Among the most enjoyable aspects of searching for overlooked gems in the far reaches of the online auction jungle is discussing one’s finds with experts in the field. One of these experts in the field of Dutch 17th century art is Stephanie Dickey, herself a sharp follower of such auctions. In early 2024 Stephanie and I both stumbled upon the fascinating portrait presented here in a tiny Florida estate sale, where it was catalogued as ‘Old Master Painting. Rembrandt School’ (fig. 1). The ensuing attribution and identification – argued in this article – came about in consultation with Stephanie and other scholars.1
Strongly reminiscent of Rembrandt’s late style, this engaging and striking portrait, today with a distinguished European collector, depicts a young man, squarely facing the beholder with a sympathetic demeanor. Evidently in his early twenties, the sitter has long chestnut-colored curly hair, pale skin, dark eyes, a firm nose, downy moustache, full red lips and a conspicuous dimple in his chin. The left side of his face remains dark; his left eye seems positioned relatively low, accentuating the recession of the far side of the face, already cast in shadow. The black velvet beret, worn obliquely, blends in with the dark background, while hues on top provide volume and contrast. The sitter is dressed in a dark brown coat with a high upstanding collar, partly protruding beyond his cheek; the collar casts a shadow on the cheek, adding to the spatial effect. The red doublet underneath his coat enlivens the soft browns and resonates with the yellow ochre highlights on the coat’s lapel. The face is subtly executed with thinner paint, applied in transparent layers of pinks and olive over a dark ground; the execution of the clothing is sturdier. The chiaroscuro and tight cropping contribute to the portrait’s intimate, personal atmosphere.
The earliest known reference to the portrait dates from February 1959, when its owner at the time, Mrs. Mary van Berg in New York, handed a photo of her painting to the Frick Art Reference Library, stating that she had obtained it from a London art dealer, who had offered it as ‘Rembrandt (?)’.2 This purchase must have taken place after 1947, when Mr. and Mrs. Van Berg published a catalogue of their collection, which does not include the portrait.3 Mrs. Van Berg further related that the painting had been studied by no less than Julius Held, then professor at Barnard College who, according to Van Berg’s statement, considered the work to be a self-portrait by Rembrandt’s son Titus van Rijn (1641-1668). The portrait briefly surfaced again at a New York auction in 1978, as ‘Portrait of a Young Man, said to be Titus van Rijn’ carrying an attribution to Philips Koninck (1619-1688).4 In 1983 Werner Sumowski included the portrait in his Gemälde der Rembrandt-Schüler, as by Rembrandt’s pupil Willem Drost (1633-1659).5 However, this attribution was rejected by Jonathan Bikker in his 2005 monograph on Drost, where he also referred to the opinion of Horst Gerson, who had attributed the work to Nicolaes Maes (1634-1693).6
1650s? 1660s!
This leaves us with varying scholarly opinions, and several names regarding maker and sitter, all pointing to the later Rembrandt and his circle. Before considering the portrait’s possible painter, let us reassess its approximate dating and its sitter. By attributing the portrait to Drost, Sumowski compellingly placed its execution around 1653, during or after Drost’s period in Rembrandt’s studio, before his departure in 1654/55 for Italy. The portrait’s atmosphere and composition, however, rely on Rembrandt’s later output, from the early 1660s. Such a dating was already implied by Held, whose identification of Titus, and attribution to him, inevitably place the work in the 1660s. Rembrandt’s Self-Portrait of 1660 in the Metropolitan Museum, New York, above all, resembles our portrait, to the extent that it must have provided a template for its painter (fig. 2).7 There Rembrandt depicted himself à trois-quarts in his brown work gown, worn over a doublet with a turned-up collar, a red shirt underneath, and a black velvet beret. Especially when cropping the image (fig. 3), the parallels with the present painting are striking: the opened coat with yellow-ochre hatches to emphasize its structure; the collar’s edges, highlighted with lighter brown and warm orange, similarly protruding beyond the cheek; a red shirt with a white edge worn underneath; and obliquely worn beret. The stark lighting from the left and the frontal view of the face in our portrait differs from Rembrandt’s three-quarter New York Self-Portrait, but is found in other Rembrandts from the period, such as the St Bavo in the Göteborgs Konstmuseum (fig. 4).8 While the St Bavo is executed more vigorously, the lighting, which highlights the cheekbone and the nose while striking the right side of the forehead, leaving dark the left side of the face, is surprisingly similar to that in the portrait discussed here. Another strong example of this concept is Rembrandt’s Portrait of Jeremias de Decker of 1656/66 in the Hermitage, St Petersburg.9 Not only does this empathic portrait employ the same lighting, but the sitter’s eyes also are likewise positioned at slightly differing heights. This tendency is observed again in Rembrandt’s Man in a Red Cloak in the Metropolitan Museum of Art, New York of c. 1662/65, which, with its intimate shadowy setting and atmospheric color range, conveys a similar mood.10
- In addition to Stephanie, I wish to thank Eric Jan Sluijter, Nicolette Sluijter-Seijffert and David de Witt for listening to my ideas concerning the attribution and identification presented here, offering support and feedback, and commenting constructively on an earlier draft of this article.
