich Museum, inv. no. Z 335; https://rkd.nl/images/71286, 17 July 2025). We may even assume that The Crucifixion predates it; the departing angel in the  Braunschweig drawing – also seen from the back – appears to be a more developed and refined treatment of the motif of a figure seen from behind.
  97. Samuel van Hoogstraten, The Adoration of the Shepherds. London, The British Museum, inv. no. 1895,0915.1203; https://rkd.nl/images/313552, 17 July 2025. A drawing of The Circumcision, likewise painted as a part of the Passion series in 1646, has been attributed to Gerbrand van den Eeckhout (Brussels, Koninklijke Musea voor Schone Kunsten België, inv. no. 4060/1212). There are also two copies after Rembrandt’s Holy Family with a Curtain from 1646 (London, The British Museum, inv. no. 1895,0915.1200; Oxford, Ashmolean Museum, inv. no. WA1986.56).
  98. Josua Bruyn in: Josua Bruyn et al., A Corpus of Rembrandt Paintings III: 1635-1642, Amsterdam 1989 pp. 13-16.
  99. Martin Royalton-Kisch, Drawings by Rembrandt and his Circle in the British Museum, London: The British Museum, 1992, cat. no. 87, pp. 180-182; Holm Bevers, “Drawings in Rembrandt’s Workshop”, in: exh. cat. Los Angeles 2009 (see note 51), pp. 13-17; David de Witt, “Leren van het leven: tekeningen van Rembrandts leerlingen” in: Judith Noorman, David de Witt, Rembrandts Naakte Waarheid. Tekenen naar naaktmodellen in de Gouden Eeuw, exh. cat. Amsterdam: Rembrandt House Museum, 2015, pp. 117-120.
  100. Initially, this drawing was attributed to Rembrandt, but as early as 1908, this attribution was already being questioned (Martin Conway, “Some Rembrandt Drawings”, Burlington Magazine 14 (1908/1909), p.37).
  101. This sheet has previously been judged the weakest of the three (David de Witt, in: exh. cat. Amsterdam 2015 (see note 64), p. 118), and it has even been suggested that Rembrandt may have corrected it. (Martin Royalton-Kisch, in: col. cat. London 2010 (see note 48), cat. 71). The fine parallel pen strokes in the boy’s torso are comparable to those in the body of Susanna in the Budapest drawing. The somewhat arbitrary use of red chalk (in the model’s right armpit area, on the reverse side of the cushion, and in the upper left corner) also stands out in both sheets. The type of loose, heavy pen lines used for the cushion corresponds to those found in the cloak of the old man in the Susanna drawing.
  102. For a first suggestion of Bol being the assistant of Rembrandt, see: Albert Blanckert, Ferdinand Bol (1616-1680). Rembrandt’s Pupil, Doornspijk 1982, pp. 17-18.
  103. Blanckert, Bol (see note 67), pp. 17-18; David de Witt, “Ferdinand Bol, discipel van Rembrandt”, in: Norbert Middelkoop, Ferdinand Bol en Govert Flinck. Rembrandts meesterleerlingen, Amsterdam (Rembrandt House Museum/Amsterdam Museum) 2017, pp. 44-45
  104. Portrait of a Lady, 1642. Berlin, Staatliche Museen zu Berlin, Gemäldegalerie, inv. no. 809. However, there are paintings by Bol, or attributed to him, of an earlier date or dating. The Liberation of St Peter (private collection), dated around 1636, may be, given its strong connection to the work of Benjamin Cuyp (David de Witt, in: exh. cat. Amsterdam 2017 (see note 68), pp. 42-43), made before Bol’s departure to Amsterdam. Gideon’s Sacrifice of 1640, signed by Bol (Utrecht, Museum Catharijneconvent, inv. no. RMCC s24), is typical in subject matter and composition of his later work from the 1640s, and may
    be made under conditions comparable to those proposed in this article for the paintings by Van Hoogstraten, dating from
    between 1644 and 1647. Other works attributed to Bol prior to 1642 are often copies or adaptations of compositions by
    Rembrandt.
  105. Christopher Brown, Carel Fabritius, Oxford 1981, p. 47; Gero Seelig in: Frederik J. Duparc, Carel Fabritius 1622-1654, exh. cat. The Hague: Mauritshuis; Schwerin: Staatliches Museum, 2004-2005, cat. no. 4, p. 97.
  106. Erna Kok erroneously states that Bol is mentioned as Rembrandt’s “werckgesel” in a document of 30 August 1640 (Erna Kok, “Govert Flinck en Ferdinand Bol en hun netwerken van opdrachtgevers,” in: exh. cat. Amsterdam 2017 (see note 68), p. 71, p. 244, n. 37). Bol’s exact role during his time in Rembrandt’s workshop is never documented. It is striking that the drawn copies after three of Rembrandt’s paintings from around 1636 are attributed to Ferdinand Bol (Peter Schatborn, “Tekeningen van Govert Flinck en Ferdinand Bol”, in: exh. cat. Amsterdam 2017 (see note 68), p.185). Apart from these sheets and those datable around 1646 by later pupils, there are few, if any, known drawings by Rembrandt’s pupils that are direct copies after his history or figure paintings. It is possible that Bol played an important role in introducing this method into the studio, and that it was later adopted by Van Hoogstraten. Van Hoogstraten is likely to have been in contact with Bol while in Amsterdam. After Bol established himself as an independent master, around 1642, he too began to draw in red chalk. He did so, however, almost exclusively in preparatory studies for (mainly) paintings – see, for instance, Joseph brings his Father before Pharaoh (Dresden, Gemäldegalerie, inv. no. 1605), and its preliminary drawing (Amsterdam, Rijksmuseum, inv. no. RP-T-1883-A-276). Van Hoogstraten may well have adopted this practice from him. This suggests that, even as an official pupil of Rembrandt, Van Hoogstraten felt the freedom to look to the work of other contemporaries as well. Van Sloten has argued that Bol continued to visit Rembrandt during the first half of the 1640s (Leonore van Sloten, “Ferdinand Bol, de etser”, in: exh. cat. Amsterdam 2017 (see note 68), pp. 218–221). Bol’s use of red chalk for preparatory studies may therefore have been the source of Van Hoogstraten’s conception that the use of red chalk contributes to the painterly quality of a drawing.
  107. Arnold Houbraken, De groote schouburgh der Nederlantsche konstschilders en schilderessen, Amsterdam, 1976, p. 165.
  108. Jan Jacobsz. Orlers, Beschrijvinge der Stadt Leyden, 2nd ed., Leiden, 1641, p. 376.
  109. See the translation from the original Latin: “Constantijn Huygens on Lievens and Rembrandt,” in: Arthur K. Wheelock et al., Jan Lievens. A Dutch Master Rediscovered, exh. cat. Washington: National Gallery of Art; Milwaukee: Milwaukee Art Museum; Amsterdam: Museum Het Rembrandthuis, 2008-2009, p. 287.
  110. See: Arthur K. Wheelock, “Jan Lievens: Bringing New Light to an Old Master,” in: Wheelock, Lievens (see note 2), pp. 13-23; and: Lloyd DeWitt, Evolution and Ambition in the Career of Jan Lievens (1607-1674), Ph.D. dissertation, University of Maryland, 2006: https://www.researchgate.net/publication/277127128_Evolution_and_Ambition_in_the_Career_of_Jan_Lievens_1607-1674
  111. Property from Aristocratic Estates and Important Provenance, Vienna (Dorotheum), 8 September 2020, lot 59 (as Circle of Bartholomeus van der Helst).
  112. Werner Sumowski, Gemälde der Rembrandt-Schüler, Landau, vol. 5, 1990, p. 3109, no. 2127, ill. p. 3279
  113. Ernst van de Wetering, Rembrandt: the Painter at Work, Amsterdam, 1997, pp. 182-185.
  114. Jan Lievens, Job in his Misery, monogrammed and dated 1631, canvas, 171.5 x 148.6 cm, Ottawa, National Gallery of Canada (4093). See Lloyd DeWitt in Wheelock, Lievens (see note 2), pp. 130-131, no. 25 (colour illus.).
  115. Jan Lievens, The Penitent Magdalene, c. 1631. Canvas, 63.5 x 49.5 cm. Kingston, Agnes Etherington Art Centre, gift of Dr. and Mrs. Alfred Bader, 1975 (18.126). See David de Witt in Wheelock, Lievens, pp. 128-129, no. 24 (colour illus.).
  116. Portrait of Jan Davidsz. de Heem, c. 1635/37, black chalk with some white body colour, 265 x 201 mm, London, British Museum (1895,0915.1199); Werner Sumowski, Drawings of the Rembrandt School, New York, vol. 7 (1983), pp. 3682-3683, no. 1652x (illus.).
  117. See entry by Lloyd DeWitt in: Wheelock, Lievens (see note 2), pp. 154-155, no. 38 (colour illus.).
  118. Jan Lievens, Head of a Bearded Old Man, c. 1640. Panel, 55 x 43 cm (oval), Kingston, Agnes Etherington Art Centre, gift of Alfred and Isabel Bader. See: David de Witt, The Bader Collection: Dutch and Flemish Paintings. Kingston, 2008, p. 198, no. 117 (colour illus.).
  119. Jan Lievens, Portrait of Adriaen Brouwer, c. 1635/37, black chalk with touches of pen in black, 221 x 185 mm, Paris, Fondation Custodia, Collection Frits Lugt (1203); Sumowski, Drawings (see note 9), pp. 3356-3357, no. 1594 (illus.).
  120. Jan Lievens, Portrait of Constantijn Huygens, 1639, black chalk with touches of pen in brown, 238 x 174 mm, London, British Museum (1836.8.11.342); see Wheelock, Lievens (see note 2), p. 242-243, no. 103 (colour illus.).
  121. Email correspondence with the author, 9 September 2020.
  122. My thanks to Stephanie Dickey for this information (email, 31 October 2022), confirmed by Marieke de Winkel.
  123. See Wheelock, Lievens (see note 2), p. 286.
  124. Lucas Vorsterman, after Anthony van Dyck, Portrait of Jan Lievens, c. 1630-1645, engraving, 241 x 158 mm, in 6 states, for the series: Icones Principorum Vivorum Doctorum Pictorum…; see: Marie Mauquoy-Hendrickx, L’Iconographie d’Antoine van Dyck, 2nd ed., Brussels, 1991, vol. 1, p. 155, no. 85; vol. 2, pl. 54 (illus.).
  125. Wheelock, Lievens (see note 2), pp. 112-113, no. 112 (colour illus.).
  126. Jan Lievens, Portrait of Charles I, pen in brown, 183 x 140 mm, Turin, Biblioteca Reale (D. C. 16365); Sumowski, Drawings (see note 9), pp. 3898-3899, no. 1754xx, (illus.); Orlers, Beschrijvinge (see note 1), pp. 375-377.
  127. Karolien de Klippel, “Adriaen Brouwer, Portrait Painter: New Identifications and an Iconographic Novelty,” Simiolus 30 (2003), pp. 196-216.
  128. Stephanie Dickey, “Jan Lievens and Printmaking,” in Wheelock, Lievens (see note 2), pp. 60-62. On the Iconography, see Mauquoy-Hendrickx, Iconographie (see note 7).
  129. DeWitt, Evolution (see note 3), p. 192, illus. fig. 144 (Lievens c. 1635/43, H. de Bran); attribution by Werner Sumowski: written correspondence with the museum of 28 July 1986; and: Drawings of the Rembrandt School, vol. 12 (Addenda), Leiden (forthcoming), no. 3104x.
  130. See Mauquoy-Hendrick, Iconography (see note 17), vol. 1, p. 214, no. 190; vol. 2, pl. 119.
  131. See DeWitt, Evolution (see note 3), pp. 160-164.
  132. Jan Lievens, Portrait of Thomas Howard, Earl of Arundel, black and red chalk, 180 x 140 mm, Staatliche Museen zu Berlin, Kupferstichkabinett (KdZ 5869); Wheelock, Lievens (see note 2), p. 249, no. 109 (colour illus.).
  133. Jan Lievens, Profile Head of an Old Woman in Oriental Dress, c. 1630, panel, 43.2 x 33.7 cm, Kingston, Agnes Etherington Art Centre, gift of Alfred and Isabel Bader, 2005 (48-002). See entry by David de Witt in Wheelock, Lievens (see note 2), pp. 122-123, no. 21 (colour illus.).
  134. Letter to his son the Earl of Lothian, May 1654: Correspondence of Sir Robert Kerr, First Earl of Ancram, and His Son William, Third Earl of Lothian, vol. 2, London, 1875, p. 383; C. Hofstede de Groot, “Hollandsche Kunst in Schotland,” Oud Holland 11 (1893), p. 214.
  135. On Sinclair: Jeannette Ewin, Fine Wines and Fish Oil: The Life of Hugh Macdonald Sinclair, Oxford 2001.
  136. The typescript is available in the “Library acquisition file for the Sinclair collection”.
  137. UBC Library, WZ250 .T9 1641.
  138. “7,000 rare books arrive”, UBC Reports 12, no. 3 (March-April, 1966). https://www.library.ubc.ca/archives/pdfs/ubcreports/UBC_Reports_1966_03_00.pdf
  139. Michiel Roscam Abbing, Rembrandt’s Elephant. Following in Hansken’s Footsteps, Amstelveen 2021.
  140. Nina Siegal, “When Rembrandt Met an Elephant”, The New York Times, July 16, 2021.
  141. UBC Library, WZ250 .T9 1641 and WZ260 .T83 1739 with the title Observationes Medicae.
  142. Allard Pierson, University of Amsterdam, Archives of Menno Hertzberger (UBA235). Sales catalogue Medicine Hippocrates-Claude Bernard, Amsterdam [February 1954], lot 442.
  143. Note 8 for this annotated copy.
  144. He also kept the relevant page from the catalogue in his files. Hamburg, Warburg Haus, Heckscher Archiv, Box 121 (‘Rembrandt: Dr. Tulp’), folder ‘Dr. Tulp Photo’s I’. Sinclair’s copy is kept in UBC Library call number Z999.74.
  145. According to Heckscher’s own administration he sent letters to Hugh Sinclair on 15 February and 2 March 1963. Hamburg, Warburg Haus, Heckscher Archiv, Box 52 (‘Heckscher: Korrespondenz und Arbeiten’). We thank Ms. Fanny Weidehaas of the Heckscher Archiv for her assistance. These letters were not found among Sinclair’s papers in The Museum of English Rural Life at the University of Reading. We thank Ms. Emma Farmer for checking these files.
  146. The translation was not published until 1991: Nicolaes Tulp, Geneesinzichten van Dr. Nicolaes Tulp etc., eds. (and transcriptions) C.G.L. Apeldoorn and T. Beijer. Amsterdam, 1991.
  147. The title page of the manuscript reads: “Nicolaes Tulp. Inzichten over de geneeskunst in vier boeken met koperen platen” (Nicolaes Tulp. Medical Insights in Four Books with Copper Plates).
  148. “D. Meppen Norda Frisii 1682 d. 18 8.bris”. We thank Koert van der Horst, retired keeper of manuscripts of the Utrecht University Library, for this identification. A third (unidentified) ownership’s inscription reads: “L. Fries stud. med. 1838 16/2.”
  149. The visit is not recorded in Sinclair’s Visitors book. Reading, The Museum of English Rural Life, Papers of Hugh Macdonald Sinclair, D HS 1/7/1: Visitor’s book 1941-1989: Dr Hugh Sinclair’s book of visitors to his home, Lady Place in Sutton Courtenay. We are grateful to Ms. Hollie Piff for checking.
  150. In the National Archives in The Hague we consulted the archives of the Department of Archeology and Nature Conservation, inv. no. 105 (Stukken betreffende de aanvraag van vergunningen voor de in- en uitvoer van voorwerpen van geschiedenis en kunst. 1946-1964).
  151. Allard Pierson, University of Amsterdam, Archives of Menno Hertzberger (UBA235), personal archives.
  152. Kindly provided information by Ms. Nina Duggen, Inspectie Overheidsinformatie en Erfgoed (Information and Heritage Inspectorate).
  153. Peter Schatborn and Erik Hinterding, Rembrandt. The Complete Drawings and Etchings, Cologne 2019. Peter Schatborn gave his judgement in an email of September 15, 2021, in translation: “In any case, the drawing was not made by Rembrandt. The stylistic differences are too great and I can’t find any drawing by Rembrandt that is comparable”.
  154. Ernest Theodore Hamy, ‚Documents inédits sur l‘Homo sylvestris rapporté d’Angola en 1630′, Bulletin du Muséum d’histoire naturelle 3 (1897), pp. 277-282.
  155. Michiel Roscam Abbing is currently preparing a book-length study, The Ape of Tulp, in which these data are to be published.
  156. Peter van der Krogt and Erlend de Groot, The Atlas Blaeu-Van der Hem of the Austrian National Library V (Utrecht 2005), pp. 88-89 (no. 35:40). The suggestion that Blaeu, who died in 1638, had access to the engraving of the chimpanzee and that this engraving was made by Tulp long before 1641, as argued by Kees Zandvliet (De Wereld van de familie Blaeu, Zutphen 2023, p. 66) must be rejected.

Drawing on the Neighbourhood in Rembrandt’s Inscription on a Drawing

Workshop of Rembrandt, with inscription by Rembrandt, The Departure of Rebecca, c. 1637. Reed pen with bistre, wash and fine highlights mounted on cardboard
1. Workshop of Rembrandt, with inscription by Rembrandt, The Departure of Rebecca, c. 1637. Reed pen with bistre, wash and fine highlights mounted on cardboard, 185 x 306 mm. Stuttgart, Staatsgalerie, Graphische Sammlung (C 1965/GL 936). Photo: © Staatsgalerie Stuttgart.

In the undisputed hand of Rembrandt Harmensz van Rijn, the intriguing inscription that appears beneath the drawing of an Old Testament scene, The Departure of Rebecca, c. 1637, has generated various studies (fig. 1).157 The rarity of the artist’s annotations, in general, has served to intensify scholarly interest in them. Discussions of the inscription have examined its relationship to the drawing’s attribution, the artist’s teaching methods, and his instructional intent. This study posits that the inscription’s specific wording raises additional significant questions, which have yet to be considered.

Written in ink different from that of the drawing, Rembrandt’s directive reads: “This should contain the figures of many neighbours who witness the departure of the noble bride.”158 In another hand, “Rembrandt” appears just above the inscription. The master’s critique emphasises the importance of having many “gebueren” (neighbours) in attendance at the housefront of Rebecca’s parents as she departs for her marriage to Isaac, even while the related biblical text lacks any reference to such persons.159

This study considers the significance of Rembrandt’s specific instructions to include neighbours, rather than generic figures, “who witness the departure of the noble bride.” Gary Schwartz also noted that the Old Testament story does not allude to neighbours, and he accounted for Rembrandt’s artistic licence by concluding the artist wished to approximate everyday experience.160  Schwartz, however, did not elaborate further on his observation.

Rembrandt’s instructions to add many neighbours in the drawing of Rebecca’s departure from her home did, in fact, result in a scene that resembled everyday life for a seventeenth-century Dutch viewer. I argue that neighbours’ well-embedded social practices—in particular, gatherings on domestic stoops and engagement with each other’s nuptial rituals—account for the artistic licence taken by Rembrandt with the biblical text. In the drawing, both the inclusion of neighbours at the housefront and their interest in the procession leading Rebecca to her marriage would have evoked in viewers their own, comparable experiences as neighbours.

Similarly in some other biblical works, as Amy Golahny has shown, Rembrandt melded reality that he had observed or experienced with imagined history.161 Contemporary with The Departure of Rebecca, Rembrandt’s black chalk drawing A Blind Beggar with a Boy and a Dog (private collection), for example, showcases figures he observed in daily life that he later incorporated in the biblical etchings such as The Hundred Guilder Print, c. 1647–1649 (B.074), and The Blind Tobit, 1651 (B.042), and which also appear in some students’ drawings.162

Like most of his urban contemporaries, Rembrandt belonged to self-determined and robust neighbourhood organizations (gebuyrten) in Leiden and Amsterdam. The written regulations (buurtbrieven) of such official organizations typically mandated membership of all who lived within the respective unit’s geographical footprint.163 Many official gebuyrten decrees, as well as unofficial expectations, relied on neighbours’ familiarity with each other’s daily affairs. Residents frequently shared news and gossip on domestic stoops, and at housefront windows and open doors to maintain the collective honour of their neighbourhood. Communal conviviality helped to construct and reinforce the neighbourhoods’ shared goals of brotherhood, friendship, and unity.164 Typically, neighbours also observed or attended various social gatherings, including before, during, and after the marriage of fellow residents. I argue that the expectation among neighbours to keep abreast of news and gossip shared informally on front stoops, and to participate in celebratory occasions, including nuptial festivities, informed the assumptions, advice, and wording of Rembrandt’s inscription beneath the drawing The Departure of Rebecca.

The various Old Testament events described in Genesis 24 that led to the marriage of Isaac and Rebecca appear in numerous seventeenth-century Dutch paintings, prints, and drawings, including those by Rembrandt and his pupils.165 The specific scene in The Departure of Rebecca captures the realization of instructions initially given by Abraham to his servant Eliezer to find a wife for the patriarch’s son, Isaac. With camels and gifts, Eliezer left Abraham and embarked on his mission. As evening fell, he approached a well where he foretold that if a woman agreed to share her water with him and his camels, she would be Isaac’s future wife. In time, Rebecca fulfilled the servant’s request.166 Eliezer revealed his objective to Rebecca’s brother and father, who, along with Rebecca, happily agreed to the marriage. Subsequently, Rebecca and her companions climbed onto camels and followed Eliezer on his return journey to join Isaac.

In the drawing, several figures assemble on or near the domestic threshold of Rebecca’s parents, or peer out from the housefront’s doorway and open windows. Since some of the figures overlap the drawn details of the window and door, their addition may postdate Rembrandt’s inscribed instructions.167 A man—presumably Rebecca’s brother or father—overlooks the scene from the low balcony attached to the façade.

Seen at an oblique angle, the domestic structure fills most of the right side of the composition. The home’s expansive stoop extends into the foreground, parallels the bottom edge of the composition, and readily affords the viewer, as neighbour, close visual and spatial engagement with the event. On the right, Rebecca bids farewell to her mother. The additional individuals gather behind them. A camel kneels on the stoop ready for Rebecca’s journey. Behind the docile animal, a standing man holds a large open umbrella at an angle. On the left, a retinue of people on foot and on horseback begins to take its leave. After the Old Testament’s account of Rebecca’s departure, which the scene in the drawing anticipates, the text describes the subsequent journey through the countryside to meet Isaac, who took her as his wife.

Studies of Rembrandt’s inscription have addressed the relevance of the artist’s instructions for the drawing’s inconclusive attribution to either the master himself or to one of his pupils.168 The latter include Salomon Koninck or a Koninck group; perhaps Govert Flinck; and Gerbrand van den Eeckhout.169

One scholar has argued that Rembrandt wrote the comment on his own drawing in order to provide a model as a correction to a pupil’s image.170 However, Rembrandt rarely inscribed his own drawings and unlikely with self-criticism.171 Instead, as several scholars have convincingly concluded, the master’s inscription appears on a student’s drawing about that work, rather than on his own drawing.172 Such studio instruction by Rembrandt was long-lived. Under the master’s tutelage, the painter Samuel van Hoogstraten learned from comparable corrections and recommended such artistic training in his Introduction to the Academy of Painting, or the Visible World, 1678.173

Further discussions of Rembrandt’s inscription—like analyses of his other written comments on, and corrections of, students’ drawings—have assessed the master’s artistic instructions vis-à-vis the scene’s compositional and narrative elements.174 Although the inscription evokes art theory’s concern for the appropriate number of figures in a text-based story, art theory does not account for Rembrandt’s explicit call for neighbours, rather than generic figures.175

To the observations that Rembrandt’s instructions addressed compositional and iconographic elements of the scene, I add discussion of significant Dutch social practices, which, I contend, the master evoked in his specific call for the depiction of neighbours. The social network, social exchange, and social control inherent in seventeenth-century Dutch neighbourhoods provide a rich interpretive context, which further illuminates the significance of Rembrandt’s inscription on the drawing.

 

Rembrandt and Neighbourhood Culture

The artist would have been intimately familiar with the social practices, social network, and social exchange of neighbourhoods, which constituted a primary organizing unit of social control in everyday relations. Small in footprint, Dutch neighbourhoods were typically circumscribed by the borders of only one or two streets or one side of a canal, and adjacent alleys. Membership typically included all residents living within the small community’s geographical parameters: men and women; natives and immigrants; and diverse socioeconomic classes, trades, and religions.176 Neighbours selected a governing board from among themselves consisting of various administrators. They oversaw neighbourhood meetings; played conciliatory and mediatory roles to protect order and quiet; ensured the rights, responsibilities, and honour of residents; and enforced the binding regulations, which did not warrant the intervention of civic authorities.177

Neighbourhood organizations resulted from a desire for calm, stability, camaraderie, and the preservation of individual and communal honour. The most compelling goal of seventeenth-century Dutch neighbourhood organizations centred around harmonious shared experience. Attendance at various informal gatherings as well as official social events fostered a sense of community. To maintain a neighbourhood’s mores and reinforce convivial relations, regulations required residents to participate in each other’s lives and stay abreast of good and bad news through daily interaction of all kinds, including conversation and gossip.178 At housefront thresholds, stoops, and windows, much as we see in The Departure of Rebecca, neighbours kept aware of communal news of large and little consequence. They also intervened as witnesses to social infractions and negotiated resolutions to conflicts.

Rembrandt was certainly familiar with the official regulations, unofficial expectations, social values, and experiences of neighbourhood life. In Leiden, where he was born in 1606, his family lived in the Pelikaanshoek (Pelican Corner) neighbourhood.179 Prominent administrative roles held by Rembrandt’s father and brother in their neighbourhood organization would have provided the artist even greater familiarity with the social control characteristic of gebuyrten. While the young Rembrandt still lived in Leiden, his father Harmen Gerritsz van Rijn, a miller, served as chairman (heer) of the family’s neighbourhood. From 1643 until his death in 1652, Rembrandt’s brother, Adriaen Harmensz van Rijn, served as heer of the same Leiden neighbourhood organization.180

The various drawings by Rembrandt that evince his familiarity with neighbourhood life at the intersection of home and street are close in date to The Departure of Rebecca, c. 1637. The subjects and compositions of the drawings pictorially educe the ebb and flow of neighbourhood social exchange before a housefront, as Rembrandt’s inscription similarly called for in the Old Testament scene. A resident either sits on a domestic stoop or peers out from an open window or half-open Dutch door. The figures’ positions and their gazes invite neighbourhood encounters.

Schilderij van Rembrandt, Seated Man Wearing a Flat Cap, c. 1635–1640. Pen and brown ink, brush and brown wash, heightened with white gouache.
2. Rembrandt, Seated Man Wearing a Flat Cap, c. 1635–1640. Pen and brown ink, brush and brown wash, heightened with white gouache, 148 x 138 mm. Metropolitan Museum of Art, H. O. Havemeyer Collection, Bequest of Mrs. H. O. Havemeyer, 1929 (29.100.935). Photo: The Metropolitan Museum of Art, New York, Thomas J. Watson Library.

In Seated Man Wearing a Flat Cap, c. 1635–1640, for example, a resting figure on his stoop gazes directly out at the viewer as passerby/neighbour (fig. 2). Woman Holding a Child Frightened by a Dog, on the Doorstep of a House, c. 1635–1636, pictures a woman leaning out of a housefront window surveying the scene below (fig. 3). On the top step, a smiling mother kneels and embraces a frightened toddler, while a carefree dog edges close. In Three Women and a Child by a Door, c. 1645, a female figure behind a half-open Dutch door leans on the ledge of the bottom half and watches two women and a child, seated below on the stoop and step (fig. 4).

Schilderij van Rembrandt, Woman Holding a Child Frightened by a Dog, on the Doorstep of a House.
3. Rembrandt, Woman Holding a Child Frightened by a Dog, on the Doorstep of a House, c. 1635–1636. Pen, brown ink on paper, 180 x 150 mm. Budapest, Szépmüvészeti Múzeum (1589). © The Museum of Fine Arts Budapest/Scala/Art Resource, NY, Photo: Jozsa Denes.

Such scenes attest to the good cheer and engagement essential to shared goals of friendship, brotherhood, and unity, which neighbours enjoyed on domestic front stoops, steps, and in the adjacent street. Rembrandt also called for such neighbourly engagement in the scene of Rebecca’s departure from the front stoop of her parents’ house. A century and a half later, in 1773, Jan le Francq de Berkheij, a professor of natural history at Leiden University, published his short description of that city—Rembrandt’s hometown—in which he described neighbourly gatherings at housefronts.

A very old custom of sociability [gezelligheid] occurs on summer evenings when various neighbours, after eating, come together outside the front door, usually in the street, on the bench, or in the house’s front room [voorhuis], and treat each other to a cup of coffee or beer, [a custom] which they refer to as “benching” [banken], and [which] usually lasts until eleven o’clock or later.181

The long-lived, gezellig custom among Leiden neighbours, who gathered socially “outside the front door, usually in the street, on the bench, or in the house’s front room,” was also enjoyed in other Dutch cities.

 

 

 

Schilderij van Rembrandt, Three Women and a Child by a Door, c. 1645. Paper, pen and brown ink, framing line in brown ink
4. Rembrandt, Three Women and a Child by a Door, c. 1645. Paper, pen and brown ink, framing line in brown ink, 233 x 178 mm. Amsterdam, Rijksmuseum (RP-T-1889-A-2056).


Neighbours as Nuptial Celebrants

Rembrandt’s instructions to depict “many neighbours who witness the departure of the noble bride” also allude to the commonplace attendance by neighbours at each other’s marital events. Their presence at an array of such occasions would have informed Rembrandt’s inscription. While seventeenth-century Dutch neighbours often observed or joined celebratory events in honour of a betrothed or newly married couple, the bride and groom (or their parents), in turn, fulfilled a widespread regulation to honour their neighbourhood at the time of a wedding. An example of such a decree was published on 24 March 1593, by the city fathers of Leiden—Rembrandt’s hometown.182 The 1593 General Regulation included “Article 6. Marriages,” which remained in effect in Leiden throughout the seventeenth century. The ruling declared that

He who marries off a son or daughter, or himself marries—whether one stays in the neighbourhood; whether one leaves for another neighbourhood—is obliged to make a respectable contribution to the neighbourhood where he lives according to his own discretion, civility, and the state of his marriage.183

A “respectable contribution” referred to one that was monetary and made to the neighbourhood’s cash box, which funded communal enterprises, such as the annual neighbourhood feast.184  Such reciprocity of significant engagement and support by neighbours on behalf of a newly betrothed couple amongst them, on the one hand, and by a newly married couple or their parents on behalf of their neighbourhood, on the other hand, further illuminates Rembrandt’s call for the inclusion of neighbours in The Departure of Rebecca.

By Dutch tradition, when an engaged couple departed from the bride’s home to be married, neighbours and other interested observers gathered on her household stoop and in the adjacent street. Among all Dutch marriage customs involving neighbours, this ritualised step in the nuptial narrative most closely parallels details and circumstances in The Departure of Rebecca. Similarities between the custom and the drawing include the bride’s departure from her home for the wedding ceremony; the domestic threshold setting; and the array of bystanders and onlookers, including neighbours, whose depiction Rembrandt called for in the scene. The drawing, however, does not replicate that ritualised step in the contemporary nuptial narrative. Consistent with the biblical account, Rebecca’s future groom, Isaac, who remained at some distance away, does not accompany her as she departs from her home.

Schilderij van Bernard Picart, Bride and Bridegroom on Their Way to the Church/ Dutch Reformed Church Marriage Ceremony, 1730. Etching and engraving
5. Bernard Picart, Bride and Bridegroom on Their Way to the Church/ Dutch Reformed Church Marriage Ceremony, 1730. Etching and engraving, 333 × 218 mm. In: Bernard Picart, Cérémonies et coutumes religieuses de tous les peuples du monde […]. Tome troisieme, qui contient les cérémonies des Grecs & des protestans. Deel 3 (Amsterdam: Jean Frederic Bernard, 1733). Amsterdam, Rijksprentenkabinet, Rijksmuseum (RP-P-OB-51.714).

The specific Dutch ritual of the bride’s departure from her home was documented in an etched and engraved print, Bride and Bridegroom on Their Way to the Church/ Dutch Reformed Church Marriage Ceremony, 1730, by Bernard Picart (working in Amsterdam beginning in 1711) (fig. 5).185 An engaged couple leaves the bride’s home for their Dutch Reformed church wedding.186 Although impressions of Picart’s print sold individually, the artist also reproduced the image in his five-volume publication Cérémonies et coutumes religieuses de tous les peuples du monde (Ceremonies and religious customs of all the people of the world).187

In the Netherlandish edition of Picart’s volumes, the Dutch text that expounds upon the print Bride and Bridegroom on Their Way to the Church/ Dutch Reformed Church Marriage Ceremony references neighbours who watch the couple’s departure from the bride’s home. Notably, this passage corresponds to the instructions that Rembrandt inscribed under the drawing in which Rebecca leaves her parents’ house. The text in Picart’s publication advises that “the full splendour of the future spouses can be seen by all of the neighbours and the crowd of people, who approach from all sides of the house.”188

In Picart’s print, numerous figures, including neighbours, in everyday dress stand in the left foreground, the right middle ground, and in the background and they happily observe the departure of the engaged couple.189  On the right, a small boy has climbed a tree to get a better view. In the middle distance, a woman—perhaps late for the occasion—runs across a bridge in the direction of the foreground gathering.

After a seventeenth-century Dutch wedding ceremony, a second traditional procession composed of the bride, her neighbours, and friends travelled together to meet the groom. The bride and celebrants made their way to the groom at his house or an inn, where elaborate wedding festivities typically took place.190 Although the scene in The Departure of Rebecca marks an earlier moment in a nuptial narrative, neighbours figure prominently in both Rembrandt’s call for their inclusion in the drawing and in their actual participation in the second type of Dutch wedding procession.

Schilderij van Jan Steen, The Village Wedding, 1653. Canvas
6. Jan Steen, The Village Wedding, 1653. Canvas, 64 x 81 cm. Rotterdam, Museum Boijmans Van Beuningen (2314 [OK]), on loan from: Rijksdienst voor het Cultureel Erfgoed. Photo: Studio Tromp, Rotterdam.

Jan Steen’s The Village Wedding, 1653, depicts the post-wedding parade of celebrants led by the bride (fig. 6). The groom descends the steps to greet his approaching wife, who is accompanied in the procession by family members, neighbours, and friends. As noted by Petra van Boheemen, in Steen’s scene “half the neighbourhood has run out to be present at the meeting” of the couple.191

Other seventeenth-century Dutch marriage customs also manifest the widespread engagement of neighbours in wedding-related events. Such traditions further contextualise the social practices invoked by Rembrandt’s instructions to include neighbours in the drawing of Rebecca’s departure to join her future groom. Elaborate celebratory meals occurred before, as well as after Dutch marriage ceremonies. Like family and friends, neighbours often received formal invitations to attend them.192

Sometime between 1590 and 1595, the Englishman Fynes Moryson noted in his journal of travels through the northern Netherlands that on the third day after a typical wedding ceremony, the couple invited their “neighbours and ordinary freundes” for “supper and dauncing.” His comments appear midst his more detailed observations about Dutch marriage celebrations.193 Preparations for engagement and wedding festivities began days in advance, included special food and drink, and often a dinner or banquet.194

Schilderij van Rembrandt, Wedding of Samson, 1638. Canvas, 127 x 178 cm. Dresden, Gemäldegalerie Alte Meister, Staatliche Kunstsammlungen Dresden (1560)
7. Rembrandt, Wedding of Samson, 1638. Canvas, 127 x 178 cm. Dresden, Gemäldegalerie Alte Meister, Staatliche Kunstsammlungen Dresden (1560). Photo: bpk Bildagentur/ Dresden, Gemäldegalerie Alte Meister/ Hans-Peter Klut/ Art Resource, NY.

Several Old Testament pictures by Rembrandt and his contemporaries showcase wedding banquets with numerous guests.195 Viewers may have assumed the revellers included neighbours in a melding of lived experience with imagined history. Close in date to The Departure of Rebecca, c. 1637, Rembrandt’s painting The Wedding of Samson, 1638, stages several celebrants at the Old Testament meal (fig. 7). In comments on the painting four years later, a Leiden observer noted a similar blending of lived Dutch customs with the imagined biblical past. In his Lof der Schilder-konst (Praise of Painting), 1642, Philips Angel observed: “since all the guests are not concerned with one and the same matter, [Rembrandt] showed others making merry, not listening to [Samson’s] riddle, but holding up a glass of wine and laughing. Others were kissing—in short, it was a merry wedding feast . . . the actions were of the kind found in our modern wedding feasts.”196

Schilderij van Willem Cornelisz Duyster, A Wedding Feast, long known as “The Wedding of Adriaen Ploos van Amstel and Agnes van Bijler, 1616”
8. Willem Cornelisz Duyster, A Wedding Feast, long known as “The Wedding of Adriaen Ploos van Amstel and Agnes van Bijler, 1616”, c. 1625. Panel, 75.5 x 106.5 cm. Amsterdam, Rijksmuseum (SK-C-514).

In addition to paintings of Old Testament wedding festivities, Dutch portraits of newly married couples place them midst their nuptial celebrations. Presumably, the wide range of guests included neighbours. Willem Cornelisz Duyster’s Wedding Feast, long known as “The Wedding of Adriaen Ploos van Amstel and Agnes van Bijler, 1616,” c. 1625, exemplifies such a celebration with numerous participants (fig. 8). Since the average size of an urban, Dutch nuclear family consisted of approximately three and three-quarter persons, including two children, but rarely extended family members, the large number of celebrants in Duyster’s painting suggests they include neighbours.197

Gatherings on domestic stoops as well as nuptial customs that neighbours shared provide a revealing context in which to elucidate Rembrandt’s inscription: “This should contain the figures of many neighbours who witness the departure of the noble bride.” Like other occasions staged in genre imagery, Old Testament scenes, and portraiture, The Departure of Rebecca includes engaged neighbours. Although Rembrandt’s biblical imagery has long been admired for its universal themes, the evocation of neighbourhood social practices in his inscription demonstrates that lived reality also informed his conception of the past. As a member himself of Leiden and Amsterdam neighbourhoods, Rembrandt valued the rich texture of neighbourly relationships in his own art and in that of his pupils.

Linda Stone-Ferrier is a professor of seventeenth-century Dutch and Flemish art in the Kress Foundation Department of Art History at the University of Kansas. Her book, The Little Street: The Neighborhood in Seventeenth-Century Dutch Art and Culture, was published in August 2022 by Yale University Press.

 

 

 

  1. Werner Sumowski, Paul Huys Janssen, The Hoogsteder Exhibition of Rembrandt’s Academy, exh. cat. The Hague: Hoogsteder & Hoogsteder, 1992, cat. no. 28.
  2. Exhibition catalogues: Albert Blanckert, Jezus in de Gouden Eeuw, exh. cat. Rotterdam: Kunsthal, 2000–2001; Akira Kofuku, Rembrandt and the Rembrandt School. The Bible, mythology and ancient history, exh. cat. Tokyo: Museum of Western Art, 2003; Arthur K. Wheelock et al., Jan Lievens. A Dutch Master Rediscovered, exh. cat. Washington: National Gallery of Art; Milwaukee: Milwaukee Art Museum; Amsterdam: Rembrandt House Museum, 2008-2009, cat.no. 52; Louis van Tilborgh, Constantijn Huygens. Kunstkenner en verzamelaar, exh. cat. The Hague: Museum Bredius, 2013, cat. no. 14. Other literature: Werner Sumowski, Gemälde der Rembrandtschüler, vol. 4, Landau, 1983, p. 3726, no. 2356, fig. 3964; Helga Gutbrod, Lievens und Rembrandt : Studien zum Verhältnis ihrer Kunst, Frankfurt am Main, 1996, p. 299; Edwin Buijssen (ed.), Haagse schilders in de Gouden Eeuw, Het Hoogsteder lexicon van alle schilders werkzaam in Den Haag 1600-1700, The Hague, 1998, p. 191; Lloyd DeWitt, Evolution and Ambition in the career of Jan Lievens, 1607-1674, Phd. Diss. University of Maryland, College Park, 2006, p. 228.
  3. DeWitt, Evolution (see note 2), p. 228.
  4. For example those mentioned in the Montias Database of 17th Century Dutch Art Inventories and the Getty Provenance Research Index.
  5. Sumowski, Huys Janssen, Academy (see note 1), p. 220.
  6. Dr Gaston Gaudinot sale, Paris (Drouot), 13-14 February 1869.
  7. Sumowski, Huys Janssen, Academy (see note 1), p. 220.
  8. Ibid.
  9. Sumowski, Huys Janssen, Academy (see note 1), p. 226. Huys Janssen explains that the miracle as described in Luke and John differs from the version told by Matthew.
  10. After listening to the centurion, and before addressing him directly, Jesus speaks to his followers: “I tell you, many will come from east and west and sit at table with Abraham, Isaac, and Jacob in the kingdom of heaven.” (Matthew 8:11) Perhaps Lievens incorporated this part of the text and explicitly included people coming from the east (from the standpoint of his Dutch audience). A second possibility is that they are Pharisees. This group plays the role elsewhere in Matthew of disbelieving critics, and here they may serve to accentuate the belief of the centurion in the Christian faith. In early prints (Sebald Beham, Israhel van Meckenem, Hans Schaüfelein and Cornelis Massijs) and several Italian prints from Lievens’s time (seventeenth century prints after Paolo Veronese), Pharisees wear such headdresses. A parallel between blacks and overseas regions, such as in Lievens’s Brinio, is convincingly outlined by Elmer Kolfin (in: Elmer Kolfin, De kunst van de macht, Jordaens, Lievens en Rembrandt in het Paleis op de Dam, Zwolle, 2023, p. 67), does not seem to apply here.
  11. Sumowski, Huys Janssen, Academy (see note 1), p. 223.
  12. Sumowski, Huys Janssen, Academy (see note 1), pp. 223, 226.
  13. The right eye from the perspective of the viewer. There, a pupil was painted in, in a later restoration. Because of the sketchy manner it is difficult to ascertain whether or not both eyes are present, but in the left the lower eyelid is visible, while it is undefined in the right eye.
  14. For example: Jacobus Neeffs (after Jacob Jordaens), Judgement of Christ, etching, c. 1630-1645; Marinus van der Goes (after Jacques Jordaens), Judgement of Christ, engraving, c. 1614-1639; Willem Panneels (after Peter Paul Rubens), Adoration of the kings, etching, 1630; Nicolaes Lauwers (after Peter Paul Rubens), Ecce Homo, engraving, c. 1619-1652; and many more. Generally, for examples of inspiration drawn from prints by Lievens, see De
    Witt, Evolution (see note 2).
  15. Sumowski, Huys Janssen, Academy (see note 1), p. 226. Huys Janssen refers to examples by Nicolaes Moeyaert (Herentals, St. Waltrudis church) and Adam Camerarius (Amsterdam, Rijksmuseum, inv. no. SK-A-733). DeWitt refers to a painting by Bartholomeus Breenbergh (Karlsruhe, Staatliche Kunsthalle Karlsruhe, inv. no. 228) and the Moeyaert in Herentals (DeWitt, Evolution (see note 2), p. 227). But also see a woodcut with this subject by Cornelis van Sichem II in Der zielen lusthof (1629). Also of interest: Claes Moeyeart, Christ and the Centurion, 1632 (Minneapolis, Minneapolis Institute of Art, inv. no. 2012.84.5). Although the painting is known under this subject, it may in fact depict Cornelius kneeling before Peter, since more than one figure is shown kneeling and the composition closely resembles prints of this subject.
  16. Henri van de Waal, “’s Lands oudste verleden in de voorstelling van Vondel en zijn tijdgenooten”, Elsevier’s Maandschrift 47 (1937); Henri van de Waal, “Tempesta en de historieschilderingen op het Amsterdamse stadhuis”, Oud Holland 56 (1939); Henri van de Waal, Drie eeuwen vaderlandsche geschied-uitbeelding 1500-1800, een iconologische studie, The Hague, 1952; Kolfin, Kunst (see note 10).
  17. Antonio Tempesta (after Otto van Veen), Print 8 in (…)De Batavische oft oude Hollandtsche oorloghe teghen de Romeynen, 1612. Etching, 167 x 210 mm. Rijksmuseum, Amsterdam, inv. no. RP-P-OB-37.614. Jürgen Ovens based his drawing for the Batavian Series depicting Claudius Civilis leaving the Women and Children to fight at Xanten (Hamburg, Hamburger Kunsthalle, inv. no. 22342) on this print.
  18. On the period in The Hague: Buijssen Haagse (see note 2), pp.191-193.
  19. Haarlem, Teylers Museum, inv. no. P 006. For the identification and context, see: Gregor Weber, “Dus leeft de dappre Graaf: Zu einem Bildnis Andries de Graeffs von Jan Lievens (1607-1674)”, Oud Holland 99 (1985), pp. 44-56.
  20. Van de Waal, Eeuwen (see note 16), p. 230; Kolfin, De kunst van de macht (see note 10), pp. 19-20.
  21. Van de Waal, “’s Lands” (see note 16), p. 301-302.
  22.  Kolfin, Kunst (see note 10), p. 41. Four Batavian scenes were never completed. For two the themes are known, for the other two are not known.
  23. Munich, Staatliche Graphische Sammlung München, inv. no. 1451; Hamburg, Hamburger Kunsthalle, Kupferstichkabinett, inv. no. 22342. A lesser-known drawing of Rembrandt’s Conspiracy of Claudius Civilis (Edinburgh, National Galleries of Scotland, inv. no. D 23862) shows – when compared to the drawing in Munich – that the lower section of the painting is covered by a frieze and that portions of the left and right sides are obscured. This may indicate that an alternative conception of the framing of the lunettes was considered before the one ultimately implemented. It is possible that this earlier framing was already envisioned when Lievens produced his oil sketch Christ and the Centurion.
  24. Van de Waal, Eeuwen (see note 16), p. 225, referring to SAA, 5039, 2 resolutieboek, f. 66r.
  25. Ibid., referring to SAA, 5039, 153 rapiamus 1661, f.195v.
  26. Van de Waal, Eeuwen (see note 16), p. 225.
  27. Gregor Weber, “Jan Lievens’s ‘The Shield-raising of Brinio’ a Second Oil Sketch”, Hoogsteder-Naumann Mercury 12/13 (1992), nt. 8.
  28. Dewitt, Evolution (see note 2), p. 221.
  29. Kolfin, Kunst (see note 10), p.67.
  30. Kolfin, Kunst (see note 10), p. 44.
  31. For, among other things, contemporary poetry in which Civilis and others are compared to the members of the House of Orange: Van de Waal, Eeuwen (see note 16), pp. 220-221, 223.
  32. Kolfin, Kunst (see note 10), p. 47.
  33. Margriet van Eikema Hommes, Elmer Kolfin, De Oranjezaal in Huis ten Bosch, Een zaal uit loutere liefde, Zwolle, 2013, p. 77.
  34. Kolfin, Kunst (see note 10), pp. 41-47, 77.
  35. One may ask, in light of points discussed in this article, whether the “Christ” figure in the first version was in fact Christ at all. If so, the oil sketch would initially have represented solely a Christian scene without any reference to the Batavian Revolt, thereby less relatable to the (eventual) decoration program of the Town Hall’s gallery. Given that in the initial design the groups left and right with Biblical and/or eastern figures do not seem to have been included (aside from a bearded man on the right, judging from the x-ray), the large central figure may originally have been Julius Civilis. In compositional terms, this would align the painting more closely with the print by Tempesta after Van Veen. The apparent similarity in hairstyle between the final Christ figure and the initial figure, together with the possible initial presence of a (holy) beam of light directed toward the figure, may argue against this hypothesis; nevertheless, Brinno in Lievens’s Brinio Raised on the Shield likewise features long hair and even incorporates a diagonal compositional line through the clouds, comparable to the line through the foliage in the initial version of the present subject. The later insertion of Christ could then be understood as a deliberate twist, imparting a more prominent Christian meaning to the historical scene. These suggestions and observations were kindly shared by Jochem van Eijsden.
  36. Samuel van Hoogstraten, Inleyding tot de hooge schoole der schilderkonst: anders de zichtbaere werelt, Rotterdam 1678, p. 18. Van Hoogstraten here refers to the period when he was “still a disciple”, during which, as part of a “we”, he and others discussed a particular question, to which a certain “Fabritius” responded with an answer. It is generally assumed that this refers to Carel Fabritius, who is assumed to have studied with Rembrandt between approximately 1641 and 1643.
  37. Werner Sumowski described Van Hoogstraten as “pädagogisch begabt, Assistent Rembrandts gewesen” (Werner Sumowski, Gemälde der Rembrandt-Schüler II, Landau/Pfalz 1984, p. 1286). As supporting evidence, Sumowski argued that Van Hoogstraten corrected drawings by Constantijn Daniël van Renesse (; p. 1290, nt. 2). When discussing one of these drawings (Moses and Reuel’s Daughters at the Well, Amsterdam, Rijksmuseum, inv. no. RP-T-1893-A-2782) Sumowski suggested the possibility that “Samuel van Hoogstraten acted as assistant to the master on occasional trips even at a later date”. (Werner Sumowski, Drawings of the Rembrandt School IX, New York 1985, no. 2159x). Building on this, Jonathan Bikker suggested in his monograph on Willem Drost that Van Hoogstraten “might have supervised Drost during his early days in Rembrandt’s studio” (Jonathan Bikker, Willem Drost, A Rembrandt Pupil in Amsterdam and Venice, New Haven/London 2005, p. 11). David de Witt later observed, in his Abraham van Dijck monograph, concerning Van Hoogstraten: “by 1646 his training would have been complete, but he appears to have stayed on as a tutor or head pupil for several years” (David De Witt, Life and Work of Late Rembrandt Pupil Abraham van Dijck, c. 1635-1680, Amsterdam 2020, p. 11).
  38. Sabine Pénot, Rembrandt – Hoogstraten. Colour and Illusion, exh. cat. Vienna: Kunsthistorisches Museum Wien, 2024; Nathalie Maciesza, Epco Runia, Samuel van Hoogstraten. De Illusionist, exh. cat. Amsterdam: Rembrandt House Museum, 2025; Sabine van Beek, Leonore van Sloten, David de Witt et al., Samuel van Hoogstraten: Catalogue Raisonné, The Hague 2025.
  39. The catalogue of the Vienna exhibition assumes a position for Van Hoogstraten as an assistant for approximately three to four years (Angelina Illes, in: exh. cat. Vienna 2024 (see note 3), p. 29; Jonathan Bikker, in: exh. cat. Vienna 2024 (see note 3), p. 93), though it makes no mention of any teaching responsibilities. These are, however, included in the publication accompanying the exhibition at the Rembrandt House Museum (Michiel Roscam Abbing, in: exh. cat. Amsterdam 2025 (see note 3), p. 19; David De Witt, in: exh. cat. Amsterdam 2025 (see note 3), p. 131), and in the online Van Hoogstraten catalogue raisonné by the RKD (Michiel Roscam Abbing, in: The Hague 2025 (see note 3), “With Rembrandt in Amsterdam”. https://vanhoogstraten.rkdstudies.nl/samuel-van-hoogstraten-the-ingenious-and-poetic-painter/with-rembrandt-inamsterdam/, 26 May 2025).
  40. The term “assistent” was used in Holland in the 17th century, albeit in other contexts, see: Woordenboek Nederlandse taal, s.v. assistent, https://gtb.ivdnt.org/iWDB/search?actie=article&wdb=WNT&id=M004535&lemma=assistent&domein=0&conc=true, 11
    July 2025.
  41. “Een min of meer ondergeschikte helper”, a more or less subordinate helper (see note 5); “A person who helps or supports somebody, usually in their job”: Oxford English Dictionary, s.v. assistant, https://www.oed.com/view/Entry/12041, 11 July 2025.
  42. The guild archive has been lost. For a comprehensive account of the Amsterdam Guild of Saint Luke and its ordinances, see: Isabella H. van Eeghen, “Schilders of Sint Lucasgilde”, in: Isabella H. van Eeghen (ed.), Inventarissen der archieven van de gilden en van het brouwerscollege, Amsterdam 1951, passim.; Isabella H. van Eeghen (Jasper Hillegers, translator), “The Amsterdam Guild of Saint Luke in the 17th Century”, Journal of Historians for Netherlandish Art 4.2 (2012), passim., DOI:10.5092/jhna.2012.4.2.4, 11 July 2025. The current article relies exclusively on the guild regulations of the Amsterdam De Kroniek 2024/25 – Museum Rembrandthuis 10 painters’ guild. It is often assumed that the regulations of painters’ guilds in different Dutch towns did not differ substantially in content. On that assumption, gaps in the regulations of one town might be filled by those of another. However, the discussion later in this article regarding whether apprentices were permitted to produce their own work shows that crucial differences did in fact exist. For that reason, guild regulations from other cities are not used here to fill the gaps in the surviving Amsterdam regulations.
  43. Extract van de willekeuren en ordonnantien den gilde van St. Lucas verleent, Amsterdam 1720, p. 11.
  44. Extract (see note 8), p. 11; This is also the case in the chapter title and margin of the 1766 publication of all known guild charters: Ordonnantien en willekeuren van het Lucas-gilde binnen Amsterdam, Amsterdam 1766, p. 64, 68. It is noteworthy that the dean and headmen of the guild employed a gilde kneght (Extract (see note 8), pp. 26-27. This was not a pupilship, and the tasks meet the definition of an assistant in the Oxford English Dictionary and the Woordenboek Nederlandse Taal (see note 6)
  45. Extract (see note 8), pp. 12-13
  46. Extract (see note 8), pp. 11-12.
  47. Extract (see note 8), p. 12.
  48. Cornelis Kiliaen (ed. Frans Claes), Etymologicum teutonicae linguae, Antwerp 1599 (The Hague 1972), p. 278, s.v. leerionghe; leer-kind; leer-knecht; leerlinck; p. 703, s.v. discipel. In the regulations of the Haarlem Guild of St. Luke from 1634 (NHA, 1105, Ambachtsgilden te Haarlem (Gilden Haarlem), no. 219), the terms “leerling”, “leerjongen”, and “discipel” are
    used. This might suggest that a distinction existed between them, but they are actually used interchangeably. The same applies to the terms “(werk)gezel”, “knecht”, and – a new term – “gast”. The latter is synonymous with journeyman or servant: “Knecht van een ambachtsman of fabrikant; gezel, werkknecht”, servant of a tradesman or manufacturer; journeyman, workshop hand: Woordenboek Nederlandse taal, s.v. gast, https://gtb.ivdnt.org/iWDB/searchactie=article&wdb=WNT&id=M017355.re.35&lemma=werkgast&domein=0&conc=true,
    16 oktober 2025.
  49. Kiliaen, Etymologicum (see note 13), p. 139, s.v. ghe-selle van een ampt. The Latin word “collega” is likewise a translation for “ambtgenoot”, “maet”, and “vennoot” (Kiliaen, Etymologicum (see note 13), p. 18, s.v. ampt-ghenoot; p. 302, s.v. maet, med-maet, maetken; p. 579, s.v. veyn-out, veyn-noot, ven-noot, vennoot, veyn-gnoot).
  50. Kiliaen, Etymologicum (see note 13), p. 244, s.v. knecht, dienaer.
  51. Nicolaas de Roever, “Drie Amsterdamsche Schilders (Pieter Isaaksz, Abraham Vinck, Cornelis van der Voort)”, Oud Holland 3 (1885), p. 198.
  52. In 1619, he was asked together with several artists who had traveled to Italy, including Pieter Lastman, Adriaen van Nieulandt, and Barent van Someren, to assess the authenticity of a Caravaggio painting from the collection of the late Louis Finson. Abraham Bredius, Nicolaas de Roever, “Pieter Lastman en François Venant”, Oud Holland 4 (1886), pp. 7-8.
  53. Ronald de Jager “Meester, leerjongen, leertijd. Een analyse van Zeventiende-eeuwse Noord-Nederlandse leerlingcontracten van kunstschilders, goud- en zilversmeden”, Oud Holland 104 (1990), p. 96, nt. 107. The title of “gezel” is, in fact, never mentioned in the known Amsterdam contracts.
  54. De Jager, “Meester” (see note 18), pp. 73-75.
  55. De Jager, “Meester” (see note 18), p. 71.
  56. Stadsarchief Amsterdam (hereafter SAA), 5075, 393A, nots. Jacob Jacobs and Nicolaes Jacobs, ff. 59r-59v, 20-07-1626; Abraham Bredius, “Gerrit Willemsz. Horst”, Oud Holland 50 (1933), pp. 5-6; De Jager, “Meester” (see note 18), p. 98, no. 7.
  57. This underscores a clear distinction: as was also evidenced by the entries in Kiliaen, Etymologicum (see note 13), dienaer was a synonym for knecht, not for leerknecht (see note 15).
  58. Abraham Bredius, Künstlerinventare. Urkunden zur Geschichte der holländischen Kunst des XVIten, XVIIten und XVIIIten Jahrhunderts V, The Hague 191, pp. 1482-1483; De Jager, “Meester” (see note 18), p. 98, no. 10.
  59. The value of a barrel of herring in Amsterdam in 1635 was approximately 120 grams of silver (Bo Poulsen, Dutch Herring. An Environmental History, c. 1600–1860, Amsterdam 2008, p. 93, table 6.9); in the seventeenth century, ten grams of silver corresponded to the value of roughly one guilder.
  60. The tuition fees in Holland for a two-year contract averaged 61.5 guilders per year (De Jager, “Meester” (see note 18), p. 75).
  61. Josua Bruyn, “Een onderzoek naar 17de -eeuwse schilderijformaten, voornamelijk in Noord-Nederland”, Oud Holland 93 (1979), p. 113.
  62. Abraham Bredius, Künstlerinventare. Urkunden zur Geschichte der holländischen Kunst des XVIten, XVIIten und XVIIIten Jahrhunderts II, The Hague 1916, pp. 400-401; De Jager, “Meester” (see note 18), p. 98
  63. As a journeyman painter Waltusz earned less than half the daily wage of peers in other trades. In 1652, journeymen carpenters and bricklayers in Amsterdam earned approximately 26 to 27 stivers per summer day (although there are no exact figures for 1651, data is available for 1633, 27 and 25 stivers respectively, and for 1667, 28 and 27 stivers respectively).
    This disparity between painter’s journeymen and their peers in other trades mirrors the situation in 1579. The guild
    regulations (gildebrief) of the St. Luke’s Guild from that year mention journeymen earning 4 stivers and others earning 10
    stivers per day (Ordonnantien (see note 9), p. 17, art. 11). Taking the average of 7 stivers, these were notably low wages –
    practically half – when compared to the 14 and 12 stivers earned by carpenters and bricklayers, respectively, in that same
    year. For the wages of the workers mentioned here, see: Hubert Nutseling, Welvaart en werkgelegenheid in Amsterdam
    1540–1860, Amsterdam/Dieren 1985, p. 252, appendix 5.1, table A.
  64. SAA, DTB 5001, 469, p. 241, 30-09-1651; Judith van Gent, Bartholomeus van der Helst (circa 1613-1670): een studie naar zijn leven en zijn werk, Utrecht (Utrecht University), p. 41.
  65. Virtually nothing is known about Gerardus van Berleborch (Bernard Renckens, “G. van Berkborch”, Oud Holland 84 (1967), no. 4, passim). He or his father was likely from the region around Bad Berleburg in Germany. He appears to have been present in Leiden in 1665, when he is recorded as a witness (“Gerrit van Berleberg”) at the baptism of a child of the painter Jacobus Geutkien (Erfgoed Leiden en Omstreken (hereafter ELO), DTB 1004, 237, fol. 236v, 3-12-1665).
  66. SAA, 5075, 875, not. Jacob van Zwieten, pp. 638-640, 16-10-1649; Johannes G. van Dillen, Bronnen tot de geschiedenis van het bedrijfsleven en het gildewezen van Amsterdam 1510-1672 III, p. 540, no. 1057.
  67. A possible reason for this may be that young painters attained the status of master more quickly. This benefited the guild financially, as it earned income only from masters and pupils, not from journeymen.
  68. Ordonnantien (see note 9), p. 10, art. 3.
  69. Ordonnantien (see note 9), p. 17, art. 11.
  70. Joachim von Sandrart’s famous anecdote about Rembrandt’s studio being filled with “countless elite children”, pupils who each paid an annual tuition fee of 100 guilders suggests that the legal limit on the number of pupils was, in practice, a dead letter (Joachim von Sandrardt, Teutsche Academie, Nuremberg 1675, p. 326; Van Eeghen, “Guild” (see note 7), p. 6).
  71. Young Man Reading with a Vanitas Still Life, 1644, oil on panel, 58 x 74 cm, Rotterdam, Museum Boijmans Van Beuningen, inv. no. 1386; Self-portrait, 1644, oil on panel, 63 x 48 cm, The Hague, Museum Bredius, inv. no. 056-1946; Self-portrait, 1645, oil on panel, 54.1 x 44.8 cm, Liechtenstein, The Princely Collections, Vaduz-Vienna, inv. no. GE 107; Portrait of a Child, 1645, oil on panel, 68.6 x 57.8 cm, private collection; The Adoration of the Shepherds, 1647, oil on canvas, 58.2 x 70.8 cm, Dordrecht, Dordrechts Museum, inv. no. DM/980/567.
  72. Godefridus J. Hoogewerff, De geschiedenis van de St. Lucasgilden in Nederland, Amsterdam 1947, p. 24; Ernst van de Wetering “Problems of Pupilship and Studio Practice” in: Josua Bruyn et al., A Corpus of Rembrandt Paintings II: 1631-1634, Amsterdam 1986, p. 57; Bikker, Drost (see note 2), p. 11; Angelina Illes, in: exh. cat. Vienna 2024 (see note 3), p. 29.
  73. Samuel Muller Fz., Schilders-vereenigingen te Utrecht. Bescheiden uit het Gemeentearchief, Utrecht 1880, p. 76; Frederik D.O. Obreen, Archief voor Nederlandsche Kunstgeschiedenis IV, Rotterdam 1881/1882, p. 51. The very fact that such a regulation had to be instituted in these cities already indicates that works were being signed by non-masters.
  74. De Jager, “Meester” (see note 18), pp. 77-79.
  75. Bruyn, “Onderzoek”, (see note 26), p. 113.
  76. David de Witt, Leonore van Sloten, in: The Hague 2025 (see note 3), “Rembrandt’s Impact”, https://vanhoogstraten.rkdstudies.nl/catalogus-schilderijen/rembrandts-impact/, 3 June 2025.
  77. Almost exclusively, reference is made to Bikker, Drost (see note 2), p. 11. Also in the exhibition catalogue of the Van Hoogstraten exhibition in Amsterdam, Drost is cited as an example of an early student of Van Hoogstraten (David de Witt, in: exh. cat. Amsterdam 2025 (see note 3), p. 131.
  78. Since Daniël Pont’s monograph on Barent Fabritius, (Daniël Pont, Barent Fabritius 1624–1673, The Hague, 1958) and Sumowski’s Drawings of the Rembrandt School (see note 2), no subsequent scholarly efforts have systematically De Kroniek 2024/25 – Museum Rembrandthuis 12 reconstructed his drawn oeuvre or analyzed the development of his distinctive style. The author’s forthcoming dissertation addresses this lacuna, and catalogues drawings by Barent Fabritius.
  79. Pont was among the first to suggest he may not have been a direct pupil of Rembrandt, but instead only came into contact with Rembrandt’s work indirectly, through his brother Carel (Pont, Barent (see note 43), p. 96). In the literature, uncertainty on this matter appears to have become the norm, with scholars consistently noting – or implicitly dealing with – the lack of evidence for a formal pupilship with Rembrandt (see: Paul Huys Jansen, Werner Sumowski, The Hoogsteder Exhibition of Rembrandt’s Academy, exh. cat. The Hague: Hoogsteder & Hoogsteder, 1992, p. 139; Walter A. Liedkte in: Hubert von Sonneburg, Rembrandt/Not Rembrandt in the Metropolitan Museum of Art I, exh. cat. New York City: The Metropolitan Museum of Art, 1995, cat. 48, pp. 145-146; Peter C. Sutton in: Albert Blankert, Rembrandt. A Genius and his impact, exh. cat. Melbourne: National Gallery of Victoria; Canberra: National Gallery of Australia, 1997, p. 283; Jan Blanc, Dans l’atelier de Rembrandt. Le maître et ses élèves, Paris 2006, p. 140.
  80. Holm Bevers, “Das Susanna-Thema im Werkstattzusammenhang: Zeichnungen”, in: Holm Bevers, Katja Kleinert, Claudia Laurenze-Landsberg, Rembrandts Berliner Susanna und die beiden Alten. Die Schaffung eins meisterwerks, exh. cat. Berlin: Staatliche Museen zu Berlin, Kupferstichkabinett; Gemäldegalerie, 2015, pp. 49-50.
  81. Katja Kleinert, Claudia Laurenze-Landsberg, “Wandlungen eines Gemäldes. Rembrandts Berliner Susanna und die beiden Alten”, in: exh. cat. Berlin 2015 (see note 45), p. 19, 32.
  82. See for instance Rembrandt’s Holy Family in the Carpenter’s workshop or his Star of the Kings (London, The British Museum, inv. nos. 1900,0824.144, 1910,0212.189).
  83. The drawing of a male model (here attributed to Barent Fabritius) has been described as stylistically very close to Van Hoogstraten (Martin Royalton-Kisch in: Catalogue of Drawings by Rembrandt and his School, London: The British Museum, 2010, cat. 71). The Departure of the Prodigal Son, a drawing already earlier attributed to Fabritius, is still considered a work by Van Hoogstraten (Frankfurt am Main, Städel Museum, inv. no. 817).
  84. A convincing spatial representation of the scene, achieved through a successful use of proportion, perspective, light, and color. For a elaboration on this definition, including references, see: Leonore van Sloten, “Regels voor de kunst”, in: David de Witt, Leonore van Sloten, Jaap van der Veen, Rembrandts late leerlingen. In de leer bij een genie, exh. cat. Amsterdam: Rembrandt House Museum, 2015, p. 73, note 31.
  85. In drawings by Barent Fabritius from the second half of the 1640s, his preparatory chalk underdrawing is generally careful and precise but not detailed, with clear, exact contours rendered in continuous, rounded lines. The somewhat squat figures possess a doll-like, slightly caricatural character. When using pen to trace or fill in the figures, particularly those in the foreground, the style becomes sketchier and more angular. Fabritius’s hatching lines become more carefully placed as they  grow finer, laid loosely side by side with only occasional thin-pen scratching, while thicker lines, including contours, are rendered in a zigzag, looser manner, often applied to foreground elements such as a repoussoir. Groups of hatching in shadowed, complex motifs (e.g., figures or foreground foliage) are neither intertwined nor uniformly oriented, and though the balance of light and shadow varies between drawings, it remains consistent within each composition; early mastery is evident in his wash applications, where loosely brushed transitions in shadows lend a painterly quality, enhancing figural plasticity and atmospheric depth, as seen in drawings with dramatic chiaroscuro effects.
  86. Although it has been argued by Holm Bevers that this drawing is by Constantijn Daniël van Renesse and dates from between 1650 and 1652 (Holm Bevers, “Ausstellungen zu Rembrandt in Rückblick”, Kunstchronik, 58 (2005), p. 480; Holm Bevers, in: Rembrandt. Die Zeichnungen im Berliner Kupferstichkabinett, exh. cat. Berlin: Staatliche Museen zu Berlin, Kupferstichkabinett, 2006, cat. no. 45, p. 158, nt. 12; Holm Bevers in: Holm Bevers et al., Drawings by Rembrandt and his Pupils. Telling the Difference, exh. cat. Los Angeles: The J. Paul Getty Museum, 2009, cat. no. 31.2, pp. 190-191), a number of features are so uncharacteristic of Van Renesse that the attribution cannot be sustained. This applies in particular to elements such as the heavy, coarse scratches in the shadow areas and the sketch-like rendering of the faces of Joseph and Mary. Van Renesse typically keeps shadow areas and light transitions in brush clear and even. Also characteristic is his meticulous penwork, marked by fine, short strokes in the contours and hatching lines (see for instance: The Judgment of Salomon, New York City (The Metropolitan Museum of Art, Robert Lehman Collection, inv. no. 1975.1.806; Daniel in the Lion’s Den, Rotterdam, Museum Boijmans Van Beuningen, inv. no. MB 200). Generally, it shows the boldness of Barent much more than the careful restraint of Renesse
  87. “Beeter waer ‚t dat [om de veranderin[g]] een eesel van achteren was, dan dat al de hoofden iuist wt het stuck sien. Dat oock omtrent de boom wat meerder groente was. | 1 losep heft af te swaer en te onbesuist | 2 Maria most het kindeken wat meerder vieren, want een teeder kint magh sulck duwen niet ver[dragen]. | losep al te kort en dick, sijn hooft wast hem wt de [borst?]. Sijn hebben alle beide al te groote koppen”. Transcript from: Leonore van Sloten, in: exh. cat. Amsterdam 2015 (see note 49), p. 73, nt. 27. “It would be better that [for the alteration] there were a donkey from the back, than that all the heads are looking straight out of the work. That there were also somewhat more greenery around the tree. | 1 Joseph lifts too heavily and too inconsiderately. | 2 Mary ought to ease the little child somewhat more, for a tender infant cannot [endure] such pushing. | Joseph is all too short and stout, his head grows out of the [chest?]. They both have all too large heads”. These instructions are also partly articulated within the drawing itself. Joseph is indeed shown tugging firmly at Mary’s arm, whereas in the more sketch-like version, he supports her more gently at the back. The small patch of greenery in the lower corner may also be a later addition, in correspondence with the suggestion.
  88. The face does not appear to be a correction in the technical sense, but rather an example of a foreshortened face viewed from below – a challenging principle of perspective.
  89. An attribution proposed Christian Dittrich (Christian Dittrich in: Christian Dittrich, Thomas Ketelsen, Rembrandt. Die Dresdener Zeichnungen 2004, exh. cat. Dresden: Staatliche Kunstsammlungen Dresden, Kupferstich-Kabinett, 2004, cat. no.14, pp. 80-81).
  90. Brusati implied the possibility that the text was written partly by Rembrandt and partly by Van Hoogstraten (Celeste Brusati, Artifice & Illusion. The Art and Writing of Samuel van Hoogstraten, Chicago/London 1995, pp. 31, 275, note 40). Rembrandt was excluded as the author of the instructions by Bevers, while Van Hoogstraten as author remained an option. Van Renesse was likewise ruled out by Bevers, based on a comparison with the handwriting on his Daniel in the Lions’ Den drawing and The Judgment of Solomon drawing (see note 51); Holm Bevers, in: exh. cat. Los Angeles 2009 (see note 51), cat. 31.1–31.2, p. 190; 191, note 3). To this may be added that the handwriting also closely resembles that of Barent Fabritius. Although little comparative material survives, the compact, small script of Fabritius’s name beneath the death inventory of his sister-in-law Aeltje, dated 24 April 1643 (SAA, 5075, 1628a, not. David de l’Hommel, p. 399), shows a strong resemblance to the instructions on the Dresden sheet.
  91. “Once you have mastered your handling and your eye is somewhat clarified, it will no longer trouble you to translate many naturalistic paintings into a naturalistic drawing”. “Wanneer gy uwe handeling nu machtich zijt, en uw oog wat verklaert is, zoo zal ‚t u ook niet verscheelen veel verwige Schilderyen in een verwige teykeningen na te klaren” (Van Hoogstraten, Inleyding (see note 1), p. 27)
  92. “I advise masters, when they review the drawings of their pupils, to improve them by making sketches of the same subject themselves. This is an excellent exercise and has greatly assisted many in the art of composition”. “De meesters raed ik, als ze de Teykeningen haerer discipelen overzien, datze de zelve, met schetssen op ‚t zelve voorwerp te maeken, verbeeteren. Dit oeffent ongemeen, en heeft veelen geweldich in de schikkunst geholpen” (Van Hoogstraten, Inleyding (see note 1), p. 192).
  93. “And certainly, this manner of drawing with pen and brush is likewise the most suitable for completing a masterly work in its full force. For one can also, whenever it proves convenient, work into it with red chalk and crayons, as though one were almost painting with colours”. “En zeker deeze wijze van met pen en pinseel te teykenen, is ook allerbequaemst om een meesterlijk werk in zijn volle kracht te voleinden. Dewijl men’er ook, als’t pas geeft, met rood krijt en kryons in kan speelen, als of men byna met verwen schilderde” (Van Hoogstraten, Inleyding (see note 1), p. 31.
  94. On stylistic grounds, this Rembrandt drawing has been placed among a group of history drawings dating to around 1650 (Otto Benesch, The Drawings of Rembrandt V, New York 1957, no. 902). Among other arguments, this dating led Bevers to attribute the Dresden drawing to Constantijn van Renesse, rather than Barent Fabritius (Holm Bevers, in: exh. cat. Berlin 2006 (see note 51), cat. no. 45, p. 157, 158, nt. 12) However, it remains questionable whether the Rembrandt drawing in Berlin should be understood within that context. Unlike the other history drawings, this work is not an autonomous composition but rather a sketched response to the Dresden sheet. It is plausible that the sketch was already made around 1647. In terms of linework, it is not far removed from the portrait sketch of Jan Six, dating from in or before 1647 (Amsterdam, Six Collection).
    It is drawn in a similarly free style, applied in a sketch, comparable to other drawings from the second half of the 1640’s (see
    note 47). Rembrandt’s Berlin drawing could thus have been made quite soon after Fabritius’s corrected drawing
  95. Josua Bruyn, “Gemälde der Rembrandt-Schüler II by Werner Sumowski Review”, Oud Holland 101 (1987) no. 3, p. 229.
  96. https://rkd.nl/images/313061, 17 July 2025. In terms of drawing style, this work is not far removed from Van Hoogstraten’s drawing The Sacrifice of Manoah of 1649 (Braunschweig, Herzog Anton Ulrich Museum, inv. no. Z 335; https://rkd.nl/images/71286, 17 July 2025). We may even assume that The Crucifixion predates it; the departing angel in the  Braunschweig drawing – also seen from the back – appears to be a more developed and refined treatment of the motif of a figure seen from behind.
  97. Samuel van Hoogstraten, The Adoration of the Shepherds. London, The British Museum, inv. no. 1895,0915.1203; https://rkd.nl/images/313552, 17 July 2025. A drawing of The Circumcision, likewise painted as a part of the Passion series in 1646, has been attributed to Gerbrand van den Eeckhout (Brussels, Koninklijke Musea voor Schone Kunsten België, inv. no. 4060/1212). There are also two copies after Rembrandt’s Holy Family with a Curtain from 1646 (London, The British Museum, inv. no. 1895,0915.1200; Oxford, Ashmolean Museum, inv. no. WA1986.56).
  98. Josua Bruyn in: Josua Bruyn et al., A Corpus of Rembrandt Paintings III: 1635-1642, Amsterdam 1989 pp. 13-16.
  99. Martin Royalton-Kisch, Drawings by Rembrandt and his Circle in the British Museum, London: The British Museum, 1992, cat. no. 87, pp. 180-182; Holm Bevers, “Drawings in Rembrandt’s Workshop”, in: exh. cat. Los Angeles 2009 (see note 51), pp. 13-17; David de Witt, “Leren van het leven: tekeningen van Rembrandts leerlingen” in: Judith Noorman, David de Witt, Rembrandts Naakte Waarheid. Tekenen naar naaktmodellen in de Gouden Eeuw, exh. cat. Amsterdam: Rembrandt House Museum, 2015, pp. 117-120.
  100. Initially, this drawing was attributed to Rembrandt, but as early as 1908, this attribution was already being questioned (Martin Conway, “Some Rembrandt Drawings”, Burlington Magazine 14 (1908/1909), p.37).
  101. This sheet has previously been judged the weakest of the three (David de Witt, in: exh. cat. Amsterdam 2015 (see note 64), p. 118), and it has even been suggested that Rembrandt may have corrected it. (Martin Royalton-Kisch, in: col. cat. London 2010 (see note 48), cat. 71). The fine parallel pen strokes in the boy’s torso are comparable to those in the body of Susanna in the Budapest drawing. The somewhat arbitrary use of red chalk (in the model’s right armpit area, on the reverse side of the cushion, and in the upper left corner) also stands out in both sheets. The type of loose, heavy pen lines used for the cushion corresponds to those found in the cloak of the old man in the Susanna drawing.
  102. For a first suggestion of Bol being the assistant of Rembrandt, see: Albert Blanckert, Ferdinand Bol (1616-1680). Rembrandt’s Pupil, Doornspijk 1982, pp. 17-18.
  103. Blanckert, Bol (see note 67), pp. 17-18; David de Witt, “Ferdinand Bol, discipel van Rembrandt”, in: Norbert Middelkoop, Ferdinand Bol en Govert Flinck. Rembrandts meesterleerlingen, Amsterdam (Rembrandt House Museum/Amsterdam Museum) 2017, pp. 44-45
  104. Portrait of a Lady, 1642. Berlin, Staatliche Museen zu Berlin, Gemäldegalerie, inv. no. 809. However, there are paintings by Bol, or attributed to him, of an earlier date or dating. The Liberation of St Peter (private collection), dated around 1636, may be, given its strong connection to the work of Benjamin Cuyp (David de Witt, in: exh. cat. Amsterdam 2017 (see note 68), pp. 42-43), made before Bol’s departure to Amsterdam. Gideon’s Sacrifice of 1640, signed by Bol (Utrecht, Museum Catharijneconvent, inv. no. RMCC s24), is typical in subject matter and composition of his later work from the 1640s, and may
    be made under conditions comparable to those proposed in this article for the paintings by Van Hoogstraten, dating from
    between 1644 and 1647. Other works attributed to Bol prior to 1642 are often copies or adaptations of compositions by
    Rembrandt.
  105. Christopher Brown, Carel Fabritius, Oxford 1981, p. 47; Gero Seelig in: Frederik J. Duparc, Carel Fabritius 1622-1654, exh. cat. The Hague: Mauritshuis; Schwerin: Staatliches Museum, 2004-2005, cat. no. 4, p. 97.
  106. Erna Kok erroneously states that Bol is mentioned as Rembrandt’s “werckgesel” in a document of 30 August 1640 (Erna Kok, “Govert Flinck en Ferdinand Bol en hun netwerken van opdrachtgevers,” in: exh. cat. Amsterdam 2017 (see note 68), p. 71, p. 244, n. 37). Bol’s exact role during his time in Rembrandt’s workshop is never documented. It is striking that the drawn copies after three of Rembrandt’s paintings from around 1636 are attributed to Ferdinand Bol (Peter Schatborn, “Tekeningen van Govert Flinck en Ferdinand Bol”, in: exh. cat. Amsterdam 2017 (see note 68), p.185). Apart from these sheets and those datable around 1646 by later pupils, there are few, if any, known drawings by Rembrandt’s pupils that are direct copies after his history or figure paintings. It is possible that Bol played an important role in introducing this method into the studio, and that it was later adopted by Van Hoogstraten. Van Hoogstraten is likely to have been in contact with Bol while in Amsterdam. After Bol established himself as an independent master, around 1642, he too began to draw in red chalk. He did so, however, almost exclusively in preparatory studies for (mainly) paintings – see, for instance, Joseph brings his Father before Pharaoh (Dresden, Gemäldegalerie, inv. no. 1605), and its preliminary drawing (Amsterdam, Rijksmuseum, inv. no. RP-T-1883-A-276). Van Hoogstraten may well have adopted this practice from him. This suggests that, even as an official pupil of Rembrandt, Van Hoogstraten felt the freedom to look to the work of other contemporaries as well. Van Sloten has argued that Bol continued to visit Rembrandt during the first half of the 1640s (Leonore van Sloten, “Ferdinand Bol, de etser”, in: exh. cat. Amsterdam 2017 (see note 68), pp. 218–221). Bol’s use of red chalk for preparatory studies may therefore have been the source of Van Hoogstraten’s conception that the use of red chalk contributes to the painterly quality of a drawing.
  107. Arnold Houbraken, De groote schouburgh der Nederlantsche konstschilders en schilderessen, Amsterdam, 1976, p. 165.
  108. Jan Jacobsz. Orlers, Beschrijvinge der Stadt Leyden, 2nd ed., Leiden, 1641, p. 376.
  109. See the translation from the original Latin: “Constantijn Huygens on Lievens and Rembrandt,” in: Arthur K. Wheelock et al., Jan Lievens. A Dutch Master Rediscovered, exh. cat. Washington: National Gallery of Art; Milwaukee: Milwaukee Art Museum; Amsterdam: Museum Het Rembrandthuis, 2008-2009, p. 287.
  110. See: Arthur K. Wheelock, “Jan Lievens: Bringing New Light to an Old Master,” in: Wheelock, Lievens (see note 2), pp. 13-23; and: Lloyd DeWitt, Evolution and Ambition in the Career of Jan Lievens (1607-1674), Ph.D. dissertation, University of Maryland, 2006: https://www.researchgate.net/publication/277127128_Evolution_and_Ambition_in_the_Career_of_Jan_Lievens_1607-1674
  111. Property from Aristocratic Estates and Important Provenance, Vienna (Dorotheum), 8 September 2020, lot 59 (as Circle of Bartholomeus van der Helst).
  112. Werner Sumowski, Gemälde der Rembrandt-Schüler, Landau, vol. 5, 1990, p. 3109, no. 2127, ill. p. 3279
  113. Ernst van de Wetering, Rembrandt: the Painter at Work, Amsterdam, 1997, pp. 182-185.
  114. Jan Lievens, Job in his Misery, monogrammed and dated 1631, canvas, 171.5 x 148.6 cm, Ottawa, National Gallery of Canada (4093). See Lloyd DeWitt in Wheelock, Lievens (see note 2), pp. 130-131, no. 25 (colour illus.).
  115. Jan Lievens, The Penitent Magdalene, c. 1631. Canvas, 63.5 x 49.5 cm. Kingston, Agnes Etherington Art Centre, gift of Dr. and Mrs. Alfred Bader, 1975 (18.126). See David de Witt in Wheelock, Lievens, pp. 128-129, no. 24 (colour illus.).
  116. Portrait of Jan Davidsz. de Heem, c. 1635/37, black chalk with some white body colour, 265 x 201 mm, London, British Museum (1895,0915.1199); Werner Sumowski, Drawings of the Rembrandt School, New York, vol. 7 (1983), pp. 3682-3683, no. 1652x (illus.).
  117. See entry by Lloyd DeWitt in: Wheelock, Lievens (see note 2), pp. 154-155, no. 38 (colour illus.).
  118. Jan Lievens, Head of a Bearded Old Man, c. 1640. Panel, 55 x 43 cm (oval), Kingston, Agnes Etherington Art Centre, gift of Alfred and Isabel Bader. See: David de Witt, The Bader Collection: Dutch and Flemish Paintings. Kingston, 2008, p. 198, no. 117 (colour illus.).
  119. Jan Lievens, Portrait of Adriaen Brouwer, c. 1635/37, black chalk with touches of pen in black, 221 x 185 mm, Paris, Fondation Custodia, Collection Frits Lugt (1203); Sumowski, Drawings (see note 9), pp. 3356-3357, no. 1594 (illus.).
  120. Jan Lievens, Portrait of Constantijn Huygens, 1639, black chalk with touches of pen in brown, 238 x 174 mm, London, British Museum (1836.8.11.342); see Wheelock, Lievens (see note 2), p. 242-243, no. 103 (colour illus.).
  121. Email correspondence with the author, 9 September 2020.
  122. My thanks to Stephanie Dickey for this information (email, 31 October 2022), confirmed by Marieke de Winkel.
  123. See Wheelock, Lievens (see note 2), p. 286.
  124. Lucas Vorsterman, after Anthony van Dyck, Portrait of Jan Lievens, c. 1630-1645, engraving, 241 x 158 mm, in 6 states, for the series: Icones Principorum Vivorum Doctorum Pictorum…; see: Marie Mauquoy-Hendrickx, L’Iconographie d’Antoine van Dyck, 2nd ed., Brussels, 1991, vol. 1, p. 155, no. 85; vol. 2, pl. 54 (illus.).
  125. Wheelock, Lievens (see note 2), pp. 112-113, no. 112 (colour illus.).
  126. Jan Lievens, Portrait of Charles I, pen in brown, 183 x 140 mm, Turin, Biblioteca Reale (D. C. 16365); Sumowski, Drawings (see note 9), pp. 3898-3899, no. 1754xx, (illus.); Orlers, Beschrijvinge (see note 1), pp. 375-377.
  127. Karolien de Klippel, “Adriaen Brouwer, Portrait Painter: New Identifications and an Iconographic Novelty,” Simiolus 30 (2003), pp. 196-216.
  128. Stephanie Dickey, “Jan Lievens and Printmaking,” in Wheelock, Lievens (see note 2), pp. 60-62. On the Iconography, see Mauquoy-Hendrickx, Iconographie (see note 7).
  129. DeWitt, Evolution (see note 3), p. 192, illus. fig. 144 (Lievens c. 1635/43, H. de Bran); attribution by Werner Sumowski: written correspondence with the museum of 28 July 1986; and: Drawings of the Rembrandt School, vol. 12 (Addenda), Leiden (forthcoming), no. 3104x.
  130. See Mauquoy-Hendrick, Iconography (see note 17), vol. 1, p. 214, no. 190; vol. 2, pl. 119.
  131. See DeWitt, Evolution (see note 3), pp. 160-164.
  132. Jan Lievens, Portrait of Thomas Howard, Earl of Arundel, black and red chalk, 180 x 140 mm, Staatliche Museen zu Berlin, Kupferstichkabinett (KdZ 5869); Wheelock, Lievens (see note 2), p. 249, no. 109 (colour illus.).
  133. Jan Lievens, Profile Head of an Old Woman in Oriental Dress, c. 1630, panel, 43.2 x 33.7 cm, Kingston, Agnes Etherington Art Centre, gift of Alfred and Isabel Bader, 2005 (48-002). See entry by David de Witt in Wheelock, Lievens (see note 2), pp. 122-123, no. 21 (colour illus.).
  134. Letter to his son the Earl of Lothian, May 1654: Correspondence of Sir Robert Kerr, First Earl of Ancram, and His Son William, Third Earl of Lothian, vol. 2, London, 1875, p. 383; C. Hofstede de Groot, “Hollandsche Kunst in Schotland,” Oud Holland 11 (1893), p. 214.
  135. On Sinclair: Jeannette Ewin, Fine Wines and Fish Oil: The Life of Hugh Macdonald Sinclair, Oxford 2001.
  136. The typescript is available in the “Library acquisition file for the Sinclair collection”.
  137. UBC Library, WZ250 .T9 1641.
  138. “7,000 rare books arrive”, UBC Reports 12, no. 3 (March-April, 1966). https://www.library.ubc.ca/archives/pdfs/ubcreports/UBC_Reports_1966_03_00.pdf
  139. Michiel Roscam Abbing, Rembrandt’s Elephant. Following in Hansken’s Footsteps, Amstelveen 2021.
  140. Nina Siegal, “When Rembrandt Met an Elephant”, The New York Times, July 16, 2021.
  141. UBC Library, WZ250 .T9 1641 and WZ260 .T83 1739 with the title Observationes Medicae.
  142. Allard Pierson, University of Amsterdam, Archives of Menno Hertzberger (UBA235). Sales catalogue Medicine Hippocrates-Claude Bernard, Amsterdam [February 1954], lot 442.
  143. Note 8 for this annotated copy.
  144. He also kept the relevant page from the catalogue in his files. Hamburg, Warburg Haus, Heckscher Archiv, Box 121 (‘Rembrandt: Dr. Tulp’), folder ‘Dr. Tulp Photo’s I’. Sinclair’s copy is kept in UBC Library call number Z999.74.
  145. According to Heckscher’s own administration he sent letters to Hugh Sinclair on 15 February and 2 March 1963. Hamburg, Warburg Haus, Heckscher Archiv, Box 52 (‘Heckscher: Korrespondenz und Arbeiten’). We thank Ms. Fanny Weidehaas of the Heckscher Archiv for her assistance. These letters were not found among Sinclair’s papers in The Museum of English Rural Life at the University of Reading. We thank Ms. Emma Farmer for checking these files.
  146. The translation was not published until 1991: Nicolaes Tulp, Geneesinzichten van Dr. Nicolaes Tulp etc., eds. (and transcriptions) C.G.L. Apeldoorn and T. Beijer. Amsterdam, 1991.
  147. The title page of the manuscript reads: “Nicolaes Tulp. Inzichten over de geneeskunst in vier boeken met koperen platen” (Nicolaes Tulp. Medical Insights in Four Books with Copper Plates).
  148. “D. Meppen Norda Frisii 1682 d. 18 8.bris”. We thank Koert van der Horst, retired keeper of manuscripts of the Utrecht University Library, for this identification. A third (unidentified) ownership’s inscription reads: “L. Fries stud. med. 1838 16/2.”
  149. The visit is not recorded in Sinclair’s Visitors book. Reading, The Museum of English Rural Life, Papers of Hugh Macdonald Sinclair, D HS 1/7/1: Visitor’s book 1941-1989: Dr Hugh Sinclair’s book of visitors to his home, Lady Place in Sutton Courtenay. We are grateful to Ms. Hollie Piff for checking.
  150. In the National Archives in The Hague we consulted the archives of the Department of Archeology and Nature Conservation, inv. no. 105 (Stukken betreffende de aanvraag van vergunningen voor de in- en uitvoer van voorwerpen van geschiedenis en kunst. 1946-1964).
  151. Allard Pierson, University of Amsterdam, Archives of Menno Hertzberger (UBA235), personal archives.
  152. Kindly provided information by Ms. Nina Duggen, Inspectie Overheidsinformatie en Erfgoed (Information and Heritage Inspectorate).
  153. Peter Schatborn and Erik Hinterding, Rembrandt. The Complete Drawings and Etchings, Cologne 2019. Peter Schatborn gave his judgement in an email of September 15, 2021, in translation: “In any case, the drawing was not made by Rembrandt. The stylistic differences are too great and I can’t find any drawing by Rembrandt that is comparable”.
  154. Ernest Theodore Hamy, ‚Documents inédits sur l‘Homo sylvestris rapporté d’Angola en 1630′, Bulletin du Muséum d’histoire naturelle 3 (1897), pp. 277-282.
  155. Michiel Roscam Abbing is currently preparing a book-length study, The Ape of Tulp, in which these data are to be published.
  156. Peter van der Krogt and Erlend de Groot, The Atlas Blaeu-Van der Hem of the Austrian National Library V (Utrecht 2005), pp. 88-89 (no. 35:40). The suggestion that Blaeu, who died in 1638, had access to the engraving of the chimpanzee and that this engraving was made by Tulp long before 1641, as argued by Kees Zandvliet (De Wereld van de familie Blaeu, Zutphen 2023, p. 66) must be rejected.
  157. Much of the previous literature cites the drawing as The Departure of Rebecca from Her Parents’ House. The Staatsgalerie, Stuttgart, which owns the drawing, adopted the shorter title (https://www.staatsgalerie.de/en/html).
  158. “dit behoorde vervoucht te weesen me[t] veel gebueren die deese hoge bruijt sien vertrek[k]en”: Peter Schatborn, “The Core Group of Rembrandt Drawings, I: Overview,” Master Drawings 49 (2011), p. 320.
  159. According to the Woordenboek der Nederlandsche Taal, “geburen” may mean “figures” or “bystanders,” as two scholars interpreted the word in Rembrandt’s inscription: (https://gtb.ivdnt.org/iWDB/search?actie=article&wdb=WNT&id=M017638.re.1&lemma=geburen&domein=0&conc=true). For “figures,” see: Volker Manuth, in: Rembrandt: A Genius and His Impact, exh. cat. Canberra, Australian National Gallery; Melbourne, National Gallery of Victoria, 1997, p. 270, cat. no. 53. For “bystanders,” see: Marieke de Winkel, Fashion and Fancy: Dress and Meaning in Rembrandt’s Paintings, Amsterdam 2006, pp. 214–215). However, in the full context of Rembrandt’s inscription and the drawing’s iconography, “geburen” most strongly refers to neighbours, as translated for example by Gary Schwartz and Peter Schatborn. See: Gary Schwartz, The Rembrandt Book, New York 2006, p. 107, fig. 195; Schatborn, “Core” (see note 2), p. 320.
  160. Schwartz, Rembrandt (see note 3), p. 107.
  161. Amy Golahny, “Rembrandt and ‘Everyday Life’: the Fusion of Genre and History,” in: Genre Imagery in Early Modern Northern Europe: New Perspectives, London 2016, pp. 174, 177.
  162. The Rembrandt drawing (130 x 185 mm) was sold at Christie’s (London) on 3 July 2012, lot. 50, sale 5688. Golahny, “Rembrandt” (see note 5), pp. 170–174, figs. 7.5–9.
  163. Herman Roodenburg, “Naar een etnografie van de vroegmoderne stad: de ‘gebuyrten’ in Leiden en Den Haag,” in: Cultuur en maatschappij in Nederland 1500–1850. Een historisch-antropologisch perspectief, Meppel 1992, p. 233.
  164. For a discussion of neighbourhoods’ goals, see: Herman Roodenburg, “’Freundschaft’, ‘Brüderlichkeit’ und ‘Einigkeit’: Städtische Nachbarschaften im Westen der Republik,” in: Ausbreitung bürgerlicher Kultur in den Niederlanden und Nordwestdeutschland, Münster 1991, pp. 11, 12, 21; Gabrielle Dorren, “Communities within the Community: Aspects of Neighbourhood in Seventeenth-Century Haarlem,” Urban History 25 (1998), pp. 180, 188.
  165. See, for example, Rembrandt’s drawings Benesch 491, 503, 566, 988 and his painting Portrait of a Couple as Isaac and Rebecca, c. 1665–1669 (oil on canvas, 121.5 x 166.5 cm, Amsterdam, Rijksmuseum).
  166. All Biblical translations from: The New English Bible with the Apocrypha, New York 1971.
  167. Schatborn, “Core” (see note 2), p. 320.
  168. The Staatsgalerie Stuttgart attributes the inscription to Rembrandt and the drawing to either Rembrandt or Gerbrand van den Eeckhout. Hans Martin Kaulbach, Curator of German and Netherlandish Prints and Drawings before 1800, Graphische Sammlung, Staatsgalerie Stuttgart, email message to the author, 25 April 2018.
  169. For Koninck see for example: Horst Gerson, Philips Koninck; ein beitrag zur Erforschung der holländischen Malerei des XVII. Jahrhunderts, Berlin 1936, p. 174, Z.LXV. For Flinck: Wilhelm Reinhold Valentiner, Rembrandt: des Meisters Handzeichnungen, Stuttgart 1933, part 2, p. 247. For Van den Eeckhout: Martin Royalton-Kisch, Drawings by Rembrandt and His Circle in the British Museum, exh. cat., London, British Museum 1992, p. 202, cat. no. 97; Holm Bevers, “Drawing in Rembrandt’s Workshop,” in: Drawings by Rembrandt and His Pupils: Telling the Difference, exh. cat., Los Angeles, J. Paul Getty Museum 2009, p. 27; Schatborn, “Core” (see note 2), pp. 320, 322, note 38. For an argument against the Van den Eeckhout attribution, see: Eric Jan Sluijter and Nicolette Sluijter-Seijffert, “Rembrandt’s Pupils? The Attribution of Early Drawings to Gerbrand van den Eeckhout and Jan Victors,” in: Connoisseurship Essays in Honour of Fred G. Meijer, Leiden 2020, pp. 289–296.
  170. Werner Sumowski, Drawings of the Rembrandt School, New York 1979–1992, vol. 3, p. 1734, 806xx; Bevers, “Drawing” (see note 13), pp. 27, notes 97–98.
  171. Seymour Slive, Rembrandt Drawings, Los Angeles 2009, p. 215; Schatborn, “Core” (see note 2), p. 320; Bevers, “Drawing” (see note 13), p. 2.
  172. Cornelis Hofstede de Groot and Bob Haak, Rembrandt Zeichnungen, Köln 1974, p. 13; Manuth, Rembrandt (see note 3), p. 270, cat. no. 53.
  173. Samuel van Hoogstraten, De Inleyding tot de hooge schoole der schilderkunst anders de zichtbaere werelt, Rotterdam 1678, p. 192. Bevers, “Drawing” (see note 13), p. 25, notes 86–87.
  174. Bevers, “Drawing” (see note 13), pp. 25–27, 187, 189­–90; Schatborn, “Core” (see note 2), p. 320.
  175. Bevers, “Drawing” (see note 13), p. 27.
  176. Roodenburg, “Naar” (see note 7), pp. 222–224; Dorren, “Communities” (see note 8), p. 177; Llewellyn Bogaers, “Geleund over de onderdeur: Doorkijkjes in het Utrechtse buurtleven van de vroege middeleeuwen tot in de zeventiende eeuw,” in: Bijdragen en mededelingen betreffende de geschiedenis der Nederlanden 112 (1997), pp. 349, 357, 359.
  177. Roodenburg, “Naar” (see note 7), pp. 224, 233–234; Bogaers, “Geleund” (see note 20), pp. 340–342, 348.
  178. Catherina Lis and Hugo Soly, “Neighborhood Social Change in Western European Cities,” International Review of Social History 38 (1993), p. 5.
  179. Kees Walle, Buurthouden. De geschiedenis van burengebruiken en buurtorganisaties in Leiden (14e–19e eeuw), Leiden 2005, pp. 75, 306.
  180. Regionaal Archief Leiden (RAL); Stadsarchief (SA) II inv.nr. 1216, f. 149 and RAL SA II inv.nr. 1217, f. 10 vso; cited in: Walle, Buurthouden (see note 23), p. 231, note 77.
  181. Jan le Francq van Berkheij, Natuurlyke historie van Holland, 12 parts in 9 vols., Amsterdam 1769–1811, vol. 3, part 2, pp. 1045–1046; Roodenburg, “Naar” (see note 7), p. 225.
  182. RAL; SA II inv.nr. 16; Aflezingboek F, f. 58 vso; cited in: Walle, Buurthouden (see note 23), pp. 43, 227, notes 141, 270.
  183. Algemene Verordening, n.p.; cited in: Walle, Buurthouden (see note 23), pp. 46, 275.
  184. Roodenburg, “’Freundschaft’” (see note 8), p. 15; Bogaers, “Geleund” (see note 20), p. 349.
  185. Ilja Veldman and Lynne Richards, “Familiar Customs and Exotic Rituals: Picart’s Illustrations for Cérémonies et coutumes religieuses de tous les peuples,” Simiolus: Netherlandish quarterly for the history of art, vol. 33 (2007/2008), p. 94.
  186. Picart’s widow explained that “the prints of the Reformed congregation were drawn from life and are very accurate.” Bernard Picart and Anne Vincent, Impostures innocentes ou recueil d’estampes d’après divers peintres illustres . . . etc. gravées par Bernard Picart avec son éloge historique et le catalogue de ses ouvrages, Amsterdam 1734, p. 9; Veldman and Richards, “Familiar” (see note 29), p. 99, note 20.
  187. Veldman and Richards, “Familiar” (see note 29), p. 97.
  188. Bernard Picart, Cérémonies et coutumes religieuses de tous les peuples du monde, Amsterdam 1723–1743, p. 345.
  189. As Petra van Boheemen noted, the “interest of the neighbourhood is visible” in Picart’s print. Petra van Boheemen et al., Kent, en versint, eer datje mint: vrijen en trouwen, 1500–1800, Apeldoorn, Historisch Museum Marialust; Zwolle 1989, p. 170.
  190. Van Boheemen, Kent (see note 33), pp. 170–172; H. Perry Chapman, Jan Steen, Painter and Storyteller, exh. cat., Washington, DC, National Gallery of Art; Amsterdam, Rijksmuseum 1996, pp. 116–118 note 1, cat. no. 6.
  191. Van Boheemen, Kent (see note 33), p. 170.
  192. Irma Thoen, Strategic Affection? Gift Exchange in Seventeenth-Century Holland, Amsterdam 2007, p. 106.
  193. Fynes Moryson and Charles Hughes, Shakespeare’s Europe. Unpublished Chapters of Fynes Moryson’s Itinerary Being a Survey of the Condition of Europe at the End of the 16th Century, London 1903, pp. 379–380.
  194. A. Lynn Martin, Alcohol, Sex, and Gender in Late Medieval and Early Modern Europe, New York 2001, pp. 52–53; Thoen, Strategic (see note 36), p. 105.
  195. See, for example, Jan Steen’s The Wedding of Tobias and Sarah, c. 1667–1668, oil on canvas, 131 x 172 cm, Braunschweig, Herzog Anton Ulrich-Museum; Chapman, Jan Steen (see note 34), pp. 203–205, cat. no. 32.
  196. Philips Angel, Lof der schilder-konst, Leyden 1642, p. 48. Translation from: Philips Angel, Michael Hoyle, and Hessel Miedema, “Philips Angel, Praise of Painting,” Simiolus, Netherlandish Quarterly for the History of Art 24 (1996), p. 246.
  197. A. M. van der Woude, “Variations in Size and Structure of the Household in the United Provinces of the Netherlands in the Seventeenth and Eighteenth Centuries,” in: Household and Family in Past Time: Comparative Studies in the Size and Structure of the Domestic Group over the Last Three Centuries in England, France, Serbia, Japan and Colonial North America, with Further Materials from Western Europe, Cambridge 1972, p. 315.