- Frick Art Reference Library, as attributed to Titus van Rijn, Presumed Self-Portrait (https://library.frick.org/permalink/01NYA_INST/d73c5u/alma991000313219707141, website accessed 26 June 2024). The information on the mount mentions that the Frick’s reference worker, identified only by the initals DMH, had visited Mary van Berg at home in January 1959, where she saw the painting in the flesh. I thank Elizabeth Kobert, archivist of the Frick, for identifying DMH as Daphne Mebane Hoffman.
- M. van Berg, The van Berg collection of paintings, New York 1947.
- Sale New York, Christie’s, 9 June 1978, lot 44 (as attributed to Philips Koninck, Portrait of a Young Man, said to be Titus van Rijn).
- W. Sumowski, Gemälde der Rembrandt-Schüler, 6 vols., Landau/Pfalz 1983-1994, 1 (1983), pp. 610, 616, 636, cat no. 327, ill., as Willem Drost.
- J. Bikker, Willem Drost (1633-1659) : a Rembrandt pupil in Amsterdam and Venice, New Haven 2005, p. 150, cat. no. R18 (not by Drost). Known only from a black/white photo. Bikker mentions a note by Gerson at the RKD. He agrees with Sumowski that the identification of the sitter as Titus van Rijn cannot be substantiated. His remark that the work was probably cut down on the left and the bottom makes sense, insofar that the photo he consulted (and reproduced in his book) was cropped on both sides.
- W. Liedtke, Dutch paintings in The Metropolitan Museum of Art, 2 vols., New York 2007, 2, pp. 687-692, cat. no. 157. E. van de Wetering, in: E. van de Wetering et al., A Corpus of Rembrandt Paintings, 6 vols., The Hague/Boston/London 1982-2014, 4 (2005), pp. 288-294, 517-525, cat. no 20; 6 (2014), p. 665, cat. no. 282.
- Göteborg, Göteborgs Konstmuseum. See A. Blankert, M. Blokhuis, in: A. Blankert et al., Rembrandt : A Genius and his Impact, exh. cat. Melbourne, National Gallery of Victoria, Canberra, National Gallery of Australia 1997-1998, pp. 168-172, cat. no. 24 (c. 1662/65); P.C. Sutton, in: A.K. Wheelock, Jr., P.C. Sutton, Rembrandt’s Late Religious Portraits, exh. cat. Washington, National Gallery of Art, Los Angeles, J. Paul Getty Museum 2005, pp. 129-131, cat. no 17. Sutton compares the painting to works from 1661 but refers (note 3) to Blankert (in Melbourne/Canberra 1997-1998) and Giltaij (J. Giltaij, Rembrandt Rembrandt, exh. cat. Kyoto, Kyoto National Museum, Frankfurt, Städelsches Kunstinstitut 2002-2003, pp. 214-216, cat. no. 42) and follows them in dating the work 1662/65 (p. 131). Van de Wetering, in: Corpus 6 (2014), p. 658, cat. no. 272, dates the painting slightly earlier (N.B. Van de Wetering dates the supposed study for the work, cat. no. 271 (Copenhagen, Statens Museum) c. 1660).
- Oil on panel, 71 x 56 cm., St. Petersburg State Hermitage Museum. The portrait’s date is difficult to decipher but was always read as 1666. Van de Wetering, in: Corpus 6 (2014), p. 636, cat. no. 250, proposed to read the date as 1656.
- New York, Metropolitan Museum of Art.The small painting was rejected as autograph by Gerson in 1969. Van de Wetering, in: Corpus 6 (2014), p. 678, cat. no. 310 has included it again in Rembrandt’s oeuvre, suggesting its function as a preparatory study for the male figure in the Jewish Bride, following earlier scholarship. The dendrochronological report by Prof. Peter Klein states that an origin of the painting is plausible from 1658 onwards. See also Liedtke 2007, pp. 754-757, cat. no. 171, as ‘style of Rembrandt’, suggesting the possibility that the work is a tronie based on the Jewish Bride.