New Light on Family Ties: Rembrandt, Vinck, Van Swanenburgh

Tekst van Nicolaes Vinck, Memoriael, Leiden, Erfgoed Leiden en Omstreken
2. Nicolaes Vinck, Memoriael, Leiden, Erfgoed Leiden en Omstreken, Manuscript LB 6761 klein deel, page for late 1669 with note of Rembrandt’s death (photo: S. Dickey).
Schilderij van Nicolaes Vinck, Memoriael. Leiden, Erfgoed Leiden en Omstreken
1. Nicolaes Vinck, Memoriael. Leiden, Erfgoed Leiden en Omstreken, Manuscript LB 6761 klein deel), title page (photo: S. Dickey).

The most basic facts of Rembrandt’s life, his birth and death, are sparsely documented. In 1641, the Leiden city historian Jan Orlers listed the artist’s birthdate as 15 July 1606. Lacking a baptismal record, most scholars have taken Orlers at his word.198 The only source for Rembrandt’s date of death is the Memoriael, or family record book, kept by Nicolaes Sebastiaensz Vinck (1608-1679), an apothecary who grew up in Leiden and moved to Amsterdam a few years before Rembrandt did (fig. 1). In a list of events from 1669, Vinck writes that his neef (relative or cousin), ‚Rembrandt van Rhyn, painter‘, died on 4 October (fig. 2). The ‚4‘ is corrected from a ‚5‘, suggesting that Vinck received the information at some remove from the event, but the date aligns with burial records indicating that Rembrandt was interred in the Westerkerk in Amsterdam on 8 October 1669.199

A partial transcription of Vinck’s Memoriael was published in 1906 but failed to catch the attention of Rembrandt scholars.200  In 1956, Dirk Rühl cited Vinck’s account in an article on heraldry and the Van Rijn family.201 When Walter Strauss compiled The Rembrandt Documents in 1979, he repeated Rühl’s brief citation and dismissed Vinck as a ‚distant relative‘.202 There the matter rested until 2022, when research for a new publication contextualizing Rembrandt’s death prompted us to seek out Vinck’s Memoriael for a first-hand look. We found it in the archives of Erfgoed Leiden en Omstreken (not in the Centraal Bureau voor Genealogie in The Hague, as stated by Rühl and Strauss).203 As it turns out, this family chronicle sheds light not only on Rembrandt’s death, but also on his childhood in Leiden.

            The clue lies in two entries that follow Vinck’s reference to Rembrandt:

            den 4 8b[er] is overleeden neeff Rembrant van Rhijn schilder

            item neeff Corn[elis] Swanenburch

            item Silvester van Swaneburch

Remarkably, these notes have not been examined until now. A similar chronicle written by Willem Jacobsz. van Heemskerk (1613-1692), husband of Maria van Swanenburgh (1616-1680), confirms that ‚Silvester van Swaneburch‘ can be identified as the son born in Naples in 1610 to the Leiden painter Jacob van Swanenburgh (1578-1638) and his Neapolitan wife, Margaretha Cardone (d. 1639). Vinck’s ‚neeff Corn[elis]‘ must be Silvester’s second cousin, the eldest child of Jacob van Swanenburgh’s first cousin, Huygh Claesz van Swanenburgh, alias van Rossum (1578/79-1635), and Adriana Claesdr. van Leeuwen (d. 1640). Huygh was a cloth merchant, and Cornelis followed his father’s profession, becoming a staalmeester in 1641. Born the same year as Rembrandt, Cornelis was buried in Leiden on 7 October 1669. Silvester van Swanenburgh died soon after.204

This essay explores Rembrandt’s connections with the Vinck and Van Swanenburgh families and their implications for his life and career. Given the importance of family alliances in early modern Dutch society, we consider relations by marriage as well as by blood. Through this research, Nicolaes Vinck and Silvester van Swanenburgh gain substance as persons in Rembrandt’s social network. A key discovery is that if Silvester was related to Vinck, and hence to Rembrandt, so too was Silvester’s father: Jacob van Swanenburgh, Rembrandt’s first teacher.

Detail of Fig. 2 (bottom of page)
2. Detail of Fig. 2 (bottom of page)

Nicolaes Vinck and his
Memoriael

As noted on his title page (fig. 1), Vinck started the chronicle in Leiden in 1627. Milestones in the lives of several generations fill its small, densely packed pages. While some entries are brief, others convey vivid details. When a child is born, Vinck often records which older relative the child is named for and who stands as godparent. He describes painful deliveries, protracted illnesses, and difficult deaths. For instance, his neef Lambert Teunissen suffered for five days before dying on 23 May 1669; he had fallen off a wagon that then rolled over him.205 On a page for 1679, a line is drawn and new handwriting appears. Nicolaes’s eldest son Sebastiaen (1638–1717) writes that his father ‚Claes Vinck‘ died between four and five in the morning of 14 November after ailing for several weeks. He was laid to rest in the Begijnkerk in Amsterdam beside his wife, Maria Dircks Haegen (1614-1678), who had died on 4 August 1678.206 Sebastiaen and other descendants continue to add data to the Memoriael until the mid-1760s.

When Vinck turned the page of his notebook after listing the deaths of Rembrandt and the Van Swanenburghs, he recorded one of the few general reflections in his text: Anno 1669 was een jaer van groote sieckte ende sturven door veel Hollandsche steeden verscheyde gequalificeerde burgers principael tot Leyden daer allevier de burgemeesters overleeden. (‚1669 was a year heavy with disease, and in many cities in Holland various distinguished burghers died, especially in Leiden, where all four burgomasters passed away‘.)207 The Van Heemskerk chronicle also mentions this epidemic and the deaths of many relatives during this period, including two within fifteen hours in October: Silvester and another cousin, Mr. Isaac van Swanenburgh (c. 1643-1669).208 Historical research has confirmed a widespread outbreak of an unspecified disease in 1669; Amsterdam was affected but Leiden was especially hard hit.209 It is unlikely that Rembrandt died from this epidemic; there are numerous indications that the artist continued painting and receiving visitors until his final days, suggesting that his death was quite sudden.210

Tekening Rembrandt, Head of an Old Woman with a Cap (Rembrandt's Mother), etching touched with black chalk
3. Rembrandt, Head of an Old Woman with a Cap (Rembrandt’s Mother), etching touched with black chalk, 65 x 58 mm, Amsterdam, Rijksmuseum, inv. RP-P-OB-747 (photo: Rijksmuseum).


Family Ties: Vinck and Rembrandt

Rembrandt’s mother, Neeltje (or Cornelia) Willemsdr. van Zuytbroeck (1568-1640), is often identified as the model who posed for numerous studies of elderly ladies by the young artist and his associates in Leiden (fig. 3).211 Neeltje’s family tree provides the connection to Nicolaes Vinck (fig. 4).212 Neeltje and Bastiaen Dircsz. Vinck (before 1581-1623), Nicolaes’s father, shared the same grandmother, Reymptgen (or Rijmpje / Rimigia) van Banchem (or Bancken) (c. 1510-1581/5).213 Strauss suggested that Rembrandt’s unusual first name was chosen to honor her.214 Reymptgen’s husband Cornelis van Tetrode (d. 1564) adopted his mother’s surname, Vinck. Their children included Rembrandt’s grandmother (Neeltje’s mother) Elisabeth Cornelisdr. [Van Tetrode] (1530-1603), Nicolaes Vinck’s grandfather Dirk Cornelisz. Vinck (1542-1632), who became a grain dealer, and Gerrit Cornelisz. Vinck (before 1544-after 1588), a painter and baker.215 

Family tree: relationship of Rembrandt and Nicolaes Vinck
4. Family tree: relationship of Rembrandt and Nicolaes Vinck (only family members relevant to article)(A. Jager): SEE PDF.

In 1581, Rembrandt’s widowed great-grandmother Reymptgen was living with her son Dirck Cornelisz. Vinck and his wife in a house called ‚t Gulden Warcken (‚the Golden Hog‘) on the Warmoesmarkt in Leiden. The census document records their household immediately before that of Rembrandt’s grandparents, Elisabeth Cornelisdr. and Willem van Zuytbroeck, a baker (d. 1609). Thus, Rembrandt’s mother Neeltje and Nicolaes Vinck’s father Bastiaen grew up next door to one another.216 Nicolaes was born on 14 December 1608, two and a half years after Rembrandt. It seems likely they knew each other as children.

 

Vinck tells us that on 16 May 1628, he moved to Amsterdam to join the apothecary practice of Roelof Ortsz Walsburch. On 20 April 1629, Walsburch and his wife drowned in the IJ.217 This tragic accident enabled Vinck to purchase their house and business, located on the Kalverstraat on the corner of the Watersteeg, close to the Begijnhof; he lived there for the rest of his life.218  On 10 May 1636, Vinck and Maria Dircks Haegen were married at the Begijnkerk; the renowned Catholic pastor Leonardus Marius (1588-1652) officiated.219 Other family members also joined the Catholic community in Amsterdam. Baptisms in the Begijnkerk are recorded, and several of the women became beguines, including Vinck’s sister Clara (1617-1657), who lived in the Begijnhof until her death.220 His brother Albert (1611-1683), a grocer and baker, married Maria Jansdr. Poef (d. 1654) in Amsterdam on 2 January 1642 and became a citizen (poorter) a few months later.221 In 1647, they buried their mother, Jannetje Gerritsdr. de Man (1585-1647), in the Begijnkerk.222 Like Nicolaes and his wife, Clara and Albert would also be buried there.223

5. Family tree: relationship of Rembrandt, Nicolaes Vinck and Karel van der Pluym (only family members relevant to article)(A. Jager): SEE PDF.

Belonging to another branch of this family tree was the painter Karel van der Pluym (1625-1672) (fig. 5). Karel was the only child of Rembrandt’s cousin Cornelia Cornelisdr van Zuytbroeck (d. 1652); her father, Cornelis Willemsz. van Zuytbroeck (1566-1631), a baker, was Neeltje’s brother (thus, Rembrandt’s uncle).224 Karel’s father was Domenicus van der Pluym (d. 1661), a prosperous plumber and slater in Leiden. In the 1640s and 1650s, Karel produced history paintings and figure studies that follow Rembrandt’s example so closely that it seems clear he moved to Amsterdam to study with his cousin. He might have lodged with another uncle, Willem Jansz van der Pluym (d. 1675), whose inventory includes a portrait drawing of himself by Rembrandt. Other documents show that the families kept in touch. Karel gave up painting a few years after he returned to Leiden in 1648. He joined the city’s governing Council of Forty in 1664 and died a wealthy man. If Rembrandt and his son Titus had not predeceased him, they would have been among his beneficiaries.225

Although Nicolaes Vinck has been overlooked as a ‚distant relative‘, his genealogical connection to Rembrandt was closer than that of Karel van der Pluym. His father, Bastiaen Dircksz. Vinck, and Rembrandt’s mother, Neeltje, were first cousins; Van der Pluym’s grandfather Cornelis was their second cousin. So far, however, there is no evidence that Rembrandt maintained a relationship with the Vincks as he apparently did with the Van der Pluyms. This might partly be explained by the fact that Vinck’s social network was largely Catholic. Yet, Nicolaes Vinck, his brother Albert, and Rembrandt were cousins, close in age and social status, who lived near each other as children and moved from Leiden to Amsterdam within a few years of each other. Profession offers another possible contact point: apothecaries often supplied painters with pigments.226 While Rembrandt developed close ties with another apothecary, Abraham Francen (1612-after 1678), their friendship may have been based on their shared passion for collecting, documented in Rembrandt’s etched portrait of Francen surrounded by his treasures (c. 1657).227 We do not know from whom Rembrandt purchased his painting materials.

Family tree: relationship of Rembrandt, Nicolaes Vinck and Jacob van Swanenburgh
6. Family tree: relationship of Rembrandt, Nicolaes Vinck and Jacob van Swanenburgh (only family members relevant to article)(A. Jager): SEE PDF.


Vinck, Van Swanenburgh, and Rembrandt’s Training as a Painter

The connection between the Van Swanenburghs and the Vincks is found in Nicolaes’s mother, Jannetje Gerritsdr. de Man (fig. 6). She was the daughter of Gerrit Arentsz. de Man, a Catholic baker and zoutzieder (salt refiner), and Jacobge Claesdr. van Swanenburgh. This lineage adds another artist to the family tree: Gerrit was the brother of the landscape painter Jan Arentsz. de Man (d. 1625), named by Orlers as teacher to Jan van Goyen (1596-1656).228 Jacobge was the youngest sister of the painter and burgomaster Isaac Claesz. van Swanenburgh (1537-1614) and, hence, the aunt of Rembrandt’s instructor, Jacob van Swanenburgh.229 In the Leiden census of 1581 (before Jannetje was born), the couple De Man and their three children were recorded living on the Boterstraat, around the corner from the Vinck and Van Zuytbroeck families on the Warmoesmarkt, mentioned above.230 The involvement of these families in grain dealing, milling, and baking bound them together within the city’s economy. It is highly likely that they were in contact.

Jacob van Swanenburgh, Aeneas and the Sybil in the Underworld, c. 1600, oil on canvas
7. Jacob van Swanenburgh, Aeneas and the Sybil in the Underworld, c. 1600, oil on canvas, 101.5 x 150 cm, Brussels, Old Masters Museum, Royal Museums of Fine Arts of Belgium, inv. 10241 (photo: Wikimedia Commons).

As a child, Jannetje Gerritsdr. de Man may well have observed her older brother, Isaac van Swanenburgh, instructing her cousin Jacob in the art of painting. In 1591, Jacob left Leiden for adventures abroad. From 1596 to 1615, he resided in Naples, where he married and joined a community of Dutch and Flemish artists.231 The year after his father died, he returned to Leiden, and in 1618, he brought his wife to live there along with their son Silvester and two daughters. In Leiden, Jacob continued to produce the dramatic history paintings and scenes of hellfire and witchcraft that had brought him notoriety in Italy (fig. 7), but he also received commissions for decorative painting from the Stadholder’s court.232

In 1620, Rembrandt’s parents enrolled him in Leiden University, and it has recently been discovered that he renewed his registration in 1622.233 Nevertheless, as Orlers describes, he was determined to pursue a career in painting, and his parents chose Jacob van Swanenburgh as his first instructor. Perhaps Jannetje Gerritsdr. de Man played a role in establishing contact between Rembrandt’s parents and her cousin Jacob. Orlers states that Rembrandt spent three years in Jacob’s studio before going to Amsterdam to work for six months with Pieter Lastman (1583-1633).234 During these years (1622-25), Silvester van Swanenburgh would surely have encountered Rembrandt in the family home. Silvester resided on the Breestraat in Leiden until 1654, when he moved to Huis ter Lucht on the Donkersteeg.235 By 1637, he was established as a public notary, and in 1638 he is listed as a citizen (poorter) of Leiden and secretaris van het baljuwschap van Rijnland (Secretary of the Bailiwick of Rijnland). He still held that post when he was recorded on 12 October 1669 as sick in bed; he must have died shortly thereafter.236

Rembrandt, Musical Allegory, 1626, oil on panel, Amsterdam,
8. Rembrandt, Musical Allegory, 1626, oil on panel, 63.5 x 48 cm, Amsterdam, Rijksmuseum, inv. SK-A-4674 (photo: Rijksmuseum).

Many authors have sought to explain why Rembrandt’s parents chose Jacob van Swanenburgh as his first teacher. There is little obvious connection between the two artists‘ approaches to subject matter or style. Yet, this disparity is less concerning than it seems: from his initial instructor, Rembrandt would be expected to learn fundamental skills rather than a specific style, and many painters developed independently as they matured.237 Constantijn Huygens, not realizing that Rembrandt’s parents were prosperous, supposed they sought a local artist ‚whose fees were modest‘, but this dismissive statement seems disingenuous when we realize that Jacob received court patronage and that Huygens‘ own son, Constantijn the Younger, was tutored by Jacob’s cousin Johan and married into the family.238 The simplest explanation is lack of choice: in Leiden in the 1620s, only Jacob van Swanenburgh and Joris van Schooten (1587-1651) were painting historical subjects. Van Schooten, teacher of Rembrandt’s friend and rival Jan Lievens (1607-1674), was better known for portraiture.239 That said, the assumption that Rembrandt set out to be a history painter is challenged by the large number of genre scenes and tronies (figure studies) he created in his early years, together with Lievens and their associates. The iconographic fluidity of Rembrandt’s early work suggests that he aspired to an even higher goal: to be a ‚universal artist‘, adept at all aspects of his craft.240 A case in point is the cryptic Musical Allegory (fig. 8), in which we recognize Rembrandt’s mother in the richly dressed old woman, while Lievens plays the harpist whose rude gesture signals a moralizing connotation for the scene.241 The inventiveness of Van Swanenburgh’s dramatic imagery must have caught Rembrandt’s interest, while techniques and anecdotes collected abroad would have dazzled an ambitious young artist who had never left his native city.

All this may explain why Rembrandt was content to stay in Van Swanenburgh’s workshop for three years, but, as Orlers stated, the choice to send him there was made by his parents. As far as we know, they were not scholars or art collectors. One of their older sons took over the family business; another became a baker and grain dealer. Baking and milling were respectable professions that could lead to prosperity, but they were also practical trades, pursued by a network of families whose interests and connections were more local than global. Perhaps for Rembrandt’s parents, international cachet was all very well, but faith and family ties would have resonated more directly.242 Although Catholicism after 1618 became a political liability, Rembrandt’s mother, who came from a Catholic family, might have appreciated the fact that Jacob van Swanenburgh and his Italian wife were Catholic.243 We can now add the reassuring factor of a family relationship, through the Vincks, with the distinguished Van Swanenburgh clan. Rembrandt’s choice of profession seems less surprising when we realize there were already artists in the family.


Family Network and Art Patronage in Leiden

While our research sheds light on Rembrandt’s choice of teacher, it does not yet add evidence of Leiden patronage for him.244 In fact, several people in his network seem to have preferred the work of Lievens. Arnold Houbraken transcribed a poem published in 1662 by the Leiden author Dirk Traudenius, Op de gedootverfde beeldenis van de Heer Secretaris Silvester van Swanenburg door Johan Lievens (‚On the painted likeness of Mr. Secretary Silvester van Swanenburgh by Jan Lievens‘). The text adopts a conventional trope praising the portrait as almost lifelike enough to speak.245 Lievens left Leiden in 1632, but he returned in 1639 for a commission to paint The Magnanimity of Scipio for the Leiden Town Hall. Completed in 1641, the painting was praised by Orlers, and the Leiden city fathers awarded Lievens the impressive sum of 1500 guilders and a gold medal.246 Perhaps it was in this context that Lievens painted Silvester to celebrate his role as Heer Secretaris.

Jan Lievens, Allegory of the Five Senses, c.
9. Jan Lievens, Allegory of the Five Senses, c. 1622, oil on panel, 78.2 x 124.4 cm, private collection (photo: Arthive).

Since Rembrandt and Lievens continued to share interests and patrons as they matured, Silvester’s portrait belongs by extension to Rembrandt’s milieu.247  Thus, it remains intriguing that Silvester chose Lievens and not Rembrandt. The same can be said for the Van Leeuwens, a prominent Leiden family with which the Van Swanenburghs and two of Rembrandt’s brothers were connected by marriage.248 In his recent study of the Leiden art market, Piet Bakker found 43 mentions of Lievens in 22 Leiden inventories, including a painting of ‚The Five Senses‘ in the estate of the wealthy brewer Adriaen van Leeuwen (1641), husband of Jacob van Swanenburgh’s niece Maria (fig. 9). He found only 16 paintings by Rembrandt in 10 estates.249 Orlers stated that Jan van der Graft — father-in-law of ‚our‘ Cornelis van Swanenburgh — owned so many paintings by Lievens that he could not list them all, yet he did not mention one painting by Rembrandt in a Leiden collection.250 It begins to seem that Rembrandt’s family contacts were not so useful after all. Perhaps even at this early stage, his work appealed more to elite connoisseurs such as Petrus Scriverius (1576-1680), the scholar who owned two of his early history paintings. Further research is warranted.251

 

By 1632, Rembrandt and Lievens had joined an exodus of youthful talent from Leiden that also included Jan van Goyen and Jan Davidsz de Heem (1606-1683/4).252 Lievens sought court patronage in London, while Amsterdam offered Rembrandt a more liberal religious climate and a richer art market. In Nicolaes Vinck, Rembrandt would have found a cousin already established in the city. The fact that Vinck took note of the artist’s death more than thirty years later hints at the possibility of continued contact. That he squeezed in the two Van Swanenburgh entries just below suggests connection as well as chronology. The previous generation of this family network included Jacob van Swanenburgh, first cousin of Vinck’s mother, cousin-in-law of Rembrandt’s mother, father of Silvester, and teacher of Rembrandt.

 

Stephanie Dickey is Professor of Art History and Bader Chair in Northern Baroque Art at Queen’s University, Kingston, Canada. She recently co-curated the exhibition Rembrandt in Amsterdam: Creativity and Competition (Städel Museum, Frankfurt, and Ottawa, National Gallery of Canada, 2021-22) and is the author of numerous publications on Rembrandt and artists in his circle.

 

Angela Jager is Curator of Dutch and Flemish Old Master Painting at the RKD – Netherlands Institute for Art History. She has published on the mass market for seventeenth-century paintings and the international trade in Dutch art. In her research, she draws on a variety of archival sources on early modern artists, art dealers and their clients.

 

  1. Werner Sumowski, Paul Huys Janssen, The Hoogsteder Exhibition of Rembrandt’s Academy, exh. cat. The Hague: Hoogsteder & Hoogsteder, 1992, cat. no. 28.
  2. Exhibition catalogues: Albert Blanckert, Jezus in de Gouden Eeuw, exh. cat. Rotterdam: Kunsthal, 2000–2001; Akira Kofuku, Rembrandt and the Rembrandt School. The Bible, mythology and ancient history, exh. cat. Tokyo: Museum of Western Art, 2003; Arthur K. Wheelock et al., Jan Lievens. A Dutch Master Rediscovered, exh. cat. Washington: National Gallery of Art; Milwaukee: Milwaukee Art Museum; Amsterdam: Rembrandt House Museum, 2008-2009, cat.no. 52; Louis van Tilborgh, Constantijn Huygens. Kunstkenner en verzamelaar, exh. cat. The Hague: Museum Bredius, 2013, cat. no. 14. Other literature: Werner Sumowski, Gemälde der Rembrandtschüler, vol. 4, Landau, 1983, p. 3726, no. 2356, fig. 3964; Helga Gutbrod, Lievens und Rembrandt : Studien zum Verhältnis ihrer Kunst, Frankfurt am Main, 1996, p. 299; Edwin Buijssen (ed.), Haagse schilders in de Gouden Eeuw, Het Hoogsteder lexicon van alle schilders werkzaam in Den Haag 1600-1700, The Hague, 1998, p. 191; Lloyd DeWitt, Evolution and Ambition in the career of Jan Lievens, 1607-1674, Phd. Diss. University of Maryland, College Park, 2006, p. 228.
  3. DeWitt, Evolution (see note 2), p. 228.
  4. For example those mentioned in the Montias Database of 17th Century Dutch Art Inventories and the Getty Provenance Research Index.
  5. Sumowski, Huys Janssen, Academy (see note 1), p. 220.
  6. Dr Gaston Gaudinot sale, Paris (Drouot), 13-14 February 1869.
  7. Sumowski, Huys Janssen, Academy (see note 1), p. 220.
  8. Ibid.
  9. Sumowski, Huys Janssen, Academy (see note 1), p. 226. Huys Janssen explains that the miracle as described in Luke and John differs from the version told by Matthew.
  10. After listening to the centurion, and before addressing him directly, Jesus speaks to his followers: “I tell you, many will come from east and west and sit at table with Abraham, Isaac, and Jacob in the kingdom of heaven.” (Matthew 8:11) Perhaps Lievens incorporated this part of the text and explicitly included people coming from the east (from the standpoint of his Dutch audience). A second possibility is that they are Pharisees. This group plays the role elsewhere in Matthew of disbelieving critics, and here they may serve to accentuate the belief of the centurion in the Christian faith. In early prints (Sebald Beham, Israhel van Meckenem, Hans Schaüfelein and Cornelis Massijs) and several Italian prints from Lievens’s time (seventeenth century prints after Paolo Veronese), Pharisees wear such headdresses. A parallel between blacks and overseas regions, such as in Lievens’s Brinio, is convincingly outlined by Elmer Kolfin (in: Elmer Kolfin, De kunst van de macht, Jordaens, Lievens en Rembrandt in het Paleis op de Dam, Zwolle, 2023, p. 67), does not seem to apply here.
  11. Sumowski, Huys Janssen, Academy (see note 1), p. 223.
  12. Sumowski, Huys Janssen, Academy (see note 1), pp. 223, 226.
  13. The right eye from the perspective of the viewer. There, a pupil was painted in, in a later restoration. Because of the sketchy manner it is difficult to ascertain whether or not both eyes are present, but in the left the lower eyelid is visible, while it is undefined in the right eye.
  14. For example: Jacobus Neeffs (after Jacob Jordaens), Judgement of Christ, etching, c. 1630-1645; Marinus van der Goes (after Jacques Jordaens), Judgement of Christ, engraving, c. 1614-1639; Willem Panneels (after Peter Paul Rubens), Adoration of the kings, etching, 1630; Nicolaes Lauwers (after Peter Paul Rubens), Ecce Homo, engraving, c. 1619-1652; and many more. Generally, for examples of inspiration drawn from prints by Lievens, see De
    Witt, Evolution (see note 2).
  15. Sumowski, Huys Janssen, Academy (see note 1), p. 226. Huys Janssen refers to examples by Nicolaes Moeyaert (Herentals, St. Waltrudis church) and Adam Camerarius (Amsterdam, Rijksmuseum, inv. no. SK-A-733). DeWitt refers to a painting by Bartholomeus Breenbergh (Karlsruhe, Staatliche Kunsthalle Karlsruhe, inv. no. 228) and the Moeyaert in Herentals (DeWitt, Evolution (see note 2), p. 227). But also see a woodcut with this subject by Cornelis van Sichem II in Der zielen lusthof (1629). Also of interest: Claes Moeyeart, Christ and the Centurion, 1632 (Minneapolis, Minneapolis Institute of Art, inv. no. 2012.84.5). Although the painting is known under this subject, it may in fact depict Cornelius kneeling before Peter, since more than one figure is shown kneeling and the composition closely resembles prints of this subject.
  16. Henri van de Waal, “’s Lands oudste verleden in de voorstelling van Vondel en zijn tijdgenooten”, Elsevier’s Maandschrift 47 (1937); Henri van de Waal, “Tempesta en de historieschilderingen op het Amsterdamse stadhuis”, Oud Holland 56 (1939); Henri van de Waal, Drie eeuwen vaderlandsche geschied-uitbeelding 1500-1800, een iconologische studie, The Hague, 1952; Kolfin, Kunst (see note 10).
  17. Antonio Tempesta (after Otto van Veen), Print 8 in (…)De Batavische oft oude Hollandtsche oorloghe teghen de Romeynen, 1612. Etching, 167 x 210 mm. Rijksmuseum, Amsterdam, inv. no. RP-P-OB-37.614. Jürgen Ovens based his drawing for the Batavian Series depicting Claudius Civilis leaving the Women and Children to fight at Xanten (Hamburg, Hamburger Kunsthalle, inv. no. 22342) on this print.
  18. On the period in The Hague: Buijssen Haagse (see note 2), pp.191-193.
  19. Haarlem, Teylers Museum, inv. no. P 006. For the identification and context, see: Gregor Weber, “Dus leeft de dappre Graaf: Zu einem Bildnis Andries de Graeffs von Jan Lievens (1607-1674)”, Oud Holland 99 (1985), pp. 44-56.
  20. Van de Waal, Eeuwen (see note 16), p. 230; Kolfin, De kunst van de macht (see note 10), pp. 19-20.
  21. Van de Waal, “’s Lands” (see note 16), p. 301-302.
  22.  Kolfin, Kunst (see note 10), p. 41. Four Batavian scenes were never completed. For two the themes are known, for the other two are not known.
  23. Munich, Staatliche Graphische Sammlung München, inv. no. 1451; Hamburg, Hamburger Kunsthalle, Kupferstichkabinett, inv. no. 22342. A lesser-known drawing of Rembrandt’s Conspiracy of Claudius Civilis (Edinburgh, National Galleries of Scotland, inv. no. D 23862) shows – when compared to the drawing in Munich – that the lower section of the painting is covered by a frieze and that portions of the left and right sides are obscured. This may indicate that an alternative conception of the framing of the lunettes was considered before the one ultimately implemented. It is possible that this earlier framing was already envisioned when Lievens produced his oil sketch Christ and the Centurion.
  24. Van de Waal, Eeuwen (see note 16), p. 225, referring to SAA, 5039, 2 resolutieboek, f. 66r.
  25. Ibid., referring to SAA, 5039, 153 rapiamus 1661, f.195v.
  26. Van de Waal, Eeuwen (see note 16), p. 225.
  27. Gregor Weber, “Jan Lievens’s ‘The Shield-raising of Brinio’ a Second Oil Sketch”, Hoogsteder-Naumann Mercury 12/13 (1992), nt. 8.
  28. Dewitt, Evolution (see note 2), p. 221.
  29. Kolfin, Kunst (see note 10), p.67.
  30. Kolfin, Kunst (see note 10), p. 44.
  31. For, among other things, contemporary poetry in which Civilis and others are compared to the members of the House of Orange: Van de Waal, Eeuwen (see note 16), pp. 220-221, 223.
  32. Kolfin, Kunst (see note 10), p. 47.
  33. Margriet van Eikema Hommes, Elmer Kolfin, De Oranjezaal in Huis ten Bosch, Een zaal uit loutere liefde, Zwolle, 2013, p. 77.
  34. Kolfin, Kunst (see note 10), pp. 41-47, 77.
  35. One may ask, in light of points discussed in this article, whether the “Christ” figure in the first version was in fact Christ at all. If so, the oil sketch would initially have represented solely a Christian scene without any reference to the Batavian Revolt, thereby less relatable to the (eventual) decoration program of the Town Hall’s gallery. Given that in the initial design the groups left and right with Biblical and/or eastern figures do not seem to have been included (aside from a bearded man on the right, judging from the x-ray), the large central figure may originally have been Julius Civilis. In compositional terms, this would align the painting more closely with the print by Tempesta after Van Veen. The apparent similarity in hairstyle between the final Christ figure and the initial figure, together with the possible initial presence of a (holy) beam of light directed toward the figure, may argue against this hypothesis; nevertheless, Brinno in Lievens’s Brinio Raised on the Shield likewise features long hair and even incorporates a diagonal compositional line through the clouds, comparable to the line through the foliage in the initial version of the present subject. The later insertion of Christ could then be understood as a deliberate twist, imparting a more prominent Christian meaning to the historical scene. These suggestions and observations were kindly shared by Jochem van Eijsden.
  36. Samuel van Hoogstraten, Inleyding tot de hooge schoole der schilderkonst: anders de zichtbaere werelt, Rotterdam 1678, p. 18. Van Hoogstraten here refers to the period when he was “still a disciple”, during which, as part of a “we”, he and others discussed a particular question, to which a certain “Fabritius” responded with an answer. It is generally assumed that this refers to Carel Fabritius, who is assumed to have studied with Rembrandt between approximately 1641 and 1643.
  37. Werner Sumowski described Van Hoogstraten as “pädagogisch begabt, Assistent Rembrandts gewesen” (Werner Sumowski, Gemälde der Rembrandt-Schüler II, Landau/Pfalz 1984, p. 1286). As supporting evidence, Sumowski argued that Van Hoogstraten corrected drawings by Constantijn Daniël van Renesse (; p. 1290, nt. 2). When discussing one of these drawings (Moses and Reuel’s Daughters at the Well, Amsterdam, Rijksmuseum, inv. no. RP-T-1893-A-2782) Sumowski suggested the possibility that “Samuel van Hoogstraten acted as assistant to the master on occasional trips even at a later date”. (Werner Sumowski, Drawings of the Rembrandt School IX, New York 1985, no. 2159x). Building on this, Jonathan Bikker suggested in his monograph on Willem Drost that Van Hoogstraten “might have supervised Drost during his early days in Rembrandt’s studio” (Jonathan Bikker, Willem Drost, A Rembrandt Pupil in Amsterdam and Venice, New Haven/London 2005, p. 11). David de Witt later observed, in his Abraham van Dijck monograph, concerning Van Hoogstraten: “by 1646 his training would have been complete, but he appears to have stayed on as a tutor or head pupil for several years” (David De Witt, Life and Work of Late Rembrandt Pupil Abraham van Dijck, c. 1635-1680, Amsterdam 2020, p. 11).
  38. Sabine Pénot, Rembrandt – Hoogstraten. Colour and Illusion, exh. cat. Vienna: Kunsthistorisches Museum Wien, 2024; Nathalie Maciesza, Epco Runia, Samuel van Hoogstraten. De Illusionist, exh. cat. Amsterdam: Rembrandt House Museum, 2025; Sabine van Beek, Leonore van Sloten, David de Witt et al., Samuel van Hoogstraten: Catalogue Raisonné, The Hague 2025.
  39. The catalogue of the Vienna exhibition assumes a position for Van Hoogstraten as an assistant for approximately three to four years (Angelina Illes, in: exh. cat. Vienna 2024 (see note 3), p. 29; Jonathan Bikker, in: exh. cat. Vienna 2024 (see note 3), p. 93), though it makes no mention of any teaching responsibilities. These are, however, included in the publication accompanying the exhibition at the Rembrandt House Museum (Michiel Roscam Abbing, in: exh. cat. Amsterdam 2025 (see note 3), p. 19; David De Witt, in: exh. cat. Amsterdam 2025 (see note 3), p. 131), and in the online Van Hoogstraten catalogue raisonné by the RKD (Michiel Roscam Abbing, in: The Hague 2025 (see note 3), “With Rembrandt in Amsterdam”. https://vanhoogstraten.rkdstudies.nl/samuel-van-hoogstraten-the-ingenious-and-poetic-painter/with-rembrandt-inamsterdam/, 26 May 2025).
  40. The term “assistent” was used in Holland in the 17th century, albeit in other contexts, see: Woordenboek Nederlandse taal, s.v. assistent, https://gtb.ivdnt.org/iWDB/search?actie=article&wdb=WNT&id=M004535&lemma=assistent&domein=0&conc=true, 11
    July 2025.
  41. “Een min of meer ondergeschikte helper”, a more or less subordinate helper (see note 5); “A person who helps or supports somebody, usually in their job”: Oxford English Dictionary, s.v. assistant, https://www.oed.com/view/Entry/12041, 11 July 2025.
  42. The guild archive has been lost. For a comprehensive account of the Amsterdam Guild of Saint Luke and its ordinances, see: Isabella H. van Eeghen, “Schilders of Sint Lucasgilde”, in: Isabella H. van Eeghen (ed.), Inventarissen der archieven van de gilden en van het brouwerscollege, Amsterdam 1951, passim.; Isabella H. van Eeghen (Jasper Hillegers, translator), “The Amsterdam Guild of Saint Luke in the 17th Century”, Journal of Historians for Netherlandish Art 4.2 (2012), passim., DOI:10.5092/jhna.2012.4.2.4, 11 July 2025. The current article relies exclusively on the guild regulations of the Amsterdam De Kroniek 2024/25 – Museum Rembrandthuis 10 painters’ guild. It is often assumed that the regulations of painters’ guilds in different Dutch towns did not differ substantially in content. On that assumption, gaps in the regulations of one town might be filled by those of another. However, the discussion later in this article regarding whether apprentices were permitted to produce their own work shows that crucial differences did in fact exist. For that reason, guild regulations from other cities are not used here to fill the gaps in the surviving Amsterdam regulations.
  43. Extract van de willekeuren en ordonnantien den gilde van St. Lucas verleent, Amsterdam 1720, p. 11.
  44. Extract (see note 8), p. 11; This is also the case in the chapter title and margin of the 1766 publication of all known guild charters: Ordonnantien en willekeuren van het Lucas-gilde binnen Amsterdam, Amsterdam 1766, p. 64, 68. It is noteworthy that the dean and headmen of the guild employed a gilde kneght (Extract (see note 8), pp. 26-27. This was not a pupilship, and the tasks meet the definition of an assistant in the Oxford English Dictionary and the Woordenboek Nederlandse Taal (see note 6)
  45. Extract (see note 8), pp. 12-13
  46. Extract (see note 8), pp. 11-12.
  47. Extract (see note 8), p. 12.
  48. Cornelis Kiliaen (ed. Frans Claes), Etymologicum teutonicae linguae, Antwerp 1599 (The Hague 1972), p. 278, s.v. leerionghe; leer-kind; leer-knecht; leerlinck; p. 703, s.v. discipel. In the regulations of the Haarlem Guild of St. Luke from 1634 (NHA, 1105, Ambachtsgilden te Haarlem (Gilden Haarlem), no. 219), the terms “leerling”, “leerjongen”, and “discipel” are
    used. This might suggest that a distinction existed between them, but they are actually used interchangeably. The same applies to the terms “(werk)gezel”, “knecht”, and – a new term – “gast”. The latter is synonymous with journeyman or servant: “Knecht van een ambachtsman of fabrikant; gezel, werkknecht”, servant of a tradesman or manufacturer; journeyman, workshop hand: Woordenboek Nederlandse taal, s.v. gast, https://gtb.ivdnt.org/iWDB/searchactie=article&wdb=WNT&id=M017355.re.35&lemma=werkgast&domein=0&conc=true,
    16 oktober 2025.
  49. Kiliaen, Etymologicum (see note 13), p. 139, s.v. ghe-selle van een ampt. The Latin word “collega” is likewise a translation for “ambtgenoot”, “maet”, and “vennoot” (Kiliaen, Etymologicum (see note 13), p. 18, s.v. ampt-ghenoot; p. 302, s.v. maet, med-maet, maetken; p. 579, s.v. veyn-out, veyn-noot, ven-noot, vennoot, veyn-gnoot).
  50. Kiliaen, Etymologicum (see note 13), p. 244, s.v. knecht, dienaer.
  51. Nicolaas de Roever, “Drie Amsterdamsche Schilders (Pieter Isaaksz, Abraham Vinck, Cornelis van der Voort)”, Oud Holland 3 (1885), p. 198.
  52. In 1619, he was asked together with several artists who had traveled to Italy, including Pieter Lastman, Adriaen van Nieulandt, and Barent van Someren, to assess the authenticity of a Caravaggio painting from the collection of the late Louis Finson. Abraham Bredius, Nicolaas de Roever, “Pieter Lastman en François Venant”, Oud Holland 4 (1886), pp. 7-8.
  53. Ronald de Jager “Meester, leerjongen, leertijd. Een analyse van Zeventiende-eeuwse Noord-Nederlandse leerlingcontracten van kunstschilders, goud- en zilversmeden”, Oud Holland 104 (1990), p. 96, nt. 107. The title of “gezel” is, in fact, never mentioned in the known Amsterdam contracts.
  54. De Jager, “Meester” (see note 18), pp. 73-75.
  55. De Jager, “Meester” (see note 18), p. 71.
  56. Stadsarchief Amsterdam (hereafter SAA), 5075, 393A, nots. Jacob Jacobs and Nicolaes Jacobs, ff. 59r-59v, 20-07-1626; Abraham Bredius, “Gerrit Willemsz. Horst”, Oud Holland 50 (1933), pp. 5-6; De Jager, “Meester” (see note 18), p. 98, no. 7.
  57. This underscores a clear distinction: as was also evidenced by the entries in Kiliaen, Etymologicum (see note 13), dienaer was a synonym for knecht, not for leerknecht (see note 15).
  58. Abraham Bredius, Künstlerinventare. Urkunden zur Geschichte der holländischen Kunst des XVIten, XVIIten und XVIIIten Jahrhunderts V, The Hague 191, pp. 1482-1483; De Jager, “Meester” (see note 18), p. 98, no. 10.
  59. The value of a barrel of herring in Amsterdam in 1635 was approximately 120 grams of silver (Bo Poulsen, Dutch Herring. An Environmental History, c. 1600–1860, Amsterdam 2008, p. 93, table 6.9); in the seventeenth century, ten grams of silver corresponded to the value of roughly one guilder.
  60. The tuition fees in Holland for a two-year contract averaged 61.5 guilders per year (De Jager, “Meester” (see note 18), p. 75).
  61. Josua Bruyn, “Een onderzoek naar 17de -eeuwse schilderijformaten, voornamelijk in Noord-Nederland”, Oud Holland 93 (1979), p. 113.
  62. Abraham Bredius, Künstlerinventare. Urkunden zur Geschichte der holländischen Kunst des XVIten, XVIIten und XVIIIten Jahrhunderts II, The Hague 1916, pp. 400-401; De Jager, “Meester” (see note 18), p. 98
  63. As a journeyman painter Waltusz earned less than half the daily wage of peers in other trades. In 1652, journeymen carpenters and bricklayers in Amsterdam earned approximately 26 to 27 stivers per summer day (although there are no exact figures for 1651, data is available for 1633, 27 and 25 stivers respectively, and for 1667, 28 and 27 stivers respectively).
    This disparity between painter’s journeymen and their peers in other trades mirrors the situation in 1579. The guild
    regulations (gildebrief) of the St. Luke’s Guild from that year mention journeymen earning 4 stivers and others earning 10
    stivers per day (Ordonnantien (see note 9), p. 17, art. 11). Taking the average of 7 stivers, these were notably low wages –
    practically half – when compared to the 14 and 12 stivers earned by carpenters and bricklayers, respectively, in that same
    year. For the wages of the workers mentioned here, see: Hubert Nutseling, Welvaart en werkgelegenheid in Amsterdam
    1540–1860, Amsterdam/Dieren 1985, p. 252, appendix 5.1, table A.
  64. SAA, DTB 5001, 469, p. 241, 30-09-1651; Judith van Gent, Bartholomeus van der Helst (circa 1613-1670): een studie naar zijn leven en zijn werk, Utrecht (Utrecht University), p. 41.
  65. Virtually nothing is known about Gerardus van Berleborch (Bernard Renckens, “G. van Berkborch”, Oud Holland 84 (1967), no. 4, passim). He or his father was likely from the region around Bad Berleburg in Germany. He appears to have been present in Leiden in 1665, when he is recorded as a witness (“Gerrit van Berleberg”) at the baptism of a child of the painter Jacobus Geutkien (Erfgoed Leiden en Omstreken (hereafter ELO), DTB 1004, 237, fol. 236v, 3-12-1665).
  66. SAA, 5075, 875, not. Jacob van Zwieten, pp. 638-640, 16-10-1649; Johannes G. van Dillen, Bronnen tot de geschiedenis van het bedrijfsleven en het gildewezen van Amsterdam 1510-1672 III, p. 540, no. 1057.
  67. A possible reason for this may be that young painters attained the status of master more quickly. This benefited the guild financially, as it earned income only from masters and pupils, not from journeymen.
  68. Ordonnantien (see note 9), p. 10, art. 3.
  69. Ordonnantien (see note 9), p. 17, art. 11.
  70. Joachim von Sandrart’s famous anecdote about Rembrandt’s studio being filled with “countless elite children”, pupils who each paid an annual tuition fee of 100 guilders suggests that the legal limit on the number of pupils was, in practice, a dead letter (Joachim von Sandrardt, Teutsche Academie, Nuremberg 1675, p. 326; Van Eeghen, “Guild” (see note 7), p. 6).
  71. Young Man Reading with a Vanitas Still Life, 1644, oil on panel, 58 x 74 cm, Rotterdam, Museum Boijmans Van Beuningen, inv. no. 1386; Self-portrait, 1644, oil on panel, 63 x 48 cm, The Hague, Museum Bredius, inv. no. 056-1946; Self-portrait, 1645, oil on panel, 54.1 x 44.8 cm, Liechtenstein, The Princely Collections, Vaduz-Vienna, inv. no. GE 107; Portrait of a Child, 1645, oil on panel, 68.6 x 57.8 cm, private collection; The Adoration of the Shepherds, 1647, oil on canvas, 58.2 x 70.8 cm, Dordrecht, Dordrechts Museum, inv. no. DM/980/567.
  72. Godefridus J. Hoogewerff, De geschiedenis van de St. Lucasgilden in Nederland, Amsterdam 1947, p. 24; Ernst van de Wetering “Problems of Pupilship and Studio Practice” in: Josua Bruyn et al., A Corpus of Rembrandt Paintings II: 1631-1634, Amsterdam 1986, p. 57; Bikker, Drost (see note 2), p. 11; Angelina Illes, in: exh. cat. Vienna 2024 (see note 3), p. 29.
  73. Samuel Muller Fz., Schilders-vereenigingen te Utrecht. Bescheiden uit het Gemeentearchief, Utrecht 1880, p. 76; Frederik D.O. Obreen, Archief voor Nederlandsche Kunstgeschiedenis IV, Rotterdam 1881/1882, p. 51. The very fact that such a regulation had to be instituted in these cities already indicates that works were being signed by non-masters.
  74. De Jager, “Meester” (see note 18), pp. 77-79.
  75. Bruyn, “Onderzoek”, (see note 26), p. 113.
  76. David de Witt, Leonore van Sloten, in: The Hague 2025 (see note 3), “Rembrandt’s Impact”, https://vanhoogstraten.rkdstudies.nl/catalogus-schilderijen/rembrandts-impact/, 3 June 2025.
  77. Almost exclusively, reference is made to Bikker, Drost (see note 2), p. 11. Also in the exhibition catalogue of the Van Hoogstraten exhibition in Amsterdam, Drost is cited as an example of an early student of Van Hoogstraten (David de Witt, in: exh. cat. Amsterdam 2025 (see note 3), p. 131.
  78. Since Daniël Pont’s monograph on Barent Fabritius, (Daniël Pont, Barent Fabritius 1624–1673, The Hague, 1958) and Sumowski’s Drawings of the Rembrandt School (see note 2), no subsequent scholarly efforts have systematically De Kroniek 2024/25 – Museum Rembrandthuis 12 reconstructed his drawn oeuvre or analyzed the development of his distinctive style. The author’s forthcoming dissertation addresses this lacuna, and catalogues drawings by Barent Fabritius.
  79. Pont was among the first to suggest he may not have been a direct pupil of Rembrandt, but instead only came into contact with Rembrandt’s work indirectly, through his brother Carel (Pont, Barent (see note 43), p. 96). In the literature, uncertainty on this matter appears to have become the norm, with scholars consistently noting – or implicitly dealing with – the lack of evidence for a formal pupilship with Rembrandt (see: Paul Huys Jansen, Werner Sumowski, The Hoogsteder Exhibition of Rembrandt’s Academy, exh. cat. The Hague: Hoogsteder & Hoogsteder, 1992, p. 139; Walter A. Liedkte in: Hubert von Sonneburg, Rembrandt/Not Rembrandt in the Metropolitan Museum of Art I, exh. cat. New York City: The Metropolitan Museum of Art, 1995, cat. 48, pp. 145-146; Peter C. Sutton in: Albert Blankert, Rembrandt. A Genius and his impact, exh. cat. Melbourne: National Gallery of Victoria; Canberra: National Gallery of Australia, 1997, p. 283; Jan Blanc, Dans l’atelier de Rembrandt. Le maître et ses élèves, Paris 2006, p. 140.
  80. Holm Bevers, “Das Susanna-Thema im Werkstattzusammenhang: Zeichnungen”, in: Holm Bevers, Katja Kleinert, Claudia Laurenze-Landsberg, Rembrandts Berliner Susanna und die beiden Alten. Die Schaffung eins meisterwerks, exh. cat. Berlin: Staatliche Museen zu Berlin, Kupferstichkabinett; Gemäldegalerie, 2015, pp. 49-50.
  81. Katja Kleinert, Claudia Laurenze-Landsberg, “Wandlungen eines Gemäldes. Rembrandts Berliner Susanna und die beiden Alten”, in: exh. cat. Berlin 2015 (see note 45), p. 19, 32.
  82. See for instance Rembrandt’s Holy Family in the Carpenter’s workshop or his Star of the Kings (London, The British Museum, inv. nos. 1900,0824.144, 1910,0212.189).
  83. The drawing of a male model (here attributed to Barent Fabritius) has been described as stylistically very close to Van Hoogstraten (Martin Royalton-Kisch in: Catalogue of Drawings by Rembrandt and his School, London: The British Museum, 2010, cat. 71). The Departure of the Prodigal Son, a drawing already earlier attributed to Fabritius, is still considered a work by Van Hoogstraten (Frankfurt am Main, Städel Museum, inv. no. 817).
  84. A convincing spatial representation of the scene, achieved through a successful use of proportion, perspective, light, and color. For a elaboration on this definition, including references, see: Leonore van Sloten, “Regels voor de kunst”, in: David de Witt, Leonore van Sloten, Jaap van der Veen, Rembrandts late leerlingen. In de leer bij een genie, exh. cat. Amsterdam: Rembrandt House Museum, 2015, p. 73, note 31.
  85. In drawings by Barent Fabritius from the second half of the 1640s, his preparatory chalk underdrawing is generally careful and precise but not detailed, with clear, exact contours rendered in continuous, rounded lines. The somewhat squat figures possess a doll-like, slightly caricatural character. When using pen to trace or fill in the figures, particularly those in the foreground, the style becomes sketchier and more angular. Fabritius’s hatching lines become more carefully placed as they  grow finer, laid loosely side by side with only occasional thin-pen scratching, while thicker lines, including contours, are rendered in a zigzag, looser manner, often applied to foreground elements such as a repoussoir. Groups of hatching in shadowed, complex motifs (e.g., figures or foreground foliage) are neither intertwined nor uniformly oriented, and though the balance of light and shadow varies between drawings, it remains consistent within each composition; early mastery is evident in his wash applications, where loosely brushed transitions in shadows lend a painterly quality, enhancing figural plasticity and atmospheric depth, as seen in drawings with dramatic chiaroscuro effects.
  86. Although it has been argued by Holm Bevers that this drawing is by Constantijn Daniël van Renesse and dates from between 1650 and 1652 (Holm Bevers, “Ausstellungen zu Rembrandt in Rückblick”, Kunstchronik, 58 (2005), p. 480; Holm Bevers, in: Rembrandt. Die Zeichnungen im Berliner Kupferstichkabinett, exh. cat. Berlin: Staatliche Museen zu Berlin, Kupferstichkabinett, 2006, cat. no. 45, p. 158, nt. 12; Holm Bevers in: Holm Bevers et al., Drawings by Rembrandt and his Pupils. Telling the Difference, exh. cat. Los Angeles: The J. Paul Getty Museum, 2009, cat. no. 31.2, pp. 190-191), a number of features are so uncharacteristic of Van Renesse that the attribution cannot be sustained. This applies in particular to elements such as the heavy, coarse scratches in the shadow areas and the sketch-like rendering of the faces of Joseph and Mary. Van Renesse typically keeps shadow areas and light transitions in brush clear and even. Also characteristic is his meticulous penwork, marked by fine, short strokes in the contours and hatching lines (see for instance: The Judgment of Salomon, New York City (The Metropolitan Museum of Art, Robert Lehman Collection, inv. no. 1975.1.806; Daniel in the Lion’s Den, Rotterdam, Museum Boijmans Van Beuningen, inv. no. MB 200). Generally, it shows the boldness of Barent much more than the careful restraint of Renesse
  87. “Beeter waer ‚t dat [om de veranderin[g]] een eesel van achteren was, dan dat al de hoofden iuist wt het stuck sien. Dat oock omtrent de boom wat meerder groente was. | 1 losep heft af te swaer en te onbesuist | 2 Maria most het kindeken wat meerder vieren, want een teeder kint magh sulck duwen niet ver[dragen]. | losep al te kort en dick, sijn hooft wast hem wt de [borst?]. Sijn hebben alle beide al te groote koppen”. Transcript from: Leonore van Sloten, in: exh. cat. Amsterdam 2015 (see note 49), p. 73, nt. 27. “It would be better that [for the alteration] there were a donkey from the back, than that all the heads are looking straight out of the work. That there were also somewhat more greenery around the tree. | 1 Joseph lifts too heavily and too inconsiderately. | 2 Mary ought to ease the little child somewhat more, for a tender infant cannot [endure] such pushing. | Joseph is all too short and stout, his head grows out of the [chest?]. They both have all too large heads”. These instructions are also partly articulated within the drawing itself. Joseph is indeed shown tugging firmly at Mary’s arm, whereas in the more sketch-like version, he supports her more gently at the back. The small patch of greenery in the lower corner may also be a later addition, in correspondence with the suggestion.
  88. The face does not appear to be a correction in the technical sense, but rather an example of a foreshortened face viewed from below – a challenging principle of perspective.
  89. An attribution proposed Christian Dittrich (Christian Dittrich in: Christian Dittrich, Thomas Ketelsen, Rembrandt. Die Dresdener Zeichnungen 2004, exh. cat. Dresden: Staatliche Kunstsammlungen Dresden, Kupferstich-Kabinett, 2004, cat. no.14, pp. 80-81).
  90. Brusati implied the possibility that the text was written partly by Rembrandt and partly by Van Hoogstraten (Celeste Brusati, Artifice & Illusion. The Art and Writing of Samuel van Hoogstraten, Chicago/London 1995, pp. 31, 275, note 40). Rembrandt was excluded as the author of the instructions by Bevers, while Van Hoogstraten as author remained an option. Van Renesse was likewise ruled out by Bevers, based on a comparison with the handwriting on his Daniel in the Lions’ Den drawing and The Judgment of Solomon drawing (see note 51); Holm Bevers, in: exh. cat. Los Angeles 2009 (see note 51), cat. 31.1–31.2, p. 190; 191, note 3). To this may be added that the handwriting also closely resembles that of Barent Fabritius. Although little comparative material survives, the compact, small script of Fabritius’s name beneath the death inventory of his sister-in-law Aeltje, dated 24 April 1643 (SAA, 5075, 1628a, not. David de l’Hommel, p. 399), shows a strong resemblance to the instructions on the Dresden sheet.
  91. “Once you have mastered your handling and your eye is somewhat clarified, it will no longer trouble you to translate many naturalistic paintings into a naturalistic drawing”. “Wanneer gy uwe handeling nu machtich zijt, en uw oog wat verklaert is, zoo zal ‚t u ook niet verscheelen veel verwige Schilderyen in een verwige teykeningen na te klaren” (Van Hoogstraten, Inleyding (see note 1), p. 27)
  92. “I advise masters, when they review the drawings of their pupils, to improve them by making sketches of the same subject themselves. This is an excellent exercise and has greatly assisted many in the art of composition”. “De meesters raed ik, als ze de Teykeningen haerer discipelen overzien, datze de zelve, met schetssen op ‚t zelve voorwerp te maeken, verbeeteren. Dit oeffent ongemeen, en heeft veelen geweldich in de schikkunst geholpen” (Van Hoogstraten, Inleyding (see note 1), p. 192).
  93. “And certainly, this manner of drawing with pen and brush is likewise the most suitable for completing a masterly work in its full force. For one can also, whenever it proves convenient, work into it with red chalk and crayons, as though one were almost painting with colours”. “En zeker deeze wijze van met pen en pinseel te teykenen, is ook allerbequaemst om een meesterlijk werk in zijn volle kracht te voleinden. Dewijl men’er ook, als’t pas geeft, met rood krijt en kryons in kan speelen, als of men byna met verwen schilderde” (Van Hoogstraten, Inleyding (see note 1), p. 31.
  94. On stylistic grounds, this Rembrandt drawing has been placed among a group of history drawings dating to around 1650 (Otto Benesch, The Drawings of Rembrandt V, New York 1957, no. 902). Among other arguments, this dating led Bevers to attribute the Dresden drawing to Constantijn van Renesse, rather than Barent Fabritius (Holm Bevers, in: exh. cat. Berlin 2006 (see note 51), cat. no. 45, p. 157, 158, nt. 12) However, it remains questionable whether the Rembrandt drawing in Berlin should be understood within that context. Unlike the other history drawings, this work is not an autonomous composition but rather a sketched response to the Dresden sheet. It is plausible that the sketch was already made around 1647. In terms of linework, it is not far removed from the portrait sketch of Jan Six, dating from in or before 1647 (Amsterdam, Six Collection).
    It is drawn in a similarly free style, applied in a sketch, comparable to other drawings from the second half of the 1640’s (see
    note 47). Rembrandt’s Berlin drawing could thus have been made quite soon after Fabritius’s corrected drawing
  95. Josua Bruyn, “Gemälde der Rembrandt-Schüler II by Werner Sumowski Review”, Oud Holland 101 (1987) no. 3, p. 229.
  96. https://rkd.nl/images/313061, 17 July 2025. In terms of drawing style, this work is not far removed from Van Hoogstraten’s drawing The Sacrifice of Manoah of 1649 (Braunschweig, Herzog Anton Ulrich Museum, inv. no. Z 335; https://rkd.nl/images/71286, 17 July 2025). We may even assume that The Crucifixion predates it; the departing angel in the  Braunschweig drawing – also seen from the back – appears to be a more developed and refined treatment of the motif of a figure seen from behind.
  97. Samuel van Hoogstraten, The Adoration of the Shepherds. London, The British Museum, inv. no. 1895,0915.1203; https://rkd.nl/images/313552, 17 July 2025. A drawing of The Circumcision, likewise painted as a part of the Passion series in 1646, has been attributed to Gerbrand van den Eeckhout (Brussels, Koninklijke Musea voor Schone Kunsten België, inv. no. 4060/1212). There are also two copies after Rembrandt’s Holy Family with a Curtain from 1646 (London, The British Museum, inv. no. 1895,0915.1200; Oxford, Ashmolean Museum, inv. no. WA1986.56).
  98. Josua Bruyn in: Josua Bruyn et al., A Corpus of Rembrandt Paintings III: 1635-1642, Amsterdam 1989 pp. 13-16.
  99. Martin Royalton-Kisch, Drawings by Rembrandt and his Circle in the British Museum, London: The British Museum, 1992, cat. no. 87, pp. 180-182; Holm Bevers, “Drawings in Rembrandt’s Workshop”, in: exh. cat. Los Angeles 2009 (see note 51), pp. 13-17; David de Witt, “Leren van het leven: tekeningen van Rembrandts leerlingen” in: Judith Noorman, David de Witt, Rembrandts Naakte Waarheid. Tekenen naar naaktmodellen in de Gouden Eeuw, exh. cat. Amsterdam: Rembrandt House Museum, 2015, pp. 117-120.
  100. Initially, this drawing was attributed to Rembrandt, but as early as 1908, this attribution was already being questioned (Martin Conway, “Some Rembrandt Drawings”, Burlington Magazine 14 (1908/1909), p.37).
  101. This sheet has previously been judged the weakest of the three (David de Witt, in: exh. cat. Amsterdam 2015 (see note 64), p. 118), and it has even been suggested that Rembrandt may have corrected it. (Martin Royalton-Kisch, in: col. cat. London 2010 (see note 48), cat. 71). The fine parallel pen strokes in the boy’s torso are comparable to those in the body of Susanna in the Budapest drawing. The somewhat arbitrary use of red chalk (in the model’s right armpit area, on the reverse side of the cushion, and in the upper left corner) also stands out in both sheets. The type of loose, heavy pen lines used for the cushion corresponds to those found in the cloak of the old man in the Susanna drawing.
  102. For a first suggestion of Bol being the assistant of Rembrandt, see: Albert Blanckert, Ferdinand Bol (1616-1680). Rembrandt’s Pupil, Doornspijk 1982, pp. 17-18.
  103. Blanckert, Bol (see note 67), pp. 17-18; David de Witt, “Ferdinand Bol, discipel van Rembrandt”, in: Norbert Middelkoop, Ferdinand Bol en Govert Flinck. Rembrandts meesterleerlingen, Amsterdam (Rembrandt House Museum/Amsterdam Museum) 2017, pp. 44-45
  104. Portrait of a Lady, 1642. Berlin, Staatliche Museen zu Berlin, Gemäldegalerie, inv. no. 809. However, there are paintings by Bol, or attributed to him, of an earlier date or dating. The Liberation of St Peter (private collection), dated around 1636, may be, given its strong connection to the work of Benjamin Cuyp (David de Witt, in: exh. cat. Amsterdam 2017 (see note 68), pp. 42-43), made before Bol’s departure to Amsterdam. Gideon’s Sacrifice of 1640, signed by Bol (Utrecht, Museum Catharijneconvent, inv. no. RMCC s24), is typical in subject matter and composition of his later work from the 1640s, and may
    be made under conditions comparable to those proposed in this article for the paintings by Van Hoogstraten, dating from
    between 1644 and 1647. Other works attributed to Bol prior to 1642 are often copies or adaptations of compositions by
    Rembrandt.
  105. Christopher Brown, Carel Fabritius, Oxford 1981, p. 47; Gero Seelig in: Frederik J. Duparc, Carel Fabritius 1622-1654, exh. cat. The Hague: Mauritshuis; Schwerin: Staatliches Museum, 2004-2005, cat. no. 4, p. 97.
  106. Erna Kok erroneously states that Bol is mentioned as Rembrandt’s “werckgesel” in a document of 30 August 1640 (Erna Kok, “Govert Flinck en Ferdinand Bol en hun netwerken van opdrachtgevers,” in: exh. cat. Amsterdam 2017 (see note 68), p. 71, p. 244, n. 37). Bol’s exact role during his time in Rembrandt’s workshop is never documented. It is striking that the drawn copies after three of Rembrandt’s paintings from around 1636 are attributed to Ferdinand Bol (Peter Schatborn, “Tekeningen van Govert Flinck en Ferdinand Bol”, in: exh. cat. Amsterdam 2017 (see note 68), p.185). Apart from these sheets and those datable around 1646 by later pupils, there are few, if any, known drawings by Rembrandt’s pupils that are direct copies after his history or figure paintings. It is possible that Bol played an important role in introducing this method into the studio, and that it was later adopted by Van Hoogstraten. Van Hoogstraten is likely to have been in contact with Bol while in Amsterdam. After Bol established himself as an independent master, around 1642, he too began to draw in red chalk. He did so, however, almost exclusively in preparatory studies for (mainly) paintings – see, for instance, Joseph brings his Father before Pharaoh (Dresden, Gemäldegalerie, inv. no. 1605), and its preliminary drawing (Amsterdam, Rijksmuseum, inv. no. RP-T-1883-A-276). Van Hoogstraten may well have adopted this practice from him. This suggests that, even as an official pupil of Rembrandt, Van Hoogstraten felt the freedom to look to the work of other contemporaries as well. Van Sloten has argued that Bol continued to visit Rembrandt during the first half of the 1640s (Leonore van Sloten, “Ferdinand Bol, de etser”, in: exh. cat. Amsterdam 2017 (see note 68), pp. 218–221). Bol’s use of red chalk for preparatory studies may therefore have been the source of Van Hoogstraten’s conception that the use of red chalk contributes to the painterly quality of a drawing.
  107. Arnold Houbraken, De groote schouburgh der Nederlantsche konstschilders en schilderessen, Amsterdam, 1976, p. 165.
  108. Jan Jacobsz. Orlers, Beschrijvinge der Stadt Leyden, 2nd ed., Leiden, 1641, p. 376.
  109. See the translation from the original Latin: “Constantijn Huygens on Lievens and Rembrandt,” in: Arthur K. Wheelock et al., Jan Lievens. A Dutch Master Rediscovered, exh. cat. Washington: National Gallery of Art; Milwaukee: Milwaukee Art Museum; Amsterdam: Museum Het Rembrandthuis, 2008-2009, p. 287.
  110. See: Arthur K. Wheelock, “Jan Lievens: Bringing New Light to an Old Master,” in: Wheelock, Lievens (see note 2), pp. 13-23; and: Lloyd DeWitt, Evolution and Ambition in the Career of Jan Lievens (1607-1674), Ph.D. dissertation, University of Maryland, 2006: https://www.researchgate.net/publication/277127128_Evolution_and_Ambition_in_the_Career_of_Jan_Lievens_1607-1674
  111. Property from Aristocratic Estates and Important Provenance, Vienna (Dorotheum), 8 September 2020, lot 59 (as Circle of Bartholomeus van der Helst).
  112. Werner Sumowski, Gemälde der Rembrandt-Schüler, Landau, vol. 5, 1990, p. 3109, no. 2127, ill. p. 3279
  113. Ernst van de Wetering, Rembrandt: the Painter at Work, Amsterdam, 1997, pp. 182-185.
  114. Jan Lievens, Job in his Misery, monogrammed and dated 1631, canvas, 171.5 x 148.6 cm, Ottawa, National Gallery of Canada (4093). See Lloyd DeWitt in Wheelock, Lievens (see note 2), pp. 130-131, no. 25 (colour illus.).
  115. Jan Lievens, The Penitent Magdalene, c. 1631. Canvas, 63.5 x 49.5 cm. Kingston, Agnes Etherington Art Centre, gift of Dr. and Mrs. Alfred Bader, 1975 (18.126). See David de Witt in Wheelock, Lievens, pp. 128-129, no. 24 (colour illus.).
  116. Portrait of Jan Davidsz. de Heem, c. 1635/37, black chalk with some white body colour, 265 x 201 mm, London, British Museum (1895,0915.1199); Werner Sumowski, Drawings of the Rembrandt School, New York, vol. 7 (1983), pp. 3682-3683, no. 1652x (illus.).
  117. See entry by Lloyd DeWitt in: Wheelock, Lievens (see note 2), pp. 154-155, no. 38 (colour illus.).
  118. Jan Lievens, Head of a Bearded Old Man, c. 1640. Panel, 55 x 43 cm (oval), Kingston, Agnes Etherington Art Centre, gift of Alfred and Isabel Bader. See: David de Witt, The Bader Collection: Dutch and Flemish Paintings. Kingston, 2008, p. 198, no. 117 (colour illus.).
  119. Jan Lievens, Portrait of Adriaen Brouwer, c. 1635/37, black chalk with touches of pen in black, 221 x 185 mm, Paris, Fondation Custodia, Collection Frits Lugt (1203); Sumowski, Drawings (see note 9), pp. 3356-3357, no. 1594 (illus.).
  120. Jan Lievens, Portrait of Constantijn Huygens, 1639, black chalk with touches of pen in brown, 238 x 174 mm, London, British Museum (1836.8.11.342); see Wheelock, Lievens (see note 2), p. 242-243, no. 103 (colour illus.).
  121. Email correspondence with the author, 9 September 2020.
  122. My thanks to Stephanie Dickey for this information (email, 31 October 2022), confirmed by Marieke de Winkel.
  123. See Wheelock, Lievens (see note 2), p. 286.
  124. Lucas Vorsterman, after Anthony van Dyck, Portrait of Jan Lievens, c. 1630-1645, engraving, 241 x 158 mm, in 6 states, for the series: Icones Principorum Vivorum Doctorum Pictorum…; see: Marie Mauquoy-Hendrickx, L’Iconographie d’Antoine van Dyck, 2nd ed., Brussels, 1991, vol. 1, p. 155, no. 85; vol. 2, pl. 54 (illus.).
  125. Wheelock, Lievens (see note 2), pp. 112-113, no. 112 (colour illus.).
  126. Jan Lievens, Portrait of Charles I, pen in brown, 183 x 140 mm, Turin, Biblioteca Reale (D. C. 16365); Sumowski, Drawings (see note 9), pp. 3898-3899, no. 1754xx, (illus.); Orlers, Beschrijvinge (see note 1), pp. 375-377.
  127. Karolien de Klippel, “Adriaen Brouwer, Portrait Painter: New Identifications and an Iconographic Novelty,” Simiolus 30 (2003), pp. 196-216.
  128. Stephanie Dickey, “Jan Lievens and Printmaking,” in Wheelock, Lievens (see note 2), pp. 60-62. On the Iconography, see Mauquoy-Hendrickx, Iconographie (see note 7).
  129. DeWitt, Evolution (see note 3), p. 192, illus. fig. 144 (Lievens c. 1635/43, H. de Bran); attribution by Werner Sumowski: written correspondence with the museum of 28 July 1986; and: Drawings of the Rembrandt School, vol. 12 (Addenda), Leiden (forthcoming), no. 3104x.
  130. See Mauquoy-Hendrick, Iconography (see note 17), vol. 1, p. 214, no. 190; vol. 2, pl. 119.
  131. See DeWitt, Evolution (see note 3), pp. 160-164.
  132. Jan Lievens, Portrait of Thomas Howard, Earl of Arundel, black and red chalk, 180 x 140 mm, Staatliche Museen zu Berlin, Kupferstichkabinett (KdZ 5869); Wheelock, Lievens (see note 2), p. 249, no. 109 (colour illus.).
  133. Jan Lievens, Profile Head of an Old Woman in Oriental Dress, c. 1630, panel, 43.2 x 33.7 cm, Kingston, Agnes Etherington Art Centre, gift of Alfred and Isabel Bader, 2005 (48-002). See entry by David de Witt in Wheelock, Lievens (see note 2), pp. 122-123, no. 21 (colour illus.).
  134. Letter to his son the Earl of Lothian, May 1654: Correspondence of Sir Robert Kerr, First Earl of Ancram, and His Son William, Third Earl of Lothian, vol. 2, London, 1875, p. 383; C. Hofstede de Groot, “Hollandsche Kunst in Schotland,” Oud Holland 11 (1893), p. 214.
  135. On Sinclair: Jeannette Ewin, Fine Wines and Fish Oil: The Life of Hugh Macdonald Sinclair, Oxford 2001.
  136. The typescript is available in the “Library acquisition file for the Sinclair collection”.
  137. UBC Library, WZ250 .T9 1641.
  138. “7,000 rare books arrive”, UBC Reports 12, no. 3 (March-April, 1966). https://www.library.ubc.ca/archives/pdfs/ubcreports/UBC_Reports_1966_03_00.pdf
  139. Michiel Roscam Abbing, Rembrandt’s Elephant. Following in Hansken’s Footsteps, Amstelveen 2021.
  140. Nina Siegal, “When Rembrandt Met an Elephant”, The New York Times, July 16, 2021.
  141. UBC Library, WZ250 .T9 1641 and WZ260 .T83 1739 with the title Observationes Medicae.
  142. Allard Pierson, University of Amsterdam, Archives of Menno Hertzberger (UBA235). Sales catalogue Medicine Hippocrates-Claude Bernard, Amsterdam [February 1954], lot 442.
  143. Note 8 for this annotated copy.
  144. He also kept the relevant page from the catalogue in his files. Hamburg, Warburg Haus, Heckscher Archiv, Box 121 (‘Rembrandt: Dr. Tulp’), folder ‘Dr. Tulp Photo’s I’. Sinclair’s copy is kept in UBC Library call number Z999.74.
  145. According to Heckscher’s own administration he sent letters to Hugh Sinclair on 15 February and 2 March 1963. Hamburg, Warburg Haus, Heckscher Archiv, Box 52 (‘Heckscher: Korrespondenz und Arbeiten’). We thank Ms. Fanny Weidehaas of the Heckscher Archiv for her assistance. These letters were not found among Sinclair’s papers in The Museum of English Rural Life at the University of Reading. We thank Ms. Emma Farmer for checking these files.
  146. The translation was not published until 1991: Nicolaes Tulp, Geneesinzichten van Dr. Nicolaes Tulp etc., eds. (and transcriptions) C.G.L. Apeldoorn and T. Beijer. Amsterdam, 1991.
  147. The title page of the manuscript reads: “Nicolaes Tulp. Inzichten over de geneeskunst in vier boeken met koperen platen” (Nicolaes Tulp. Medical Insights in Four Books with Copper Plates).
  148. “D. Meppen Norda Frisii 1682 d. 18 8.bris”. We thank Koert van der Horst, retired keeper of manuscripts of the Utrecht University Library, for this identification. A third (unidentified) ownership’s inscription reads: “L. Fries stud. med. 1838 16/2.”
  149. The visit is not recorded in Sinclair’s Visitors book. Reading, The Museum of English Rural Life, Papers of Hugh Macdonald Sinclair, D HS 1/7/1: Visitor’s book 1941-1989: Dr Hugh Sinclair’s book of visitors to his home, Lady Place in Sutton Courtenay. We are grateful to Ms. Hollie Piff for checking.
  150. In the National Archives in The Hague we consulted the archives of the Department of Archeology and Nature Conservation, inv. no. 105 (Stukken betreffende de aanvraag van vergunningen voor de in- en uitvoer van voorwerpen van geschiedenis en kunst. 1946-1964).
  151. Allard Pierson, University of Amsterdam, Archives of Menno Hertzberger (UBA235), personal archives.
  152. Kindly provided information by Ms. Nina Duggen, Inspectie Overheidsinformatie en Erfgoed (Information and Heritage Inspectorate).
  153. Peter Schatborn and Erik Hinterding, Rembrandt. The Complete Drawings and Etchings, Cologne 2019. Peter Schatborn gave his judgement in an email of September 15, 2021, in translation: “In any case, the drawing was not made by Rembrandt. The stylistic differences are too great and I can’t find any drawing by Rembrandt that is comparable”.
  154. Ernest Theodore Hamy, ‚Documents inédits sur l‘Homo sylvestris rapporté d’Angola en 1630′, Bulletin du Muséum d’histoire naturelle 3 (1897), pp. 277-282.
  155. Michiel Roscam Abbing is currently preparing a book-length study, The Ape of Tulp, in which these data are to be published.
  156. Peter van der Krogt and Erlend de Groot, The Atlas Blaeu-Van der Hem of the Austrian National Library V (Utrecht 2005), pp. 88-89 (no. 35:40). The suggestion that Blaeu, who died in 1638, had access to the engraving of the chimpanzee and that this engraving was made by Tulp long before 1641, as argued by Kees Zandvliet (De Wereld van de familie Blaeu, Zutphen 2023, p. 66) must be rejected.
  157. Much of the previous literature cites the drawing as The Departure of Rebecca from Her Parents’ House. The Staatsgalerie, Stuttgart, which owns the drawing, adopted the shorter title (https://www.staatsgalerie.de/en/html).
  158. “dit behoorde vervoucht te weesen me[t] veel gebueren die deese hoge bruijt sien vertrek[k]en”: Peter Schatborn, “The Core Group of Rembrandt Drawings, I: Overview,” Master Drawings 49 (2011), p. 320.
  159. According to the Woordenboek der Nederlandsche Taal, “geburen” may mean “figures” or “bystanders,” as two scholars interpreted the word in Rembrandt’s inscription: (https://gtb.ivdnt.org/iWDB/search?actie=article&wdb=WNT&id=M017638.re.1&lemma=geburen&domein=0&conc=true). For “figures,” see: Volker Manuth, in: Rembrandt: A Genius and His Impact, exh. cat. Canberra, Australian National Gallery; Melbourne, National Gallery of Victoria, 1997, p. 270, cat. no. 53. For “bystanders,” see: Marieke de Winkel, Fashion and Fancy: Dress and Meaning in Rembrandt’s Paintings, Amsterdam 2006, pp. 214–215). However, in the full context of Rembrandt’s inscription and the drawing’s iconography, “geburen” most strongly refers to neighbours, as translated for example by Gary Schwartz and Peter Schatborn. See: Gary Schwartz, The Rembrandt Book, New York 2006, p. 107, fig. 195; Schatborn, “Core” (see note 2), p. 320.
  160. Schwartz, Rembrandt (see note 3), p. 107.
  161. Amy Golahny, “Rembrandt and ‘Everyday Life’: the Fusion of Genre and History,” in: Genre Imagery in Early Modern Northern Europe: New Perspectives, London 2016, pp. 174, 177.
  162. The Rembrandt drawing (130 x 185 mm) was sold at Christie’s (London) on 3 July 2012, lot. 50, sale 5688. Golahny, “Rembrandt” (see note 5), pp. 170–174, figs. 7.5–9.
  163. Herman Roodenburg, “Naar een etnografie van de vroegmoderne stad: de ‘gebuyrten’ in Leiden en Den Haag,” in: Cultuur en maatschappij in Nederland 1500–1850. Een historisch-antropologisch perspectief, Meppel 1992, p. 233.
  164. For a discussion of neighbourhoods’ goals, see: Herman Roodenburg, “’Freundschaft’, ‘Brüderlichkeit’ und ‘Einigkeit’: Städtische Nachbarschaften im Westen der Republik,” in: Ausbreitung bürgerlicher Kultur in den Niederlanden und Nordwestdeutschland, Münster 1991, pp. 11, 12, 21; Gabrielle Dorren, “Communities within the Community: Aspects of Neighbourhood in Seventeenth-Century Haarlem,” Urban History 25 (1998), pp. 180, 188.
  165. See, for example, Rembrandt’s drawings Benesch 491, 503, 566, 988 and his painting Portrait of a Couple as Isaac and Rebecca, c. 1665–1669 (oil on canvas, 121.5 x 166.5 cm, Amsterdam, Rijksmuseum).
  166. All Biblical translations from: The New English Bible with the Apocrypha, New York 1971.
  167. Schatborn, “Core” (see note 2), p. 320.
  168. The Staatsgalerie Stuttgart attributes the inscription to Rembrandt and the drawing to either Rembrandt or Gerbrand van den Eeckhout. Hans Martin Kaulbach, Curator of German and Netherlandish Prints and Drawings before 1800, Graphische Sammlung, Staatsgalerie Stuttgart, email message to the author, 25 April 2018.
  169. For Koninck see for example: Horst Gerson, Philips Koninck; ein beitrag zur Erforschung der holländischen Malerei des XVII. Jahrhunderts, Berlin 1936, p. 174, Z.LXV. For Flinck: Wilhelm Reinhold Valentiner, Rembrandt: des Meisters Handzeichnungen, Stuttgart 1933, part 2, p. 247. For Van den Eeckhout: Martin Royalton-Kisch, Drawings by Rembrandt and His Circle in the British Museum, exh. cat., London, British Museum 1992, p. 202, cat. no. 97; Holm Bevers, “Drawing in Rembrandt’s Workshop,” in: Drawings by Rembrandt and His Pupils: Telling the Difference, exh. cat., Los Angeles, J. Paul Getty Museum 2009, p. 27; Schatborn, “Core” (see note 2), pp. 320, 322, note 38. For an argument against the Van den Eeckhout attribution, see: Eric Jan Sluijter and Nicolette Sluijter-Seijffert, “Rembrandt’s Pupils? The Attribution of Early Drawings to Gerbrand van den Eeckhout and Jan Victors,” in: Connoisseurship Essays in Honour of Fred G. Meijer, Leiden 2020, pp. 289–296.
  170. Werner Sumowski, Drawings of the Rembrandt School, New York 1979–1992, vol. 3, p. 1734, 806xx; Bevers, “Drawing” (see note 13), pp. 27, notes 97–98.
  171. Seymour Slive, Rembrandt Drawings, Los Angeles 2009, p. 215; Schatborn, “Core” (see note 2), p. 320; Bevers, “Drawing” (see note 13), p. 2.
  172. Cornelis Hofstede de Groot and Bob Haak, Rembrandt Zeichnungen, Köln 1974, p. 13; Manuth, Rembrandt (see note 3), p. 270, cat. no. 53.
  173. Samuel van Hoogstraten, De Inleyding tot de hooge schoole der schilderkunst anders de zichtbaere werelt, Rotterdam 1678, p. 192. Bevers, “Drawing” (see note 13), p. 25, notes 86–87.
  174. Bevers, “Drawing” (see note 13), pp. 25–27, 187, 189­–90; Schatborn, “Core” (see note 2), p. 320.
  175. Bevers, “Drawing” (see note 13), p. 27.
  176. Roodenburg, “Naar” (see note 7), pp. 222–224; Dorren, “Communities” (see note 8), p. 177; Llewellyn Bogaers, “Geleund over de onderdeur: Doorkijkjes in het Utrechtse buurtleven van de vroege middeleeuwen tot in de zeventiende eeuw,” in: Bijdragen en mededelingen betreffende de geschiedenis der Nederlanden 112 (1997), pp. 349, 357, 359.
  177. Roodenburg, “Naar” (see note 7), pp. 224, 233–234; Bogaers, “Geleund” (see note 20), pp. 340–342, 348.
  178. Catherina Lis and Hugo Soly, “Neighborhood Social Change in Western European Cities,” International Review of Social History 38 (1993), p. 5.
  179. Kees Walle, Buurthouden. De geschiedenis van burengebruiken en buurtorganisaties in Leiden (14e–19e eeuw), Leiden 2005, pp. 75, 306.
  180. Regionaal Archief Leiden (RAL); Stadsarchief (SA) II inv.nr. 1216, f. 149 and RAL SA II inv.nr. 1217, f. 10 vso; cited in: Walle, Buurthouden (see note 23), p. 231, note 77.
  181. Jan le Francq van Berkheij, Natuurlyke historie van Holland, 12 parts in 9 vols., Amsterdam 1769–1811, vol. 3, part 2, pp. 1045–1046; Roodenburg, “Naar” (see note 7), p. 225.
  182. RAL; SA II inv.nr. 16; Aflezingboek F, f. 58 vso; cited in: Walle, Buurthouden (see note 23), pp. 43, 227, notes 141, 270.
  183. Algemene Verordening, n.p.; cited in: Walle, Buurthouden (see note 23), pp. 46, 275.
  184. Roodenburg, “’Freundschaft’” (see note 8), p. 15; Bogaers, “Geleund” (see note 20), p. 349.
  185. Ilja Veldman and Lynne Richards, “Familiar Customs and Exotic Rituals: Picart’s Illustrations for Cérémonies et coutumes religieuses de tous les peuples,” Simiolus: Netherlandish quarterly for the history of art, vol. 33 (2007/2008), p. 94.
  186. Picart’s widow explained that “the prints of the Reformed congregation were drawn from life and are very accurate.” Bernard Picart and Anne Vincent, Impostures innocentes ou recueil d’estampes d’après divers peintres illustres . . . etc. gravées par Bernard Picart avec son éloge historique et le catalogue de ses ouvrages, Amsterdam 1734, p. 9; Veldman and Richards, “Familiar” (see note 29), p. 99, note 20.
  187. Veldman and Richards, “Familiar” (see note 29), p. 97.
  188. Bernard Picart, Cérémonies et coutumes religieuses de tous les peuples du monde, Amsterdam 1723–1743, p. 345.
  189. As Petra van Boheemen noted, the “interest of the neighbourhood is visible” in Picart’s print. Petra van Boheemen et al., Kent, en versint, eer datje mint: vrijen en trouwen, 1500–1800, Apeldoorn, Historisch Museum Marialust; Zwolle 1989, p. 170.
  190. Van Boheemen, Kent (see note 33), pp. 170–172; H. Perry Chapman, Jan Steen, Painter and Storyteller, exh. cat., Washington, DC, National Gallery of Art; Amsterdam, Rijksmuseum 1996, pp. 116–118 note 1, cat. no. 6.
  191. Van Boheemen, Kent (see note 33), p. 170.
  192. Irma Thoen, Strategic Affection? Gift Exchange in Seventeenth-Century Holland, Amsterdam 2007, p. 106.
  193. Fynes Moryson and Charles Hughes, Shakespeare’s Europe. Unpublished Chapters of Fynes Moryson’s Itinerary Being a Survey of the Condition of Europe at the End of the 16th Century, London 1903, pp. 379–380.
  194. A. Lynn Martin, Alcohol, Sex, and Gender in Late Medieval and Early Modern Europe, New York 2001, pp. 52–53; Thoen, Strategic (see note 36), p. 105.
  195. See, for example, Jan Steen’s The Wedding of Tobias and Sarah, c. 1667–1668, oil on canvas, 131 x 172 cm, Braunschweig, Herzog Anton Ulrich-Museum; Chapman, Jan Steen (see note 34), pp. 203–205, cat. no. 32.
  196. Philips Angel, Lof der schilder-konst, Leyden 1642, p. 48. Translation from: Philips Angel, Michael Hoyle, and Hessel Miedema, “Philips Angel, Praise of Painting,” Simiolus, Netherlandish Quarterly for the History of Art 24 (1996), p. 246.
  197. A. M. van der Woude, “Variations in Size and Structure of the Household in the United Provinces of the Netherlands in the Seventeenth and Eighteenth Centuries,” in: Household and Family in Past Time: Comparative Studies in the Size and Structure of the Domestic Group over the Last Three Centuries in England, France, Serbia, Japan and Colonial North America, with Further Materials from Western Europe, Cambridge 1972, p. 315.
  198. Jan Jansz Orlers, Beschrijvinge der stadt Leyden, 2nd ed., Leiden 1641, p. 375; Walter L. Strauss et al., Rembrandt Documents, New York 1979, doc. 1641/8. For rare objections, see Roelof van Straten, Young Rembrandt. The Leiden Years, 1606-1632, Leiden 2005, p. 16; Benjamin Binstock, ‚The birth of Rembrandt‘, in Michiel Roscam Abbing, ed., Rembrandt 2006. Essays, Leiden 2006, pp. 267-278 (arguing for 1607).
  199. Strauss, Rembrandt Documents, doc. 1669/6.
  200. E.B.F.F. Wittert van Hoogland, ‚Genealogie van den tak van het geslacht van Tetrode, welke zich Vinck genoemd heeft. Reconstructie van de genealogie voorkomende in het stam- en wapenboek van aanzienlijke Nederlandsche geslachten. Memoriael Gemaeck door N(icolaas) S(ebastiaensz.) V(inck)‘, Genealogische en heraldische bladen 1 (1906), pp. 122-149.
  201. Dirk Rühl, ‚Het wapen van Rembrandt’s broeder Willem Harmensz. van Rijn een gelegenheids-wapen? Een heraldisch probleem‘, Gens Nostra. Maandblad van de Nederlandsche Genealogische Vereniging 11 (1956), pp. 117-128, esp. p. 127.
  202. Strauss et al., Rembrandt Documents, doc. 1669/4 (misspelling the name as ‚Vlinck‘). See also: http://remdoc.huygens.knaw.nl/#/document/remdoc/e13470 (accessed 22 December 2022).
  203. Warm thanks to Ingrid Pot for her kind assistance, and to P.J.M. De Baar for an impromptu consultation on the document, manuscript LB 6761 klein deel, Erfgoed Leiden en Omstreken, Leiden (hereafter ELO). The notebook is chronological but unpaginated; we therefore cite Wittert van Hoogland. See further Stephanie S. Dickey, ‚Ars longa vita brevis. Rembrandt’s death and the status of the artist in late seventeenth-century Amsterdam‘, Nederlands Kunsthistorisch Jaarboek 72 (2022), pp. 234-271.
  204. R.E.O. Ekkart, ‚Familiekroniek Van Heemskerck en Van Swanenburg (I)‘, Jaarboek van het Centraal Bureau voor Genealogie 32 (1978), pp. 41-70; idem., ‚Familiekroniek Van Heemskerck en Van Swanenburg (II)‘, Jaarboek van het Centraal Bureau voor Genealogie 33 (1979), pp. 44-75 (deaths of Cornelis and Sylvester van Swanenburgh, pp. 54, 72, 75). See also Gary Schwartz, Rembrandt, his life, his paintings, New York 1985, p. 22; https://www.mijnstambomen.nl/leiden/swanenburg.htm (accessed 16 December 2022). The dates of Silvester van Swanenburgh’s death and burial are unrecorded; he prepared his will on 12 October 1669, being siechelick van lichaem leggende te bedde (sick in bed); ELO, 0506, notary Justus Gerstecoren, no. 1144, deed 124, 12-10-1669.
  205. Wittert van Hoogland, ‚Genealogie‘, p. 135.
  206. Wittert van Hoogland, ‚Genealogie‘, pp. 136, 137. Burial: https://archief.amsterdam/archief/5001/1056 (accessed 16 December 2022).
  207. Wittert van Hoogland, ‚Genealogie‘, pp. 135.
  208. Ekkart, ‚Familiekroniek‘, pp. 54, 72.
  209. Rudi van Maanen and Leendert van Maanen, ‘De grote epidemie van 1669-1670’, Leids Jaarboekje 2021, pp. 67-83, with further references.
  210. See Dickey, ‚Ars longa vita brevis‚, with further references.
  211. See esp. Christaan Vogelaar and Gerbrand Korevaar, eds., Rembrandt’s Mother. Myth and Reality, exh. cat. Leiden: Stedelijk Museum de Lakenhal 2005, pp. 88-91, 97-98, cat. 3-6, 9-10.
  212. We are grateful to Jos Beerens and Weixuan Li for advice on software to visualize this data.
  213. Reymptgen’s husband, Cornelis Bartholomeusz (Meesz.) van Tetrode (1505-1550), a grain dealer in Leiden, died before Neeltje and Bastiaen were born. See Strauss et al., Rembrandt Documents, doc. 1561/1, 1574/3, 1579/1, 1581/1,1582/2.
  214. Strauss et al., Rembrandt Documents, p. 24.
  215. Gerrit Cornelisz. Vinck is registered living in Leiden 1544-1583; Historisch Leiden in Kaart, https://historischleideninkaart.nl/persoonformulier/?Id=8986 (accessed 16 December 2022). He became poorter of Delft in 1584; Stadsarchief Delft, 1.733, fol. 054v, 5-5-1584. See also W.C. Tettero, Genealogie van Tetrode 1300-1600, Voorburg 2000, p. 61; J.P. Jacobs, ‘Rembrandt verwant met Philips van Leyden’, De Nederlandse Leeuw 102 (1985), column 457-465.
  216. See also ELO, Stadsarchief van Leiden, 0501A, 6597, Register Vetus 1582-1601, p. 8v. ‚t Gulden Warken belonged to Reymptgen In 1579; by 1581, she had transferred ownership to Dirck; Strauss et al., Rembrandt Documents, p. 31 and doc. 1579/1, 1581/1, 1585/1.
  217. Wittert van Hoogland, p. 123. Walsburch was buried several weeks later; SAA DTB 5001, 1054, p. 46vo, 8-5-1629. Prenuptual agreement, SAA 5075, 445, not. Palm Mathijsz, 17-2-1631.
  218. SAA DTB 5001, 671, p. 33 (marriage bans) 27-1-1628; DTB 1054, p. 46vo, 8-5-1629 (burial record).
  219. Wittert van Hoogland, p. 124. They married on 10 May at the Begijnhof and 13 May at the Amsterdam Town Hall.
  220. Wittert van Hoogland, p. 126. Clara became a begijn in 1643 and registered her will as a bejaaarde geestelijke dochter, wonende op het Begijnhof, in 1655, appointing her brothers her heirs; SAA 5075, 2454, not. R. Duee, akte nummer 57860, 8-10-1655.
  221. Wittert van Hoogland, p. 127; SAA, DTB 676, p. 145, 2-1-1642; 5033 Poorterboeken, no. 2, p. 199, 24-4-1642. In 1647 Albert purchased a home on the Haarlemmerstraat; SAA, 5073, Kwijtscheldingen, no. 928, 5-1-1647. He posted the banns for his second marriage, to Grietje Harmens van der Aa, on 2 December 1655; SAA, DTB 682, p. 356, 2-12-1655.
  222. Wittert van Hoogland, p. 127.
  223. SAA DTB, 1055, p. 94v (Clara); 1056, p. 252, 26-6-1683 (Albert).
  224. Cornelis was recorded on 24 April 1587 as a baker, age 21. In 1600, he purchased a house later owned by Karel van der Pluym. Strauss et al., Rembrandt Documents, doc. 1581/2, 1662/4; Schwartz, Rembrandt, p. 18 (diagram of Rembrandt’s family tree by P.J.M. de Baar).
  225. Strauss et al., Rembrandt Documents, doc. 1662/4; Marieke de Winkel, ‚“Cousin“ Karel van der Pluym and the benefit of family‘, in Epco Runia and David de Witt, eds., Rembrandt’s Social Network. Family, friends, acquaintances, exh. cat., Amsterdam: Museum het Rembrandthuis 2019, pp. 61-65, citing a red and black chalk drawing on vellum, dated 1634 (private collection in New York).
  226. See Koos Levy-Halm, ‚Where did Vermeer buy his painting materials? Theory and practice‘, in Ivan Gaskell and Michiel Jonker, eds., National Gallery Studies in the History of Art, Vol. 55, Vermeer Studies, 1988, pp. 137-143; Jo Kirby, ‚The painter’s trade in the seventeenth century: theory and practice‘, National Gallery Technical Bulletin 20 (1999), pp. 5-49.
  227. See Stephanie S. Dickey, Rembrandt. Portraits in Print, Amsterdam/Philadelphia 2004, pp. 141-149; Runia and De Witt, eds., Rembrandt’s Social Network, p. 124.
  228. Orlers, Beschryvinge, p. 373; https://rkd.nl/explore/artists/51111 (accessed 2 January 2023)
  229. Rudolf E.O. Ekkart, Isaac Claesz. van Swanenburgh 1537-1614, Zwolle 1998, p. 14. For the prenuptial agreement, Jacobge was assisted by her father Claes Isaacsz and her brothers Isaac Claesz and Claes Claesz; ELO, 0508 Het oude rechterlijke archief van Leiden, no. 76B-2, fol. 375, 15-10-1570.
  230. ELO, 0501A, Stadsarchief van Leiden, 1574-1816, no. 1289, Register van de volkstelling 1581, fol. 9.
  231. See Marije Osnabrugge, The Neapolitan Lives and Careers of Netherlandish Immigrant Painters (1575-1655), Amsterdam 2019, esp. pp. 66-73, 115-123. The Antwerp-born portraitist Abraham Vinck (1574/75-1619) associated with Jacob van Swanenburgh in Hamburg 1589-1598 and later in Naples; in 1602, he witnessed Van Swanenburgh’s marriage to Margaretha Cardone. He lived in Amsterdam 1609-1619. Rembrandt’s bankruptcy inventory includes ‚een doode Contrefijtsel van Abraham Vinck‚; Strauss et al., Rembrandt Documents, doc. 1656/12, no. 86, but we have not yet found a link between Abraham and the Vinck family discussed here.
  232. Ekkart, Isaac Claesz. van Swanenburgh, esp. p. 71; Schwartz, Rembrandt, pp. 22-23.
  233. Strauss et al., Rembrandt Documents, doc. 1620/1; Jef Schaeps and Mart van Duijn, Rembrandt en de Universiteit Leiden, Leiden 2019, esp. p. 28.
  234. Orlers, Beschryvinge, p. 375.
  235. Ekkart, ‚Familiekroniek‘, pp. 71-72. Schwartz, Rembrandt, p. 17; Van Straten, Young Rembrandt, p. 24.
  236. ELO, Register van poorterinschrijvingen F, 1267, fol. 279v, 16-4-1638; Buurquestieboeken, 48G, fol. 105v, no. 2355, 12-9-1661; 0506, Notary Justus Gerstecoren, 1144, deed no. 124, 12-10-1669.
  237. Ernst van de Wetering, ‚Rembrandt’s gift and the underrated importance of his apprenticeship with Jacob isaacsz. van Swanenburg‘, in Ernst van de Wetering and Bernhard Schnackenburg, eds., The Mystery of the Young Rembrandt, exh. cat., Kassel: Gemäldegalerie Alte Meister and Amsterdam: Museum het Rembrandthuis 2001, pp. 32-38.
  238. Strauss, et al., Rembrandt Documents, p. 69, doc. 1630/5; Schwartz, Rembrandt, p. 23; English translation: Wheelock, ed., et al., Jan Lievens, p. 286.
  239. Bakker, ‚Rembrandt and the emergence‘; Vogelaar, ‚Rembrandt in Leiden‘; Orlers, Beschryvinge, p. 376.
  240. See Boudewijn Bakker, ‚Rembrandt and the humanist ideal of the universal painter‘, in Stephanie S. Dickey, ed., Rembrandt and his Circle. Insights and Discoveries, Amsterdam 2017, pp. 67-98.
  241. Volker Manuth, Marieke de Winkel and Rudie van Leeuwen, Rembrandt. The Complete Paintings, Cologne 2019, cat. 121.
  242. Carel Vosmaer, Rembrandt. Sa vie et ses oeuvres, The Hague 1877, pp. 28-35, 469, 461, unaware of Vinck’s Memoriael, posited a relationship to the Van Swanenburghs on Rembrandt’s father’s side. Ekkart, Isaac Claesz van Swanenburgh, p. 11, dismissed this. However, Claes Cornelisz van Berckel, half-brother of Harmen Gerritsz van Rijn, was married to Brechtje Mourijnsdr. van Swanenburch. The half-brothers lived next door to each other on the Weddesteeg in 1605 and 1624 and owned a mill together; ELO, Buurquesties 48B, blad 2, aktenummer 520, 4-4-1605; 48D, blad 201, aktenumer 1339, 22-4-1624; Tiende Register, Bon Noord-Rijnevest (B), Stadsvrijdom en molens op de wallen, archiefnummer 501A, Stukken betreffende afzonderlijke onderwerpen; Registratie van onroerend goed 1585-1816 (1819), inventarisnummer 6634, blad 31, 1602-1724. It is not yet clear how Brechtje Mourijnsdr. connects to Jacob and Silvester van Swanenburgh. See also Schwartz, Rembrandt, pp. 21-25.
  243. For context, see S.A.C. Dudok van Heel, ‚Rembrandt van Rijn (1606-1669), een remonstrantsgezind schilder uit calvinistisch Leiden‘, in idem., De jonge Rembrandt onder tijdgenoten. Godsdienst en schilderkunst in Leiden en Amsterdam, Nijmegen 2006, pp. 177-223.
  244. On art patronage in Leiden, see esp. Gerbrand Korevaar, ‚Leiden in Rembrandt’s time‘, in Van de Wetering and Schnackenburg, Mystery, pp. 12-21; Piet Bakker, ‚Rembrandt and the emergence of the Leiden art market‘, in Jacquelyn N. Coutré, ed., Leiden ca. 1630. Rembrandt Emerges, exh. cat., Kingston: Agnes Etherington Art Centre 2019, pp. 66-95. We are grateful to Piet Bakker for advice on the present essay.
  245. Dirk Traudenius, Tyd-zifter, Amsterdam 1662, p. 16; Arnold Houbraken, De groote schouburgh der Nederlandtsche konstschilders en schilderessen, Amsterdam 1718-21, III, p. 33; H. Schneider, ed. by R.E.O. Ekkart, Jan Lievens, Sein Leben und Seine Werke, Amsterdam 1973, p. 151, no. 262; https://houbraken-translated.rkdstudies.nl/3-1-59/page-30-39/ (accessed 16 December 2022,) with English translation. The painting has not been discovered.
  246. Wheelock, ed., Jan Lievens, pp. 3, 16-17, fig. 19. The painting was destroyed in 1929.
  247. On their extended connection, see Stephanie S. Dickey, ‚Jan Lievens in Rembrandt’s house‘, Kroniek van het Rembrandthuis 2008, pp. 36-53.
  248. As noted above, Cornelis van Swanenburgh’s mother was Adriana van Leeuwen. Rembrandt’s oldest brother, Adriaen van Rijn, married Lystbertgen Symonsdr van Leeuwen in 1617, and Willem van Rijn married Willempje Pietersdr van Steylandt, widow of Jacob Symonsz van Leeuwen, in 1636; Rühl, ‚Het wapen‘, pp. 117-119, 123.
  249. Bakker, ‚Rembrandt and the Emergence‘, pp. 81-83; Wheelock, ed., Jan Lievens, p. 84, cat. 2.
  250. Orlers, Beschryvinge, pp. 367-377; Bakker, ‚Rembrandt and the emergence‘, p. 82. One of these was a ‚Pylatus‘, possibly Pilate Washing his Hands (Raleigh, North Carolina Museum of Art); Wheelock, ed., Jan Lievens, p. 289.
  251. Strauss et al., Rembrandt Documents, doc. 1663/7; Schwartz, Rembrandt, p. 37; Dudok van Heel, ‚Rembrandt van Rijn‘, pp. 190-193; Christopher Brown, An van Camp and Christiaan Vogelaar, eds., Young Rembrandt, exh. cat., Leiden: Museum De Lakenhal and Oxford: Ashmolean Museum 2019, pp. 24, 158-160. Angela Jager is preparing a study of art patronage in Rembrandt’s family network.
  252. Bakker, ‚Rembrandt and the Emergence‘, pp. 85-90.  See also C. Willemijn Fock, trans. by Anne Baudoin, ‚Art ownership in Leiden in the seventeenth century‘, Journal of Historians of Netherlandish Art  13:1 (2021), DOI: 10.5092/jhna.2021.13.1.4.

In memoriam Willemijn Fock (1942-2021)

On the third of June this year Willemijn Fock, Emeritus Professor of the History of Applied Arts at Leiden University, passed away at the age of 78. In the late 1990s she was engaged by The Rembrandt House Museum as advisor on the reinstallation of the interior according to the situation in Rembrandt’s time.

Foto van Willemijn Fock (1942-2021), Foto gemaakt door Leo van Velzen, 2007
Photo: Leo van Velzen, 2007

Under Willemijn Fock’s leadership the Applied Arts section in Leiden achieved international recognition. Willemijn Fock was inspiring through the depth of her knowledge and her drive to research and map out the history of the Applied Arts in The Netherlands. These qualities led, among other things, to an imposing six-volume publication on the history of residency on the Rapenburg Canal in Leiden. The investigation of properties on Rapenburg on the basis of inventories, construction plans and other source material yielded groundbreaking new insights. How did the original residents live in the houses and with what objects did they surround themselves?

This large-scale research project was of great significance for the subsequent approach to reconstruction of historic interiors. For this reason, Willemijn Fock’s expertise was brought to bear on questions arising from the reinstallation of the Rembrandt House in the late 1990s. Together with among others the architect and architectural historian Henk Zandkuijl, she formed part of the team that was charged with bringing the interior of the former house of Rembrandt back to life. Additionally she guided the research that the undersigned, Titia Vellenga, undertook on Rembrandt’s art cabinet. But also in more recent years the museum drew on her advice in the area of mid-seventeenth-century domestic interior arrangements in Amsterdam.

Willemijn Fock hereby made a decisive contribution to the reinstallation – based on scholarly research – of the building and the historical atmosphere that the Rembrandt House breathes. Since 2014 Professor Reinier Baarsen and Assistant Professor Alexander Dencher have assumed the tasks that she had laid down in 2007 with her retirement. They perform these roles alongside their duties as Curators at the Rijksmuseum. As a museum institution with a historical interior the Rembrandt House Museum also recognizes the importance of maintaining and expanding knowledge of the applied arts. The museum furthermore aspires – where possible and in memory of Willemijn Fock – to making a contribution to this field in the present and the future.

Titia Vellenga, former student of Willemijn Fock and former PR-Manager of the Rembrandt House Museum

Leonore van Sloten, Curator, The Rembrandt House Museum

  1. Werner Sumowski, Paul Huys Janssen, The Hoogsteder Exhibition of Rembrandt’s Academy, exh. cat. The Hague: Hoogsteder & Hoogsteder, 1992, cat. no. 28.
  2. Exhibition catalogues: Albert Blanckert, Jezus in de Gouden Eeuw, exh. cat. Rotterdam: Kunsthal, 2000–2001; Akira Kofuku, Rembrandt and the Rembrandt School. The Bible, mythology and ancient history, exh. cat. Tokyo: Museum of Western Art, 2003; Arthur K. Wheelock et al., Jan Lievens. A Dutch Master Rediscovered, exh. cat. Washington: National Gallery of Art; Milwaukee: Milwaukee Art Museum; Amsterdam: Rembrandt House Museum, 2008-2009, cat.no. 52; Louis van Tilborgh, Constantijn Huygens. Kunstkenner en verzamelaar, exh. cat. The Hague: Museum Bredius, 2013, cat. no. 14. Other literature: Werner Sumowski, Gemälde der Rembrandtschüler, vol. 4, Landau, 1983, p. 3726, no. 2356, fig. 3964; Helga Gutbrod, Lievens und Rembrandt : Studien zum Verhältnis ihrer Kunst, Frankfurt am Main, 1996, p. 299; Edwin Buijssen (ed.), Haagse schilders in de Gouden Eeuw, Het Hoogsteder lexicon van alle schilders werkzaam in Den Haag 1600-1700, The Hague, 1998, p. 191; Lloyd DeWitt, Evolution and Ambition in the career of Jan Lievens, 1607-1674, Phd. Diss. University of Maryland, College Park, 2006, p. 228.
  3. DeWitt, Evolution (see note 2), p. 228.
  4. For example those mentioned in the Montias Database of 17th Century Dutch Art Inventories and the Getty Provenance Research Index.
  5. Sumowski, Huys Janssen, Academy (see note 1), p. 220.
  6. Dr Gaston Gaudinot sale, Paris (Drouot), 13-14 February 1869.
  7. Sumowski, Huys Janssen, Academy (see note 1), p. 220.
  8. Ibid.
  9. Sumowski, Huys Janssen, Academy (see note 1), p. 226. Huys Janssen explains that the miracle as described in Luke and John differs from the version told by Matthew.
  10. After listening to the centurion, and before addressing him directly, Jesus speaks to his followers: “I tell you, many will come from east and west and sit at table with Abraham, Isaac, and Jacob in the kingdom of heaven.” (Matthew 8:11) Perhaps Lievens incorporated this part of the text and explicitly included people coming from the east (from the standpoint of his Dutch audience). A second possibility is that they are Pharisees. This group plays the role elsewhere in Matthew of disbelieving critics, and here they may serve to accentuate the belief of the centurion in the Christian faith. In early prints (Sebald Beham, Israhel van Meckenem, Hans Schaüfelein and Cornelis Massijs) and several Italian prints from Lievens’s time (seventeenth century prints after Paolo Veronese), Pharisees wear such headdresses. A parallel between blacks and overseas regions, such as in Lievens’s Brinio, is convincingly outlined by Elmer Kolfin (in: Elmer Kolfin, De kunst van de macht, Jordaens, Lievens en Rembrandt in het Paleis op de Dam, Zwolle, 2023, p. 67), does not seem to apply here.
  11. Sumowski, Huys Janssen, Academy (see note 1), p. 223.
  12. Sumowski, Huys Janssen, Academy (see note 1), pp. 223, 226.
  13. The right eye from the perspective of the viewer. There, a pupil was painted in, in a later restoration. Because of the sketchy manner it is difficult to ascertain whether or not both eyes are present, but in the left the lower eyelid is visible, while it is undefined in the right eye.
  14. For example: Jacobus Neeffs (after Jacob Jordaens), Judgement of Christ, etching, c. 1630-1645; Marinus van der Goes (after Jacques Jordaens), Judgement of Christ, engraving, c. 1614-1639; Willem Panneels (after Peter Paul Rubens), Adoration of the kings, etching, 1630; Nicolaes Lauwers (after Peter Paul Rubens), Ecce Homo, engraving, c. 1619-1652; and many more. Generally, for examples of inspiration drawn from prints by Lievens, see De
    Witt, Evolution (see note 2).
  15. Sumowski, Huys Janssen, Academy (see note 1), p. 226. Huys Janssen refers to examples by Nicolaes Moeyaert (Herentals, St. Waltrudis church) and Adam Camerarius (Amsterdam, Rijksmuseum, inv. no. SK-A-733). DeWitt refers to a painting by Bartholomeus Breenbergh (Karlsruhe, Staatliche Kunsthalle Karlsruhe, inv. no. 228) and the Moeyaert in Herentals (DeWitt, Evolution (see note 2), p. 227). But also see a woodcut with this subject by Cornelis van Sichem II in Der zielen lusthof (1629). Also of interest: Claes Moeyeart, Christ and the Centurion, 1632 (Minneapolis, Minneapolis Institute of Art, inv. no. 2012.84.5). Although the painting is known under this subject, it may in fact depict Cornelius kneeling before Peter, since more than one figure is shown kneeling and the composition closely resembles prints of this subject.
  16. Henri van de Waal, “’s Lands oudste verleden in de voorstelling van Vondel en zijn tijdgenooten”, Elsevier’s Maandschrift 47 (1937); Henri van de Waal, “Tempesta en de historieschilderingen op het Amsterdamse stadhuis”, Oud Holland 56 (1939); Henri van de Waal, Drie eeuwen vaderlandsche geschied-uitbeelding 1500-1800, een iconologische studie, The Hague, 1952; Kolfin, Kunst (see note 10).
  17. Antonio Tempesta (after Otto van Veen), Print 8 in (…)De Batavische oft oude Hollandtsche oorloghe teghen de Romeynen, 1612. Etching, 167 x 210 mm. Rijksmuseum, Amsterdam, inv. no. RP-P-OB-37.614. Jürgen Ovens based his drawing for the Batavian Series depicting Claudius Civilis leaving the Women and Children to fight at Xanten (Hamburg, Hamburger Kunsthalle, inv. no. 22342) on this print.
  18. On the period in The Hague: Buijssen Haagse (see note 2), pp.191-193.
  19. Haarlem, Teylers Museum, inv. no. P 006. For the identification and context, see: Gregor Weber, “Dus leeft de dappre Graaf: Zu einem Bildnis Andries de Graeffs von Jan Lievens (1607-1674)”, Oud Holland 99 (1985), pp. 44-56.
  20. Van de Waal, Eeuwen (see note 16), p. 230; Kolfin, De kunst van de macht (see note 10), pp. 19-20.
  21. Van de Waal, “’s Lands” (see note 16), p. 301-302.
  22.  Kolfin, Kunst (see note 10), p. 41. Four Batavian scenes were never completed. For two the themes are known, for the other two are not known.
  23. Munich, Staatliche Graphische Sammlung München, inv. no. 1451; Hamburg, Hamburger Kunsthalle, Kupferstichkabinett, inv. no. 22342. A lesser-known drawing of Rembrandt’s Conspiracy of Claudius Civilis (Edinburgh, National Galleries of Scotland, inv. no. D 23862) shows – when compared to the drawing in Munich – that the lower section of the painting is covered by a frieze and that portions of the left and right sides are obscured. This may indicate that an alternative conception of the framing of the lunettes was considered before the one ultimately implemented. It is possible that this earlier framing was already envisioned when Lievens produced his oil sketch Christ and the Centurion.
  24. Van de Waal, Eeuwen (see note 16), p. 225, referring to SAA, 5039, 2 resolutieboek, f. 66r.
  25. Ibid., referring to SAA, 5039, 153 rapiamus 1661, f.195v.
  26. Van de Waal, Eeuwen (see note 16), p. 225.
  27. Gregor Weber, “Jan Lievens’s ‘The Shield-raising of Brinio’ a Second Oil Sketch”, Hoogsteder-Naumann Mercury 12/13 (1992), nt. 8.
  28. Dewitt, Evolution (see note 2), p. 221.
  29. Kolfin, Kunst (see note 10), p.67.
  30. Kolfin, Kunst (see note 10), p. 44.
  31. For, among other things, contemporary poetry in which Civilis and others are compared to the members of the House of Orange: Van de Waal, Eeuwen (see note 16), pp. 220-221, 223.
  32. Kolfin, Kunst (see note 10), p. 47.
  33. Margriet van Eikema Hommes, Elmer Kolfin, De Oranjezaal in Huis ten Bosch, Een zaal uit loutere liefde, Zwolle, 2013, p. 77.
  34. Kolfin, Kunst (see note 10), pp. 41-47, 77.
  35. One may ask, in light of points discussed in this article, whether the “Christ” figure in the first version was in fact Christ at all. If so, the oil sketch would initially have represented solely a Christian scene without any reference to the Batavian Revolt, thereby less relatable to the (eventual) decoration program of the Town Hall’s gallery. Given that in the initial design the groups left and right with Biblical and/or eastern figures do not seem to have been included (aside from a bearded man on the right, judging from the x-ray), the large central figure may originally have been Julius Civilis. In compositional terms, this would align the painting more closely with the print by Tempesta after Van Veen. The apparent similarity in hairstyle between the final Christ figure and the initial figure, together with the possible initial presence of a (holy) beam of light directed toward the figure, may argue against this hypothesis; nevertheless, Brinno in Lievens’s Brinio Raised on the Shield likewise features long hair and even incorporates a diagonal compositional line through the clouds, comparable to the line through the foliage in the initial version of the present subject. The later insertion of Christ could then be understood as a deliberate twist, imparting a more prominent Christian meaning to the historical scene. These suggestions and observations were kindly shared by Jochem van Eijsden.
  36. Samuel van Hoogstraten, Inleyding tot de hooge schoole der schilderkonst: anders de zichtbaere werelt, Rotterdam 1678, p. 18. Van Hoogstraten here refers to the period when he was “still a disciple”, during which, as part of a “we”, he and others discussed a particular question, to which a certain “Fabritius” responded with an answer. It is generally assumed that this refers to Carel Fabritius, who is assumed to have studied with Rembrandt between approximately 1641 and 1643.
  37. Werner Sumowski described Van Hoogstraten as “pädagogisch begabt, Assistent Rembrandts gewesen” (Werner Sumowski, Gemälde der Rembrandt-Schüler II, Landau/Pfalz 1984, p. 1286). As supporting evidence, Sumowski argued that Van Hoogstraten corrected drawings by Constantijn Daniël van Renesse (; p. 1290, nt. 2). When discussing one of these drawings (Moses and Reuel’s Daughters at the Well, Amsterdam, Rijksmuseum, inv. no. RP-T-1893-A-2782) Sumowski suggested the possibility that “Samuel van Hoogstraten acted as assistant to the master on occasional trips even at a later date”. (Werner Sumowski, Drawings of the Rembrandt School IX, New York 1985, no. 2159x). Building on this, Jonathan Bikker suggested in his monograph on Willem Drost that Van Hoogstraten “might have supervised Drost during his early days in Rembrandt’s studio” (Jonathan Bikker, Willem Drost, A Rembrandt Pupil in Amsterdam and Venice, New Haven/London 2005, p. 11). David de Witt later observed, in his Abraham van Dijck monograph, concerning Van Hoogstraten: “by 1646 his training would have been complete, but he appears to have stayed on as a tutor or head pupil for several years” (David De Witt, Life and Work of Late Rembrandt Pupil Abraham van Dijck, c. 1635-1680, Amsterdam 2020, p. 11).
  38. Sabine Pénot, Rembrandt – Hoogstraten. Colour and Illusion, exh. cat. Vienna: Kunsthistorisches Museum Wien, 2024; Nathalie Maciesza, Epco Runia, Samuel van Hoogstraten. De Illusionist, exh. cat. Amsterdam: Rembrandt House Museum, 2025; Sabine van Beek, Leonore van Sloten, David de Witt et al., Samuel van Hoogstraten: Catalogue Raisonné, The Hague 2025.
  39. The catalogue of the Vienna exhibition assumes a position for Van Hoogstraten as an assistant for approximately three to four years (Angelina Illes, in: exh. cat. Vienna 2024 (see note 3), p. 29; Jonathan Bikker, in: exh. cat. Vienna 2024 (see note 3), p. 93), though it makes no mention of any teaching responsibilities. These are, however, included in the publication accompanying the exhibition at the Rembrandt House Museum (Michiel Roscam Abbing, in: exh. cat. Amsterdam 2025 (see note 3), p. 19; David De Witt, in: exh. cat. Amsterdam 2025 (see note 3), p. 131), and in the online Van Hoogstraten catalogue raisonné by the RKD (Michiel Roscam Abbing, in: The Hague 2025 (see note 3), “With Rembrandt in Amsterdam”. https://vanhoogstraten.rkdstudies.nl/samuel-van-hoogstraten-the-ingenious-and-poetic-painter/with-rembrandt-inamsterdam/, 26 May 2025).
  40. The term “assistent” was used in Holland in the 17th century, albeit in other contexts, see: Woordenboek Nederlandse taal, s.v. assistent, https://gtb.ivdnt.org/iWDB/search?actie=article&wdb=WNT&id=M004535&lemma=assistent&domein=0&conc=true, 11
    July 2025.
  41. “Een min of meer ondergeschikte helper”, a more or less subordinate helper (see note 5); “A person who helps or supports somebody, usually in their job”: Oxford English Dictionary, s.v. assistant, https://www.oed.com/view/Entry/12041, 11 July 2025.
  42. The guild archive has been lost. For a comprehensive account of the Amsterdam Guild of Saint Luke and its ordinances, see: Isabella H. van Eeghen, “Schilders of Sint Lucasgilde”, in: Isabella H. van Eeghen (ed.), Inventarissen der archieven van de gilden en van het brouwerscollege, Amsterdam 1951, passim.; Isabella H. van Eeghen (Jasper Hillegers, translator), “The Amsterdam Guild of Saint Luke in the 17th Century”, Journal of Historians for Netherlandish Art 4.2 (2012), passim., DOI:10.5092/jhna.2012.4.2.4, 11 July 2025. The current article relies exclusively on the guild regulations of the Amsterdam De Kroniek 2024/25 – Museum Rembrandthuis 10 painters’ guild. It is often assumed that the regulations of painters’ guilds in different Dutch towns did not differ substantially in content. On that assumption, gaps in the regulations of one town might be filled by those of another. However, the discussion later in this article regarding whether apprentices were permitted to produce their own work shows that crucial differences did in fact exist. For that reason, guild regulations from other cities are not used here to fill the gaps in the surviving Amsterdam regulations.
  43. Extract van de willekeuren en ordonnantien den gilde van St. Lucas verleent, Amsterdam 1720, p. 11.
  44. Extract (see note 8), p. 11; This is also the case in the chapter title and margin of the 1766 publication of all known guild charters: Ordonnantien en willekeuren van het Lucas-gilde binnen Amsterdam, Amsterdam 1766, p. 64, 68. It is noteworthy that the dean and headmen of the guild employed a gilde kneght (Extract (see note 8), pp. 26-27. This was not a pupilship, and the tasks meet the definition of an assistant in the Oxford English Dictionary and the Woordenboek Nederlandse Taal (see note 6)
  45. Extract (see note 8), pp. 12-13
  46. Extract (see note 8), pp. 11-12.
  47. Extract (see note 8), p. 12.
  48. Cornelis Kiliaen (ed. Frans Claes), Etymologicum teutonicae linguae, Antwerp 1599 (The Hague 1972), p. 278, s.v. leerionghe; leer-kind; leer-knecht; leerlinck; p. 703, s.v. discipel. In the regulations of the Haarlem Guild of St. Luke from 1634 (NHA, 1105, Ambachtsgilden te Haarlem (Gilden Haarlem), no. 219), the terms “leerling”, “leerjongen”, and “discipel” are
    used. This might suggest that a distinction existed between them, but they are actually used interchangeably. The same applies to the terms “(werk)gezel”, “knecht”, and – a new term – “gast”. The latter is synonymous with journeyman or servant: “Knecht van een ambachtsman of fabrikant; gezel, werkknecht”, servant of a tradesman or manufacturer; journeyman, workshop hand: Woordenboek Nederlandse taal, s.v. gast, https://gtb.ivdnt.org/iWDB/searchactie=article&wdb=WNT&id=M017355.re.35&lemma=werkgast&domein=0&conc=true,
    16 oktober 2025.
  49. Kiliaen, Etymologicum (see note 13), p. 139, s.v. ghe-selle van een ampt. The Latin word “collega” is likewise a translation for “ambtgenoot”, “maet”, and “vennoot” (Kiliaen, Etymologicum (see note 13), p. 18, s.v. ampt-ghenoot; p. 302, s.v. maet, med-maet, maetken; p. 579, s.v. veyn-out, veyn-noot, ven-noot, vennoot, veyn-gnoot).
  50. Kiliaen, Etymologicum (see note 13), p. 244, s.v. knecht, dienaer.
  51. Nicolaas de Roever, “Drie Amsterdamsche Schilders (Pieter Isaaksz, Abraham Vinck, Cornelis van der Voort)”, Oud Holland 3 (1885), p. 198.
  52. In 1619, he was asked together with several artists who had traveled to Italy, including Pieter Lastman, Adriaen van Nieulandt, and Barent van Someren, to assess the authenticity of a Caravaggio painting from the collection of the late Louis Finson. Abraham Bredius, Nicolaas de Roever, “Pieter Lastman en François Venant”, Oud Holland 4 (1886), pp. 7-8.
  53. Ronald de Jager “Meester, leerjongen, leertijd. Een analyse van Zeventiende-eeuwse Noord-Nederlandse leerlingcontracten van kunstschilders, goud- en zilversmeden”, Oud Holland 104 (1990), p. 96, nt. 107. The title of “gezel” is, in fact, never mentioned in the known Amsterdam contracts.
  54. De Jager, “Meester” (see note 18), pp. 73-75.
  55. De Jager, “Meester” (see note 18), p. 71.
  56. Stadsarchief Amsterdam (hereafter SAA), 5075, 393A, nots. Jacob Jacobs and Nicolaes Jacobs, ff. 59r-59v, 20-07-1626; Abraham Bredius, “Gerrit Willemsz. Horst”, Oud Holland 50 (1933), pp. 5-6; De Jager, “Meester” (see note 18), p. 98, no. 7.
  57. This underscores a clear distinction: as was also evidenced by the entries in Kiliaen, Etymologicum (see note 13), dienaer was a synonym for knecht, not for leerknecht (see note 15).
  58. Abraham Bredius, Künstlerinventare. Urkunden zur Geschichte der holländischen Kunst des XVIten, XVIIten und XVIIIten Jahrhunderts V, The Hague 191, pp. 1482-1483; De Jager, “Meester” (see note 18), p. 98, no. 10.
  59. The value of a barrel of herring in Amsterdam in 1635 was approximately 120 grams of silver (Bo Poulsen, Dutch Herring. An Environmental History, c. 1600–1860, Amsterdam 2008, p. 93, table 6.9); in the seventeenth century, ten grams of silver corresponded to the value of roughly one guilder.
  60. The tuition fees in Holland for a two-year contract averaged 61.5 guilders per year (De Jager, “Meester” (see note 18), p. 75).
  61. Josua Bruyn, “Een onderzoek naar 17de -eeuwse schilderijformaten, voornamelijk in Noord-Nederland”, Oud Holland 93 (1979), p. 113.
  62. Abraham Bredius, Künstlerinventare. Urkunden zur Geschichte der holländischen Kunst des XVIten, XVIIten und XVIIIten Jahrhunderts II, The Hague 1916, pp. 400-401; De Jager, “Meester” (see note 18), p. 98
  63. As a journeyman painter Waltusz earned less than half the daily wage of peers in other trades. In 1652, journeymen carpenters and bricklayers in Amsterdam earned approximately 26 to 27 stivers per summer day (although there are no exact figures for 1651, data is available for 1633, 27 and 25 stivers respectively, and for 1667, 28 and 27 stivers respectively).
    This disparity between painter’s journeymen and their peers in other trades mirrors the situation in 1579. The guild
    regulations (gildebrief) of the St. Luke’s Guild from that year mention journeymen earning 4 stivers and others earning 10
    stivers per day (Ordonnantien (see note 9), p. 17, art. 11). Taking the average of 7 stivers, these were notably low wages –
    practically half – when compared to the 14 and 12 stivers earned by carpenters and bricklayers, respectively, in that same
    year. For the wages of the workers mentioned here, see: Hubert Nutseling, Welvaart en werkgelegenheid in Amsterdam
    1540–1860, Amsterdam/Dieren 1985, p. 252, appendix 5.1, table A.
  64. SAA, DTB 5001, 469, p. 241, 30-09-1651; Judith van Gent, Bartholomeus van der Helst (circa 1613-1670): een studie naar zijn leven en zijn werk, Utrecht (Utrecht University), p. 41.
  65. Virtually nothing is known about Gerardus van Berleborch (Bernard Renckens, “G. van Berkborch”, Oud Holland 84 (1967), no. 4, passim). He or his father was likely from the region around Bad Berleburg in Germany. He appears to have been present in Leiden in 1665, when he is recorded as a witness (“Gerrit van Berleberg”) at the baptism of a child of the painter Jacobus Geutkien (Erfgoed Leiden en Omstreken (hereafter ELO), DTB 1004, 237, fol. 236v, 3-12-1665).
  66. SAA, 5075, 875, not. Jacob van Zwieten, pp. 638-640, 16-10-1649; Johannes G. van Dillen, Bronnen tot de geschiedenis van het bedrijfsleven en het gildewezen van Amsterdam 1510-1672 III, p. 540, no. 1057.
  67. A possible reason for this may be that young painters attained the status of master more quickly. This benefited the guild financially, as it earned income only from masters and pupils, not from journeymen.
  68. Ordonnantien (see note 9), p. 10, art. 3.
  69. Ordonnantien (see note 9), p. 17, art. 11.
  70. Joachim von Sandrart’s famous anecdote about Rembrandt’s studio being filled with “countless elite children”, pupils who each paid an annual tuition fee of 100 guilders suggests that the legal limit on the number of pupils was, in practice, a dead letter (Joachim von Sandrardt, Teutsche Academie, Nuremberg 1675, p. 326; Van Eeghen, “Guild” (see note 7), p. 6).
  71. Young Man Reading with a Vanitas Still Life, 1644, oil on panel, 58 x 74 cm, Rotterdam, Museum Boijmans Van Beuningen, inv. no. 1386; Self-portrait, 1644, oil on panel, 63 x 48 cm, The Hague, Museum Bredius, inv. no. 056-1946; Self-portrait, 1645, oil on panel, 54.1 x 44.8 cm, Liechtenstein, The Princely Collections, Vaduz-Vienna, inv. no. GE 107; Portrait of a Child, 1645, oil on panel, 68.6 x 57.8 cm, private collection; The Adoration of the Shepherds, 1647, oil on canvas, 58.2 x 70.8 cm, Dordrecht, Dordrechts Museum, inv. no. DM/980/567.
  72. Godefridus J. Hoogewerff, De geschiedenis van de St. Lucasgilden in Nederland, Amsterdam 1947, p. 24; Ernst van de Wetering “Problems of Pupilship and Studio Practice” in: Josua Bruyn et al., A Corpus of Rembrandt Paintings II: 1631-1634, Amsterdam 1986, p. 57; Bikker, Drost (see note 2), p. 11; Angelina Illes, in: exh. cat. Vienna 2024 (see note 3), p. 29.
  73. Samuel Muller Fz., Schilders-vereenigingen te Utrecht. Bescheiden uit het Gemeentearchief, Utrecht 1880, p. 76; Frederik D.O. Obreen, Archief voor Nederlandsche Kunstgeschiedenis IV, Rotterdam 1881/1882, p. 51. The very fact that such a regulation had to be instituted in these cities already indicates that works were being signed by non-masters.
  74. De Jager, “Meester” (see note 18), pp. 77-79.
  75. Bruyn, “Onderzoek”, (see note 26), p. 113.
  76. David de Witt, Leonore van Sloten, in: The Hague 2025 (see note 3), “Rembrandt’s Impact”, https://vanhoogstraten.rkdstudies.nl/catalogus-schilderijen/rembrandts-impact/, 3 June 2025.
  77. Almost exclusively, reference is made to Bikker, Drost (see note 2), p. 11. Also in the exhibition catalogue of the Van Hoogstraten exhibition in Amsterdam, Drost is cited as an example of an early student of Van Hoogstraten (David de Witt, in: exh. cat. Amsterdam 2025 (see note 3), p. 131.
  78. Since Daniël Pont’s monograph on Barent Fabritius, (Daniël Pont, Barent Fabritius 1624–1673, The Hague, 1958) and Sumowski’s Drawings of the Rembrandt School (see note 2), no subsequent scholarly efforts have systematically De Kroniek 2024/25 – Museum Rembrandthuis 12 reconstructed his drawn oeuvre or analyzed the development of his distinctive style. The author’s forthcoming dissertation addresses this lacuna, and catalogues drawings by Barent Fabritius.
  79. Pont was among the first to suggest he may not have been a direct pupil of Rembrandt, but instead only came into contact with Rembrandt’s work indirectly, through his brother Carel (Pont, Barent (see note 43), p. 96). In the literature, uncertainty on this matter appears to have become the norm, with scholars consistently noting – or implicitly dealing with – the lack of evidence for a formal pupilship with Rembrandt (see: Paul Huys Jansen, Werner Sumowski, The Hoogsteder Exhibition of Rembrandt’s Academy, exh. cat. The Hague: Hoogsteder & Hoogsteder, 1992, p. 139; Walter A. Liedkte in: Hubert von Sonneburg, Rembrandt/Not Rembrandt in the Metropolitan Museum of Art I, exh. cat. New York City: The Metropolitan Museum of Art, 1995, cat. 48, pp. 145-146; Peter C. Sutton in: Albert Blankert, Rembrandt. A Genius and his impact, exh. cat. Melbourne: National Gallery of Victoria; Canberra: National Gallery of Australia, 1997, p. 283; Jan Blanc, Dans l’atelier de Rembrandt. Le maître et ses élèves, Paris 2006, p. 140.
  80. Holm Bevers, “Das Susanna-Thema im Werkstattzusammenhang: Zeichnungen”, in: Holm Bevers, Katja Kleinert, Claudia Laurenze-Landsberg, Rembrandts Berliner Susanna und die beiden Alten. Die Schaffung eins meisterwerks, exh. cat. Berlin: Staatliche Museen zu Berlin, Kupferstichkabinett; Gemäldegalerie, 2015, pp. 49-50.
  81. Katja Kleinert, Claudia Laurenze-Landsberg, “Wandlungen eines Gemäldes. Rembrandts Berliner Susanna und die beiden Alten”, in: exh. cat. Berlin 2015 (see note 45), p. 19, 32.
  82. See for instance Rembrandt’s Holy Family in the Carpenter’s workshop or his Star of the Kings (London, The British Museum, inv. nos. 1900,0824.144, 1910,0212.189).
  83. The drawing of a male model (here attributed to Barent Fabritius) has been described as stylistically very close to Van Hoogstraten (Martin Royalton-Kisch in: Catalogue of Drawings by Rembrandt and his School, London: The British Museum, 2010, cat. 71). The Departure of the Prodigal Son, a drawing already earlier attributed to Fabritius, is still considered a work by Van Hoogstraten (Frankfurt am Main, Städel Museum, inv. no. 817).
  84. A convincing spatial representation of the scene, achieved through a successful use of proportion, perspective, light, and color. For a elaboration on this definition, including references, see: Leonore van Sloten, “Regels voor de kunst”, in: David de Witt, Leonore van Sloten, Jaap van der Veen, Rembrandts late leerlingen. In de leer bij een genie, exh. cat. Amsterdam: Rembrandt House Museum, 2015, p. 73, note 31.
  85. In drawings by Barent Fabritius from the second half of the 1640s, his preparatory chalk underdrawing is generally careful and precise but not detailed, with clear, exact contours rendered in continuous, rounded lines. The somewhat squat figures possess a doll-like, slightly caricatural character. When using pen to trace or fill in the figures, particularly those in the foreground, the style becomes sketchier and more angular. Fabritius’s hatching lines become more carefully placed as they  grow finer, laid loosely side by side with only occasional thin-pen scratching, while thicker lines, including contours, are rendered in a zigzag, looser manner, often applied to foreground elements such as a repoussoir. Groups of hatching in shadowed, complex motifs (e.g., figures or foreground foliage) are neither intertwined nor uniformly oriented, and though the balance of light and shadow varies between drawings, it remains consistent within each composition; early mastery is evident in his wash applications, where loosely brushed transitions in shadows lend a painterly quality, enhancing figural plasticity and atmospheric depth, as seen in drawings with dramatic chiaroscuro effects.
  86. Although it has been argued by Holm Bevers that this drawing is by Constantijn Daniël van Renesse and dates from between 1650 and 1652 (Holm Bevers, “Ausstellungen zu Rembrandt in Rückblick”, Kunstchronik, 58 (2005), p. 480; Holm Bevers, in: Rembrandt. Die Zeichnungen im Berliner Kupferstichkabinett, exh. cat. Berlin: Staatliche Museen zu Berlin, Kupferstichkabinett, 2006, cat. no. 45, p. 158, nt. 12; Holm Bevers in: Holm Bevers et al., Drawings by Rembrandt and his Pupils. Telling the Difference, exh. cat. Los Angeles: The J. Paul Getty Museum, 2009, cat. no. 31.2, pp. 190-191), a number of features are so uncharacteristic of Van Renesse that the attribution cannot be sustained. This applies in particular to elements such as the heavy, coarse scratches in the shadow areas and the sketch-like rendering of the faces of Joseph and Mary. Van Renesse typically keeps shadow areas and light transitions in brush clear and even. Also characteristic is his meticulous penwork, marked by fine, short strokes in the contours and hatching lines (see for instance: The Judgment of Salomon, New York City (The Metropolitan Museum of Art, Robert Lehman Collection, inv. no. 1975.1.806; Daniel in the Lion’s Den, Rotterdam, Museum Boijmans Van Beuningen, inv. no. MB 200). Generally, it shows the boldness of Barent much more than the careful restraint of Renesse
  87. “Beeter waer ‚t dat [om de veranderin[g]] een eesel van achteren was, dan dat al de hoofden iuist wt het stuck sien. Dat oock omtrent de boom wat meerder groente was. | 1 losep heft af te swaer en te onbesuist | 2 Maria most het kindeken wat meerder vieren, want een teeder kint magh sulck duwen niet ver[dragen]. | losep al te kort en dick, sijn hooft wast hem wt de [borst?]. Sijn hebben alle beide al te groote koppen”. Transcript from: Leonore van Sloten, in: exh. cat. Amsterdam 2015 (see note 49), p. 73, nt. 27. “It would be better that [for the alteration] there were a donkey from the back, than that all the heads are looking straight out of the work. That there were also somewhat more greenery around the tree. | 1 Joseph lifts too heavily and too inconsiderately. | 2 Mary ought to ease the little child somewhat more, for a tender infant cannot [endure] such pushing. | Joseph is all too short and stout, his head grows out of the [chest?]. They both have all too large heads”. These instructions are also partly articulated within the drawing itself. Joseph is indeed shown tugging firmly at Mary’s arm, whereas in the more sketch-like version, he supports her more gently at the back. The small patch of greenery in the lower corner may also be a later addition, in correspondence with the suggestion.
  88. The face does not appear to be a correction in the technical sense, but rather an example of a foreshortened face viewed from below – a challenging principle of perspective.
  89. An attribution proposed Christian Dittrich (Christian Dittrich in: Christian Dittrich, Thomas Ketelsen, Rembrandt. Die Dresdener Zeichnungen 2004, exh. cat. Dresden: Staatliche Kunstsammlungen Dresden, Kupferstich-Kabinett, 2004, cat. no.14, pp. 80-81).
  90. Brusati implied the possibility that the text was written partly by Rembrandt and partly by Van Hoogstraten (Celeste Brusati, Artifice & Illusion. The Art and Writing of Samuel van Hoogstraten, Chicago/London 1995, pp. 31, 275, note 40). Rembrandt was excluded as the author of the instructions by Bevers, while Van Hoogstraten as author remained an option. Van Renesse was likewise ruled out by Bevers, based on a comparison with the handwriting on his Daniel in the Lions’ Den drawing and The Judgment of Solomon drawing (see note 51); Holm Bevers, in: exh. cat. Los Angeles 2009 (see note 51), cat. 31.1–31.2, p. 190; 191, note 3). To this may be added that the handwriting also closely resembles that of Barent Fabritius. Although little comparative material survives, the compact, small script of Fabritius’s name beneath the death inventory of his sister-in-law Aeltje, dated 24 April 1643 (SAA, 5075, 1628a, not. David de l’Hommel, p. 399), shows a strong resemblance to the instructions on the Dresden sheet.
  91. “Once you have mastered your handling and your eye is somewhat clarified, it will no longer trouble you to translate many naturalistic paintings into a naturalistic drawing”. “Wanneer gy uwe handeling nu machtich zijt, en uw oog wat verklaert is, zoo zal ‚t u ook niet verscheelen veel verwige Schilderyen in een verwige teykeningen na te klaren” (Van Hoogstraten, Inleyding (see note 1), p. 27)
  92. “I advise masters, when they review the drawings of their pupils, to improve them by making sketches of the same subject themselves. This is an excellent exercise and has greatly assisted many in the art of composition”. “De meesters raed ik, als ze de Teykeningen haerer discipelen overzien, datze de zelve, met schetssen op ‚t zelve voorwerp te maeken, verbeeteren. Dit oeffent ongemeen, en heeft veelen geweldich in de schikkunst geholpen” (Van Hoogstraten, Inleyding (see note 1), p. 192).
  93. “And certainly, this manner of drawing with pen and brush is likewise the most suitable for completing a masterly work in its full force. For one can also, whenever it proves convenient, work into it with red chalk and crayons, as though one were almost painting with colours”. “En zeker deeze wijze van met pen en pinseel te teykenen, is ook allerbequaemst om een meesterlijk werk in zijn volle kracht te voleinden. Dewijl men’er ook, als’t pas geeft, met rood krijt en kryons in kan speelen, als of men byna met verwen schilderde” (Van Hoogstraten, Inleyding (see note 1), p. 31.
  94. On stylistic grounds, this Rembrandt drawing has been placed among a group of history drawings dating to around 1650 (Otto Benesch, The Drawings of Rembrandt V, New York 1957, no. 902). Among other arguments, this dating led Bevers to attribute the Dresden drawing to Constantijn van Renesse, rather than Barent Fabritius (Holm Bevers, in: exh. cat. Berlin 2006 (see note 51), cat. no. 45, p. 157, 158, nt. 12) However, it remains questionable whether the Rembrandt drawing in Berlin should be understood within that context. Unlike the other history drawings, this work is not an autonomous composition but rather a sketched response to the Dresden sheet. It is plausible that the sketch was already made around 1647. In terms of linework, it is not far removed from the portrait sketch of Jan Six, dating from in or before 1647 (Amsterdam, Six Collection).
    It is drawn in a similarly free style, applied in a sketch, comparable to other drawings from the second half of the 1640’s (see
    note 47). Rembrandt’s Berlin drawing could thus have been made quite soon after Fabritius’s corrected drawing
  95. Josua Bruyn, “Gemälde der Rembrandt-Schüler II by Werner Sumowski Review”, Oud Holland 101 (1987) no. 3, p. 229.
  96. https://rkd.nl/images/313061, 17 July 2025. In terms of drawing style, this work is not far removed from Van Hoogstraten’s drawing The Sacrifice of Manoah of 1649 (Braunschweig, Herzog Anton Ulrich Museum, inv. no. Z 335; https://rkd.nl/images/71286, 17 July 2025). We may even assume that The Crucifixion predates it; the departing angel in the  Braunschweig drawing – also seen from the back – appears to be a more developed and refined treatment of the motif of a figure seen from behind.
  97. Samuel van Hoogstraten, The Adoration of the Shepherds. London, The British Museum, inv. no. 1895,0915.1203; https://rkd.nl/images/313552, 17 July 2025. A drawing of The Circumcision, likewise painted as a part of the Passion series in 1646, has been attributed to Gerbrand van den Eeckhout (Brussels, Koninklijke Musea voor Schone Kunsten België, inv. no. 4060/1212). There are also two copies after Rembrandt’s Holy Family with a Curtain from 1646 (London, The British Museum, inv. no. 1895,0915.1200; Oxford, Ashmolean Museum, inv. no. WA1986.56).
  98. Josua Bruyn in: Josua Bruyn et al., A Corpus of Rembrandt Paintings III: 1635-1642, Amsterdam 1989 pp. 13-16.
  99. Martin Royalton-Kisch, Drawings by Rembrandt and his Circle in the British Museum, London: The British Museum, 1992, cat. no. 87, pp. 180-182; Holm Bevers, “Drawings in Rembrandt’s Workshop”, in: exh. cat. Los Angeles 2009 (see note 51), pp. 13-17; David de Witt, “Leren van het leven: tekeningen van Rembrandts leerlingen” in: Judith Noorman, David de Witt, Rembrandts Naakte Waarheid. Tekenen naar naaktmodellen in de Gouden Eeuw, exh. cat. Amsterdam: Rembrandt House Museum, 2015, pp. 117-120.
  100. Initially, this drawing was attributed to Rembrandt, but as early as 1908, this attribution was already being questioned (Martin Conway, “Some Rembrandt Drawings”, Burlington Magazine 14 (1908/1909), p.37).
  101. This sheet has previously been judged the weakest of the three (David de Witt, in: exh. cat. Amsterdam 2015 (see note 64), p. 118), and it has even been suggested that Rembrandt may have corrected it. (Martin Royalton-Kisch, in: col. cat. London 2010 (see note 48), cat. 71). The fine parallel pen strokes in the boy’s torso are comparable to those in the body of Susanna in the Budapest drawing. The somewhat arbitrary use of red chalk (in the model’s right armpit area, on the reverse side of the cushion, and in the upper left corner) also stands out in both sheets. The type of loose, heavy pen lines used for the cushion corresponds to those found in the cloak of the old man in the Susanna drawing.
  102. For a first suggestion of Bol being the assistant of Rembrandt, see: Albert Blanckert, Ferdinand Bol (1616-1680). Rembrandt’s Pupil, Doornspijk 1982, pp. 17-18.
  103. Blanckert, Bol (see note 67), pp. 17-18; David de Witt, “Ferdinand Bol, discipel van Rembrandt”, in: Norbert Middelkoop, Ferdinand Bol en Govert Flinck. Rembrandts meesterleerlingen, Amsterdam (Rembrandt House Museum/Amsterdam Museum) 2017, pp. 44-45
  104. Portrait of a Lady, 1642. Berlin, Staatliche Museen zu Berlin, Gemäldegalerie, inv. no. 809. However, there are paintings by Bol, or attributed to him, of an earlier date or dating. The Liberation of St Peter (private collection), dated around 1636, may be, given its strong connection to the work of Benjamin Cuyp (David de Witt, in: exh. cat. Amsterdam 2017 (see note 68), pp. 42-43), made before Bol’s departure to Amsterdam. Gideon’s Sacrifice of 1640, signed by Bol (Utrecht, Museum Catharijneconvent, inv. no. RMCC s24), is typical in subject matter and composition of his later work from the 1640s, and may
    be made under conditions comparable to those proposed in this article for the paintings by Van Hoogstraten, dating from
    between 1644 and 1647. Other works attributed to Bol prior to 1642 are often copies or adaptations of compositions by
    Rembrandt.
  105. Christopher Brown, Carel Fabritius, Oxford 1981, p. 47; Gero Seelig in: Frederik J. Duparc, Carel Fabritius 1622-1654, exh. cat. The Hague: Mauritshuis; Schwerin: Staatliches Museum, 2004-2005, cat. no. 4, p. 97.
  106. Erna Kok erroneously states that Bol is mentioned as Rembrandt’s “werckgesel” in a document of 30 August 1640 (Erna Kok, “Govert Flinck en Ferdinand Bol en hun netwerken van opdrachtgevers,” in: exh. cat. Amsterdam 2017 (see note 68), p. 71, p. 244, n. 37). Bol’s exact role during his time in Rembrandt’s workshop is never documented. It is striking that the drawn copies after three of Rembrandt’s paintings from around 1636 are attributed to Ferdinand Bol (Peter Schatborn, “Tekeningen van Govert Flinck en Ferdinand Bol”, in: exh. cat. Amsterdam 2017 (see note 68), p.185). Apart from these sheets and those datable around 1646 by later pupils, there are few, if any, known drawings by Rembrandt’s pupils that are direct copies after his history or figure paintings. It is possible that Bol played an important role in introducing this method into the studio, and that it was later adopted by Van Hoogstraten. Van Hoogstraten is likely to have been in contact with Bol while in Amsterdam. After Bol established himself as an independent master, around 1642, he too began to draw in red chalk. He did so, however, almost exclusively in preparatory studies for (mainly) paintings – see, for instance, Joseph brings his Father before Pharaoh (Dresden, Gemäldegalerie, inv. no. 1605), and its preliminary drawing (Amsterdam, Rijksmuseum, inv. no. RP-T-1883-A-276). Van Hoogstraten may well have adopted this practice from him. This suggests that, even as an official pupil of Rembrandt, Van Hoogstraten felt the freedom to look to the work of other contemporaries as well. Van Sloten has argued that Bol continued to visit Rembrandt during the first half of the 1640s (Leonore van Sloten, “Ferdinand Bol, de etser”, in: exh. cat. Amsterdam 2017 (see note 68), pp. 218–221). Bol’s use of red chalk for preparatory studies may therefore have been the source of Van Hoogstraten’s conception that the use of red chalk contributes to the painterly quality of a drawing.
  107. Arnold Houbraken, De groote schouburgh der Nederlantsche konstschilders en schilderessen, Amsterdam, 1976, p. 165.
  108. Jan Jacobsz. Orlers, Beschrijvinge der Stadt Leyden, 2nd ed., Leiden, 1641, p. 376.
  109. See the translation from the original Latin: “Constantijn Huygens on Lievens and Rembrandt,” in: Arthur K. Wheelock et al., Jan Lievens. A Dutch Master Rediscovered, exh. cat. Washington: National Gallery of Art; Milwaukee: Milwaukee Art Museum; Amsterdam: Museum Het Rembrandthuis, 2008-2009, p. 287.
  110. See: Arthur K. Wheelock, “Jan Lievens: Bringing New Light to an Old Master,” in: Wheelock, Lievens (see note 2), pp. 13-23; and: Lloyd DeWitt, Evolution and Ambition in the Career of Jan Lievens (1607-1674), Ph.D. dissertation, University of Maryland, 2006: https://www.researchgate.net/publication/277127128_Evolution_and_Ambition_in_the_Career_of_Jan_Lievens_1607-1674
  111. Property from Aristocratic Estates and Important Provenance, Vienna (Dorotheum), 8 September 2020, lot 59 (as Circle of Bartholomeus van der Helst).
  112. Werner Sumowski, Gemälde der Rembrandt-Schüler, Landau, vol. 5, 1990, p. 3109, no. 2127, ill. p. 3279
  113. Ernst van de Wetering, Rembrandt: the Painter at Work, Amsterdam, 1997, pp. 182-185.
  114. Jan Lievens, Job in his Misery, monogrammed and dated 1631, canvas, 171.5 x 148.6 cm, Ottawa, National Gallery of Canada (4093). See Lloyd DeWitt in Wheelock, Lievens (see note 2), pp. 130-131, no. 25 (colour illus.).
  115. Jan Lievens, The Penitent Magdalene, c. 1631. Canvas, 63.5 x 49.5 cm. Kingston, Agnes Etherington Art Centre, gift of Dr. and Mrs. Alfred Bader, 1975 (18.126). See David de Witt in Wheelock, Lievens, pp. 128-129, no. 24 (colour illus.).
  116. Portrait of Jan Davidsz. de Heem, c. 1635/37, black chalk with some white body colour, 265 x 201 mm, London, British Museum (1895,0915.1199); Werner Sumowski, Drawings of the Rembrandt School, New York, vol. 7 (1983), pp. 3682-3683, no. 1652x (illus.).
  117. See entry by Lloyd DeWitt in: Wheelock, Lievens (see note 2), pp. 154-155, no. 38 (colour illus.).
  118. Jan Lievens, Head of a Bearded Old Man, c. 1640. Panel, 55 x 43 cm (oval), Kingston, Agnes Etherington Art Centre, gift of Alfred and Isabel Bader. See: David de Witt, The Bader Collection: Dutch and Flemish Paintings. Kingston, 2008, p. 198, no. 117 (colour illus.).
  119. Jan Lievens, Portrait of Adriaen Brouwer, c. 1635/37, black chalk with touches of pen in black, 221 x 185 mm, Paris, Fondation Custodia, Collection Frits Lugt (1203); Sumowski, Drawings (see note 9), pp. 3356-3357, no. 1594 (illus.).
  120. Jan Lievens, Portrait of Constantijn Huygens, 1639, black chalk with touches of pen in brown, 238 x 174 mm, London, British Museum (1836.8.11.342); see Wheelock, Lievens (see note 2), p. 242-243, no. 103 (colour illus.).
  121. Email correspondence with the author, 9 September 2020.
  122. My thanks to Stephanie Dickey for this information (email, 31 October 2022), confirmed by Marieke de Winkel.
  123. See Wheelock, Lievens (see note 2), p. 286.
  124. Lucas Vorsterman, after Anthony van Dyck, Portrait of Jan Lievens, c. 1630-1645, engraving, 241 x 158 mm, in 6 states, for the series: Icones Principorum Vivorum Doctorum Pictorum…; see: Marie Mauquoy-Hendrickx, L’Iconographie d’Antoine van Dyck, 2nd ed., Brussels, 1991, vol. 1, p. 155, no. 85; vol. 2, pl. 54 (illus.).
  125. Wheelock, Lievens (see note 2), pp. 112-113, no. 112 (colour illus.).
  126. Jan Lievens, Portrait of Charles I, pen in brown, 183 x 140 mm, Turin, Biblioteca Reale (D. C. 16365); Sumowski, Drawings (see note 9), pp. 3898-3899, no. 1754xx, (illus.); Orlers, Beschrijvinge (see note 1), pp. 375-377.
  127. Karolien de Klippel, “Adriaen Brouwer, Portrait Painter: New Identifications and an Iconographic Novelty,” Simiolus 30 (2003), pp. 196-216.
  128. Stephanie Dickey, “Jan Lievens and Printmaking,” in Wheelock, Lievens (see note 2), pp. 60-62. On the Iconography, see Mauquoy-Hendrickx, Iconographie (see note 7).
  129. DeWitt, Evolution (see note 3), p. 192, illus. fig. 144 (Lievens c. 1635/43, H. de Bran); attribution by Werner Sumowski: written correspondence with the museum of 28 July 1986; and: Drawings of the Rembrandt School, vol. 12 (Addenda), Leiden (forthcoming), no. 3104x.
  130. See Mauquoy-Hendrick, Iconography (see note 17), vol. 1, p. 214, no. 190; vol. 2, pl. 119.
  131. See DeWitt, Evolution (see note 3), pp. 160-164.
  132. Jan Lievens, Portrait of Thomas Howard, Earl of Arundel, black and red chalk, 180 x 140 mm, Staatliche Museen zu Berlin, Kupferstichkabinett (KdZ 5869); Wheelock, Lievens (see note 2), p. 249, no. 109 (colour illus.).
  133. Jan Lievens, Profile Head of an Old Woman in Oriental Dress, c. 1630, panel, 43.2 x 33.7 cm, Kingston, Agnes Etherington Art Centre, gift of Alfred and Isabel Bader, 2005 (48-002). See entry by David de Witt in Wheelock, Lievens (see note 2), pp. 122-123, no. 21 (colour illus.).
  134. Letter to his son the Earl of Lothian, May 1654: Correspondence of Sir Robert Kerr, First Earl of Ancram, and His Son William, Third Earl of Lothian, vol. 2, London, 1875, p. 383; C. Hofstede de Groot, “Hollandsche Kunst in Schotland,” Oud Holland 11 (1893), p. 214.
  135. On Sinclair: Jeannette Ewin, Fine Wines and Fish Oil: The Life of Hugh Macdonald Sinclair, Oxford 2001.
  136. The typescript is available in the “Library acquisition file for the Sinclair collection”.
  137. UBC Library, WZ250 .T9 1641.
  138. “7,000 rare books arrive”, UBC Reports 12, no. 3 (March-April, 1966). https://www.library.ubc.ca/archives/pdfs/ubcreports/UBC_Reports_1966_03_00.pdf
  139. Michiel Roscam Abbing, Rembrandt’s Elephant. Following in Hansken’s Footsteps, Amstelveen 2021.
  140. Nina Siegal, “When Rembrandt Met an Elephant”, The New York Times, July 16, 2021.
  141. UBC Library, WZ250 .T9 1641 and WZ260 .T83 1739 with the title Observationes Medicae.
  142. Allard Pierson, University of Amsterdam, Archives of Menno Hertzberger (UBA235). Sales catalogue Medicine Hippocrates-Claude Bernard, Amsterdam [February 1954], lot 442.
  143. Note 8 for this annotated copy.
  144. He also kept the relevant page from the catalogue in his files. Hamburg, Warburg Haus, Heckscher Archiv, Box 121 (‘Rembrandt: Dr. Tulp’), folder ‘Dr. Tulp Photo’s I’. Sinclair’s copy is kept in UBC Library call number Z999.74.
  145. According to Heckscher’s own administration he sent letters to Hugh Sinclair on 15 February and 2 March 1963. Hamburg, Warburg Haus, Heckscher Archiv, Box 52 (‘Heckscher: Korrespondenz und Arbeiten’). We thank Ms. Fanny Weidehaas of the Heckscher Archiv for her assistance. These letters were not found among Sinclair’s papers in The Museum of English Rural Life at the University of Reading. We thank Ms. Emma Farmer for checking these files.
  146. The translation was not published until 1991: Nicolaes Tulp, Geneesinzichten van Dr. Nicolaes Tulp etc., eds. (and transcriptions) C.G.L. Apeldoorn and T. Beijer. Amsterdam, 1991.
  147. The title page of the manuscript reads: “Nicolaes Tulp. Inzichten over de geneeskunst in vier boeken met koperen platen” (Nicolaes Tulp. Medical Insights in Four Books with Copper Plates).
  148. “D. Meppen Norda Frisii 1682 d. 18 8.bris”. We thank Koert van der Horst, retired keeper of manuscripts of the Utrecht University Library, for this identification. A third (unidentified) ownership’s inscription reads: “L. Fries stud. med. 1838 16/2.”
  149. The visit is not recorded in Sinclair’s Visitors book. Reading, The Museum of English Rural Life, Papers of Hugh Macdonald Sinclair, D HS 1/7/1: Visitor’s book 1941-1989: Dr Hugh Sinclair’s book of visitors to his home, Lady Place in Sutton Courtenay. We are grateful to Ms. Hollie Piff for checking.
  150. In the National Archives in The Hague we consulted the archives of the Department of Archeology and Nature Conservation, inv. no. 105 (Stukken betreffende de aanvraag van vergunningen voor de in- en uitvoer van voorwerpen van geschiedenis en kunst. 1946-1964).
  151. Allard Pierson, University of Amsterdam, Archives of Menno Hertzberger (UBA235), personal archives.
  152. Kindly provided information by Ms. Nina Duggen, Inspectie Overheidsinformatie en Erfgoed (Information and Heritage Inspectorate).
  153. Peter Schatborn and Erik Hinterding, Rembrandt. The Complete Drawings and Etchings, Cologne 2019. Peter Schatborn gave his judgement in an email of September 15, 2021, in translation: “In any case, the drawing was not made by Rembrandt. The stylistic differences are too great and I can’t find any drawing by Rembrandt that is comparable”.
  154. Ernest Theodore Hamy, ‚Documents inédits sur l‘Homo sylvestris rapporté d’Angola en 1630′, Bulletin du Muséum d’histoire naturelle 3 (1897), pp. 277-282.
  155. Michiel Roscam Abbing is currently preparing a book-length study, The Ape of Tulp, in which these data are to be published.
  156. Peter van der Krogt and Erlend de Groot, The Atlas Blaeu-Van der Hem of the Austrian National Library V (Utrecht 2005), pp. 88-89 (no. 35:40). The suggestion that Blaeu, who died in 1638, had access to the engraving of the chimpanzee and that this engraving was made by Tulp long before 1641, as argued by Kees Zandvliet (De Wereld van de familie Blaeu, Zutphen 2023, p. 66) must be rejected.
  157. Much of the previous literature cites the drawing as The Departure of Rebecca from Her Parents’ House. The Staatsgalerie, Stuttgart, which owns the drawing, adopted the shorter title (https://www.staatsgalerie.de/en/html).
  158. “dit behoorde vervoucht te weesen me[t] veel gebueren die deese hoge bruijt sien vertrek[k]en”: Peter Schatborn, “The Core Group of Rembrandt Drawings, I: Overview,” Master Drawings 49 (2011), p. 320.
  159. According to the Woordenboek der Nederlandsche Taal, “geburen” may mean “figures” or “bystanders,” as two scholars interpreted the word in Rembrandt’s inscription: (https://gtb.ivdnt.org/iWDB/search?actie=article&wdb=WNT&id=M017638.re.1&lemma=geburen&domein=0&conc=true). For “figures,” see: Volker Manuth, in: Rembrandt: A Genius and His Impact, exh. cat. Canberra, Australian National Gallery; Melbourne, National Gallery of Victoria, 1997, p. 270, cat. no. 53. For “bystanders,” see: Marieke de Winkel, Fashion and Fancy: Dress and Meaning in Rembrandt’s Paintings, Amsterdam 2006, pp. 214–215). However, in the full context of Rembrandt’s inscription and the drawing’s iconography, “geburen” most strongly refers to neighbours, as translated for example by Gary Schwartz and Peter Schatborn. See: Gary Schwartz, The Rembrandt Book, New York 2006, p. 107, fig. 195; Schatborn, “Core” (see note 2), p. 320.
  160. Schwartz, Rembrandt (see note 3), p. 107.
  161. Amy Golahny, “Rembrandt and ‘Everyday Life’: the Fusion of Genre and History,” in: Genre Imagery in Early Modern Northern Europe: New Perspectives, London 2016, pp. 174, 177.
  162. The Rembrandt drawing (130 x 185 mm) was sold at Christie’s (London) on 3 July 2012, lot. 50, sale 5688. Golahny, “Rembrandt” (see note 5), pp. 170–174, figs. 7.5–9.
  163. Herman Roodenburg, “Naar een etnografie van de vroegmoderne stad: de ‘gebuyrten’ in Leiden en Den Haag,” in: Cultuur en maatschappij in Nederland 1500–1850. Een historisch-antropologisch perspectief, Meppel 1992, p. 233.
  164. For a discussion of neighbourhoods’ goals, see: Herman Roodenburg, “’Freundschaft’, ‘Brüderlichkeit’ und ‘Einigkeit’: Städtische Nachbarschaften im Westen der Republik,” in: Ausbreitung bürgerlicher Kultur in den Niederlanden und Nordwestdeutschland, Münster 1991, pp. 11, 12, 21; Gabrielle Dorren, “Communities within the Community: Aspects of Neighbourhood in Seventeenth-Century Haarlem,” Urban History 25 (1998), pp. 180, 188.
  165. See, for example, Rembrandt’s drawings Benesch 491, 503, 566, 988 and his painting Portrait of a Couple as Isaac and Rebecca, c. 1665–1669 (oil on canvas, 121.5 x 166.5 cm, Amsterdam, Rijksmuseum).
  166. All Biblical translations from: The New English Bible with the Apocrypha, New York 1971.
  167. Schatborn, “Core” (see note 2), p. 320.
  168. The Staatsgalerie Stuttgart attributes the inscription to Rembrandt and the drawing to either Rembrandt or Gerbrand van den Eeckhout. Hans Martin Kaulbach, Curator of German and Netherlandish Prints and Drawings before 1800, Graphische Sammlung, Staatsgalerie Stuttgart, email message to the author, 25 April 2018.
  169. For Koninck see for example: Horst Gerson, Philips Koninck; ein beitrag zur Erforschung der holländischen Malerei des XVII. Jahrhunderts, Berlin 1936, p. 174, Z.LXV. For Flinck: Wilhelm Reinhold Valentiner, Rembrandt: des Meisters Handzeichnungen, Stuttgart 1933, part 2, p. 247. For Van den Eeckhout: Martin Royalton-Kisch, Drawings by Rembrandt and His Circle in the British Museum, exh. cat., London, British Museum 1992, p. 202, cat. no. 97; Holm Bevers, “Drawing in Rembrandt’s Workshop,” in: Drawings by Rembrandt and His Pupils: Telling the Difference, exh. cat., Los Angeles, J. Paul Getty Museum 2009, p. 27; Schatborn, “Core” (see note 2), pp. 320, 322, note 38. For an argument against the Van den Eeckhout attribution, see: Eric Jan Sluijter and Nicolette Sluijter-Seijffert, “Rembrandt’s Pupils? The Attribution of Early Drawings to Gerbrand van den Eeckhout and Jan Victors,” in: Connoisseurship Essays in Honour of Fred G. Meijer, Leiden 2020, pp. 289–296.
  170. Werner Sumowski, Drawings of the Rembrandt School, New York 1979–1992, vol. 3, p. 1734, 806xx; Bevers, “Drawing” (see note 13), pp. 27, notes 97–98.
  171. Seymour Slive, Rembrandt Drawings, Los Angeles 2009, p. 215; Schatborn, “Core” (see note 2), p. 320; Bevers, “Drawing” (see note 13), p. 2.
  172. Cornelis Hofstede de Groot and Bob Haak, Rembrandt Zeichnungen, Köln 1974, p. 13; Manuth, Rembrandt (see note 3), p. 270, cat. no. 53.
  173. Samuel van Hoogstraten, De Inleyding tot de hooge schoole der schilderkunst anders de zichtbaere werelt, Rotterdam 1678, p. 192. Bevers, “Drawing” (see note 13), p. 25, notes 86–87.
  174. Bevers, “Drawing” (see note 13), pp. 25–27, 187, 189­–90; Schatborn, “Core” (see note 2), p. 320.
  175. Bevers, “Drawing” (see note 13), p. 27.
  176. Roodenburg, “Naar” (see note 7), pp. 222–224; Dorren, “Communities” (see note 8), p. 177; Llewellyn Bogaers, “Geleund over de onderdeur: Doorkijkjes in het Utrechtse buurtleven van de vroege middeleeuwen tot in de zeventiende eeuw,” in: Bijdragen en mededelingen betreffende de geschiedenis der Nederlanden 112 (1997), pp. 349, 357, 359.
  177. Roodenburg, “Naar” (see note 7), pp. 224, 233–234; Bogaers, “Geleund” (see note 20), pp. 340–342, 348.
  178. Catherina Lis and Hugo Soly, “Neighborhood Social Change in Western European Cities,” International Review of Social History 38 (1993), p. 5.
  179. Kees Walle, Buurthouden. De geschiedenis van burengebruiken en buurtorganisaties in Leiden (14e–19e eeuw), Leiden 2005, pp. 75, 306.
  180. Regionaal Archief Leiden (RAL); Stadsarchief (SA) II inv.nr. 1216, f. 149 and RAL SA II inv.nr. 1217, f. 10 vso; cited in: Walle, Buurthouden (see note 23), p. 231, note 77.
  181. Jan le Francq van Berkheij, Natuurlyke historie van Holland, 12 parts in 9 vols., Amsterdam 1769–1811, vol. 3, part 2, pp. 1045–1046; Roodenburg, “Naar” (see note 7), p. 225.
  182. RAL; SA II inv.nr. 16; Aflezingboek F, f. 58 vso; cited in: Walle, Buurthouden (see note 23), pp. 43, 227, notes 141, 270.
  183. Algemene Verordening, n.p.; cited in: Walle, Buurthouden (see note 23), pp. 46, 275.
  184. Roodenburg, “’Freundschaft’” (see note 8), p. 15; Bogaers, “Geleund” (see note 20), p. 349.
  185. Ilja Veldman and Lynne Richards, “Familiar Customs and Exotic Rituals: Picart’s Illustrations for Cérémonies et coutumes religieuses de tous les peuples,” Simiolus: Netherlandish quarterly for the history of art, vol. 33 (2007/2008), p. 94.
  186. Picart’s widow explained that “the prints of the Reformed congregation were drawn from life and are very accurate.” Bernard Picart and Anne Vincent, Impostures innocentes ou recueil d’estampes d’après divers peintres illustres . . . etc. gravées par Bernard Picart avec son éloge historique et le catalogue de ses ouvrages, Amsterdam 1734, p. 9; Veldman and Richards, “Familiar” (see note 29), p. 99, note 20.
  187. Veldman and Richards, “Familiar” (see note 29), p. 97.
  188. Bernard Picart, Cérémonies et coutumes religieuses de tous les peuples du monde, Amsterdam 1723–1743, p. 345.
  189. As Petra van Boheemen noted, the “interest of the neighbourhood is visible” in Picart’s print. Petra van Boheemen et al., Kent, en versint, eer datje mint: vrijen en trouwen, 1500–1800, Apeldoorn, Historisch Museum Marialust; Zwolle 1989, p. 170.
  190. Van Boheemen, Kent (see note 33), pp. 170–172; H. Perry Chapman, Jan Steen, Painter and Storyteller, exh. cat., Washington, DC, National Gallery of Art; Amsterdam, Rijksmuseum 1996, pp. 116–118 note 1, cat. no. 6.
  191. Van Boheemen, Kent (see note 33), p. 170.
  192. Irma Thoen, Strategic Affection? Gift Exchange in Seventeenth-Century Holland, Amsterdam 2007, p. 106.
  193. Fynes Moryson and Charles Hughes, Shakespeare’s Europe. Unpublished Chapters of Fynes Moryson’s Itinerary Being a Survey of the Condition of Europe at the End of the 16th Century, London 1903, pp. 379–380.
  194. A. Lynn Martin, Alcohol, Sex, and Gender in Late Medieval and Early Modern Europe, New York 2001, pp. 52–53; Thoen, Strategic (see note 36), p. 105.
  195. See, for example, Jan Steen’s The Wedding of Tobias and Sarah, c. 1667–1668, oil on canvas, 131 x 172 cm, Braunschweig, Herzog Anton Ulrich-Museum; Chapman, Jan Steen (see note 34), pp. 203–205, cat. no. 32.
  196. Philips Angel, Lof der schilder-konst, Leyden 1642, p. 48. Translation from: Philips Angel, Michael Hoyle, and Hessel Miedema, “Philips Angel, Praise of Painting,” Simiolus, Netherlandish Quarterly for the History of Art 24 (1996), p. 246.
  197. A. M. van der Woude, “Variations in Size and Structure of the Household in the United Provinces of the Netherlands in the Seventeenth and Eighteenth Centuries,” in: Household and Family in Past Time: Comparative Studies in the Size and Structure of the Domestic Group over the Last Three Centuries in England, France, Serbia, Japan and Colonial North America, with Further Materials from Western Europe, Cambridge 1972, p. 315.
  198. Jan Jansz Orlers, Beschrijvinge der stadt Leyden, 2nd ed., Leiden 1641, p. 375; Walter L. Strauss et al., Rembrandt Documents, New York 1979, doc. 1641/8. For rare objections, see Roelof van Straten, Young Rembrandt. The Leiden Years, 1606-1632, Leiden 2005, p. 16; Benjamin Binstock, ‚The birth of Rembrandt‘, in Michiel Roscam Abbing, ed., Rembrandt 2006. Essays, Leiden 2006, pp. 267-278 (arguing for 1607).
  199. Strauss, Rembrandt Documents, doc. 1669/6.
  200. E.B.F.F. Wittert van Hoogland, ‚Genealogie van den tak van het geslacht van Tetrode, welke zich Vinck genoemd heeft. Reconstructie van de genealogie voorkomende in het stam- en wapenboek van aanzienlijke Nederlandsche geslachten. Memoriael Gemaeck door N(icolaas) S(ebastiaensz.) V(inck)‘, Genealogische en heraldische bladen 1 (1906), pp. 122-149.
  201. Dirk Rühl, ‚Het wapen van Rembrandt’s broeder Willem Harmensz. van Rijn een gelegenheids-wapen? Een heraldisch probleem‘, Gens Nostra. Maandblad van de Nederlandsche Genealogische Vereniging 11 (1956), pp. 117-128, esp. p. 127.
  202. Strauss et al., Rembrandt Documents, doc. 1669/4 (misspelling the name as ‚Vlinck‘). See also: http://remdoc.huygens.knaw.nl/#/document/remdoc/e13470 (accessed 22 December 2022).
  203. Warm thanks to Ingrid Pot for her kind assistance, and to P.J.M. De Baar for an impromptu consultation on the document, manuscript LB 6761 klein deel, Erfgoed Leiden en Omstreken, Leiden (hereafter ELO). The notebook is chronological but unpaginated; we therefore cite Wittert van Hoogland. See further Stephanie S. Dickey, ‚Ars longa vita brevis. Rembrandt’s death and the status of the artist in late seventeenth-century Amsterdam‘, Nederlands Kunsthistorisch Jaarboek 72 (2022), pp. 234-271.
  204. R.E.O. Ekkart, ‚Familiekroniek Van Heemskerck en Van Swanenburg (I)‘, Jaarboek van het Centraal Bureau voor Genealogie 32 (1978), pp. 41-70; idem., ‚Familiekroniek Van Heemskerck en Van Swanenburg (II)‘, Jaarboek van het Centraal Bureau voor Genealogie 33 (1979), pp. 44-75 (deaths of Cornelis and Sylvester van Swanenburgh, pp. 54, 72, 75). See also Gary Schwartz, Rembrandt, his life, his paintings, New York 1985, p. 22; https://www.mijnstambomen.nl/leiden/swanenburg.htm (accessed 16 December 2022). The dates of Silvester van Swanenburgh’s death and burial are unrecorded; he prepared his will on 12 October 1669, being siechelick van lichaem leggende te bedde (sick in bed); ELO, 0506, notary Justus Gerstecoren, no. 1144, deed 124, 12-10-1669.
  205. Wittert van Hoogland, ‚Genealogie‘, p. 135.
  206. Wittert van Hoogland, ‚Genealogie‘, pp. 136, 137. Burial: https://archief.amsterdam/archief/5001/1056 (accessed 16 December 2022).
  207. Wittert van Hoogland, ‚Genealogie‘, pp. 135.
  208. Ekkart, ‚Familiekroniek‘, pp. 54, 72.
  209. Rudi van Maanen and Leendert van Maanen, ‘De grote epidemie van 1669-1670’, Leids Jaarboekje 2021, pp. 67-83, with further references.
  210. See Dickey, ‚Ars longa vita brevis‚, with further references.
  211. See esp. Christaan Vogelaar and Gerbrand Korevaar, eds., Rembrandt’s Mother. Myth and Reality, exh. cat. Leiden: Stedelijk Museum de Lakenhal 2005, pp. 88-91, 97-98, cat. 3-6, 9-10.
  212. We are grateful to Jos Beerens and Weixuan Li for advice on software to visualize this data.
  213. Reymptgen’s husband, Cornelis Bartholomeusz (Meesz.) van Tetrode (1505-1550), a grain dealer in Leiden, died before Neeltje and Bastiaen were born. See Strauss et al., Rembrandt Documents, doc. 1561/1, 1574/3, 1579/1, 1581/1,1582/2.
  214. Strauss et al., Rembrandt Documents, p. 24.
  215. Gerrit Cornelisz. Vinck is registered living in Leiden 1544-1583; Historisch Leiden in Kaart, https://historischleideninkaart.nl/persoonformulier/?Id=8986 (accessed 16 December 2022). He became poorter of Delft in 1584; Stadsarchief Delft, 1.733, fol. 054v, 5-5-1584. See also W.C. Tettero, Genealogie van Tetrode 1300-1600, Voorburg 2000, p. 61; J.P. Jacobs, ‘Rembrandt verwant met Philips van Leyden’, De Nederlandse Leeuw 102 (1985), column 457-465.
  216. See also ELO, Stadsarchief van Leiden, 0501A, 6597, Register Vetus 1582-1601, p. 8v. ‚t Gulden Warken belonged to Reymptgen In 1579; by 1581, she had transferred ownership to Dirck; Strauss et al., Rembrandt Documents, p. 31 and doc. 1579/1, 1581/1, 1585/1.
  217. Wittert van Hoogland, p. 123. Walsburch was buried several weeks later; SAA DTB 5001, 1054, p. 46vo, 8-5-1629. Prenuptual agreement, SAA 5075, 445, not. Palm Mathijsz, 17-2-1631.
  218. SAA DTB 5001, 671, p. 33 (marriage bans) 27-1-1628; DTB 1054, p. 46vo, 8-5-1629 (burial record).
  219. Wittert van Hoogland, p. 124. They married on 10 May at the Begijnhof and 13 May at the Amsterdam Town Hall.
  220. Wittert van Hoogland, p. 126. Clara became a begijn in 1643 and registered her will as a bejaaarde geestelijke dochter, wonende op het Begijnhof, in 1655, appointing her brothers her heirs; SAA 5075, 2454, not. R. Duee, akte nummer 57860, 8-10-1655.
  221. Wittert van Hoogland, p. 127; SAA, DTB 676, p. 145, 2-1-1642; 5033 Poorterboeken, no. 2, p. 199, 24-4-1642. In 1647 Albert purchased a home on the Haarlemmerstraat; SAA, 5073, Kwijtscheldingen, no. 928, 5-1-1647. He posted the banns for his second marriage, to Grietje Harmens van der Aa, on 2 December 1655; SAA, DTB 682, p. 356, 2-12-1655.
  222. Wittert van Hoogland, p. 127.
  223. SAA DTB, 1055, p. 94v (Clara); 1056, p. 252, 26-6-1683 (Albert).
  224. Cornelis was recorded on 24 April 1587 as a baker, age 21. In 1600, he purchased a house later owned by Karel van der Pluym. Strauss et al., Rembrandt Documents, doc. 1581/2, 1662/4; Schwartz, Rembrandt, p. 18 (diagram of Rembrandt’s family tree by P.J.M. de Baar).
  225. Strauss et al., Rembrandt Documents, doc. 1662/4; Marieke de Winkel, ‚“Cousin“ Karel van der Pluym and the benefit of family‘, in Epco Runia and David de Witt, eds., Rembrandt’s Social Network. Family, friends, acquaintances, exh. cat., Amsterdam: Museum het Rembrandthuis 2019, pp. 61-65, citing a red and black chalk drawing on vellum, dated 1634 (private collection in New York).
  226. See Koos Levy-Halm, ‚Where did Vermeer buy his painting materials? Theory and practice‘, in Ivan Gaskell and Michiel Jonker, eds., National Gallery Studies in the History of Art, Vol. 55, Vermeer Studies, 1988, pp. 137-143; Jo Kirby, ‚The painter’s trade in the seventeenth century: theory and practice‘, National Gallery Technical Bulletin 20 (1999), pp. 5-49.
  227. See Stephanie S. Dickey, Rembrandt. Portraits in Print, Amsterdam/Philadelphia 2004, pp. 141-149; Runia and De Witt, eds., Rembrandt’s Social Network, p. 124.
  228. Orlers, Beschryvinge, p. 373; https://rkd.nl/explore/artists/51111 (accessed 2 January 2023)
  229. Rudolf E.O. Ekkart, Isaac Claesz. van Swanenburgh 1537-1614, Zwolle 1998, p. 14. For the prenuptial agreement, Jacobge was assisted by her father Claes Isaacsz and her brothers Isaac Claesz and Claes Claesz; ELO, 0508 Het oude rechterlijke archief van Leiden, no. 76B-2, fol. 375, 15-10-1570.
  230. ELO, 0501A, Stadsarchief van Leiden, 1574-1816, no. 1289, Register van de volkstelling 1581, fol. 9.
  231. See Marije Osnabrugge, The Neapolitan Lives and Careers of Netherlandish Immigrant Painters (1575-1655), Amsterdam 2019, esp. pp. 66-73, 115-123. The Antwerp-born portraitist Abraham Vinck (1574/75-1619) associated with Jacob van Swanenburgh in Hamburg 1589-1598 and later in Naples; in 1602, he witnessed Van Swanenburgh’s marriage to Margaretha Cardone. He lived in Amsterdam 1609-1619. Rembrandt’s bankruptcy inventory includes ‚een doode Contrefijtsel van Abraham Vinck‚; Strauss et al., Rembrandt Documents, doc. 1656/12, no. 86, but we have not yet found a link between Abraham and the Vinck family discussed here.
  232. Ekkart, Isaac Claesz. van Swanenburgh, esp. p. 71; Schwartz, Rembrandt, pp. 22-23.
  233. Strauss et al., Rembrandt Documents, doc. 1620/1; Jef Schaeps and Mart van Duijn, Rembrandt en de Universiteit Leiden, Leiden 2019, esp. p. 28.
  234. Orlers, Beschryvinge, p. 375.
  235. Ekkart, ‚Familiekroniek‘, pp. 71-72. Schwartz, Rembrandt, p. 17; Van Straten, Young Rembrandt, p. 24.
  236. ELO, Register van poorterinschrijvingen F, 1267, fol. 279v, 16-4-1638; Buurquestieboeken, 48G, fol. 105v, no. 2355, 12-9-1661; 0506, Notary Justus Gerstecoren, 1144, deed no. 124, 12-10-1669.
  237. Ernst van de Wetering, ‚Rembrandt’s gift and the underrated importance of his apprenticeship with Jacob isaacsz. van Swanenburg‘, in Ernst van de Wetering and Bernhard Schnackenburg, eds., The Mystery of the Young Rembrandt, exh. cat., Kassel: Gemäldegalerie Alte Meister and Amsterdam: Museum het Rembrandthuis 2001, pp. 32-38.
  238. Strauss, et al., Rembrandt Documents, p. 69, doc. 1630/5; Schwartz, Rembrandt, p. 23; English translation: Wheelock, ed., et al., Jan Lievens, p. 286.
  239. Bakker, ‚Rembrandt and the emergence‘; Vogelaar, ‚Rembrandt in Leiden‘; Orlers, Beschryvinge, p. 376.
  240. See Boudewijn Bakker, ‚Rembrandt and the humanist ideal of the universal painter‘, in Stephanie S. Dickey, ed., Rembrandt and his Circle. Insights and Discoveries, Amsterdam 2017, pp. 67-98.
  241. Volker Manuth, Marieke de Winkel and Rudie van Leeuwen, Rembrandt. The Complete Paintings, Cologne 2019, cat. 121.
  242. Carel Vosmaer, Rembrandt. Sa vie et ses oeuvres, The Hague 1877, pp. 28-35, 469, 461, unaware of Vinck’s Memoriael, posited a relationship to the Van Swanenburghs on Rembrandt’s father’s side. Ekkart, Isaac Claesz van Swanenburgh, p. 11, dismissed this. However, Claes Cornelisz van Berckel, half-brother of Harmen Gerritsz van Rijn, was married to Brechtje Mourijnsdr. van Swanenburch. The half-brothers lived next door to each other on the Weddesteeg in 1605 and 1624 and owned a mill together; ELO, Buurquesties 48B, blad 2, aktenummer 520, 4-4-1605; 48D, blad 201, aktenumer 1339, 22-4-1624; Tiende Register, Bon Noord-Rijnevest (B), Stadsvrijdom en molens op de wallen, archiefnummer 501A, Stukken betreffende afzonderlijke onderwerpen; Registratie van onroerend goed 1585-1816 (1819), inventarisnummer 6634, blad 31, 1602-1724. It is not yet clear how Brechtje Mourijnsdr. connects to Jacob and Silvester van Swanenburgh. See also Schwartz, Rembrandt, pp. 21-25.
  243. For context, see S.A.C. Dudok van Heel, ‚Rembrandt van Rijn (1606-1669), een remonstrantsgezind schilder uit calvinistisch Leiden‘, in idem., De jonge Rembrandt onder tijdgenoten. Godsdienst en schilderkunst in Leiden en Amsterdam, Nijmegen 2006, pp. 177-223.
  244. On art patronage in Leiden, see esp. Gerbrand Korevaar, ‚Leiden in Rembrandt’s time‘, in Van de Wetering and Schnackenburg, Mystery, pp. 12-21; Piet Bakker, ‚Rembrandt and the emergence of the Leiden art market‘, in Jacquelyn N. Coutré, ed., Leiden ca. 1630. Rembrandt Emerges, exh. cat., Kingston: Agnes Etherington Art Centre 2019, pp. 66-95. We are grateful to Piet Bakker for advice on the present essay.
  245. Dirk Traudenius, Tyd-zifter, Amsterdam 1662, p. 16; Arnold Houbraken, De groote schouburgh der Nederlandtsche konstschilders en schilderessen, Amsterdam 1718-21, III, p. 33; H. Schneider, ed. by R.E.O. Ekkart, Jan Lievens, Sein Leben und Seine Werke, Amsterdam 1973, p. 151, no. 262; https://houbraken-translated.rkdstudies.nl/3-1-59/page-30-39/ (accessed 16 December 2022,) with English translation. The painting has not been discovered.
  246. Wheelock, ed., Jan Lievens, pp. 3, 16-17, fig. 19. The painting was destroyed in 1929.
  247. On their extended connection, see Stephanie S. Dickey, ‚Jan Lievens in Rembrandt’s house‘, Kroniek van het Rembrandthuis 2008, pp. 36-53.
  248. As noted above, Cornelis van Swanenburgh’s mother was Adriana van Leeuwen. Rembrandt’s oldest brother, Adriaen van Rijn, married Lystbertgen Symonsdr van Leeuwen in 1617, and Willem van Rijn married Willempje Pietersdr van Steylandt, widow of Jacob Symonsz van Leeuwen, in 1636; Rühl, ‚Het wapen‘, pp. 117-119, 123.
  249. Bakker, ‚Rembrandt and the Emergence‘, pp. 81-83; Wheelock, ed., Jan Lievens, p. 84, cat. 2.
  250. Orlers, Beschryvinge, pp. 367-377; Bakker, ‚Rembrandt and the emergence‘, p. 82. One of these was a ‚Pylatus‘, possibly Pilate Washing his Hands (Raleigh, North Carolina Museum of Art); Wheelock, ed., Jan Lievens, p. 289.
  251. Strauss et al., Rembrandt Documents, doc. 1663/7; Schwartz, Rembrandt, p. 37; Dudok van Heel, ‚Rembrandt van Rijn‘, pp. 190-193; Christopher Brown, An van Camp and Christiaan Vogelaar, eds., Young Rembrandt, exh. cat., Leiden: Museum De Lakenhal and Oxford: Ashmolean Museum 2019, pp. 24, 158-160. Angela Jager is preparing a study of art patronage in Rembrandt’s family network.
  252. Bakker, ‚Rembrandt and the Emergence‘, pp. 85-90.  See also C. Willemijn Fock, trans. by Anne Baudoin, ‚Art ownership in Leiden in the seventeenth century‘, Journal of Historians of Netherlandish Art  13:1 (2021), DOI: 10.5092/jhna.2021.13.1.4.

In memoriam Ernst van de Wetering (1938-2021)

On 11 August of this year Ernst van de Wetering, former Head of the Rembrandt Research Project (RRP) and Professor Emeritus of Art History of the Early Modern Period at the University of Amsterdam (UvA), passed away. As the world’s foremost Rembrandt connoisseur, Ernst van de Wetering was of great significance to the Rembrandt House Museum. Years of intensive collaboration between him and the museum led to high profile exhibitions, that brought the museum onto the international stage. And his research into Rembrandt’s working methods and studio practice contributed to the installation and the educational activities of the museum as a seventeenth-century artist’s house.

 

Photo: ANP / Juan Vrijdag, In the large painting studio (groote schildercaemer) of the Rembrandt House at the opening of Rembrandt: The Quest of a Genius, 30 March 2006
Photo: ANP / Juan Vrijdag, In the large painting studio (groote schildercaemer) of the Rembrandt House at the opening of Rembrandt: The Quest of a Genius, 30 March 2006

In the research that he conducted over decades on the painted oeuvre of Rembrandt, insight into seventeenth-century working practice played a central role. In the Rembrandt House he thus felt at home. After all, one cannot get any closer to the artist. After Ernst had assumed leadership of the Rembrandt Research Project – of which he had been a part since its founding in 1968 – he encountered the Rembrandt House on his path. In 1995 he took a place on its board, in a period during which the museum was to undergo a fundamental change. A new museum wing beside the historic house would finally offer space for changing exhibitions of considerable size. This expansion, which opened in 1998, also made it possible to return the former house to its seventeenth-century state, to give an impression of how Rembrandt lived and worked in the house. Ernst was intimately involved in the development of plans for the installation of both of the painting studios.

Under the inspiring leadership of then-curator Bob van den Boogert, and under the oversight of director Ed de Heer, plans were made with Ernst for Rembrandt exhibitions of international calibre with important loans. The first exhibition of an intended trio became The Mystery of the Young Rembrandt, over the early years of Rembrandt’s artistic career. This was organized in 2001-2002 in collaboration with the Gemäldegalerie Schloss Wilhelmshöhe in Kassel. In the Rembrandt anniversary year 2006 there followed Rembrandt: The Quest of a Genius in collaboration with the Gemäldegalerie Berlin, on Rembrandt’s artistic crisis and renewal after the completion of the Night Watch. The third part, that would cover the final years of Rembrandt’s oeuvre, was never realized – partly owing to internal problems that affected the Rembrandt House in 2008 and 2009, about which Ernst was very critical.

In studying Rembrandt’s paintings, Ernst steadfastly referred to the drawn and etched oeuvre of the artist. His fascination for prints resulted in the 2009-2010 exhibition Rembrandt gespiegeld (Rembrandt Reflected), based on an idea of his. Original impressions of etchings by Rembrandt from the museum’s collection were displayed next to reproductions in mirror image. The result was a surprising insight into the compositions that Rembrandt had conceived when he was drawing them on the etching plates. Due to the printing process, however, these images have come down to us in mirror image. This exhibition generated a new understanding of the artistic intentions that Rembrandt had when he made his etchings. In an introductory film Ernst enthusiastically related how these new observations give us a glimpse into the mind of the master.

Besides these thematic exhibitions, in which the visitor (in some cases also with Ernst’s voice in their ears through the audiotour) was taken along in new insights over Rembrandt as an artist, important small presentations took place. Ernst’s research into the stylistic, technical and material aspects of the work of Rembrandt brough spectacular discoveries to light and led to new attributions. These were often the result of study of paintings with technical and scientific research methods. The application of such techniques were very present for Ernst in his approach to art historical research. Between 2003 (the discovery of an early self-portrait that had been overpainted) and 2011 (the discovery of a tronie of an old man painted by Rembrandt), various new finds were presented in the Rembrandt House. Such events attracted international press coverage and drew visitors to the museum.

Foto ANP / Marco Okhuizen, in Rembrandt’s Salon, at the presentation of the Tronie of an Old Man, 2011
Foto ANP / Marco Okhuizen, in Rembrandt’s Salon, at the presentation of the Tronie of an Old Man, 2011

Ernst had a special talent for captivating his audience. This is what drew me to Amsterdam in 1996 to come and study with him at the UvA. Ernst’s lectures were inspiring experiences that gave one the feeling of attending a special event. He let his listeners look, as it were, over his shoulder, by bringing them with detail images ever closer to the brush strokes. Also in the Rembrandt House Ernst shared his insights with visitors and staff. The palpable excitement turned every lecture into  a memorable occasion. The knowledge that Ernst shared with us on Rembrandt’s painting technique, studio practice, function of art works or ideas on art has been decisive for the ways in which curatorial and educational staff members have carried out their activities. We look back in gratitude on these moments and treasure the extensive knowledge that Ernst left us in his publications.

Leonore van Sloten, former student of Ernst van de Wetering and Curator at the Rembrandt House Museum

 

  1. Werner Sumowski, Paul Huys Janssen, The Hoogsteder Exhibition of Rembrandt’s Academy, exh. cat. The Hague: Hoogsteder & Hoogsteder, 1992, cat. no. 28.
  2. Exhibition catalogues: Albert Blanckert, Jezus in de Gouden Eeuw, exh. cat. Rotterdam: Kunsthal, 2000–2001; Akira Kofuku, Rembrandt and the Rembrandt School. The Bible, mythology and ancient history, exh. cat. Tokyo: Museum of Western Art, 2003; Arthur K. Wheelock et al., Jan Lievens. A Dutch Master Rediscovered, exh. cat. Washington: National Gallery of Art; Milwaukee: Milwaukee Art Museum; Amsterdam: Rembrandt House Museum, 2008-2009, cat.no. 52; Louis van Tilborgh, Constantijn Huygens. Kunstkenner en verzamelaar, exh. cat. The Hague: Museum Bredius, 2013, cat. no. 14. Other literature: Werner Sumowski, Gemälde der Rembrandtschüler, vol. 4, Landau, 1983, p. 3726, no. 2356, fig. 3964; Helga Gutbrod, Lievens und Rembrandt : Studien zum Verhältnis ihrer Kunst, Frankfurt am Main, 1996, p. 299; Edwin Buijssen (ed.), Haagse schilders in de Gouden Eeuw, Het Hoogsteder lexicon van alle schilders werkzaam in Den Haag 1600-1700, The Hague, 1998, p. 191; Lloyd DeWitt, Evolution and Ambition in the career of Jan Lievens, 1607-1674, Phd. Diss. University of Maryland, College Park, 2006, p. 228.
  3. DeWitt, Evolution (see note 2), p. 228.
  4. For example those mentioned in the Montias Database of 17th Century Dutch Art Inventories and the Getty Provenance Research Index.
  5. Sumowski, Huys Janssen, Academy (see note 1), p. 220.
  6. Dr Gaston Gaudinot sale, Paris (Drouot), 13-14 February 1869.
  7. Sumowski, Huys Janssen, Academy (see note 1), p. 220.
  8. Ibid.
  9. Sumowski, Huys Janssen, Academy (see note 1), p. 226. Huys Janssen explains that the miracle as described in Luke and John differs from the version told by Matthew.
  10. After listening to the centurion, and before addressing him directly, Jesus speaks to his followers: “I tell you, many will come from east and west and sit at table with Abraham, Isaac, and Jacob in the kingdom of heaven.” (Matthew 8:11) Perhaps Lievens incorporated this part of the text and explicitly included people coming from the east (from the standpoint of his Dutch audience). A second possibility is that they are Pharisees. This group plays the role elsewhere in Matthew of disbelieving critics, and here they may serve to accentuate the belief of the centurion in the Christian faith. In early prints (Sebald Beham, Israhel van Meckenem, Hans Schaüfelein and Cornelis Massijs) and several Italian prints from Lievens’s time (seventeenth century prints after Paolo Veronese), Pharisees wear such headdresses. A parallel between blacks and overseas regions, such as in Lievens’s Brinio, is convincingly outlined by Elmer Kolfin (in: Elmer Kolfin, De kunst van de macht, Jordaens, Lievens en Rembrandt in het Paleis op de Dam, Zwolle, 2023, p. 67), does not seem to apply here.
  11. Sumowski, Huys Janssen, Academy (see note 1), p. 223.
  12. Sumowski, Huys Janssen, Academy (see note 1), pp. 223, 226.
  13. The right eye from the perspective of the viewer. There, a pupil was painted in, in a later restoration. Because of the sketchy manner it is difficult to ascertain whether or not both eyes are present, but in the left the lower eyelid is visible, while it is undefined in the right eye.
  14. For example: Jacobus Neeffs (after Jacob Jordaens), Judgement of Christ, etching, c. 1630-1645; Marinus van der Goes (after Jacques Jordaens), Judgement of Christ, engraving, c. 1614-1639; Willem Panneels (after Peter Paul Rubens), Adoration of the kings, etching, 1630; Nicolaes Lauwers (after Peter Paul Rubens), Ecce Homo, engraving, c. 1619-1652; and many more. Generally, for examples of inspiration drawn from prints by Lievens, see De
    Witt, Evolution (see note 2).
  15. Sumowski, Huys Janssen, Academy (see note 1), p. 226. Huys Janssen refers to examples by Nicolaes Moeyaert (Herentals, St. Waltrudis church) and Adam Camerarius (Amsterdam, Rijksmuseum, inv. no. SK-A-733). DeWitt refers to a painting by Bartholomeus Breenbergh (Karlsruhe, Staatliche Kunsthalle Karlsruhe, inv. no. 228) and the Moeyaert in Herentals (DeWitt, Evolution (see note 2), p. 227). But also see a woodcut with this subject by Cornelis van Sichem II in Der zielen lusthof (1629). Also of interest: Claes Moeyeart, Christ and the Centurion, 1632 (Minneapolis, Minneapolis Institute of Art, inv. no. 2012.84.5). Although the painting is known under this subject, it may in fact depict Cornelius kneeling before Peter, since more than one figure is shown kneeling and the composition closely resembles prints of this subject.
  16. Henri van de Waal, “’s Lands oudste verleden in de voorstelling van Vondel en zijn tijdgenooten”, Elsevier’s Maandschrift 47 (1937); Henri van de Waal, “Tempesta en de historieschilderingen op het Amsterdamse stadhuis”, Oud Holland 56 (1939); Henri van de Waal, Drie eeuwen vaderlandsche geschied-uitbeelding 1500-1800, een iconologische studie, The Hague, 1952; Kolfin, Kunst (see note 10).
  17. Antonio Tempesta (after Otto van Veen), Print 8 in (…)De Batavische oft oude Hollandtsche oorloghe teghen de Romeynen, 1612. Etching, 167 x 210 mm. Rijksmuseum, Amsterdam, inv. no. RP-P-OB-37.614. Jürgen Ovens based his drawing for the Batavian Series depicting Claudius Civilis leaving the Women and Children to fight at Xanten (Hamburg, Hamburger Kunsthalle, inv. no. 22342) on this print.
  18. On the period in The Hague: Buijssen Haagse (see note 2), pp.191-193.
  19. Haarlem, Teylers Museum, inv. no. P 006. For the identification and context, see: Gregor Weber, “Dus leeft de dappre Graaf: Zu einem Bildnis Andries de Graeffs von Jan Lievens (1607-1674)”, Oud Holland 99 (1985), pp. 44-56.
  20. Van de Waal, Eeuwen (see note 16), p. 230; Kolfin, De kunst van de macht (see note 10), pp. 19-20.
  21. Van de Waal, “’s Lands” (see note 16), p. 301-302.
  22.  Kolfin, Kunst (see note 10), p. 41. Four Batavian scenes were never completed. For two the themes are known, for the other two are not known.
  23. Munich, Staatliche Graphische Sammlung München, inv. no. 1451; Hamburg, Hamburger Kunsthalle, Kupferstichkabinett, inv. no. 22342. A lesser-known drawing of Rembrandt’s Conspiracy of Claudius Civilis (Edinburgh, National Galleries of Scotland, inv. no. D 23862) shows – when compared to the drawing in Munich – that the lower section of the painting is covered by a frieze and that portions of the left and right sides are obscured. This may indicate that an alternative conception of the framing of the lunettes was considered before the one ultimately implemented. It is possible that this earlier framing was already envisioned when Lievens produced his oil sketch Christ and the Centurion.
  24. Van de Waal, Eeuwen (see note 16), p. 225, referring to SAA, 5039, 2 resolutieboek, f. 66r.
  25. Ibid., referring to SAA, 5039, 153 rapiamus 1661, f.195v.
  26. Van de Waal, Eeuwen (see note 16), p. 225.
  27. Gregor Weber, “Jan Lievens’s ‘The Shield-raising of Brinio’ a Second Oil Sketch”, Hoogsteder-Naumann Mercury 12/13 (1992), nt. 8.
  28. Dewitt, Evolution (see note 2), p. 221.
  29. Kolfin, Kunst (see note 10), p.67.
  30. Kolfin, Kunst (see note 10), p. 44.
  31. For, among other things, contemporary poetry in which Civilis and others are compared to the members of the House of Orange: Van de Waal, Eeuwen (see note 16), pp. 220-221, 223.
  32. Kolfin, Kunst (see note 10), p. 47.
  33. Margriet van Eikema Hommes, Elmer Kolfin, De Oranjezaal in Huis ten Bosch, Een zaal uit loutere liefde, Zwolle, 2013, p. 77.
  34. Kolfin, Kunst (see note 10), pp. 41-47, 77.
  35. One may ask, in light of points discussed in this article, whether the “Christ” figure in the first version was in fact Christ at all. If so, the oil sketch would initially have represented solely a Christian scene without any reference to the Batavian Revolt, thereby less relatable to the (eventual) decoration program of the Town Hall’s gallery. Given that in the initial design the groups left and right with Biblical and/or eastern figures do not seem to have been included (aside from a bearded man on the right, judging from the x-ray), the large central figure may originally have been Julius Civilis. In compositional terms, this would align the painting more closely with the print by Tempesta after Van Veen. The apparent similarity in hairstyle between the final Christ figure and the initial figure, together with the possible initial presence of a (holy) beam of light directed toward the figure, may argue against this hypothesis; nevertheless, Brinno in Lievens’s Brinio Raised on the Shield likewise features long hair and even incorporates a diagonal compositional line through the clouds, comparable to the line through the foliage in the initial version of the present subject. The later insertion of Christ could then be understood as a deliberate twist, imparting a more prominent Christian meaning to the historical scene. These suggestions and observations were kindly shared by Jochem van Eijsden.
  36. Samuel van Hoogstraten, Inleyding tot de hooge schoole der schilderkonst: anders de zichtbaere werelt, Rotterdam 1678, p. 18. Van Hoogstraten here refers to the period when he was “still a disciple”, during which, as part of a “we”, he and others discussed a particular question, to which a certain “Fabritius” responded with an answer. It is generally assumed that this refers to Carel Fabritius, who is assumed to have studied with Rembrandt between approximately 1641 and 1643.
  37. Werner Sumowski described Van Hoogstraten as “pädagogisch begabt, Assistent Rembrandts gewesen” (Werner Sumowski, Gemälde der Rembrandt-Schüler II, Landau/Pfalz 1984, p. 1286). As supporting evidence, Sumowski argued that Van Hoogstraten corrected drawings by Constantijn Daniël van Renesse (; p. 1290, nt. 2). When discussing one of these drawings (Moses and Reuel’s Daughters at the Well, Amsterdam, Rijksmuseum, inv. no. RP-T-1893-A-2782) Sumowski suggested the possibility that “Samuel van Hoogstraten acted as assistant to the master on occasional trips even at a later date”. (Werner Sumowski, Drawings of the Rembrandt School IX, New York 1985, no. 2159x). Building on this, Jonathan Bikker suggested in his monograph on Willem Drost that Van Hoogstraten “might have supervised Drost during his early days in Rembrandt’s studio” (Jonathan Bikker, Willem Drost, A Rembrandt Pupil in Amsterdam and Venice, New Haven/London 2005, p. 11). David de Witt later observed, in his Abraham van Dijck monograph, concerning Van Hoogstraten: “by 1646 his training would have been complete, but he appears to have stayed on as a tutor or head pupil for several years” (David De Witt, Life and Work of Late Rembrandt Pupil Abraham van Dijck, c. 1635-1680, Amsterdam 2020, p. 11).
  38. Sabine Pénot, Rembrandt – Hoogstraten. Colour and Illusion, exh. cat. Vienna: Kunsthistorisches Museum Wien, 2024; Nathalie Maciesza, Epco Runia, Samuel van Hoogstraten. De Illusionist, exh. cat. Amsterdam: Rembrandt House Museum, 2025; Sabine van Beek, Leonore van Sloten, David de Witt et al., Samuel van Hoogstraten: Catalogue Raisonné, The Hague 2025.
  39. The catalogue of the Vienna exhibition assumes a position for Van Hoogstraten as an assistant for approximately three to four years (Angelina Illes, in: exh. cat. Vienna 2024 (see note 3), p. 29; Jonathan Bikker, in: exh. cat. Vienna 2024 (see note 3), p. 93), though it makes no mention of any teaching responsibilities. These are, however, included in the publication accompanying the exhibition at the Rembrandt House Museum (Michiel Roscam Abbing, in: exh. cat. Amsterdam 2025 (see note 3), p. 19; David De Witt, in: exh. cat. Amsterdam 2025 (see note 3), p. 131), and in the online Van Hoogstraten catalogue raisonné by the RKD (Michiel Roscam Abbing, in: The Hague 2025 (see note 3), “With Rembrandt in Amsterdam”. https://vanhoogstraten.rkdstudies.nl/samuel-van-hoogstraten-the-ingenious-and-poetic-painter/with-rembrandt-inamsterdam/, 26 May 2025).
  40. The term “assistent” was used in Holland in the 17th century, albeit in other contexts, see: Woordenboek Nederlandse taal, s.v. assistent, https://gtb.ivdnt.org/iWDB/search?actie=article&wdb=WNT&id=M004535&lemma=assistent&domein=0&conc=true, 11
    July 2025.
  41. “Een min of meer ondergeschikte helper”, a more or less subordinate helper (see note 5); “A person who helps or supports somebody, usually in their job”: Oxford English Dictionary, s.v. assistant, https://www.oed.com/view/Entry/12041, 11 July 2025.
  42. The guild archive has been lost. For a comprehensive account of the Amsterdam Guild of Saint Luke and its ordinances, see: Isabella H. van Eeghen, “Schilders of Sint Lucasgilde”, in: Isabella H. van Eeghen (ed.), Inventarissen der archieven van de gilden en van het brouwerscollege, Amsterdam 1951, passim.; Isabella H. van Eeghen (Jasper Hillegers, translator), “The Amsterdam Guild of Saint Luke in the 17th Century”, Journal of Historians for Netherlandish Art 4.2 (2012), passim., DOI:10.5092/jhna.2012.4.2.4, 11 July 2025. The current article relies exclusively on the guild regulations of the Amsterdam De Kroniek 2024/25 – Museum Rembrandthuis 10 painters’ guild. It is often assumed that the regulations of painters’ guilds in different Dutch towns did not differ substantially in content. On that assumption, gaps in the regulations of one town might be filled by those of another. However, the discussion later in this article regarding whether apprentices were permitted to produce their own work shows that crucial differences did in fact exist. For that reason, guild regulations from other cities are not used here to fill the gaps in the surviving Amsterdam regulations.
  43. Extract van de willekeuren en ordonnantien den gilde van St. Lucas verleent, Amsterdam 1720, p. 11.
  44. Extract (see note 8), p. 11; This is also the case in the chapter title and margin of the 1766 publication of all known guild charters: Ordonnantien en willekeuren van het Lucas-gilde binnen Amsterdam, Amsterdam 1766, p. 64, 68. It is noteworthy that the dean and headmen of the guild employed a gilde kneght (Extract (see note 8), pp. 26-27. This was not a pupilship, and the tasks meet the definition of an assistant in the Oxford English Dictionary and the Woordenboek Nederlandse Taal (see note 6)
  45. Extract (see note 8), pp. 12-13
  46. Extract (see note 8), pp. 11-12.
  47. Extract (see note 8), p. 12.
  48. Cornelis Kiliaen (ed. Frans Claes), Etymologicum teutonicae linguae, Antwerp 1599 (The Hague 1972), p. 278, s.v. leerionghe; leer-kind; leer-knecht; leerlinck; p. 703, s.v. discipel. In the regulations of the Haarlem Guild of St. Luke from 1634 (NHA, 1105, Ambachtsgilden te Haarlem (Gilden Haarlem), no. 219), the terms “leerling”, “leerjongen”, and “discipel” are
    used. This might suggest that a distinction existed between them, but they are actually used interchangeably. The same applies to the terms “(werk)gezel”, “knecht”, and – a new term – “gast”. The latter is synonymous with journeyman or servant: “Knecht van een ambachtsman of fabrikant; gezel, werkknecht”, servant of a tradesman or manufacturer; journeyman, workshop hand: Woordenboek Nederlandse taal, s.v. gast, https://gtb.ivdnt.org/iWDB/searchactie=article&wdb=WNT&id=M017355.re.35&lemma=werkgast&domein=0&conc=true,
    16 oktober 2025.
  49. Kiliaen, Etymologicum (see note 13), p. 139, s.v. ghe-selle van een ampt. The Latin word “collega” is likewise a translation for “ambtgenoot”, “maet”, and “vennoot” (Kiliaen, Etymologicum (see note 13), p. 18, s.v. ampt-ghenoot; p. 302, s.v. maet, med-maet, maetken; p. 579, s.v. veyn-out, veyn-noot, ven-noot, vennoot, veyn-gnoot).
  50. Kiliaen, Etymologicum (see note 13), p. 244, s.v. knecht, dienaer.
  51. Nicolaas de Roever, “Drie Amsterdamsche Schilders (Pieter Isaaksz, Abraham Vinck, Cornelis van der Voort)”, Oud Holland 3 (1885), p. 198.
  52. In 1619, he was asked together with several artists who had traveled to Italy, including Pieter Lastman, Adriaen van Nieulandt, and Barent van Someren, to assess the authenticity of a Caravaggio painting from the collection of the late Louis Finson. Abraham Bredius, Nicolaas de Roever, “Pieter Lastman en François Venant”, Oud Holland 4 (1886), pp. 7-8.
  53. Ronald de Jager “Meester, leerjongen, leertijd. Een analyse van Zeventiende-eeuwse Noord-Nederlandse leerlingcontracten van kunstschilders, goud- en zilversmeden”, Oud Holland 104 (1990), p. 96, nt. 107. The title of “gezel” is, in fact, never mentioned in the known Amsterdam contracts.
  54. De Jager, “Meester” (see note 18), pp. 73-75.
  55. De Jager, “Meester” (see note 18), p. 71.
  56. Stadsarchief Amsterdam (hereafter SAA), 5075, 393A, nots. Jacob Jacobs and Nicolaes Jacobs, ff. 59r-59v, 20-07-1626; Abraham Bredius, “Gerrit Willemsz. Horst”, Oud Holland 50 (1933), pp. 5-6; De Jager, “Meester” (see note 18), p. 98, no. 7.
  57. This underscores a clear distinction: as was also evidenced by the entries in Kiliaen, Etymologicum (see note 13), dienaer was a synonym for knecht, not for leerknecht (see note 15).
  58. Abraham Bredius, Künstlerinventare. Urkunden zur Geschichte der holländischen Kunst des XVIten, XVIIten und XVIIIten Jahrhunderts V, The Hague 191, pp. 1482-1483; De Jager, “Meester” (see note 18), p. 98, no. 10.
  59. The value of a barrel of herring in Amsterdam in 1635 was approximately 120 grams of silver (Bo Poulsen, Dutch Herring. An Environmental History, c. 1600–1860, Amsterdam 2008, p. 93, table 6.9); in the seventeenth century, ten grams of silver corresponded to the value of roughly one guilder.
  60. The tuition fees in Holland for a two-year contract averaged 61.5 guilders per year (De Jager, “Meester” (see note 18), p. 75).
  61. Josua Bruyn, “Een onderzoek naar 17de -eeuwse schilderijformaten, voornamelijk in Noord-Nederland”, Oud Holland 93 (1979), p. 113.
  62. Abraham Bredius, Künstlerinventare. Urkunden zur Geschichte der holländischen Kunst des XVIten, XVIIten und XVIIIten Jahrhunderts II, The Hague 1916, pp. 400-401; De Jager, “Meester” (see note 18), p. 98
  63. As a journeyman painter Waltusz earned less than half the daily wage of peers in other trades. In 1652, journeymen carpenters and bricklayers in Amsterdam earned approximately 26 to 27 stivers per summer day (although there are no exact figures for 1651, data is available for 1633, 27 and 25 stivers respectively, and for 1667, 28 and 27 stivers respectively).
    This disparity between painter’s journeymen and their peers in other trades mirrors the situation in 1579. The guild
    regulations (gildebrief) of the St. Luke’s Guild from that year mention journeymen earning 4 stivers and others earning 10
    stivers per day (Ordonnantien (see note 9), p. 17, art. 11). Taking the average of 7 stivers, these were notably low wages –
    practically half – when compared to the 14 and 12 stivers earned by carpenters and bricklayers, respectively, in that same
    year. For the wages of the workers mentioned here, see: Hubert Nutseling, Welvaart en werkgelegenheid in Amsterdam
    1540–1860, Amsterdam/Dieren 1985, p. 252, appendix 5.1, table A.
  64. SAA, DTB 5001, 469, p. 241, 30-09-1651; Judith van Gent, Bartholomeus van der Helst (circa 1613-1670): een studie naar zijn leven en zijn werk, Utrecht (Utrecht University), p. 41.
  65. Virtually nothing is known about Gerardus van Berleborch (Bernard Renckens, “G. van Berkborch”, Oud Holland 84 (1967), no. 4, passim). He or his father was likely from the region around Bad Berleburg in Germany. He appears to have been present in Leiden in 1665, when he is recorded as a witness (“Gerrit van Berleberg”) at the baptism of a child of the painter Jacobus Geutkien (Erfgoed Leiden en Omstreken (hereafter ELO), DTB 1004, 237, fol. 236v, 3-12-1665).
  66. SAA, 5075, 875, not. Jacob van Zwieten, pp. 638-640, 16-10-1649; Johannes G. van Dillen, Bronnen tot de geschiedenis van het bedrijfsleven en het gildewezen van Amsterdam 1510-1672 III, p. 540, no. 1057.
  67. A possible reason for this may be that young painters attained the status of master more quickly. This benefited the guild financially, as it earned income only from masters and pupils, not from journeymen.
  68. Ordonnantien (see note 9), p. 10, art. 3.
  69. Ordonnantien (see note 9), p. 17, art. 11.
  70. Joachim von Sandrart’s famous anecdote about Rembrandt’s studio being filled with “countless elite children”, pupils who each paid an annual tuition fee of 100 guilders suggests that the legal limit on the number of pupils was, in practice, a dead letter (Joachim von Sandrardt, Teutsche Academie, Nuremberg 1675, p. 326; Van Eeghen, “Guild” (see note 7), p. 6).
  71. Young Man Reading with a Vanitas Still Life, 1644, oil on panel, 58 x 74 cm, Rotterdam, Museum Boijmans Van Beuningen, inv. no. 1386; Self-portrait, 1644, oil on panel, 63 x 48 cm, The Hague, Museum Bredius, inv. no. 056-1946; Self-portrait, 1645, oil on panel, 54.1 x 44.8 cm, Liechtenstein, The Princely Collections, Vaduz-Vienna, inv. no. GE 107; Portrait of a Child, 1645, oil on panel, 68.6 x 57.8 cm, private collection; The Adoration of the Shepherds, 1647, oil on canvas, 58.2 x 70.8 cm, Dordrecht, Dordrechts Museum, inv. no. DM/980/567.
  72. Godefridus J. Hoogewerff, De geschiedenis van de St. Lucasgilden in Nederland, Amsterdam 1947, p. 24; Ernst van de Wetering “Problems of Pupilship and Studio Practice” in: Josua Bruyn et al., A Corpus of Rembrandt Paintings II: 1631-1634, Amsterdam 1986, p. 57; Bikker, Drost (see note 2), p. 11; Angelina Illes, in: exh. cat. Vienna 2024 (see note 3), p. 29.
  73. Samuel Muller Fz., Schilders-vereenigingen te Utrecht. Bescheiden uit het Gemeentearchief, Utrecht 1880, p. 76; Frederik D.O. Obreen, Archief voor Nederlandsche Kunstgeschiedenis IV, Rotterdam 1881/1882, p. 51. The very fact that such a regulation had to be instituted in these cities already indicates that works were being signed by non-masters.
  74. De Jager, “Meester” (see note 18), pp. 77-79.
  75. Bruyn, “Onderzoek”, (see note 26), p. 113.
  76. David de Witt, Leonore van Sloten, in: The Hague 2025 (see note 3), “Rembrandt’s Impact”, https://vanhoogstraten.rkdstudies.nl/catalogus-schilderijen/rembrandts-impact/, 3 June 2025.
  77. Almost exclusively, reference is made to Bikker, Drost (see note 2), p. 11. Also in the exhibition catalogue of the Van Hoogstraten exhibition in Amsterdam, Drost is cited as an example of an early student of Van Hoogstraten (David de Witt, in: exh. cat. Amsterdam 2025 (see note 3), p. 131.
  78. Since Daniël Pont’s monograph on Barent Fabritius, (Daniël Pont, Barent Fabritius 1624–1673, The Hague, 1958) and Sumowski’s Drawings of the Rembrandt School (see note 2), no subsequent scholarly efforts have systematically De Kroniek 2024/25 – Museum Rembrandthuis 12 reconstructed his drawn oeuvre or analyzed the development of his distinctive style. The author’s forthcoming dissertation addresses this lacuna, and catalogues drawings by Barent Fabritius.
  79. Pont was among the first to suggest he may not have been a direct pupil of Rembrandt, but instead only came into contact with Rembrandt’s work indirectly, through his brother Carel (Pont, Barent (see note 43), p. 96). In the literature, uncertainty on this matter appears to have become the norm, with scholars consistently noting – or implicitly dealing with – the lack of evidence for a formal pupilship with Rembrandt (see: Paul Huys Jansen, Werner Sumowski, The Hoogsteder Exhibition of Rembrandt’s Academy, exh. cat. The Hague: Hoogsteder & Hoogsteder, 1992, p. 139; Walter A. Liedkte in: Hubert von Sonneburg, Rembrandt/Not Rembrandt in the Metropolitan Museum of Art I, exh. cat. New York City: The Metropolitan Museum of Art, 1995, cat. 48, pp. 145-146; Peter C. Sutton in: Albert Blankert, Rembrandt. A Genius and his impact, exh. cat. Melbourne: National Gallery of Victoria; Canberra: National Gallery of Australia, 1997, p. 283; Jan Blanc, Dans l’atelier de Rembrandt. Le maître et ses élèves, Paris 2006, p. 140.
  80. Holm Bevers, “Das Susanna-Thema im Werkstattzusammenhang: Zeichnungen”, in: Holm Bevers, Katja Kleinert, Claudia Laurenze-Landsberg, Rembrandts Berliner Susanna und die beiden Alten. Die Schaffung eins meisterwerks, exh. cat. Berlin: Staatliche Museen zu Berlin, Kupferstichkabinett; Gemäldegalerie, 2015, pp. 49-50.
  81. Katja Kleinert, Claudia Laurenze-Landsberg, “Wandlungen eines Gemäldes. Rembrandts Berliner Susanna und die beiden Alten”, in: exh. cat. Berlin 2015 (see note 45), p. 19, 32.
  82. See for instance Rembrandt’s Holy Family in the Carpenter’s workshop or his Star of the Kings (London, The British Museum, inv. nos. 1900,0824.144, 1910,0212.189).
  83. The drawing of a male model (here attributed to Barent Fabritius) has been described as stylistically very close to Van Hoogstraten (Martin Royalton-Kisch in: Catalogue of Drawings by Rembrandt and his School, London: The British Museum, 2010, cat. 71). The Departure of the Prodigal Son, a drawing already earlier attributed to Fabritius, is still considered a work by Van Hoogstraten (Frankfurt am Main, Städel Museum, inv. no. 817).
  84. A convincing spatial representation of the scene, achieved through a successful use of proportion, perspective, light, and color. For a elaboration on this definition, including references, see: Leonore van Sloten, “Regels voor de kunst”, in: David de Witt, Leonore van Sloten, Jaap van der Veen, Rembrandts late leerlingen. In de leer bij een genie, exh. cat. Amsterdam: Rembrandt House Museum, 2015, p. 73, note 31.
  85. In drawings by Barent Fabritius from the second half of the 1640s, his preparatory chalk underdrawing is generally careful and precise but not detailed, with clear, exact contours rendered in continuous, rounded lines. The somewhat squat figures possess a doll-like, slightly caricatural character. When using pen to trace or fill in the figures, particularly those in the foreground, the style becomes sketchier and more angular. Fabritius’s hatching lines become more carefully placed as they  grow finer, laid loosely side by side with only occasional thin-pen scratching, while thicker lines, including contours, are rendered in a zigzag, looser manner, often applied to foreground elements such as a repoussoir. Groups of hatching in shadowed, complex motifs (e.g., figures or foreground foliage) are neither intertwined nor uniformly oriented, and though the balance of light and shadow varies between drawings, it remains consistent within each composition; early mastery is evident in his wash applications, where loosely brushed transitions in shadows lend a painterly quality, enhancing figural plasticity and atmospheric depth, as seen in drawings with dramatic chiaroscuro effects.
  86. Although it has been argued by Holm Bevers that this drawing is by Constantijn Daniël van Renesse and dates from between 1650 and 1652 (Holm Bevers, “Ausstellungen zu Rembrandt in Rückblick”, Kunstchronik, 58 (2005), p. 480; Holm Bevers, in: Rembrandt. Die Zeichnungen im Berliner Kupferstichkabinett, exh. cat. Berlin: Staatliche Museen zu Berlin, Kupferstichkabinett, 2006, cat. no. 45, p. 158, nt. 12; Holm Bevers in: Holm Bevers et al., Drawings by Rembrandt and his Pupils. Telling the Difference, exh. cat. Los Angeles: The J. Paul Getty Museum, 2009, cat. no. 31.2, pp. 190-191), a number of features are so uncharacteristic of Van Renesse that the attribution cannot be sustained. This applies in particular to elements such as the heavy, coarse scratches in the shadow areas and the sketch-like rendering of the faces of Joseph and Mary. Van Renesse typically keeps shadow areas and light transitions in brush clear and even. Also characteristic is his meticulous penwork, marked by fine, short strokes in the contours and hatching lines (see for instance: The Judgment of Salomon, New York City (The Metropolitan Museum of Art, Robert Lehman Collection, inv. no. 1975.1.806; Daniel in the Lion’s Den, Rotterdam, Museum Boijmans Van Beuningen, inv. no. MB 200). Generally, it shows the boldness of Barent much more than the careful restraint of Renesse
  87. “Beeter waer ‚t dat [om de veranderin[g]] een eesel van achteren was, dan dat al de hoofden iuist wt het stuck sien. Dat oock omtrent de boom wat meerder groente was. | 1 losep heft af te swaer en te onbesuist | 2 Maria most het kindeken wat meerder vieren, want een teeder kint magh sulck duwen niet ver[dragen]. | losep al te kort en dick, sijn hooft wast hem wt de [borst?]. Sijn hebben alle beide al te groote koppen”. Transcript from: Leonore van Sloten, in: exh. cat. Amsterdam 2015 (see note 49), p. 73, nt. 27. “It would be better that [for the alteration] there were a donkey from the back, than that all the heads are looking straight out of the work. That there were also somewhat more greenery around the tree. | 1 Joseph lifts too heavily and too inconsiderately. | 2 Mary ought to ease the little child somewhat more, for a tender infant cannot [endure] such pushing. | Joseph is all too short and stout, his head grows out of the [chest?]. They both have all too large heads”. These instructions are also partly articulated within the drawing itself. Joseph is indeed shown tugging firmly at Mary’s arm, whereas in the more sketch-like version, he supports her more gently at the back. The small patch of greenery in the lower corner may also be a later addition, in correspondence with the suggestion.
  88. The face does not appear to be a correction in the technical sense, but rather an example of a foreshortened face viewed from below – a challenging principle of perspective.
  89. An attribution proposed Christian Dittrich (Christian Dittrich in: Christian Dittrich, Thomas Ketelsen, Rembrandt. Die Dresdener Zeichnungen 2004, exh. cat. Dresden: Staatliche Kunstsammlungen Dresden, Kupferstich-Kabinett, 2004, cat. no.14, pp. 80-81).
  90. Brusati implied the possibility that the text was written partly by Rembrandt and partly by Van Hoogstraten (Celeste Brusati, Artifice & Illusion. The Art and Writing of Samuel van Hoogstraten, Chicago/London 1995, pp. 31, 275, note 40). Rembrandt was excluded as the author of the instructions by Bevers, while Van Hoogstraten as author remained an option. Van Renesse was likewise ruled out by Bevers, based on a comparison with the handwriting on his Daniel in the Lions’ Den drawing and The Judgment of Solomon drawing (see note 51); Holm Bevers, in: exh. cat. Los Angeles 2009 (see note 51), cat. 31.1–31.2, p. 190; 191, note 3). To this may be added that the handwriting also closely resembles that of Barent Fabritius. Although little comparative material survives, the compact, small script of Fabritius’s name beneath the death inventory of his sister-in-law Aeltje, dated 24 April 1643 (SAA, 5075, 1628a, not. David de l’Hommel, p. 399), shows a strong resemblance to the instructions on the Dresden sheet.
  91. “Once you have mastered your handling and your eye is somewhat clarified, it will no longer trouble you to translate many naturalistic paintings into a naturalistic drawing”. “Wanneer gy uwe handeling nu machtich zijt, en uw oog wat verklaert is, zoo zal ‚t u ook niet verscheelen veel verwige Schilderyen in een verwige teykeningen na te klaren” (Van Hoogstraten, Inleyding (see note 1), p. 27)
  92. “I advise masters, when they review the drawings of their pupils, to improve them by making sketches of the same subject themselves. This is an excellent exercise and has greatly assisted many in the art of composition”. “De meesters raed ik, als ze de Teykeningen haerer discipelen overzien, datze de zelve, met schetssen op ‚t zelve voorwerp te maeken, verbeeteren. Dit oeffent ongemeen, en heeft veelen geweldich in de schikkunst geholpen” (Van Hoogstraten, Inleyding (see note 1), p. 192).
  93. “And certainly, this manner of drawing with pen and brush is likewise the most suitable for completing a masterly work in its full force. For one can also, whenever it proves convenient, work into it with red chalk and crayons, as though one were almost painting with colours”. “En zeker deeze wijze van met pen en pinseel te teykenen, is ook allerbequaemst om een meesterlijk werk in zijn volle kracht te voleinden. Dewijl men’er ook, als’t pas geeft, met rood krijt en kryons in kan speelen, als of men byna met verwen schilderde” (Van Hoogstraten, Inleyding (see note 1), p. 31.
  94. On stylistic grounds, this Rembrandt drawing has been placed among a group of history drawings dating to around 1650 (Otto Benesch, The Drawings of Rembrandt V, New York 1957, no. 902). Among other arguments, this dating led Bevers to attribute the Dresden drawing to Constantijn van Renesse, rather than Barent Fabritius (Holm Bevers, in: exh. cat. Berlin 2006 (see note 51), cat. no. 45, p. 157, 158, nt. 12) However, it remains questionable whether the Rembrandt drawing in Berlin should be understood within that context. Unlike the other history drawings, this work is not an autonomous composition but rather a sketched response to the Dresden sheet. It is plausible that the sketch was already made around 1647. In terms of linework, it is not far removed from the portrait sketch of Jan Six, dating from in or before 1647 (Amsterdam, Six Collection).
    It is drawn in a similarly free style, applied in a sketch, comparable to other drawings from the second half of the 1640’s (see
    note 47). Rembrandt’s Berlin drawing could thus have been made quite soon after Fabritius’s corrected drawing
  95. Josua Bruyn, “Gemälde der Rembrandt-Schüler II by Werner Sumowski Review”, Oud Holland 101 (1987) no. 3, p. 229.
  96. https://rkd.nl/images/313061, 17 July 2025. In terms of drawing style, this work is not far removed from Van Hoogstraten’s drawing The Sacrifice of Manoah of 1649 (Braunschweig, Herzog Anton Ulrich Museum, inv. no. Z 335; https://rkd.nl/images/71286, 17 July 2025). We may even assume that The Crucifixion predates it; the departing angel in the  Braunschweig drawing – also seen from the back – appears to be a more developed and refined treatment of the motif of a figure seen from behind.
  97. Samuel van Hoogstraten, The Adoration of the Shepherds. London, The British Museum, inv. no. 1895,0915.1203; https://rkd.nl/images/313552, 17 July 2025. A drawing of The Circumcision, likewise painted as a part of the Passion series in 1646, has been attributed to Gerbrand van den Eeckhout (Brussels, Koninklijke Musea voor Schone Kunsten België, inv. no. 4060/1212). There are also two copies after Rembrandt’s Holy Family with a Curtain from 1646 (London, The British Museum, inv. no. 1895,0915.1200; Oxford, Ashmolean Museum, inv. no. WA1986.56).
  98. Josua Bruyn in: Josua Bruyn et al., A Corpus of Rembrandt Paintings III: 1635-1642, Amsterdam 1989 pp. 13-16.
  99. Martin Royalton-Kisch, Drawings by Rembrandt and his Circle in the British Museum, London: The British Museum, 1992, cat. no. 87, pp. 180-182; Holm Bevers, “Drawings in Rembrandt’s Workshop”, in: exh. cat. Los Angeles 2009 (see note 51), pp. 13-17; David de Witt, “Leren van het leven: tekeningen van Rembrandts leerlingen” in: Judith Noorman, David de Witt, Rembrandts Naakte Waarheid. Tekenen naar naaktmodellen in de Gouden Eeuw, exh. cat. Amsterdam: Rembrandt House Museum, 2015, pp. 117-120.
  100. Initially, this drawing was attributed to Rembrandt, but as early as 1908, this attribution was already being questioned (Martin Conway, “Some Rembrandt Drawings”, Burlington Magazine 14 (1908/1909), p.37).
  101. This sheet has previously been judged the weakest of the three (David de Witt, in: exh. cat. Amsterdam 2015 (see note 64), p. 118), and it has even been suggested that Rembrandt may have corrected it. (Martin Royalton-Kisch, in: col. cat. London 2010 (see note 48), cat. 71). The fine parallel pen strokes in the boy’s torso are comparable to those in the body of Susanna in the Budapest drawing. The somewhat arbitrary use of red chalk (in the model’s right armpit area, on the reverse side of the cushion, and in the upper left corner) also stands out in both sheets. The type of loose, heavy pen lines used for the cushion corresponds to those found in the cloak of the old man in the Susanna drawing.
  102. For a first suggestion of Bol being the assistant of Rembrandt, see: Albert Blanckert, Ferdinand Bol (1616-1680). Rembrandt’s Pupil, Doornspijk 1982, pp. 17-18.
  103. Blanckert, Bol (see note 67), pp. 17-18; David de Witt, “Ferdinand Bol, discipel van Rembrandt”, in: Norbert Middelkoop, Ferdinand Bol en Govert Flinck. Rembrandts meesterleerlingen, Amsterdam (Rembrandt House Museum/Amsterdam Museum) 2017, pp. 44-45
  104. Portrait of a Lady, 1642. Berlin, Staatliche Museen zu Berlin, Gemäldegalerie, inv. no. 809. However, there are paintings by Bol, or attributed to him, of an earlier date or dating. The Liberation of St Peter (private collection), dated around 1636, may be, given its strong connection to the work of Benjamin Cuyp (David de Witt, in: exh. cat. Amsterdam 2017 (see note 68), pp. 42-43), made before Bol’s departure to Amsterdam. Gideon’s Sacrifice of 1640, signed by Bol (Utrecht, Museum Catharijneconvent, inv. no. RMCC s24), is typical in subject matter and composition of his later work from the 1640s, and may
    be made under conditions comparable to those proposed in this article for the paintings by Van Hoogstraten, dating from
    between 1644 and 1647. Other works attributed to Bol prior to 1642 are often copies or adaptations of compositions by
    Rembrandt.
  105. Christopher Brown, Carel Fabritius, Oxford 1981, p. 47; Gero Seelig in: Frederik J. Duparc, Carel Fabritius 1622-1654, exh. cat. The Hague: Mauritshuis; Schwerin: Staatliches Museum, 2004-2005, cat. no. 4, p. 97.
  106. Erna Kok erroneously states that Bol is mentioned as Rembrandt’s “werckgesel” in a document of 30 August 1640 (Erna Kok, “Govert Flinck en Ferdinand Bol en hun netwerken van opdrachtgevers,” in: exh. cat. Amsterdam 2017 (see note 68), p. 71, p. 244, n. 37). Bol’s exact role during his time in Rembrandt’s workshop is never documented. It is striking that the drawn copies after three of Rembrandt’s paintings from around 1636 are attributed to Ferdinand Bol (Peter Schatborn, “Tekeningen van Govert Flinck en Ferdinand Bol”, in: exh. cat. Amsterdam 2017 (see note 68), p.185). Apart from these sheets and those datable around 1646 by later pupils, there are few, if any, known drawings by Rembrandt’s pupils that are direct copies after his history or figure paintings. It is possible that Bol played an important role in introducing this method into the studio, and that it was later adopted by Van Hoogstraten. Van Hoogstraten is likely to have been in contact with Bol while in Amsterdam. After Bol established himself as an independent master, around 1642, he too began to draw in red chalk. He did so, however, almost exclusively in preparatory studies for (mainly) paintings – see, for instance, Joseph brings his Father before Pharaoh (Dresden, Gemäldegalerie, inv. no. 1605), and its preliminary drawing (Amsterdam, Rijksmuseum, inv. no. RP-T-1883-A-276). Van Hoogstraten may well have adopted this practice from him. This suggests that, even as an official pupil of Rembrandt, Van Hoogstraten felt the freedom to look to the work of other contemporaries as well. Van Sloten has argued that Bol continued to visit Rembrandt during the first half of the 1640s (Leonore van Sloten, “Ferdinand Bol, de etser”, in: exh. cat. Amsterdam 2017 (see note 68), pp. 218–221). Bol’s use of red chalk for preparatory studies may therefore have been the source of Van Hoogstraten’s conception that the use of red chalk contributes to the painterly quality of a drawing.
  107. Arnold Houbraken, De groote schouburgh der Nederlantsche konstschilders en schilderessen, Amsterdam, 1976, p. 165.
  108. Jan Jacobsz. Orlers, Beschrijvinge der Stadt Leyden, 2nd ed., Leiden, 1641, p. 376.
  109. See the translation from the original Latin: “Constantijn Huygens on Lievens and Rembrandt,” in: Arthur K. Wheelock et al., Jan Lievens. A Dutch Master Rediscovered, exh. cat. Washington: National Gallery of Art; Milwaukee: Milwaukee Art Museum; Amsterdam: Museum Het Rembrandthuis, 2008-2009, p. 287.
  110. See: Arthur K. Wheelock, “Jan Lievens: Bringing New Light to an Old Master,” in: Wheelock, Lievens (see note 2), pp. 13-23; and: Lloyd DeWitt, Evolution and Ambition in the Career of Jan Lievens (1607-1674), Ph.D. dissertation, University of Maryland, 2006: https://www.researchgate.net/publication/277127128_Evolution_and_Ambition_in_the_Career_of_Jan_Lievens_1607-1674
  111. Property from Aristocratic Estates and Important Provenance, Vienna (Dorotheum), 8 September 2020, lot 59 (as Circle of Bartholomeus van der Helst).
  112. Werner Sumowski, Gemälde der Rembrandt-Schüler, Landau, vol. 5, 1990, p. 3109, no. 2127, ill. p. 3279
  113. Ernst van de Wetering, Rembrandt: the Painter at Work, Amsterdam, 1997, pp. 182-185.
  114. Jan Lievens, Job in his Misery, monogrammed and dated 1631, canvas, 171.5 x 148.6 cm, Ottawa, National Gallery of Canada (4093). See Lloyd DeWitt in Wheelock, Lievens (see note 2), pp. 130-131, no. 25 (colour illus.).
  115. Jan Lievens, The Penitent Magdalene, c. 1631. Canvas, 63.5 x 49.5 cm. Kingston, Agnes Etherington Art Centre, gift of Dr. and Mrs. Alfred Bader, 1975 (18.126). See David de Witt in Wheelock, Lievens, pp. 128-129, no. 24 (colour illus.).
  116. Portrait of Jan Davidsz. de Heem, c. 1635/37, black chalk with some white body colour, 265 x 201 mm, London, British Museum (1895,0915.1199); Werner Sumowski, Drawings of the Rembrandt School, New York, vol. 7 (1983), pp. 3682-3683, no. 1652x (illus.).
  117. See entry by Lloyd DeWitt in: Wheelock, Lievens (see note 2), pp. 154-155, no. 38 (colour illus.).
  118. Jan Lievens, Head of a Bearded Old Man, c. 1640. Panel, 55 x 43 cm (oval), Kingston, Agnes Etherington Art Centre, gift of Alfred and Isabel Bader. See: David de Witt, The Bader Collection: Dutch and Flemish Paintings. Kingston, 2008, p. 198, no. 117 (colour illus.).
  119. Jan Lievens, Portrait of Adriaen Brouwer, c. 1635/37, black chalk with touches of pen in black, 221 x 185 mm, Paris, Fondation Custodia, Collection Frits Lugt (1203); Sumowski, Drawings (see note 9), pp. 3356-3357, no. 1594 (illus.).
  120. Jan Lievens, Portrait of Constantijn Huygens, 1639, black chalk with touches of pen in brown, 238 x 174 mm, London, British Museum (1836.8.11.342); see Wheelock, Lievens (see note 2), p. 242-243, no. 103 (colour illus.).
  121. Email correspondence with the author, 9 September 2020.
  122. My thanks to Stephanie Dickey for this information (email, 31 October 2022), confirmed by Marieke de Winkel.
  123. See Wheelock, Lievens (see note 2), p. 286.
  124. Lucas Vorsterman, after Anthony van Dyck, Portrait of Jan Lievens, c. 1630-1645, engraving, 241 x 158 mm, in 6 states, for the series: Icones Principorum Vivorum Doctorum Pictorum…; see: Marie Mauquoy-Hendrickx, L’Iconographie d’Antoine van Dyck, 2nd ed., Brussels, 1991, vol. 1, p. 155, no. 85; vol. 2, pl. 54 (illus.).
  125. Wheelock, Lievens (see note 2), pp. 112-113, no. 112 (colour illus.).
  126. Jan Lievens, Portrait of Charles I, pen in brown, 183 x 140 mm, Turin, Biblioteca Reale (D. C. 16365); Sumowski, Drawings (see note 9), pp. 3898-3899, no. 1754xx, (illus.); Orlers, Beschrijvinge (see note 1), pp. 375-377.
  127. Karolien de Klippel, “Adriaen Brouwer, Portrait Painter: New Identifications and an Iconographic Novelty,” Simiolus 30 (2003), pp. 196-216.
  128. Stephanie Dickey, “Jan Lievens and Printmaking,” in Wheelock, Lievens (see note 2), pp. 60-62. On the Iconography, see Mauquoy-Hendrickx, Iconographie (see note 7).
  129. DeWitt, Evolution (see note 3), p. 192, illus. fig. 144 (Lievens c. 1635/43, H. de Bran); attribution by Werner Sumowski: written correspondence with the museum of 28 July 1986; and: Drawings of the Rembrandt School, vol. 12 (Addenda), Leiden (forthcoming), no. 3104x.
  130. See Mauquoy-Hendrick, Iconography (see note 17), vol. 1, p. 214, no. 190; vol. 2, pl. 119.
  131. See DeWitt, Evolution (see note 3), pp. 160-164.
  132. Jan Lievens, Portrait of Thomas Howard, Earl of Arundel, black and red chalk, 180 x 140 mm, Staatliche Museen zu Berlin, Kupferstichkabinett (KdZ 5869); Wheelock, Lievens (see note 2), p. 249, no. 109 (colour illus.).
  133. Jan Lievens, Profile Head of an Old Woman in Oriental Dress, c. 1630, panel, 43.2 x 33.7 cm, Kingston, Agnes Etherington Art Centre, gift of Alfred and Isabel Bader, 2005 (48-002). See entry by David de Witt in Wheelock, Lievens (see note 2), pp. 122-123, no. 21 (colour illus.).
  134. Letter to his son the Earl of Lothian, May 1654: Correspondence of Sir Robert Kerr, First Earl of Ancram, and His Son William, Third Earl of Lothian, vol. 2, London, 1875, p. 383; C. Hofstede de Groot, “Hollandsche Kunst in Schotland,” Oud Holland 11 (1893), p. 214.
  135. On Sinclair: Jeannette Ewin, Fine Wines and Fish Oil: The Life of Hugh Macdonald Sinclair, Oxford 2001.
  136. The typescript is available in the “Library acquisition file for the Sinclair collection”.
  137. UBC Library, WZ250 .T9 1641.
  138. “7,000 rare books arrive”, UBC Reports 12, no. 3 (March-April, 1966). https://www.library.ubc.ca/archives/pdfs/ubcreports/UBC_Reports_1966_03_00.pdf
  139. Michiel Roscam Abbing, Rembrandt’s Elephant. Following in Hansken’s Footsteps, Amstelveen 2021.
  140. Nina Siegal, “When Rembrandt Met an Elephant”, The New York Times, July 16, 2021.
  141. UBC Library, WZ250 .T9 1641 and WZ260 .T83 1739 with the title Observationes Medicae.
  142. Allard Pierson, University of Amsterdam, Archives of Menno Hertzberger (UBA235). Sales catalogue Medicine Hippocrates-Claude Bernard, Amsterdam [February 1954], lot 442.
  143. Note 8 for this annotated copy.
  144. He also kept the relevant page from the catalogue in his files. Hamburg, Warburg Haus, Heckscher Archiv, Box 121 (‘Rembrandt: Dr. Tulp’), folder ‘Dr. Tulp Photo’s I’. Sinclair’s copy is kept in UBC Library call number Z999.74.
  145. According to Heckscher’s own administration he sent letters to Hugh Sinclair on 15 February and 2 March 1963. Hamburg, Warburg Haus, Heckscher Archiv, Box 52 (‘Heckscher: Korrespondenz und Arbeiten’). We thank Ms. Fanny Weidehaas of the Heckscher Archiv for her assistance. These letters were not found among Sinclair’s papers in The Museum of English Rural Life at the University of Reading. We thank Ms. Emma Farmer for checking these files.
  146. The translation was not published until 1991: Nicolaes Tulp, Geneesinzichten van Dr. Nicolaes Tulp etc., eds. (and transcriptions) C.G.L. Apeldoorn and T. Beijer. Amsterdam, 1991.
  147. The title page of the manuscript reads: “Nicolaes Tulp. Inzichten over de geneeskunst in vier boeken met koperen platen” (Nicolaes Tulp. Medical Insights in Four Books with Copper Plates).
  148. “D. Meppen Norda Frisii 1682 d. 18 8.bris”. We thank Koert van der Horst, retired keeper of manuscripts of the Utrecht University Library, for this identification. A third (unidentified) ownership’s inscription reads: “L. Fries stud. med. 1838 16/2.”
  149. The visit is not recorded in Sinclair’s Visitors book. Reading, The Museum of English Rural Life, Papers of Hugh Macdonald Sinclair, D HS 1/7/1: Visitor’s book 1941-1989: Dr Hugh Sinclair’s book of visitors to his home, Lady Place in Sutton Courtenay. We are grateful to Ms. Hollie Piff for checking.
  150. In the National Archives in The Hague we consulted the archives of the Department of Archeology and Nature Conservation, inv. no. 105 (Stukken betreffende de aanvraag van vergunningen voor de in- en uitvoer van voorwerpen van geschiedenis en kunst. 1946-1964).
  151. Allard Pierson, University of Amsterdam, Archives of Menno Hertzberger (UBA235), personal archives.
  152. Kindly provided information by Ms. Nina Duggen, Inspectie Overheidsinformatie en Erfgoed (Information and Heritage Inspectorate).
  153. Peter Schatborn and Erik Hinterding, Rembrandt. The Complete Drawings and Etchings, Cologne 2019. Peter Schatborn gave his judgement in an email of September 15, 2021, in translation: “In any case, the drawing was not made by Rembrandt. The stylistic differences are too great and I can’t find any drawing by Rembrandt that is comparable”.
  154. Ernest Theodore Hamy, ‚Documents inédits sur l‘Homo sylvestris rapporté d’Angola en 1630′, Bulletin du Muséum d’histoire naturelle 3 (1897), pp. 277-282.
  155. Michiel Roscam Abbing is currently preparing a book-length study, The Ape of Tulp, in which these data are to be published.
  156. Peter van der Krogt and Erlend de Groot, The Atlas Blaeu-Van der Hem of the Austrian National Library V (Utrecht 2005), pp. 88-89 (no. 35:40). The suggestion that Blaeu, who died in 1638, had access to the engraving of the chimpanzee and that this engraving was made by Tulp long before 1641, as argued by Kees Zandvliet (De Wereld van de familie Blaeu, Zutphen 2023, p. 66) must be rejected.
  157. Much of the previous literature cites the drawing as The Departure of Rebecca from Her Parents’ House. The Staatsgalerie, Stuttgart, which owns the drawing, adopted the shorter title (https://www.staatsgalerie.de/en/html).
  158. “dit behoorde vervoucht te weesen me[t] veel gebueren die deese hoge bruijt sien vertrek[k]en”: Peter Schatborn, “The Core Group of Rembrandt Drawings, I: Overview,” Master Drawings 49 (2011), p. 320.
  159. According to the Woordenboek der Nederlandsche Taal, “geburen” may mean “figures” or “bystanders,” as two scholars interpreted the word in Rembrandt’s inscription: (https://gtb.ivdnt.org/iWDB/search?actie=article&wdb=WNT&id=M017638.re.1&lemma=geburen&domein=0&conc=true). For “figures,” see: Volker Manuth, in: Rembrandt: A Genius and His Impact, exh. cat. Canberra, Australian National Gallery; Melbourne, National Gallery of Victoria, 1997, p. 270, cat. no. 53. For “bystanders,” see: Marieke de Winkel, Fashion and Fancy: Dress and Meaning in Rembrandt’s Paintings, Amsterdam 2006, pp. 214–215). However, in the full context of Rembrandt’s inscription and the drawing’s iconography, “geburen” most strongly refers to neighbours, as translated for example by Gary Schwartz and Peter Schatborn. See: Gary Schwartz, The Rembrandt Book, New York 2006, p. 107, fig. 195; Schatborn, “Core” (see note 2), p. 320.
  160. Schwartz, Rembrandt (see note 3), p. 107.
  161. Amy Golahny, “Rembrandt and ‘Everyday Life’: the Fusion of Genre and History,” in: Genre Imagery in Early Modern Northern Europe: New Perspectives, London 2016, pp. 174, 177.
  162. The Rembrandt drawing (130 x 185 mm) was sold at Christie’s (London) on 3 July 2012, lot. 50, sale 5688. Golahny, “Rembrandt” (see note 5), pp. 170–174, figs. 7.5–9.
  163. Herman Roodenburg, “Naar een etnografie van de vroegmoderne stad: de ‘gebuyrten’ in Leiden en Den Haag,” in: Cultuur en maatschappij in Nederland 1500–1850. Een historisch-antropologisch perspectief, Meppel 1992, p. 233.
  164. For a discussion of neighbourhoods’ goals, see: Herman Roodenburg, “’Freundschaft’, ‘Brüderlichkeit’ und ‘Einigkeit’: Städtische Nachbarschaften im Westen der Republik,” in: Ausbreitung bürgerlicher Kultur in den Niederlanden und Nordwestdeutschland, Münster 1991, pp. 11, 12, 21; Gabrielle Dorren, “Communities within the Community: Aspects of Neighbourhood in Seventeenth-Century Haarlem,” Urban History 25 (1998), pp. 180, 188.
  165. See, for example, Rembrandt’s drawings Benesch 491, 503, 566, 988 and his painting Portrait of a Couple as Isaac and Rebecca, c. 1665–1669 (oil on canvas, 121.5 x 166.5 cm, Amsterdam, Rijksmuseum).
  166. All Biblical translations from: The New English Bible with the Apocrypha, New York 1971.
  167. Schatborn, “Core” (see note 2), p. 320.
  168. The Staatsgalerie Stuttgart attributes the inscription to Rembrandt and the drawing to either Rembrandt or Gerbrand van den Eeckhout. Hans Martin Kaulbach, Curator of German and Netherlandish Prints and Drawings before 1800, Graphische Sammlung, Staatsgalerie Stuttgart, email message to the author, 25 April 2018.
  169. For Koninck see for example: Horst Gerson, Philips Koninck; ein beitrag zur Erforschung der holländischen Malerei des XVII. Jahrhunderts, Berlin 1936, p. 174, Z.LXV. For Flinck: Wilhelm Reinhold Valentiner, Rembrandt: des Meisters Handzeichnungen, Stuttgart 1933, part 2, p. 247. For Van den Eeckhout: Martin Royalton-Kisch, Drawings by Rembrandt and His Circle in the British Museum, exh. cat., London, British Museum 1992, p. 202, cat. no. 97; Holm Bevers, “Drawing in Rembrandt’s Workshop,” in: Drawings by Rembrandt and His Pupils: Telling the Difference, exh. cat., Los Angeles, J. Paul Getty Museum 2009, p. 27; Schatborn, “Core” (see note 2), pp. 320, 322, note 38. For an argument against the Van den Eeckhout attribution, see: Eric Jan Sluijter and Nicolette Sluijter-Seijffert, “Rembrandt’s Pupils? The Attribution of Early Drawings to Gerbrand van den Eeckhout and Jan Victors,” in: Connoisseurship Essays in Honour of Fred G. Meijer, Leiden 2020, pp. 289–296.
  170. Werner Sumowski, Drawings of the Rembrandt School, New York 1979–1992, vol. 3, p. 1734, 806xx; Bevers, “Drawing” (see note 13), pp. 27, notes 97–98.
  171. Seymour Slive, Rembrandt Drawings, Los Angeles 2009, p. 215; Schatborn, “Core” (see note 2), p. 320; Bevers, “Drawing” (see note 13), p. 2.
  172. Cornelis Hofstede de Groot and Bob Haak, Rembrandt Zeichnungen, Köln 1974, p. 13; Manuth, Rembrandt (see note 3), p. 270, cat. no. 53.
  173. Samuel van Hoogstraten, De Inleyding tot de hooge schoole der schilderkunst anders de zichtbaere werelt, Rotterdam 1678, p. 192. Bevers, “Drawing” (see note 13), p. 25, notes 86–87.
  174. Bevers, “Drawing” (see note 13), pp. 25–27, 187, 189­–90; Schatborn, “Core” (see note 2), p. 320.
  175. Bevers, “Drawing” (see note 13), p. 27.
  176. Roodenburg, “Naar” (see note 7), pp. 222–224; Dorren, “Communities” (see note 8), p. 177; Llewellyn Bogaers, “Geleund over de onderdeur: Doorkijkjes in het Utrechtse buurtleven van de vroege middeleeuwen tot in de zeventiende eeuw,” in: Bijdragen en mededelingen betreffende de geschiedenis der Nederlanden 112 (1997), pp. 349, 357, 359.
  177. Roodenburg, “Naar” (see note 7), pp. 224, 233–234; Bogaers, “Geleund” (see note 20), pp. 340–342, 348.
  178. Catherina Lis and Hugo Soly, “Neighborhood Social Change in Western European Cities,” International Review of Social History 38 (1993), p. 5.
  179. Kees Walle, Buurthouden. De geschiedenis van burengebruiken en buurtorganisaties in Leiden (14e–19e eeuw), Leiden 2005, pp. 75, 306.
  180. Regionaal Archief Leiden (RAL); Stadsarchief (SA) II inv.nr. 1216, f. 149 and RAL SA II inv.nr. 1217, f. 10 vso; cited in: Walle, Buurthouden (see note 23), p. 231, note 77.
  181. Jan le Francq van Berkheij, Natuurlyke historie van Holland, 12 parts in 9 vols., Amsterdam 1769–1811, vol. 3, part 2, pp. 1045–1046; Roodenburg, “Naar” (see note 7), p. 225.
  182. RAL; SA II inv.nr. 16; Aflezingboek F, f. 58 vso; cited in: Walle, Buurthouden (see note 23), pp. 43, 227, notes 141, 270.
  183. Algemene Verordening, n.p.; cited in: Walle, Buurthouden (see note 23), pp. 46, 275.
  184. Roodenburg, “’Freundschaft’” (see note 8), p. 15; Bogaers, “Geleund” (see note 20), p. 349.
  185. Ilja Veldman and Lynne Richards, “Familiar Customs and Exotic Rituals: Picart’s Illustrations for Cérémonies et coutumes religieuses de tous les peuples,” Simiolus: Netherlandish quarterly for the history of art, vol. 33 (2007/2008), p. 94.
  186. Picart’s widow explained that “the prints of the Reformed congregation were drawn from life and are very accurate.” Bernard Picart and Anne Vincent, Impostures innocentes ou recueil d’estampes d’après divers peintres illustres . . . etc. gravées par Bernard Picart avec son éloge historique et le catalogue de ses ouvrages, Amsterdam 1734, p. 9; Veldman and Richards, “Familiar” (see note 29), p. 99, note 20.
  187. Veldman and Richards, “Familiar” (see note 29), p. 97.
  188. Bernard Picart, Cérémonies et coutumes religieuses de tous les peuples du monde, Amsterdam 1723–1743, p. 345.
  189. As Petra van Boheemen noted, the “interest of the neighbourhood is visible” in Picart’s print. Petra van Boheemen et al., Kent, en versint, eer datje mint: vrijen en trouwen, 1500–1800, Apeldoorn, Historisch Museum Marialust; Zwolle 1989, p. 170.
  190. Van Boheemen, Kent (see note 33), pp. 170–172; H. Perry Chapman, Jan Steen, Painter and Storyteller, exh. cat., Washington, DC, National Gallery of Art; Amsterdam, Rijksmuseum 1996, pp. 116–118 note 1, cat. no. 6.
  191. Van Boheemen, Kent (see note 33), p. 170.
  192. Irma Thoen, Strategic Affection? Gift Exchange in Seventeenth-Century Holland, Amsterdam 2007, p. 106.
  193. Fynes Moryson and Charles Hughes, Shakespeare’s Europe. Unpublished Chapters of Fynes Moryson’s Itinerary Being a Survey of the Condition of Europe at the End of the 16th Century, London 1903, pp. 379–380.
  194. A. Lynn Martin, Alcohol, Sex, and Gender in Late Medieval and Early Modern Europe, New York 2001, pp. 52–53; Thoen, Strategic (see note 36), p. 105.
  195. See, for example, Jan Steen’s The Wedding of Tobias and Sarah, c. 1667–1668, oil on canvas, 131 x 172 cm, Braunschweig, Herzog Anton Ulrich-Museum; Chapman, Jan Steen (see note 34), pp. 203–205, cat. no. 32.
  196. Philips Angel, Lof der schilder-konst, Leyden 1642, p. 48. Translation from: Philips Angel, Michael Hoyle, and Hessel Miedema, “Philips Angel, Praise of Painting,” Simiolus, Netherlandish Quarterly for the History of Art 24 (1996), p. 246.
  197. A. M. van der Woude, “Variations in Size and Structure of the Household in the United Provinces of the Netherlands in the Seventeenth and Eighteenth Centuries,” in: Household and Family in Past Time: Comparative Studies in the Size and Structure of the Domestic Group over the Last Three Centuries in England, France, Serbia, Japan and Colonial North America, with Further Materials from Western Europe, Cambridge 1972, p. 315.
  198. Jan Jansz Orlers, Beschrijvinge der stadt Leyden, 2nd ed., Leiden 1641, p. 375; Walter L. Strauss et al., Rembrandt Documents, New York 1979, doc. 1641/8. For rare objections, see Roelof van Straten, Young Rembrandt. The Leiden Years, 1606-1632, Leiden 2005, p. 16; Benjamin Binstock, ‚The birth of Rembrandt‘, in Michiel Roscam Abbing, ed., Rembrandt 2006. Essays, Leiden 2006, pp. 267-278 (arguing for 1607).
  199. Strauss, Rembrandt Documents, doc. 1669/6.
  200. E.B.F.F. Wittert van Hoogland, ‚Genealogie van den tak van het geslacht van Tetrode, welke zich Vinck genoemd heeft. Reconstructie van de genealogie voorkomende in het stam- en wapenboek van aanzienlijke Nederlandsche geslachten. Memoriael Gemaeck door N(icolaas) S(ebastiaensz.) V(inck)‘, Genealogische en heraldische bladen 1 (1906), pp. 122-149.
  201. Dirk Rühl, ‚Het wapen van Rembrandt’s broeder Willem Harmensz. van Rijn een gelegenheids-wapen? Een heraldisch probleem‘, Gens Nostra. Maandblad van de Nederlandsche Genealogische Vereniging 11 (1956), pp. 117-128, esp. p. 127.
  202. Strauss et al., Rembrandt Documents, doc. 1669/4 (misspelling the name as ‚Vlinck‘). See also: http://remdoc.huygens.knaw.nl/#/document/remdoc/e13470 (accessed 22 December 2022).
  203. Warm thanks to Ingrid Pot for her kind assistance, and to P.J.M. De Baar for an impromptu consultation on the document, manuscript LB 6761 klein deel, Erfgoed Leiden en Omstreken, Leiden (hereafter ELO). The notebook is chronological but unpaginated; we therefore cite Wittert van Hoogland. See further Stephanie S. Dickey, ‚Ars longa vita brevis. Rembrandt’s death and the status of the artist in late seventeenth-century Amsterdam‘, Nederlands Kunsthistorisch Jaarboek 72 (2022), pp. 234-271.
  204. R.E.O. Ekkart, ‚Familiekroniek Van Heemskerck en Van Swanenburg (I)‘, Jaarboek van het Centraal Bureau voor Genealogie 32 (1978), pp. 41-70; idem., ‚Familiekroniek Van Heemskerck en Van Swanenburg (II)‘, Jaarboek van het Centraal Bureau voor Genealogie 33 (1979), pp. 44-75 (deaths of Cornelis and Sylvester van Swanenburgh, pp. 54, 72, 75). See also Gary Schwartz, Rembrandt, his life, his paintings, New York 1985, p. 22; https://www.mijnstambomen.nl/leiden/swanenburg.htm (accessed 16 December 2022). The dates of Silvester van Swanenburgh’s death and burial are unrecorded; he prepared his will on 12 October 1669, being siechelick van lichaem leggende te bedde (sick in bed); ELO, 0506, notary Justus Gerstecoren, no. 1144, deed 124, 12-10-1669.
  205. Wittert van Hoogland, ‚Genealogie‘, p. 135.
  206. Wittert van Hoogland, ‚Genealogie‘, pp. 136, 137. Burial: https://archief.amsterdam/archief/5001/1056 (accessed 16 December 2022).
  207. Wittert van Hoogland, ‚Genealogie‘, pp. 135.
  208. Ekkart, ‚Familiekroniek‘, pp. 54, 72.
  209. Rudi van Maanen and Leendert van Maanen, ‘De grote epidemie van 1669-1670’, Leids Jaarboekje 2021, pp. 67-83, with further references.
  210. See Dickey, ‚Ars longa vita brevis‚, with further references.
  211. See esp. Christaan Vogelaar and Gerbrand Korevaar, eds., Rembrandt’s Mother. Myth and Reality, exh. cat. Leiden: Stedelijk Museum de Lakenhal 2005, pp. 88-91, 97-98, cat. 3-6, 9-10.
  212. We are grateful to Jos Beerens and Weixuan Li for advice on software to visualize this data.
  213. Reymptgen’s husband, Cornelis Bartholomeusz (Meesz.) van Tetrode (1505-1550), a grain dealer in Leiden, died before Neeltje and Bastiaen were born. See Strauss et al., Rembrandt Documents, doc. 1561/1, 1574/3, 1579/1, 1581/1,1582/2.
  214. Strauss et al., Rembrandt Documents, p. 24.
  215. Gerrit Cornelisz. Vinck is registered living in Leiden 1544-1583; Historisch Leiden in Kaart, https://historischleideninkaart.nl/persoonformulier/?Id=8986 (accessed 16 December 2022). He became poorter of Delft in 1584; Stadsarchief Delft, 1.733, fol. 054v, 5-5-1584. See also W.C. Tettero, Genealogie van Tetrode 1300-1600, Voorburg 2000, p. 61; J.P. Jacobs, ‘Rembrandt verwant met Philips van Leyden’, De Nederlandse Leeuw 102 (1985), column 457-465.
  216. See also ELO, Stadsarchief van Leiden, 0501A, 6597, Register Vetus 1582-1601, p. 8v. ‚t Gulden Warken belonged to Reymptgen In 1579; by 1581, she had transferred ownership to Dirck; Strauss et al., Rembrandt Documents, p. 31 and doc. 1579/1, 1581/1, 1585/1.
  217. Wittert van Hoogland, p. 123. Walsburch was buried several weeks later; SAA DTB 5001, 1054, p. 46vo, 8-5-1629. Prenuptual agreement, SAA 5075, 445, not. Palm Mathijsz, 17-2-1631.
  218. SAA DTB 5001, 671, p. 33 (marriage bans) 27-1-1628; DTB 1054, p. 46vo, 8-5-1629 (burial record).
  219. Wittert van Hoogland, p. 124. They married on 10 May at the Begijnhof and 13 May at the Amsterdam Town Hall.
  220. Wittert van Hoogland, p. 126. Clara became a begijn in 1643 and registered her will as a bejaaarde geestelijke dochter, wonende op het Begijnhof, in 1655, appointing her brothers her heirs; SAA 5075, 2454, not. R. Duee, akte nummer 57860, 8-10-1655.
  221. Wittert van Hoogland, p. 127; SAA, DTB 676, p. 145, 2-1-1642; 5033 Poorterboeken, no. 2, p. 199, 24-4-1642. In 1647 Albert purchased a home on the Haarlemmerstraat; SAA, 5073, Kwijtscheldingen, no. 928, 5-1-1647. He posted the banns for his second marriage, to Grietje Harmens van der Aa, on 2 December 1655; SAA, DTB 682, p. 356, 2-12-1655.
  222. Wittert van Hoogland, p. 127.
  223. SAA DTB, 1055, p. 94v (Clara); 1056, p. 252, 26-6-1683 (Albert).
  224. Cornelis was recorded on 24 April 1587 as a baker, age 21. In 1600, he purchased a house later owned by Karel van der Pluym. Strauss et al., Rembrandt Documents, doc. 1581/2, 1662/4; Schwartz, Rembrandt, p. 18 (diagram of Rembrandt’s family tree by P.J.M. de Baar).
  225. Strauss et al., Rembrandt Documents, doc. 1662/4; Marieke de Winkel, ‚“Cousin“ Karel van der Pluym and the benefit of family‘, in Epco Runia and David de Witt, eds., Rembrandt’s Social Network. Family, friends, acquaintances, exh. cat., Amsterdam: Museum het Rembrandthuis 2019, pp. 61-65, citing a red and black chalk drawing on vellum, dated 1634 (private collection in New York).
  226. See Koos Levy-Halm, ‚Where did Vermeer buy his painting materials? Theory and practice‘, in Ivan Gaskell and Michiel Jonker, eds., National Gallery Studies in the History of Art, Vol. 55, Vermeer Studies, 1988, pp. 137-143; Jo Kirby, ‚The painter’s trade in the seventeenth century: theory and practice‘, National Gallery Technical Bulletin 20 (1999), pp. 5-49.
  227. See Stephanie S. Dickey, Rembrandt. Portraits in Print, Amsterdam/Philadelphia 2004, pp. 141-149; Runia and De Witt, eds., Rembrandt’s Social Network, p. 124.
  228. Orlers, Beschryvinge, p. 373; https://rkd.nl/explore/artists/51111 (accessed 2 January 2023)
  229. Rudolf E.O. Ekkart, Isaac Claesz. van Swanenburgh 1537-1614, Zwolle 1998, p. 14. For the prenuptial agreement, Jacobge was assisted by her father Claes Isaacsz and her brothers Isaac Claesz and Claes Claesz; ELO, 0508 Het oude rechterlijke archief van Leiden, no. 76B-2, fol. 375, 15-10-1570.
  230. ELO, 0501A, Stadsarchief van Leiden, 1574-1816, no. 1289, Register van de volkstelling 1581, fol. 9.
  231. See Marije Osnabrugge, The Neapolitan Lives and Careers of Netherlandish Immigrant Painters (1575-1655), Amsterdam 2019, esp. pp. 66-73, 115-123. The Antwerp-born portraitist Abraham Vinck (1574/75-1619) associated with Jacob van Swanenburgh in Hamburg 1589-1598 and later in Naples; in 1602, he witnessed Van Swanenburgh’s marriage to Margaretha Cardone. He lived in Amsterdam 1609-1619. Rembrandt’s bankruptcy inventory includes ‚een doode Contrefijtsel van Abraham Vinck‚; Strauss et al., Rembrandt Documents, doc. 1656/12, no. 86, but we have not yet found a link between Abraham and the Vinck family discussed here.
  232. Ekkart, Isaac Claesz. van Swanenburgh, esp. p. 71; Schwartz, Rembrandt, pp. 22-23.
  233. Strauss et al., Rembrandt Documents, doc. 1620/1; Jef Schaeps and Mart van Duijn, Rembrandt en de Universiteit Leiden, Leiden 2019, esp. p. 28.
  234. Orlers, Beschryvinge, p. 375.
  235. Ekkart, ‚Familiekroniek‘, pp. 71-72. Schwartz, Rembrandt, p. 17; Van Straten, Young Rembrandt, p. 24.
  236. ELO, Register van poorterinschrijvingen F, 1267, fol. 279v, 16-4-1638; Buurquestieboeken, 48G, fol. 105v, no. 2355, 12-9-1661; 0506, Notary Justus Gerstecoren, 1144, deed no. 124, 12-10-1669.
  237. Ernst van de Wetering, ‚Rembrandt’s gift and the underrated importance of his apprenticeship with Jacob isaacsz. van Swanenburg‘, in Ernst van de Wetering and Bernhard Schnackenburg, eds., The Mystery of the Young Rembrandt, exh. cat., Kassel: Gemäldegalerie Alte Meister and Amsterdam: Museum het Rembrandthuis 2001, pp. 32-38.
  238. Strauss, et al., Rembrandt Documents, p. 69, doc. 1630/5; Schwartz, Rembrandt, p. 23; English translation: Wheelock, ed., et al., Jan Lievens, p. 286.
  239. Bakker, ‚Rembrandt and the emergence‘; Vogelaar, ‚Rembrandt in Leiden‘; Orlers, Beschryvinge, p. 376.
  240. See Boudewijn Bakker, ‚Rembrandt and the humanist ideal of the universal painter‘, in Stephanie S. Dickey, ed., Rembrandt and his Circle. Insights and Discoveries, Amsterdam 2017, pp. 67-98.
  241. Volker Manuth, Marieke de Winkel and Rudie van Leeuwen, Rembrandt. The Complete Paintings, Cologne 2019, cat. 121.
  242. Carel Vosmaer, Rembrandt. Sa vie et ses oeuvres, The Hague 1877, pp. 28-35, 469, 461, unaware of Vinck’s Memoriael, posited a relationship to the Van Swanenburghs on Rembrandt’s father’s side. Ekkart, Isaac Claesz van Swanenburgh, p. 11, dismissed this. However, Claes Cornelisz van Berckel, half-brother of Harmen Gerritsz van Rijn, was married to Brechtje Mourijnsdr. van Swanenburch. The half-brothers lived next door to each other on the Weddesteeg in 1605 and 1624 and owned a mill together; ELO, Buurquesties 48B, blad 2, aktenummer 520, 4-4-1605; 48D, blad 201, aktenumer 1339, 22-4-1624; Tiende Register, Bon Noord-Rijnevest (B), Stadsvrijdom en molens op de wallen, archiefnummer 501A, Stukken betreffende afzonderlijke onderwerpen; Registratie van onroerend goed 1585-1816 (1819), inventarisnummer 6634, blad 31, 1602-1724. It is not yet clear how Brechtje Mourijnsdr. connects to Jacob and Silvester van Swanenburgh. See also Schwartz, Rembrandt, pp. 21-25.
  243. For context, see S.A.C. Dudok van Heel, ‚Rembrandt van Rijn (1606-1669), een remonstrantsgezind schilder uit calvinistisch Leiden‘, in idem., De jonge Rembrandt onder tijdgenoten. Godsdienst en schilderkunst in Leiden en Amsterdam, Nijmegen 2006, pp. 177-223.
  244. On art patronage in Leiden, see esp. Gerbrand Korevaar, ‚Leiden in Rembrandt’s time‘, in Van de Wetering and Schnackenburg, Mystery, pp. 12-21; Piet Bakker, ‚Rembrandt and the emergence of the Leiden art market‘, in Jacquelyn N. Coutré, ed., Leiden ca. 1630. Rembrandt Emerges, exh. cat., Kingston: Agnes Etherington Art Centre 2019, pp. 66-95. We are grateful to Piet Bakker for advice on the present essay.
  245. Dirk Traudenius, Tyd-zifter, Amsterdam 1662, p. 16; Arnold Houbraken, De groote schouburgh der Nederlandtsche konstschilders en schilderessen, Amsterdam 1718-21, III, p. 33; H. Schneider, ed. by R.E.O. Ekkart, Jan Lievens, Sein Leben und Seine Werke, Amsterdam 1973, p. 151, no. 262; https://houbraken-translated.rkdstudies.nl/3-1-59/page-30-39/ (accessed 16 December 2022,) with English translation. The painting has not been discovered.
  246. Wheelock, ed., Jan Lievens, pp. 3, 16-17, fig. 19. The painting was destroyed in 1929.
  247. On their extended connection, see Stephanie S. Dickey, ‚Jan Lievens in Rembrandt’s house‘, Kroniek van het Rembrandthuis 2008, pp. 36-53.
  248. As noted above, Cornelis van Swanenburgh’s mother was Adriana van Leeuwen. Rembrandt’s oldest brother, Adriaen van Rijn, married Lystbertgen Symonsdr van Leeuwen in 1617, and Willem van Rijn married Willempje Pietersdr van Steylandt, widow of Jacob Symonsz van Leeuwen, in 1636; Rühl, ‚Het wapen‘, pp. 117-119, 123.
  249. Bakker, ‚Rembrandt and the Emergence‘, pp. 81-83; Wheelock, ed., Jan Lievens, p. 84, cat. 2.
  250. Orlers, Beschryvinge, pp. 367-377; Bakker, ‚Rembrandt and the emergence‘, p. 82. One of these was a ‚Pylatus‘, possibly Pilate Washing his Hands (Raleigh, North Carolina Museum of Art); Wheelock, ed., Jan Lievens, p. 289.
  251. Strauss et al., Rembrandt Documents, doc. 1663/7; Schwartz, Rembrandt, p. 37; Dudok van Heel, ‚Rembrandt van Rijn‘, pp. 190-193; Christopher Brown, An van Camp and Christiaan Vogelaar, eds., Young Rembrandt, exh. cat., Leiden: Museum De Lakenhal and Oxford: Ashmolean Museum 2019, pp. 24, 158-160. Angela Jager is preparing a study of art patronage in Rembrandt’s family network.
  252. Bakker, ‚Rembrandt and the Emergence‘, pp. 85-90.  See also C. Willemijn Fock, trans. by Anne Baudoin, ‚Art ownership in Leiden in the seventeenth century‘, Journal of Historians of Netherlandish Art  13:1 (2021), DOI: 10.5092/jhna.2021.13.1.4.
paint
kwast strepen
paint
kwast strepen
Zum Inhalt springen